10-24-2021 08:32 PM - last edited on 10-27-2021 10:09 AM by kh-ornesh
I lost an auction today that I have held the high bid for THREE STINKING DAYS. Also I wasn't near my max bid. With ONE MINUTE left this **bleep** with a 4 feedback rating comes in bids enough to hit my max. Then bids ONE DOLLAR over my max to win and with no time for me to rebid. I saw another auction site that combated sniping by add 5 minutes to the auction if someone bid with a minute or less left in the auction. I don't remember how many times they would do it. Here's my idea: Add five minutes anytime there is a bid or bids in the last two minutes of the auction. Also add "Snip-bot" detection software as well as bans for serial snipers.
What do y'all think of my idea? Tell me. Right I am seething over this, the seller isn't answering my message, and I reported it to Ebay who agreed it looked extremely suspicious and are going to investigate. However the Ebay rep. said the sniper has already paid for the item. GRRR. >.<
10-24-2021 09:44 PM
First off, you lost because you weren't smart enough to bid your max bid from the start. If you had, the only way you would ever lose an auction is if someone was willing to pay more than you were. As for the winner only bidding $1 over your max, you apparently don't understand how bidding on eBay works. You have no idea what the winner's max bid was, since eBay's automatic bidding will only bid one bid increment over the next highest bid. So if your bid is $10 and the next bidder bids $100, the winning bid will only be $11 -- one bid increment above the next highest bid.
As for your idea of extending the time, I can envision an auction being extended for hours with two fools playing quien es mas macho instead of just bidding their max and getting it over with. I've been on eBay since 1996, and the mechanics of bidding haven't changed. I really doubt eBay will change them now because you lost an auction.
For the record, I usually snipe, and I seriously doubt eBay is going to ban me as a "serial sniper". And yes, I've lost to first bid placed quite a few times. It's not the last bidder who wins, it's the highest bidder.
10-24-2021 09:44 PM
Why on earht would you use a sniping program, let alone pay for one, just proxy bid your max like most buyers do
10-24-2021 09:48 PM
Ebay auctions and horse racing have nothing in common. Sniping is not cheating. With a fixed length auction, sniping has to exist. So rather than ranting against it, you should learn how to work it.
Your rant gets an F-.
10-24-2021 09:55 PM
Placing one's bid as close to possible to the end of the announced bidding period (aka Sniping) is a sound and legitimate bidding strategy in that type of auction. It is the highest bid showing at the end of the bidding period that wins, not the necessarily the last bid placed.
10-24-2021 10:11 PM
There's nothing illegal or immoral about sniping. And there's nothing wrong with bidders who use sniping apps.
If I am interested in an item in an auction format, I wait till the end and snipe. I put in the highest I'm willing to pay and if I'm overbid, so be it. Someone else is willing to pay more!
10-24-2021 10:26 PM
Well actually....
We have a live auction and have been running auctions since 1979 or so. DH is semi-retired and doesn't call anymore, preferring to work with finding consignors.
Our next auction* is already up on Stamp Auction Network and we received the catalogs on Friday. We will have over 300 bidders, a few on the floor (fewer than usual due to COVID) most bidding by email, fax, mail, or on the phone, but a strong contingent will be bidding through live internet bidding.
The job of the auctioneer is to get the highest prices for the consignor (and by extension the highest fees for the firm).
What happens at a charity auction run by well-meaning volunteers is not germane to this argument. If you were bidding at an SF/F convention, you were not dealing with a professional auction firm. I stopped donating to auctions at cons, because the workers had no idea of the value of the donations and were leaving money on the table by poor lotting and favouritism to popular fen.
*https://sparks-auctions.com/auction-38/catalogue/
10-24-2021 10:38 PM
I never said it was immoral. I said it was Unethical.
Webster's on "immoral"
Webster's on "Unethical"
10-24-2021 10:59 PM
@hippolyta wrote:I never said it was immoral. I said it was Unethical.
Webster's on "immoral"
im·mor·al | \ (ˌ)i(m)-ˈmȯr-əl , -ˈmär- \Definition of immoral
: not moral broadly : conflicting with generally or traditionally held moral principles
Webster's on "Unethical"
un·eth·i·cal | \ ˌən-ˈe-thi-kəl \Definition of unethical
: not conforming to a high moral standard: morally wrong: not ethical: illegal and unethical business practices: immoral and unethical behaviorIts fine to bid with less than a minute remaining. So why is wrong for me to contact the seller and say "Hey that guy outbid me, but I'll pay you a $1000 or some other obscene amount for the item? Same thing isn't it? Winning anyway I can at all costs.
Not unethical either.
10-24-2021 11:11 PM
Oh I agree, they weren't professionals. they held two auctions the charity and the vendor auction. There were a lot questionable of behaviors. It wasn't just the volunteers. Often the vendors would pay a shill to make they got top dollar at the vendor auction. I knew the guys that organized the Con. They owned Starbase 21. They were great guys, two brothers. One of the brothers passed away. The remaining brother heart was no longer in it. So he closed their store and the annual Sci-Fi Con.
