I just wiped out my entire post X-( ^&%$$#^% start retyping..
I know you're not faulting me Chuck as you are prob just wondering why. This topic has been brought up before and we all deemed it as personal taste.
Part of the reson is everyone else's post on this.
Also I found after getting into N scale and tring out my skills at painting a tiny loco, I thought I would try wx'ing (weathering) as I never did wx'ing on my 1/24 scale car models. (showroom clean) I found wx'ing was fun and made a loco/boxcar look more realistic. Took away that toy look.
I see layouts in MR like Pelle Soeburg's "UP in the desert" and I am blown away how real his and others layouts look.I don't think I could do that quality or realism for a long while. So where I lack in that catagory I make up for it with my trains that look like they work.
I can repsect one's choice to spend a lot of money on freight cars and keep them mint as these things are expensive.
I've seen some layouts in MR that contain heavy industrial scenes and the trains are shiny plastic. I just find they look out of place.
I'm modelling a ficticious town in the 80-present era so most stuff is well used by now, with the exception of a few cars that just came into service or a loco that came out of overhaul.
I will have two shortlines, the SW9's will prob be fairly clean. The other branch will be a couple GP20s that make runs to the lime site with their ortner car consist so the locos will prob jsut have dust on the bottom, as I think they will be kinda like newly purchased/repainted locos.
A lot of RR will get a hold of units from a larger RR and just paint over the names and numbers. Usually the case for leased locos. Any that they buy may eventually get a whole new paintjob.
The Windsor and Hantsport RR back in NS used ex-CP SWs and all but one still have faded pacman on the sides. One got all repainted, still grungy looking.
You won't wanna see my gallery when I finsh my Kato SD40 (stripped paint,removed dyn. brake) and a consist of MTL Ortner hopper cars that will have their Conrail markings painted over (got the trucks painted dusty now)
Sorry for a long explaination.
dave
I see some locos fairly clean here in 'peg. freight cars are a different story as my photos show.