06-24-2017 11:43 AM
The kid next door to me needs to do some of his homework on a computer. His School requires this. His parents have a very low income. So all they could afford was to buy him a low-priced LapTop. He needs access to the Inernet--but cannot afford to pay those high montlhly fees.
Is it ok for him to use WIfi--to get what he needs. Or will I get in trouble if he does this.
Solved! Go to Best Answer
06-26-2017 09:09 AM
It is NOT illegal to allow the kid to access your wifi, but it MAY be a violation of you terms of service with your internet provider (Comcast, AT&T, Charter, whoever). You would need to look at the TOS to determine what they allow and don't allow.
I wouldn't worry about the above in general. Even if they do have some sort of legalese in the TOS that prohibit use of your internate outside of your household (or somesuch), the ISP doesn't really care in general until something goes wrong.
The major issue with allowing people to use your internet service is that anything they do is tied to YOUR static or dynamically assigned IP address, and therefore to your internet account.
For example, let's say the kid torrents (downloads) movies, tries to breach other systems, makes threatening posts on Facebook, whatever it is that is illegal. All the traffic leaving his laptop while on your wifi carries your IP address in the packet headers.
When the MPAA (Rightscorp) comes a knockin' trying to extort settlement money out of the movie downloader, it is via the IP address logged in the torrents or download server logs, they go to the ISP with a supoena, and get the information on the account that was asociated with the IP address at that time - which would be you.
Kid tweets some sort of threatening thing and SWAT Team shows up at your door - since your account is linked to the IP address that made the tweet.
Family roused out of bed by SWAT assault team in the middle of the night, because they had unsecured wifi (no password) and guy sittting in car out in the street had downloaded kiddie porn using their wifi signal.
The above are extreme and unlikely, but possibilities. As the account holder, you are the one everything traces back to when someone uses your wifi (or for that matter sits down and uses your computer)
You wouldn't ultimately be held responsible for movie downloading or kiddie porn, etc because the courts have ruled that "an IP address does not equate to a person", but that doesn't prevent the hassle of being swatted, possibly arrested by overzealous stupid LE that didn't get the memo, or being sued. You would eventually prevail in all the prior, but might incur legal fees, much hassle, etc.
(Kind of like the traffic camera thing - they come after the registered owner via the license plate number, but if traffic cam photo doesn't match he walks.)
Additional issue others mentioned - kid shares your wifi access key with friends and they use it on their phones, tablets, and laptops while within range of your signal - you are on the hook for all the stupid things they do now. And the data usage.
Also as others have pointed out, you overall internet bandwidth and wifi bandwidth are finite resources. If the kid is streaming youtube videos all night long your browsing speeds will decrease (probably a non-issue on 10+Mbps Comcast cable internet, but possibly a big hit on 3Mbps DSL). And everything he does adds to your data usage - if your internet service is capped that could be an issue.
On the other hand, it would be nice to help the kid out especially since it costs you nothing (you're already paying for internet access so tossing him some wifi bandwidth is like giving him a glass of water.) You could discuss it with him, come to an understanding that he needs to use it responsibly. Then again kids can be incredibly stupid.....
If you have an appropriate router with the correct firmware you can run the wifi access in a nanny mode where you can restrict bandwidth, set daily data caps, whitelist and blacklist websites, retrict by keywords, set access hours, restrict access by MAC address (solves any problem with kid's friends using your wifi), etc. [My 12+ year old Linksys WRT54GL wireless-G router running Hyperwrt 2.1b1 + Thibor15c firmware can do most of that, and newer routers have a lot of it and more from the factory with actual usable interfaces.]
tl;dnr version You are the first person law enforcement and lawsuits come looking for when someone does something naughty on your wifi.
Hope that helps and doesn't add too much confusion.
06-24-2017 11:49 AM
Yes, you could get in trouble if you allow someone in another household to piggyback off your WIFI system.
Don't allow the kid to use your computer, either, to do his homework on.
None of this is your problem.
He could go to the library and use a computer there.
06-24-2017 12:03 PM
@garmentvarmint2004 wrote:The kid next door to me needs to do some of his homework on a computer. His School requires this. His parents have a very low income. So all they could afford was to buy him a low-priced LapTop. He needs access to the Inernet--but cannot afford to pay those high montlhly fees.
Is it ok for him to use WIfi--to get what he needs. Or will I get in trouble if he does this.
