12-10-2021 12:54 PM
Hey guys, so I recently went through a buyer trying to claim the box they received was empty.
When the buyer opened the case, I immediately suspected they were lying because of the low amount of feedback & the fact that I packaged this item very well.
When looking this issue up, most sellers LOSE these cases and lose their item to scammers because eBay usually sides with them.
I’m here to share what helped me win my case against this scam.
1. CONTACT EBAY SUPPORT THROUGH THEIR FACEBOOK PAGE! They are much more helpful & understand these cases much more. Tell them all of the information that leads you to think they are lying.
2. CHECK THE DELIVERY ADDRESS & GOOGLE IT! IF your item was delivered to a 3rd party post office (like most of these scammers), let eBay support know through Facebook and they will likely end the case in your favor. Delivering to 3rd party postal spots voids seller protection because anything can happen there without our knowledge.
3. As soon as the buyer opens the case, message them and let them know you’ll be contacting their local police department and post office to investigate mail rifling that went on with their package. Let them know that they have to keep the “empty box” so an investigator can inspect it. Tell them you will get to the bottom of this. This might scare them away and possibly make them not want to continue fighting the case.
This is what I’ve learned in my experience & figured I’d post this to help other people out against these scams.
EBAY, PLEASE FIX THIS ISSUE SO US SELLERS DONT HAVE TO SUFFER MORE LOSSES! Thanks!
01-11-2026 08:30 AM
Hello, I had the same thing happen on a scam buyer. He had a decent amount of feedback. I did everything I could and also put my 3rd unsuccessful claim thru USPS. Also EBay immediately closed the case in favor of the buyer. I will not refund if this happens again. I am mailing out a graded vintage baseball card and going to videotape packing & closing up with the label as backup.
thanks for your info
01-11-2026 08:56 AM
Video taping isn't verifiable proof. This can easily be doctored. It also doesn't prove that the parcel was mishandled AFTER you shipped it. Even if you could prove that the contents matched the description when you shipped, that's not enough to prove that is what was DELIVERED.
If the buyer is claiming an empty box, you may be able to have the carrier confirm the weight of the parcel. This would help your case tremendously. More so than any videos you would be recording.