cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Is there recourse for a bid retraction in violation of rules - suspect manipulation

Item in auction format with no BIN option (my mistake). Similar items seem to sell for $400 - $500.

With one hour left in auction leading bid is $330.

48 min before end of auction bidder X bids $555 - an unreasonably high bid. Bidder X has a couple of negative comments in their history about bid manipulation and non-payment.

46 min before end of auction Bidder Y (who has never bid on this item before) bids $560, leading auction

Because $560 is an unreasonably high bid, no other action takes place in the last hour in spite of a lot of watchers - my experience (limited by eBay standards) has been that that is when the action is.

Within the last minute of the auction bidder Y retracts their bid without entering a new bid, using the reason “bid wrong amount”. Winning bid rolls back to $335 for bidder X. Bidder X saves significantly from the typical value for the item.

Bidder Y has a an activity number between 50-100, and no negative comments

Both bidder X and bidder Y live in the same state.

Questions for the community - thanks in advance for any guidance:

1. After searching fo an hour, I have found no recourse to report bidder Y for failing to follow eBay policy that an erroneously placed bid must be corrected within 2 hours AND replaced with a correct bid. Is there a way? Does it go on their record somehow?

2. Seems suspicious that bidder Y knew to bid exactly $5 more than the max bid by bidder X, and knew to retract their bid with less than a minute to go. Is there a way to report such suspicions?

 

 

Message 1 of 18
latest reply
17 REPLIES 17

Re: Is there recourse for a bid retraction in violation of rules - suspect manipulation

thank you. I did not know anyone else could see the times so exactly

Message 16 of 18
latest reply

Re: Is there recourse for a bid retraction in violation of rules - suspect manipulation

I suspect they have had practice and had their fingers on the mouse button while watching the clock!

Message 17 of 18
latest reply

Re: Is there recourse for a bid retraction in violation of rules - suspect manipulation

The timing was consistent with rules. Not replacing the bid with the amount they meant to bid is not consistent - should have been at least a few dollars more than second place bidder

Message 18 of 18
latest reply