01-14-2024 11:09 AM
I see here on this board every hour of every day the typical mail fraud scams that run rampant. My question is....does anyone know how Amazon and other E-sites deal with them? I do not sell and buy very rarely anywhere else so I really do not know how they operate but I have to believe it happens everywhere. If I were to sell a laptop on Amazon and the buyer filed a return and what came back was a rock...what does Amazon do? Do they credit the buyer unlike Ebay? Do they go after the scammers? Just curious if anyone knows or has experience from other sites regarding this as they operate a little different.
01-14-2024 11:27 AM
Amazon is considerably less seller friendly than ebay,
01-14-2024 11:41 AM
@pcobra93 wrote:I see here on this board every hour of every day the typical mail fraud scams that run rampant. My question is....does anyone know how Amazon and other E-sites deal with them? I do not sell and buy very rarely anywhere else so I really do not know how they operate but I have to believe it happens everywhere. If I were to sell a laptop on Amazon and the buyer filed a return and what came back was a rock...what does Amazon do? Do they credit the buyer unlike Ebay? Do they go after the scammers? Just curious if anyone knows or has experience from other sites regarding this as they operate a little different.
The return packages would end up sitting around in Amazon’s warehouses where they aren’t checked often. The scam wasn’t discovered until through a random search where someone opened a box and discovered it was full of dirt.
01-14-2024 11:53 AM
So the items are re-inventoried without opening the return box? Does the seller just lose the inventory on return to an Amazon warehouse? Is this maybe why some sellers here the drop ship from Amazon request the package be returned to a different address? Maybe they want it shipped back to them instead of the warehouse where they lose the money and the item?
01-14-2024 12:02 PM
This is an industry-wide problem affecting every e-commerce site.
A WSJ article last week quoted a source who claimed about 17% of all returns were not the product shipped.
01-14-2024 12:25 PM
Amazon, last I knew, had a system where the seller can APPEAL the refund and get credit from Amazon. You had to file a report though.
01-14-2024 02:19 PM
@tobaccocardyahoo wrote:This is an industry-wide problem affecting every e-commerce site.
A WSJ article last week quoted a source who claimed about 17% of all returns were not the product shipped.
Yep... Mastercard claiming 60%+ of "friendly fraud" in 2023 Gen Z, I believe they stated nearly $200 Billion estimated and by 2027 projecting $500 Billion+ as I recall (or maybe it was $7B+ few weeks since read it).
This stuff is going to come on the legislative radar, I don't see how it cant. Doesn't look pretty when you think about it in top down broadband scope. On one side got all this organized (and not) counterfeiting, numerous other "Service" scams and then some online. Big Retail experiencing the same and similar events as happen in the open ended online marketplaces and they're experiencing it growing measure. Atop that sit manufacturers, distributors and retailers far more itchy scratchy than I can ever recall with cottage resellers. I've said before in other posts I can't recall any time since the inception of the WWW that issues surrounding it in commerce more or less social media/media have been so volcanic.
Atop it all coming into an general election year whereby one party cant seem connect to the people. Whilst the other is connecting in mechanisms of using nationalism that likely result in "Be careful what you ask for you just might get it." History repeats as they say and that sort of history almost ALWAYS repeats.
--------
They needed a change no man would try.
He did understand but he didn't know why.
So he left himself in the hands of the power.
Locked up the questions in the people's towers.
Don't think twice.
Space age sacrifice.
--------
01-14-2024 03:43 PM
@retro_entertainment_collectibles wrote:
@tobaccocardyahoo wrote:This is an industry-wide problem affecting every e-commerce site.
A WSJ article last week quoted a source who claimed about 17% of all returns were not the product shipped.
Yep... Mastercard claiming 60%+ of "friendly fraud" in 2023 Gen Z, I believe they stated nearly $200 Billion estimated and by 2027 projecting $500 Billion+ as I recall (or maybe it was $7B+ few weeks since read it).
This stuff is going to come on the legislative radar, I don't see how it cant. Doesn't look pretty when you think about it in top down broadband scope. On one side got all this organized (and not) counterfeiting, numerous other "Service" scams and then some online. Big Retail experiencing the same and similar events as happen in the open ended online marketplaces and they're experiencing it growing measure. Atop that sit manufacturers, distributors and retailers far more itchy scratchy than I can ever recall with cottage resellers. I've said before in other posts I can't recall any time since the inception of the WWW that issues surrounding it in commerce more or less social media/media have been so volcanic.
Atop it all coming into an general election year whereby one party cant seem connect to the people. Whilst the other is connecting in mechanisms of using nationalism that likely result in "Be careful what you ask for you just might get it." History repeats as they say and that sort of history almost ALWAYS repeats.
--------
They needed a change no man would try.He did understand but he didn't know why.
So he left himself in the hands of the power.
