04-12-2025 11:27 PM - edited 04-12-2025 11:41 PM
Over the past several months, I’ve had multiple orders flagged by eBay as “Sold via Promoted Listings” — and frankly, I disagree with several of them.
Don’t get me wrong — I’ve seen clear benefits to promoting listings, and I believe in the value of the program when it’s accurate. But eBay seems far too liberal and opaque in how it determines when a sale is attributed to Promoted Listings. I’ve yet to see a single instance where they provide proof that an ad click actually led to the sale.
Every now and then, I see a sale marked as promoted that just doesn’t add up. I want the ability to dispute these charges with a real person who can actually review the logic and verify the attribution. I’ve scoured the Help section, and — no surprise — found nothing useful. Once again, the help bot is absolutely useless, no matter how I phrase the question.
I’ll probably end up calling support (again) to file a ticket that likely disappears into the void like all the others. No resolution. No transparency. Just another black hole.
This isn’t a complicated issue — it just requires a human with some critical thinking to take a second look. And even when you finally speak to a seemingly helpful rep who assures you the issue will be resolved, it inevitably comes back declined.
I love selling on eBay — but moments like these really make me shake my head.
The fact that I’m now turning to a community forum in hopes of getting clarity says a lot.
Solved! Go to Best Answer
04-26-2025 02:21 AM
Hi there, I know I am getting a bit long in the tooth. But I can make no sense whatsoever of this “halo subject"
To me, it is as clear as mud.
Halo attribution: eBay will report a Halo item sale from a Promoted Offsite campaign when a buyer clicks on a listing promoted using Promoted Offsite, then purchases a different item from the same seller within 30 days of that click. Ad fees are charged on a cost per click basis.
The purchased item doesn't need to be promoted, and the seller won't pay any additional ad fees for this subsequent sale, as charges are still only charged for clicks on the ad."
This reads as complete gobble de **bleep** to me. I have many promoted listings at fairly modest percentage.
Not all though, so in simpletons terms. If someone buys items of mine, which are not promoted, do ebay have the right to charge promoted fees? Many buyers do buy several items, due to my combined postage policy.
Ones which I have promoted atm all seem to expire on 08/05/25. Will the promotions end then, I wonder.
To be clear, I only use promotions, not any of these, so much a per click campaign.
I find this whole issue so complicated, sigh.
04-26-2025 02:49 AM
@grannytakesatrip17 wrote:I can make no sense whatsoever of this “halo subject"
If someone buys items of mine, which are not promoted, do ebay have the right to charge promoted fees?
If the item was never promoted: no
If the item was promoted and that promotion ended within the past 30 days: yes
If the item was promoted but the promotion ended more than 30 days ago: no
Does that help @grannytakesatrip17 ?
04-27-2025 01:12 AM
I've noticed that eBay now seems to mention the 'halo' bit / but never noticed it prior to a couple weeks or so ago. It's obvious that the question / issue / frustration is coming up more and more. So, that's nice - but, yea.
Saw a reply to my post on here from something suggesting that 'eBay doesn't hide anything'. Um, OK pal. Sure, I can be more diligent about reading the program rules / etc and 100% do/will at this point, sot that's on me. To suggest that eBay is transparent and has sellers (even buyers) best interest in mind w/ regards to a feature/up-charge, etc.. anything that makes the more money.. that's laughable. Do they care and/or budge when a seller (or buyer, i'm sure) is frustrated, complains or asks for a break.. would just like empathy and/or some acknowledgement... ha. Never. (literally, never. like -ever)
Still learning I guess. Expectations are level set at this point. Won't make similar mistakes, but man - learning / being bitten by various the various "seriously, eBay" issues I've come across thus far has been really frustrating - it's they "yea, we're ebay / that's how it is / deal with it / don't care/ you'll still be here w/ us / / stop complaining" vibe that is the biggest bummer. Upset, yes. Bummed out and kinda generally hurt a bit by it... like a sad 'really, eBay' response. That's the rub.