cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp

Ebay has restricted my selling capabilities for refusing to join mp. I can't list new items, which is fine because I am listing them on my own site. The real problem is I cannot edit items. So for an item I have multiple listed of, I can't lower the amount I have listed. So now that I sold something locally I can't change my ebay listing to reflect that which means eventually someone will buy it and then I have to cancel their order. They are still allowing me to sell, but just not to do it properly.  In their quest to fleece the sellers they are hurting the buyers too.

 

Ebay is the worst company I have ever done business with in my life. They are dying and I am glad I have the ability to continue my business without them. MP Is the final nail in the coffin for ebay. Hundreds of thousands of sellers have quit over it already and its just going to get worse and worse as sellers like me leave. The only thing that will be left on ebay is china **bleep** and direct sales from corporations.

 

 

 

 

Message 1 of 117
latest reply
116 REPLIES 116

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp

@gabriels_yardsale  I noted that there are a number of unsubstantiated comments in your post.  eBay may know how many Sellers have either left or declined to sign up but the rest of are not privy to that information.  Sure, it would be nice to know AND if indeed "Hundreds of thousands of sellers have quit ..." then perhaps sales will increase for those who have elected to stay.

Is eBay dying?  Not that I am aware of and I am not sure how one would gauge that in a Covid-19 world right now.  I am sure many businesses have suffered because of that problem.

While I was not and still am not a fan of MP I have continued to Sell ... but it will NEVER replace the streamlined process we had with PayPal.

 

Regards,
Mr. Lincoln - Community Mentor
Message 61 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp

the classic sub site makes the most sense to me and I have remarked that thought before myself ! It would work ! Everyone would be happy and I am not sure why ebay cannot think of this by themselfs ! How hard would it really be for them to have 2 or even 3 levels of selling platforms and it would not step on anyones toes and ebay would still be making money and so would some disgruntled sellers opposing MP ! Not everyone wants or needs the big business platform and it would be a fair compromise !! I like your thoughts on this one !! kudos to you !

Message 62 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp

where did the info you have come from that PP wanted out ? Is that an assumption ? I have spoke to PP twice recently and they say something different altogether !!

 

Don't confuse PP wanting to stay a money processor for sellers on Ebay and PP wanting the contract to end between Ebay and PP due to the separation of the two companies.  The two aren't the same.  In fact Ebay entered into a new agreement with PP to ensure that they would still allow Ebay buyers and sellers to use their services at least through 2023.

 

But the contract due to the split had other limitations on both companies that they both no longer have those limitations.  PP is now free to offer their services to any company they so choose to.  They didn't have that freedom before.  If you'd like more detailed information, here is the contract.

 

https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1065088/000119312515257121/d93601dex101.htm

 

I also never had a problem with any check or money order from any of my ebay buyers when we did business that way !! Guess maybe I was lucky !

 

Yes you were as there was all kinds of fakes going around about the last year before Ebay went to PP processing of payments.  My bank [a major one] would no longer take money orders from Canada due to all the fraud with the exception of some that were pink as I remember it.  And they preferred only PO money orders.  But those days are long gone now.  Likely not to return.  Buyers don't want that long drawn out process again either, well at least most likely would not as they want their stuff much faster now.

 

I have my friends that had opted in early on that tell me the problems they have had and are having (the ones that stayed) and none of them have anything good to say about it ! I will believe them over anyone on here because I have known them personally for many years and they are not by any means rookie sellers !!

 

OK, then why waste other's posters time asking questions if it means nothing to you anyway.  That doesn't make any sense.

 

Not all ebay users come to these boards to express their thoughts whether likes or dislikes !

 

Yep, I've said that too.  And even more of them do come to share feel good stories.

 

If that happened with the amount of ebay users out there this site would crash !

 

Yet another assumption.