Locked up the questions in the people's towers.
Don't think twice.
Space age sacrifice.
--------
While I agree with fraud being out of hand, what do you honestly think congress can or will do about it? You can't remove consumer protections. They are the ones that VOTE. Congress has been screaming eat the rich forever, and the "little" people ARE eating the rich. There will be no laws that back peddle consumer protections. There will not be anything done that would actually effect the fraud. It's he said she said.
Just like here, even if you have photos of you packing the item, it's not proof. I know I have had wrong items delivered. People make mistakes.
Honestly, about the ONLY thing that can be done, is banning bad buyers. But like in the case here, if a good buyer runs into a few bad buyers, who is eBay supposed to believe who's actually bad? Most sellers and buyers are good people. But lately I have run amok with more than one bad seller. I don't blame the whole of sellers here. And I know it's a hard spot to be in with eBay. Who is the bad one? Bad buyers are the same. Is a seller supposed to be kicked because they ran into 2 or 3 bad buyers in a month?
The biggest problem with fraud is, it's he said she said. And IF you found a way to limit that, then too many people would find loopholes to get around it and scam, on both sides of the issue.
This is what happens when we allow a nation to have wishy washy morals. Scammers have been around for all of time, but a moral populace kept it in check. This whole issue, is a matter of morals. You can't legislate morals, you have to teach them. People have to believe in them.
What retailers need to do, is not allow themselves to be scammed. But if we get down to it, even given the level of fraud, it's still more profitable as is, or they just would limit ways to buy that keep out scamming. They simple COULD stop online ordering and shipped delivery, but the level of profits would suffer greatly. SHRINK and COST OF DOING BUSINESS come to mind. It's still worth it to them, or they simply would not do it.
01-14-2024 03:45 PM
When Amazon launched prime service and free returns no question asked . Opened the flood door's to Buyer fraud theft and return of damaged goods a long with the return abuse . lot of big name company's went into panic mode over amazon taking their customers .So they did new and stupid crazy returns ,That cost them into the billions of dollars lost goods do to buyer fraud . The reports filed with lost prevention.com . was a eye opener.
'
'
'
01-14-2024 04:39 PM
As long as the profit exceeds to losses- as the Beatles would say, “let it be, let it be” Still, at the level of loss, it is pathetic. At least those who do this with NO MORALS are pathetic.
01-14-2024 05:11 PM
The simple fact of the matter is that there is very, very little reason to be concerned about this sort of thing as a seller because 99.99% of buyers are honest people who just want the item they purchased in the condition described. I work B&M retail and I can tell you for a fact that there are people who pull this kind of thing there as well. The ones who come in and claim that they used it once and it broke, etc.
Are SOME buyers dishonest? Yes, in every forum. Is that even more than a tiny, tiny fraction of buyers? No. The vast majority of people are in fact honest when given the chance to be.
01-14-2024 09:44 PM
There's no need to complicate things; This matter is in no way related to Congress enacting new laws.
As long as these platforms don't deliberately deprive sellers of their inherent rights, it should be fine.
Sellers have the right to refuse sales and services.
Why does AMAZON violate the Constitution by stripping sellers of this right?
And why does eBay limit the number of buyers a seller can block?
In fact, all of these are human-made problems. These platforms themselves engage in practices that violate basic laws, driven solely by their self-interest.
Sellers can easily establish websites to share information about fradulent buyers without violating constitutional privacy protections.
Sellers can share the last 10 letters of the buyer's name, all digits in the address, and the last four digits of the payment method (account), which would significantly reduce fraudulent activities for about 90% of fradulent buyers.
It's quite simple, but these platforms are hindering these legitimate rights for their own selfish interests.
Talking about human rights? Why do we always go out of our way to protect the bad guys? Hypocrisy!
-
01-14-2024 11:41 PM
"I see here on this board every hour of every day the typical mail fraud scams that run rampant."
While that is a complete overstatement of what is on the Community Forums, yes scam transaction are an issue for everyone. Both buyers and sellers. It is not just something that happens on Ebay. You are just in Ebay's community, so you see some members complaining about what happened to them. You would need to go to the community forums on other sites to see what their members are saying.
01-14-2024 11:42 PM
@farmalljr wrote:Amazon, last I knew, had a system where the seller can APPEAL the refund and get credit from Amazon. You had to file a report though.
Well sometimes, but it is certainly no guarantee. The claims system on Amazon is slightly WORSE than Ebay's for sellers.
01-15-2024 06:56 AM
Ebay appeals are less of a guarantee. You first have to file police reports and USPS fraud reports, to even have a CHANCE of winning an appeal. And even then, the buyer doesn't get the boot. They move on to the next victim.
Last I knew with Amazon, you filed a form with them, provided photos, and CS would decide the case. One that you could appeal that decision as well. There is no appealing a decision eBay makes.