Selforfun Volunteer Community Mentor
It's unfortunate that your USPS claim was denied, but it may not be a lost cause. Here’s a step-by-step approach to handling the situation, along with some insights from my experience:
1. Understand USPS Insurance
Most USPS shipments include insurance for up to $100 by default. Since your item was insured for $100, you should be eligible for reimbursement if you can provide sufficient documentation.
2. Gather Proof of Value
Since it’s an old, used item, here are some alternatives to the typical “sales receipt”:
- eBay Sales Records: Provide a screenshot or copy of the eBay transaction showing the buyer’s payment and the item's details.
- Comparable Listings: Find similar items for sale on eBay or other reputable platforms. Include screenshots or links showing their prices.
- Personal Estimate: Write a detailed description of the item, its age, and condition, and explain why you valued it at $99.50.
3. Documentation of Damage
- Include photographs of the damaged box (if the buyer sent you any).
- Ask the buyer to confirm the item's condition upon arrival and, if possible, provide a short note verifying the damage.
4. Appeal the USPS Decision
USPS sometimes reconsiders claims with additional proof. Submit:
- eBay sales records
- Comparable listings
- Photos of damage
- Your written description of the item's value and history
If you receive a letter asking you to visit your local USPS facility, they may direct you to speak with a manager. Not all USPS locations have managers on-site, and you may experience some back-and-forth until you find the correct person. This can be frustrating, but persistence often pays off.
5. Protect Yourself for Future Sales
To avoid this in the future:
- Bubble Wrap and Sturdy Packaging: Double-box fragile or high-value items and use plenty of cushioning.
- Higher Insurance: If the item’s replacement cost exceeds standard insurance, consider purchasing additional coverage.
- Signature Confirmation: Ensures the package is handled more carefully.
Personal Perspective
From my 24 years of experience on eBay, I’ve faced similar challenges. The USPS process can feel like being bounced around, but claims do get approved when the right evidence is submitted. Once, I even had to visit multiple post offices to find the right person to escalate the case—but eventually, it was resolved in my favor.
Let me know if you’d like help drafting a claim appeal or navigating the USPS process!
Reader! If you're in Myrtle Beach, SC, join our chapter eBay Legacy Sellers – click here.