 

It could not handle that kind of traffic ! So what about the silent users that hate it ? Just like I am sure there is the silent ones that like it !! But I would put my money on the ones that hate it being more in number than the ones that like MP !! Not everyone has been forced into this yet so I am sure there is more to come !!

 

I'm certain you would.


mam98031  •  Volunteer Community Member  •  Buyer/Seller since 1999
Message 63 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp


@mr_lincoln wrote:

@gabriels_yardsale  I noted that there are a number of unsubstantiated comments in your post.  eBay may know how many Sellers have either left or declined to sign up but the rest of are not privy to that information.  Sure, it would be nice to know AND if indeed "Hundreds of thousands of sellers have quit ..." then perhaps sales will increase for those who have elected to stay.

Is eBay dying?  Not that I am aware of and I am not sure how one would gauge that in a Covid-19 world right now.  I am sure many businesses have suffered because of that problem.

While I was not and still am not a fan of MP I have continued to Sell ... but it will NEVER replace the streamlined process we had with PayPal.

 


There aren't even that many sellers in MP yet.  

 

I agree with you completely on all points.


mam98031  •  Volunteer Community Member  •  Buyer/Seller since 1999
Message 64 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp

well you always have all the answers so you must be an ebay exec disguised as a seller ! After all you can give more advise and answers than ebay itself !!!

Message 65 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp

hello, maybe I am wrong but I do not believe you are permitted to advertise on the board discussions !! Good luck

Message 66 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp

Yes, she most always does. Because she does the research, rather than just wildly throwing things out there. She just gave you the link to the PP/eBay contract. Did you bother to read it? It would help you if you did.

Message 67 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp

only a lawyer would know how to properly read that contract !! Are you a lawyer ?  is she a lawyer ? Fact still remains paypal is still an excepted form of payment despite a separation from ebay ! Some have the thought paypal is going away but they are not ! Point is if a seller wants to only accept payments from paypal then that should be up to the individual seller not you or mam or ebay !! When payments are made with paypal which is simplified why does ebay have to put it through a lengthy process ? Even another member yesterday made the comment that ebay could develop a classic ebay venue for smaller volume sellers that wish not to participate in MP and what would be the the harm of that ? Ebay would still make money while regaining long time sellers that simply at this time will not sign up for it. Now what skin would that be off of you or anyone including ebay ? They could do this very simply since the system is already in place !! This is not an unreasonable compromise for ebay to do this ! It could be set up for the business level and strictly MP and have the venue for the hobbyist seller being able to stay with the classic ebay venue !! This would benefit ebay and many 1000s of other sellers.

Message 68 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp

While Q2 results were up- it had nothing to do with anything Ebay did right. It was because of the world wide pandemic that forced people to the platform. That is great and all but do not misinterpret the data thinking Ebay is all of the sudden making good policy after 10 years of the platform declining due to policy. The problem that needs to be addressed is long term retention of buyers and sellers- this can only be achieved by improving the relationship and desire of sellers to sell their product here. That can only be accomplished by helping sellers to sell and helping buyers to find what they want- there is the problem- worst search engine on the internet and bloated results of promoted listings and Chinese junk. It will never improve until they fix the search engine.

Message 69 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp

The GMV numbers are manipulated to appease shareholders.  They include figures such as sales tax and shipping that have nothing to do with actual profit or health of the company. Everything is manipulated. 

Message 70 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp


@muskingum_relics wrote:

well you always have all the answers so you must be an ebay exec disguised as a seller ! After all you can give more advise and answers than ebay itself !!!


Nope, I just pay attention and I read when Ebay makes an announcement, policy change or whatever.  I hate learning by surprise.  I'm a very proactive person.  

