03-16-2025 12:48 PM
I am receiving a prompt from Ebay when I log in to set up a Tax Identification Number on my account or I could be fined $500.00 from CRA (Canada Revenue Agency)
This is new to me. I have been buying/selling on Ebay for 20 years.
Does anybody have some context that can shared?
Thanks!
03-16-2025 12:56 PM
@tarnvik
You would likely get more pertinent information if you asked directly in the eBay Canada community forums. Though we do have some regular posters here from Canada, most are US based.
https://community.ebay.ca/t5/Discussion-Boards/ct-p/11002
Please don't feel bad about posting to the wrong place. I have been on eBay since 1998 and just found out yesterday why we are getting so many visitors from other countries on a more regular basis now. No worries.
03-16-2025 12:58 PM
Appreciate the information and advice!
03-16-2025 02:40 PM
@tarnvik wrote:I am receiving a prompt from Ebay when I log in to set up a Tax Identification Number on my account or I could be fined $500.00 from CRA (Canada Revenue Agency)
This is new to me. I have been buying/selling on Ebay for 20 years.
Does anybody have some context that can shared?
Thanks!
I'm from Canada. It's a requirement now, they started asking for SIN in January 2025.
You can get fined $500 for each platform/account you don't provide this information to. eBay is now reporting your sales to CRA, so be sure to include them on your tax return.
C.
03-16-2025 03:26 PM
Almost every country in the world will want to know if a citizen is involved in a profitable business. They may even want a percentage.
03-16-2025 03:50 PM
Thanks all. I guess it is a new year and a new financial environment. It seems if you have pieces in your basement that you liquidate the government is interested:(
Profitable. Not really. More of a hobby:)
03-16-2025 04:59 PM
@tarnvik wrote:Thanks all. I guess it is a new year and a new financial environment. It seems if you have pieces in your basement that you liquidate the government is interested:(
Profitable. Not really. More of a hobby:)
If you report the sales of personal goods and especially if you are selling at a loss, do it the correct way and you will owe nothing in taxes.
03-16-2025 06:00 PM
Thanks. Something to think about.
03-17-2025 12:45 PM
Thanks for your information. Would you know if there is a timeline as to when the SIN must be provided to Ebay?
03-17-2025 02:08 PM
@tarnvik wrote:Thanks for your information. Would you know if there is a timeline as to when the SIN must be provided to Ebay?
That's a better question for the Canadian forum. There's a 200+ replies article in there of people complaining about this (and other people posting references from CRA). It's a hot topic there. You should come join us in the Canadian forum:
https://community.ebay.ca/t5/Seller-Central/bd-p/213
There are more knowledgeable posters on Canadian issues who can answer these questions. Unfortunately I don't know how quickly you must comply. We've been providing it right away when asked to avoid having our payouts being held.
C.
03-17-2025 03:32 PM
Thanks for taking the time to provide valuable insight. I'll head to the Canadian forum.
Have a great evening!
06-28-2025 11:37 AM
Okay strap on your seatbelt and keep your eyes on the road. I guess we can say that the Honeymoon is over! But here's the thing about taxes and doing business. If you claim all your expenses, there is only a fraction of what you sell to be taxed. Maybe this will be better in the long run. I have tried to make CRA understand that Ebay isn't calculating the Fees properly. Ebay is profiting from the Taxes that the Buyer is paying. Even worse, the taxation is being encapsulated and that means you and the customer are paying taxes on taxes.
This gets Heavy but you need to understand how this Business and the Efforts you make, pan out!
Look at the breakdown in the details of a typical Ebay transaction! Here's an example:
A Snoop Dog CD is sold for $15 and shipping is $10. Sales Taxes are at 13% in Ontario.
So the Grand Total of the sale is $28.25
Now Ebay is charging the Fees based on the $28.25 amount
The Fees are currently around 15% (final value fee in music category) plus another 40 cents (order fee)
The total Fees would be $4.64 which is $4.24 plus the 40 cents
But wait, you have to pay both GST and PST on the Fees too! $4.64 x 13% = 60 cents
so now the cost is $5.24 ($4.64 + 60 cents)
* So you actually only made $9.76 on the sale of the CD ($15 - $5.24)
Reality is that you have paid 35% in Fees and Taxes on this $15 sale! Wow!
The other thing to remember here... is the fact that you are charged taxes on the shipping service. Now these taxes are embedded in the transaction.
This is what I meant about paying taxes on taxes.
And keep in mind that there may be a Promotional Fee tacked on too. A nice gimmick and key to success.
But another huge hit on the profits!
IT Doesn't seem FAIR right? The fact that Ebay is making a profit on a Fixed Cost (shipping charges) plus profiting on the Taxes.
* But keep in mind that you have shipping materials cost, power cost to run the computer and printer, and the ink for the computer. The gas cost to take the package to the Post Office. Let alone the time you put in.
So at the end of the day you might only make $8 on that $15 CD you sold.
This is what the CRA will look at with respect to your income revenue. The thing is you will have to register a Business to claim expenses and that means more cost and more work!
I have tried diligently to prove all these unfair Accounting Practices in Ebay's Fee Structure, but I digress. We can all prove a point though, and make the people running the Corporation and our Government understand that this must be a much better and equally benefiting system with Money paid for Service.
Just Another fine example of Capitalism and what drives up Inflation!
Like my Father use to say, "Look behind the Curtain".
06-28-2025 12:04 PM - edited 06-28-2025 12:06 PM
@tarnvik wrote:Does anybody have some context that can shared?
Yes, eBay created a whole page with lots of context that they want to share with you:
https://www.ebay.ca/help/account/regulatory/sales-reporting/canada-digital-sales-reporting?id=5476
It explains that eBay is required by law to report your sales to the CRA, and for that they need your taxpayer ID number.