cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Offensive Material Policy

Why not offer a way to add a disclaimer that an antique or vintage book contains offensive or racially insensitive language or images.  Now that the Dr. Suess gouging frenzy is over a year old, shouldn't this policy be revisited.  Competing selling sites are selling these books.  Couldn't eBay do it more responsibly by adding a warning statement.  Blazing Saddles, Nazi coins and swastikas are now for sale on eBay.   What percentage of eBays current inventory needs to be reported/removed based on their current policy?  There doesn't seem to be a method for sellers to make policy suggestions directly that I could find.

Message 1 of 31
latest reply
1 BEST ANSWER

Accepted Solutions

Re: Offensive Material Policy


@littlestj wrote:

 There doesn't seem to be a method for sellers to make policy suggestions directly that I could find.


eBay is not interested in policy suggestions. They actually have a policy discouraging unsolicited ideas: 

https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/member-behavior-policies/unsolicited-idea-submissions-policy?id=4...

 

 

View Best Answer in original post

Message 13 of 31
latest reply
30 REPLIES 30

Re: Offensive Material Policy


@littlestj wrote:

There doesn't seem to be a method for sellers to make policy suggestions directly that I could find.


ROTFLMFAO!   As a seller you have every right to make a policy suggestion which will then be immediately ignored and then deleted or tossed into the waste basket.  As a seller you are not a shareholder and not a stakeholder and your opinion doers not matter one iota.  Welcome to corporate Ahmerica.

Message 2 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy

My suggestion is to buy some EBay stock and attend the next shareholder meeting. As a shareholder you can bring up the suggestion during the meeting. 

 

I guruantee you will have the attention of the CEO and other upper management including the board of directors.

Message 3 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy

Anybody buying an antique or vintage book  should know it may contain less than today's PC material.

This whole thing is getting worse than adding warnings not to drink Drano.

Message 4 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy


@littlestj wrote:

the Dr. Suess gouging frenzy is over a year old, shouldn't this policy be revisited. 


Did Dr. Suess only get a one-year sentence? I thought it was lifetime.

Message 5 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy


@coolections wrote:

@littlestj wrote:

the Dr. Suess gouging frenzy is over a year old, shouldn't this policy be revisited. 


Did Dr. Suess only get a one-year sentence? I thought it was lifetime.


If Dr. Suess received a life sentence, in what prison do they have him locked up in?

Message 6 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy

Greenville; 20 miles south of Mihami? 

Message 7 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy

This is eBay's site. They want it to represent certain things. One of those things is that everyone should feel welcome. No one should come here and be insulted or feel ignored.

 

I don't like a lot of what eBay does, but I'm with them on this.

Message 8 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy

A bible is offensive to some.  Where do you draw the line?  Some think the statue David is porn.  You can't win with this.

Message 9 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy

Who decides what is offensive?

Message 10 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy

I agree.  Everyone should feel safe, and I would support their effort, if not for...  Try searching their site for Golliwog book, or early copies of Huckleberry Finn before the N word was removed.  Their policy mentions Nazi currency by name, yet it has 1400+ listings of such.   They got press for removing Dr. Suess.  Their policy should be enforced for all or updated somehow.

Message 11 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy


@bearswatching wrote:

Who decides what is offensive?


And there is the crux of the problem.

 

Thomas Jefferson had it right - If it costs me no money and does me no harm it is none of my business.

 

Within this business there is an old cliché - One man’s trash is another man’s treasure.

 

I am not really “offended” by anything. Another poster just recently did an extensive rant about a seller offering Nazi era postage stamps, demanding that they should be removed.

 

HOWEVER when I was a kid I collected stamps and, through the Nazi era stamps, I got an extensive education in hyper-inflation (which, yes, did pre-date the Nazis but gave rise to Nazism). An education in the causes of World War II (I’m betting it is not what you think) and the dangers of a politician having too much power.

 

Something which might be offensive on its face to some can also serve as an educational tool.

 

George Santayana had it dead right. Not just the one about remembering the past so as to not repeat it.

 

But also:

 

There is no tyranny so hateful as a vulgar and anonymous tyranny. It is all-permeating, all-thwarting; it blasts every budding novelty and sprig of genius with its omnipresent and fierce stupidity. Such a headless people has the mind of a worm and the claws of a dragon.

 

Message 12 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy


@littlestj wrote:

 There doesn't seem to be a method for sellers to make policy suggestions directly that I could find.


eBay is not interested in policy suggestions. They actually have a policy discouraging unsolicited ideas: 

https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/member-behavior-policies/unsolicited-idea-submissions-policy?id=4...

 

 

Message 13 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy


@richard1rst wrote: And there is the crux of the problem.

I see no problem at all. On your property, you decide what is offensive and what is permitted. On eBay's property, eBay decides what is offensive and what is permitted. 

 


@richard1rst wrote:
Thomas Jefferson had it right - If it costs me no money and does me no harm it is none of my business.

I guess that explains why his business involved owning 600 slaves.

 

 

Message 14 of 31
latest reply

Re: Offensive Material Policy


@littlestj wrote:

I... Their policy mentions Nazi currency by name, yet it has 1400+ listings of such... 


Read the policy again.  Currency is mentioned as an item from that era that is specifically allowed, as are postage stamps, and a few other things that may be listed and sold on eBay:

https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/prohibited-restricted-items/offensive-materials-policy?id=4324

 

-

 

 

Message 15 of 31
latest reply