 

https://www.ebayinc.com/stories/news/ebays-management-of-payments-begins-scaling-globally/

 

Do to being understaffed I'd suspect, there isn't a lot of participation on the threads by Ebay for the last several months.  It has only gotten worse over time.  So we are left on our own to help each other.  If you are expecting me to apologize because I'm in a position to help others, you will be very disappointed and will be waiting endlessly.  


mam98031  •  Volunteer Community Member  •  Buyer/Seller since 1999
Message 71 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp


@muskingum_relics wrote:

only a lawyer would know how to properly read that contract !! Are you a lawyer ?  is she a lawyer ? Fact still remains paypal is still an excepted form of payment despite a separation from ebay ! Some have the thought paypal is going away but they are not ! Point is if a seller wants to only accept payments from paypal then that should be up to the individual seller not you or mam or ebay !! When payments are made with paypal which is simplified why does ebay have to put it through a lengthy process ? Even another member yesterday made the comment that ebay could develop a classic ebay venue for smaller volume sellers that wish not to participate in MP and what would be the the harm of that ? Ebay would still make money while regaining long time sellers that simply at this time will not sign up for it. Now what skin would that be off of you or anyone including ebay ? They could do this very simply since the system is already in place !! This is not an unreasonable compromise for ebay to do this ! It could be set up for the business level and strictly MP and have the venue for the hobbyist seller being able to stay with the classic ebay venue !! This would benefit ebay and many 1000s of other sellers.


Well that isn't completely true.  While certainly some language used in contracts are simply legalese and often will go right over my head, there is enough plain English to be able to gather some important points about a contract.  But to find those parts of the contract, you do actually have to read it.  Not every word, skip sections and find the meet of the document.  

 

I don't know about "expected form of payment", but there are a whole lot of buyers out there that use PP which is part of why Ebay made sure it would still be available to them for the next 3 years.  I'm sure it will be revisited by both sides as the end date of that contract draws closer.

 

This separate site would be assuming that Ebay doesn't care if all sellers were moved to MP, but that isn't the case.  If Ebay were inclined to say that small sellers didn't have to move into MP, they could do that without splitting up the site.  And I don't want my stuff split to another site as I think it would reduce our sales and I wouldn't like that at all, as I'm sure others wouldn't.  But a separate site just would not be necessary if Ebay wanted to exempt small sellers from MP.  They could do that here.

 

How are you defining a small seller?  That would be the first step.  What is the definition?  The answer to that will differ quite a bit.  For me, I've always seen it as a one person operation.  But others will see it differently.  The definition will have all kinds of answers.


mam98031  •  Volunteer Community Member  •  Buyer/Seller since 1999
Message 72 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp


@siamjane8 wrote:

The GMV numbers are manipulated to appease shareholders.  They include figures such as sales tax and shipping that have nothing to do with actual profit or health of the company. Everything is manipulated. 


That is not a manipulation.  That is how GMV is arrived at.  Not just for Ebay but for other sites as well.  GMV is before ANY deductions, similar to how a 1099K numbers are.  No deductions are considered.  It is Gross Receipts.  

 

"Gross merchandise value (GMV) refers to the volume of goods sold via customer-to-customer or e-commerce platforms. Gross merchandise value is calculated prior to the deduction of any fees or expenses."

 

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/g/gross-merchandise-value.asp

 

@siamjane8 


mam98031  •  Volunteer Community Member  •  Buyer/Seller since 1999
Message 73 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp

Thanks for the explanation--that doesn't actually sound that bad. 

You said, "FVF is deducted at time of sale."

So you don't get that monthly invoice of all your fees at once?  That would appeal to me. 

And you can receive your money daily or weekly?  That sounds fine, too. 




Message 74 of 117
latest reply

Restricted my selling for refusing to join mp

@grumpus_otter 

 

Know that you will still have end of month the first time you join (mid month?) as well as every month for store fees, listing fees, Fedex/UPS if you use them etc. Just the 'item' FVF will be removed at each sale.

 

Also know that 'Daily Deposits' does NOT mean SAME day. Takes 3-5 business days to hit your bank (weekends/holidays do NOT count)

Message 75 of 117
latest reply