Allowing another person to use your wifi is a serious offense. Have him go to a public library or
a Starbucks where they have public wifi. It's not your problem if your neighbor can't afford wifi.
06-24-2017 05:40 PM
CHINO..
Thank you for this information. I will pass this along to my nephew--who told me a few days ago---that he thought it would be safe for me to let him do so. He seemed to believe that since this "signal" ia just freely moving around my apartment---that it was legal for me to I am him to do this.
Although I certainly would never allow either him---or anyone else to come in and use my Computer. I am just not that trusting a person.
HOWEVER, I am confused what you said about Starbuck's. So it IS legal for him to use THEIR WI-fi??? How come? Does he pay them a fee or something? And then does Starbuck's pay someone else a fee---to offer this Service to their coffee customers?
06-24-2017 06:20 PM
I may be entirely wrong, but this is the first time I have heard that it is ILLEGAL for you to offer wi-fi to whomever can receive your signal.
To combat this, wi-fi routers have the option to set a network password. That option is not a manditory use option.
Note the use of "without their permission" in the following.
"Piggybacking commonly occurs when a person uses their neighbor's wi-fi without their permission, or when a person sitting in a car near a home accesses the resident's wi-fi. Piggybacking is illegal according to the laws of several states, and also according to federal laws such as the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act."
You might check the laws in your state, but I believe, you can give permission for others to use your wi-fi. Is this a good idea? Maybe not.
If the neighbor creates an eBay account, eBay will connect the two accounts together. If one does not pay, the other faces restictions until the bad account is fixed.
There may be other organizations that will do similar.
There have been many cases of pedophiles using open wi-fi connections to download kiddie porn.
If you wish to allow the neighbor to use your wi-fi, establish a network password on the wi-fi router, and give them the password.
06-24-2017 06:24 PM
Not illegal if you allow it.
McDonalds and other fast food places have free wifi.
It could slow internet down for you if the entire other family start using your wifi.
06-24-2017 07:48 PM
CADD..
Thanks for asnswering this. One repliyI receved from the "Tools" Board was quitw negative. But I could not understand why they said that I could get in trouble. Because one of those Posters said I should send my neighbor's child to Sarbucks. So I would like to know how Starbucks can offer rhis Service to their customers---without getting in trouble themselves. (??)
06-24-2017 07:54 PM
many public places have free wi-fi
Town 12 miles away pays for public wi-fi in the center of town during the summer.
A tourist perk
06-24-2017 08:12 PM
CANDD...
I do not need to worry abbout the rest of the family. The father does not know how to use a computer---an he has said to me, he never intends to learn. Infact, these he parents both avoid ayything electronic. They have never even owned a Television Set! I cannot imagine what it was like for this nice kid--in this day and age---to have grown up with no computer and no TV . I imagine he does not even understand some of the conversations he tries to be part of--with his friends at school.
06-24-2017 08:24 PM
If you do decide to give your wi-fi code to this student, and things do go wrong (such as him giving the code to his buddies who are visiting his house which slows you down), then there is a fix. You just change your wi-fi code again and it's over.
06-25-2017 12:12 PM
CANND...
Huh? H e could give the code to his buddies?? But what would they do with it? Don't they have to also live next door to me---to pick up a Signal?
Some of the responses I am getting on this Thread are certainly confusing! I think some rseponders are not all that knowledeable about how Wi-Fi works.
I would rather hear from Techie people-. Sorry, but I really don't want to hear from those those who are just taking guesses.
06-25-2017 05:10 PM
I'm not a techie, but I do have a little experience with this is all.
What I mean is when his friends come over to his house or if he has older grown sisters and brothers, they will notice he can get online. They won't want to use up their own time on their phones, so they will want to connect their phones to your wifi when they are visiting at your neighbors house. He will probably give them the code too. So yes, they can only connect when they are close to your house. If that starts happening, your internet will start slowing down.
06-26-2017 09:09 AM
It is NOT illegal to allow the kid to access your wifi, but it MAY be a violation of you terms of service with your internet provider (Comcast, AT&T, Charter, whoever). You would need to look at the TOS to determine what they allow and don't allow.
I wouldn't worry about the above in general. Even if they do have some sort of legalese in the TOS that prohibit use of your internate outside of your household (or somesuch), the ISP doesn't really care in general until something goes wrong.
