cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Coin Help

Need some help, I found bunch of coins in my death pile. Anyone know if those that have these stories written are they all replicas? I had assume all were replicas until i found some price guide on the back of some of these. Live listings also looks like it also. Just wanted a double confirmation

 

20250325_170142.jpg20250325_170131.jpg20250325_170138.jpg

Message 1 of 22
latest reply
21 REPLIES 21

Coin Help

Looks like a cool coin and interesting literature there. 

Message 2 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help

look on the other side... it'll say COPY somewhere, probably very small letters hidden where it's hard to see...

Message 3 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help

I cannot imagine that is an actual coin in that condition.  It has to be a replica.

Message 4 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help

I took it out but I don't see copy anywhere.

 

20250326_122255.jpg20250326_122306.jpg

Message 5 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help

Okay, I'll bite...what's a death pile?  I don't sell in this category, so forgive me if that's a dumb question!

evry1nositswindy  â€¢  seller since 2013
Volunteer Community Mentor

Message 6 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help


@evry1nositswindy wrote:

Okay, I'll bite...what's a death pile?  I don't sell in this category, so forgive me if that's a dumb question!


just items that you hold on to that your suppose to list and haven't listed.

Message 7 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help

Thanks @funfactorychannel   So it's the pile sitting here under my desk at my feet!  

evry1nositswindy  â€¢  seller since 2013
Volunteer Community Mentor

Message 8 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help


@funfactorychannel wrote:

I took it out but I don't see copy anywhere.

 

 


i don't either... all that means is it wasn't distributed IAW the Hobby Protection Act... still, a neat thing to have...

 

interesting... i checked my four copies, none of them are marked COPY either...

 

in any case, it's not authentic... from the blurriness and general mushiness it looks to be a copy of a copy of a copy, maybe a few more copies in there...

 

the value is very low as a collectible, possibly a few dollars... you could check ebay sold listings for comps...

Message 9 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help


@funfactorychannel wrote:

@evry1nositswindy wrote:

Okay, I'll bite...what's a death pile?  I don't sell in this category, so forgive me if that's a dumb question!


just items that you hold on to that your suppose to list and haven't listed.


i've got boxes of junque like that...

Message 10 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help

How are you VERY cool looking Continental army coin 

It gave me, something to do 

I'm, confused with A few things about it 

1 is the paper it was in or with 

It has prices on it ANOTHER is it looks 

Circulated 

Why Circulate A copy ANOTHER thing is only 100 SOPOSE TO exist that's on PCGS SITE 

ITS SOPOSE TO BE Is made of pewter how did you get it 

If it's real WOW none even real or fake say copy 

Thanks for the pictures It was fun to see

Message 11 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help

@moderncoins999 

The paper did come with Item. I got a bag full of these I believe from a storage unit 3 years ago.

I have like 50ish different coins from it, never had time to research so kept them in my death pile.

 

Here are some of the coins it came with. the ones that are replica the paper did say it was a replica.

 

20250325_165916.jpg20250325_165924.jpg20250325_165930.jpg

20250325_162456.jpg20250325_162415.jpg20250325_162433.jpg

Message 12 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help

Hey @*smedley*  and @moderncoins999 :  wouldn't the OP be best off bringing these into a coin shop?  These can't really be definitively evaluated through photos, can they?

Message 13 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help


@nyr134 wrote:

Hey @*smedley*  and @moderncoins999 :  wouldn't the OP be best off bringing these into a coin shop?  These can't really be definitively evaluated through photos, can they?


decades of experience (plus the papers literally saying so) tells me those are fake, but OP should certainly do due diligence...

Message 14 of 22
latest reply

Coin Help

17431003017374162419901483466427.jpg

 A magnet won't work  on pewter  YOU could look up the weight 

Other than that I, don't know anything about the coin except what I, messaged you OH I, wouldn't rely on A coin store might say fake & buy something real 

Message 15 of 22
latest reply