Back on topic - Crappy behavior is crappy behavior in person or online. This thread illustrates the "Its online/on the internet so it doesn't matter mentality". Regardless its crappy. Its like putting a wig and lipstick on a pit-bull; regardless its still a DOG!
10-25-2021 12:14 AM
Two things you can do from this point on:
1. Stop bidding on eBay
2. Continue bidding on eBay
There are no other choices here, just those two. Good luck and happy bidding and do try and find your manner's as you seem to have miplaced them somewhere along the way.
Oh, and thanks for posting, sellers love a head's up
10-25-2021 04:28 AM
Sounds like you were willing to pay more than your max bid.
Make your max bid the most you are willing to pay, and you won't have this problem.
You will be able to walk away saying "Oh, well, I wouldn't have paid that much for it."
10-25-2021 05:06 AM
"I lost an auction today that I have held the high bid for THREE STINKING DAYS. Also I wasn't near my max bid. With ONE MINUTE left this pendejo with a 4 feedback rating comes in bids enough to hit my max".
What you do not seem to understand is that ebay's auctions are basically sealed bid auctions, like you see at charity events. There is a fixed time that all bids must be entered by and it doesn't matter when during the auction time frame a bid was placed in the box, all that matters is, how much the highest bid was. If you had a max bid in mind when you first bid, that is how much your bid should have been for.
"Hey fine I 'll go buy my own cheatware and Snip too! Everything was done with ONE MINUTE LEFT IN THE AUCTION! I had NO TIME TO REBID!".
Would you like some whine with that rant?
If you have been a member since `98 you should have figured out that snipers often win by bidding in the last seconds. If you were not smart enough to bid your max when you placed your bid, you are the only one you should be mad at. Even then you max may not be enough if someone else values the item more than you.
I do not use a sniping service. I love the rush of waiting until the very end, to see if I have been successful. I have bidding down to the point where I can bid with 3 seconds left on the clock and it is received/recorded in the last second. Sometimes, I am out bid by another sniper or an earlier max bid. That doesn't bother me because I was not willing to pay more than I bid for the item. I only bid earlier if I know I cannot be online when the auction ends.
"I have an Amex with no preset spending limit what I was suppose to bid $10,000 to insure I won?"
That is one strategy you can try, and some people do do that. We call it nuclear bidding:
Placing a bid so high you do not think anyone else in their right mind will come close to it.
Often it works out, but if another person does the same thing you may still win, but at much more than the item is worth. I think many who have or will respond to this topic, have done the same thing and some of us have had to pay the piper for doing that. I'm one who has and that taught me a lesson.
You posted an anecdotal story about someone who waited until the gavel was about to fall at a live auction. But it turned out they were working with the owner of the item. That was shill bidding pure and simple. It is also illegal in many states. It has nothing to do with your rant, because the idea behind a shill is not to win, but to get the best price possible for the seller without winning the auction. Sniping would be a foolish thing to do at a live auction for a shill.
That being said I did exactly that at an auto auction to win my favorite classic car. I waited until the two final in house bidders wore each other out, only bidding $50 at a time and placed my one and only bid just before the gavel fell for $500 more. A lot of people called me stupid for doing that, saying I had bid too much, and the loser was **bleep**, but I walked away with the prize. If I wanted to sell it today, I can get much more than I paid.
Time added, online auctions are a waste of time, sometimes hours. Because of that eBay decided to go with a modified sealed bid auction system rather than an English out cry one. It more or less ensures that the highest bid will come in by a fixed time and every one has an equal chance of winning even those who place an early maximum automatic/proxy bids.
10-25-2021 05:42 AM
I love snipers👨🎓.......they are by far the most intelligent bidders on Ebay. Its the uneducated complainers of snipers that are the real problem when it comes to bidding.
10-25-2021 06:04 AM - edited 10-25-2021 06:07 AM
@hippolyta wrote:Also I wasn't near my max bid. With ONE MINUTE left this pendejo with a 4 feedback rating comes in bids enough to hit my max. Then bids ONE DOLLAR over my max to win and with no time for me to rebid.
You really don’t get it, so you?
1) You had bid your “max”, then got upset when you didn’t get the chance to bid higher. How is it possible to bid higher than your “max”? It wasn’t really your max, was it, even though you had DAYS to figure out what your real MAX was?
2) The price wasn’t near you max bid, because eBay only used enough to put you in the lead, but when the other guy jumps ahead by $1, it never occurs to you that eBay did the same thing with their bid. They may have outbid you by $50, but they’d still only win by one bid increment, in this case $1. That’s how it works for everyone, not just you.
3) There’s nothing “highly suspicious” about this, and eBay isn’t going to investigate anything. They told you that to get you off the phone.
4) If I were the seller and you contacted me about this, I’d block you for trying to interfere with my auctions.
Learn how bidding works. Stop blaming other people for your failures.
10-25-2021 06:13 AM
You have been given nothing but sound information and advice. You are so riled up that you don't want to hear that you are wrong. But, I will say it again, YOU ARE WRONG.
I don't use a sniping app, but I do wait until the last few seconds to bid. I bid what I am willing to pay and if it isn't enough, so be it.
As for your idea of extending the bidding time, I am definitely not in favor of that. I don't have time to play those games.