The major issue with allowing people to use your internet service is that anything they do is tied to YOUR static or dynamically assigned IP address, and therefore to your internet account.
For example, let's say the kid torrents (downloads) movies, tries to breach other systems, makes threatening posts on Facebook, whatever it is that is illegal. All the traffic leaving his laptop while on your wifi carries your IP address in the packet headers.
When the MPAA (Rightscorp) comes a knockin' trying to extort settlement money out of the movie downloader, it is via the IP address logged in the torrents or download server logs, they go to the ISP with a supoena, and get the information on the account that was asociated with the IP address at that time - which would be you.
Kid tweets some sort of threatening thing and SWAT Team shows up at your door - since your account is linked to the IP address that made the tweet.
Family roused out of bed by SWAT assault team in the middle of the night, because they had unsecured wifi (no password) and guy sittting in car out in the street had downloaded kiddie porn using their wifi signal.
The above are extreme and unlikely, but possibilities. As the account holder, you are the one everything traces back to when someone uses your wifi (or for that matter sits down and uses your computer)
You wouldn't ultimately be held responsible for movie downloading or kiddie porn, etc because the courts have ruled that "an IP address does not equate to a person", but that doesn't prevent the hassle of being swatted, possibly arrested by overzealous stupid LE that didn't get the memo, or being sued. You would eventually prevail in all the prior, but might incur legal fees, much hassle, etc.
(Kind of like the traffic camera thing - they come after the registered owner via the license plate number, but if traffic cam photo doesn't match he walks.)
Additional issue others mentioned - kid shares your wifi access key with friends and they use it on their phones, tablets, and laptops while within range of your signal - you are on the hook for all the stupid things they do now. And the data usage.
Also as others have pointed out, you overall internet bandwidth and wifi bandwidth are finite resources. If the kid is streaming youtube videos all night long your browsing speeds will decrease (probably a non-issue on 10+Mbps Comcast cable internet, but possibly a big hit on 3Mbps DSL). And everything he does adds to your data usage - if your internet service is capped that could be an issue.
On the other hand, it would be nice to help the kid out especially since it costs you nothing (you're already paying for internet access so tossing him some wifi bandwidth is like giving him a glass of water.) You could discuss it with him, come to an understanding that he needs to use it responsibly. Then again kids can be incredibly stupid.....
If you have an appropriate router with the correct firmware you can run the wifi access in a nanny mode where you can restrict bandwidth, set daily data caps, whitelist and blacklist websites, retrict by keywords, set access hours, restrict access by MAC address (solves any problem with kid's friends using your wifi), etc. [My 12+ year old Linksys WRT54GL wireless-G router running Hyperwrt 2.1b1 + Thibor15c firmware can do most of that, and newer routers have a lot of it and more from the factory with actual usable interfaces.]
tl;dnr version You are the first person law enforcement and lawsuits come looking for when someone does something naughty on your wifi.
Hope that helps and doesn't add too much confusion.
06-26-2017 10:28 AM
BERSERKER..
Thank you so much much for your response! I have been vaguely aware that I might be taking some sort of risk---if I do this BIG FAVOR for this kid. However, he is a very conservative person. Very responsible. He is NOT going to do any crazy things with his computer.
In addition, his father watches him like a hawk. His dad is one of those people who looks over this kid's shoulder---and comments on every single thing he does. The kid is NOT going to be dowloading anything he shouldn't be looking at.
06-26-2017 11:53 AM
Great. You know the kid, you are now aware of what the implications can be in the worst case scenario for sharing internet, and you can assess the risk.
This wifi scenario has some parallels to some of the issues here on the boards with "bad buyers", returns, etc. The worst case scenarios can be bad (lose the item, lose the payment, get back a box of rocks), but most people are pretty good Joes in general and things usually work out and/or are just misunderstandings. (I've had I think 2 troublesome buyers out of 1700+ in 13 years of selling, and 5? difficult sellers out of 600+ in 15 years - mostly early on)
Sounds like the kid is a "Good Joe", there shouldn't be a problem for you, and you have an opportunity to help out a kid's education in a meaningful way.
BTW, I conflated 2 articles in my swatting example in the previous post. Here is the other one that involved the family 5 years ago:
Welcome to the Seller Tools board! You can chat with other members about seller tools and best practices in using them.
Tools related questions? Learn more about:
Videos: