cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

A lot of people say October was the worst month this year, I am in that boat. I think eBay would agree, especially after they sent out those $5 off coupons last week.

 

What about you? Was this the worst month? How much were you down? If not October, which month was your worst? 

 

I was down 47% last month, by far my worst this year. 

Message 1 of 118
latest reply
1 BEST ANSWER

Accepted Solutions

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

Worst month in ,ore than 10 years.  We usually do 400+k a year.  Last June we were on target to have a 600k year but with the summer update, our sales just dumped.

Its not us as the "apologists here will be quick yo point out.  Our website with no SEO is coming up in front of ebay in many searches so IM starting to not care.  I never did much with the website besides build it because we have 55k months on ebay. rarely below 45 for a long time.

We have decided to take our 4000+ listings down to 1000 and drop our store subscription to the $79. That will save us a few thousand a year in fees and the new listings and work go into our website.  This place is trashed and everything they say we need to do to makes it worse.

 

We have a special usps pickup route that comes daily and were going to lose it since we have days with 3 packages. Once that happens we close completely here, and play around more on others or just start writing and doing a lot on our site.

We were killing it month over month until last June and its been mostly down but a few moments where ebay seemed to be working ok but now its terrble as buyer and seller. 

Now were getting saturday small sales that are asked to be canceled sunday so were losing money on stuff were not selling.   Paypal is going to e boycotted by us. We use braintree on our website out of ease but its going away this week.  Weve put 8 million dollars through paypal over the years.

This is not us, we didnt overnight have a decline in interest of what we sell. Half the people I see saying "supply and demand" here sell $10 items and are pushing their commenst as absolute knowledge. Our average sale price for years is $130 approximately. Rarely a day below $1000. My partner and I both at least took micro and macro econ in college. Doesnat make us geniuses but we can clearly see what happening.  Lots of political science and were pretty big political junkies and the word salad and lack of actual trasparency here is just like the government and the terrible political campaigns that are only meant to mislead and protect the status quo. 

These companies all being bought up by private equity kills them and ruins many great small businesses. Many will survive and move elsewhere but for some the momentum and timing has passed. It is killing the american economy and hopefully we see change soon and large investigations of whats been happening everywhere. There is a big political change happening. This is politics. 

 

Its a great disservice having people here that I suspect are "social care agents" but not identifying themselves as that, who are attacking anyone with real issues.  Meaning they work while on these boards, maybe not directly for ebay but maybe Khoros/lithium, maybe even another sub-contracted party.  No issue with company reputation specialists but when the dont identify themselves, its gas lighting.  The youtube videos have blown up compared to last year about whats going on here.

Weve done everything ebay has asked for over the years, reluctantly many time sand with dire consequences many times. Now we  will downsize and sell off what is listed and promote ourselves elsewhere.  Other than the corrupt political environment, dealing with this has just been so infuriating and to be told its not happening when we are not even close to your average seller in inventory or sales. It takes all of our energy to deal with the amazonification where returns quadruple almost overnight and to be led on by ebay with platitudes and non acknowledgment of errors and issues and the cheerleaders here constantly reaching in to the TOS/UA to quickly tell everyone. Nope ebay isnt responsible for anything. If the site is down, its our fault. If the tools dont work, its our fault. If our sales dumped 80% overnight, its seasonal and noone wants what we sell anymore. Many times coming from real people selling collectable staues for $10 (no offense to anyone successfully doing that but you dont speak for the markets that you dont understand and items that are highly sought after in both function and collectability) Thats a double whammy, a useful item that goes up in value.

The first thing to go in times of recessions and hardships is "beanie babies" unless people are storing their wealth there. Things that sit on mantles. Not rare original auto parts that wealthy people need to keep their 100k cars moving.  recessions make those people more money. Those are the unfortunate dips where they buy stock and property becasue they can hang for 10 years.  In 10 years that almost useless but functional auto will be worth more to be traded between the wealthy collectors and hobbyists.  Those markets slump from time to time but, most functional design and art stands the test of time and is generally a safer bet than individual stocks.

Sorry, I dont post often but, the negativity around watching everything being destroyed and knowing its happening, whether through neglect, bad leadership, or low end algorithms that arent working as intended but noone will acknowledge it who had a hand in it is a bummer. We dont ahve to know the specifics of why or even how to see the end result is not just 10 of us complaining of catastrophically lower sales. Im sure if someone were to count accounts here and a few other places, it would be a significant number. Perhaps a poll of how much people are down this year against several other years.

I wouldnt even doubt that this could be an intentional way of cleaving the company apart, devaluing it and it being purchased cheaply to be hoolwed out and polished up and resold at a phenominal amount to unsuspecting buyer or buyers who just want to get rid of the competion but cant legally do so.   Smashing companies is profitable. You can short its stock on the way down, sell off chunks, and then PR it to death.

When people say why would ebay do this. There are many reasons and it may just be whos controlling ebay.  I pay under 9% when selling 45k a month and I'm guessing this months pitance will be at least a couple % higher. 

This morning Im seeing europeans that I keep and eye ons listings in ebay search but, when I click on "sellers other items" , I see only 1 or 2 listings. When I click on their iD it says 100 listing. I can see 4 listings advretised on the bottom of their ID page. The sidebar is missing the "worldwide" tab.  Ive been told in the past, that this is becasue they are not selling on ebay.com but only their countries sites but im literally seeing some of their listings on ebay.com when searching ebay.com but cannot access any of those listings through "sellers other items".  The items advertised on ebay.com are available to eb shipped to the US but they are not findable through the seller at all.

Ive seen this for years and at certain times our international sales dry up. I cant understand how the format of looking at sellers other items changes and how we can search. The sidebar could still say worldwide and then just not bring back listings not spec'd for worldwide shipping.  Im sure I'll get several responses from the same peopel as usual but there is no consistency. Its like 2 different ebay page layouts almost.  Is today the day where I have the option of seeing the "worldwide" box in a sellers searches or the one where i cant see their listings.

There is no conspiracy, Ebay is screwed up for a myriad of reasons and maybe that dip in items sold is from us big sellers who buy and flip on ebay stopping spending due to having very little faith in selling what was not long ago very easy.  Noep not seasonal, out of vogue goods.

I would rather write a bunch vs everyday. My blood pressure literally goes up.

View Best Answer in original post

Message 70 of 118
latest reply
117 REPLIES 117

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

I agree. No sales, offers or even one message for me since October 10th. eBay is hiding something big.

Message 2 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

My worst month in more than two years.

 

What's up GREEDBAY?

Message 3 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

Yup worst month so far.
Message 4 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

Pretty much on track. A hundred or so more than last month and Oct last year.
Message 5 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

Down 35 percent from last month anr 48 percent from last year.

Message 6 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

While this was my worst October in 20 years - down 39% from last October - it was not my worst month of 2019 - March, June, July, August, and September were all worse.   Since the recession I have had slow but steady growth year over year until this year.    Thru October 2019,  I am down 36% from 2018 after being up  18% for January and February.   I lost my TRS on this account in July, and will probably lose it on my other former store account before the end of the year.  

Message 7 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

Not incredibly down but less activity for this month than last year.  I keep praying that we stay on target for Christmas, which would make up for anything not as good this year. Let’s hope those shoppers are coming here. Best to all.

Message 8 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

Down on all 3 accounts (my 2, wife's 1)

 

I do not think it is us. 

 

I think it is a combination of many states (11 ?)  with sales tax kicking in on OCT  1st, glitches between PP - eBay payments (reported, and confirmed) during the 1st part of the month, and overall search problems.

 

Oct sales 2.jpeg

 

 

Oct sales 3.jpeg

 

Sales on only 9 days

 

Oct sales.jpeg

Message 9 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

Sorry, not my experience.  Sales were up 4.1% for me compared to September.

 

July, Sept, and Oct were all about the same for me, within 5% of each other (pretty much my baseline store performance that I expect to hit every month).  August was a great month, 23% up vs July or September.

 

April was my worst month this year by far.  -58% of my October number.  

 

Nov, Dec, Jan have been my best three months the past three years running.  If this year follows trend, my December and January will be double my October!  November should be up +20-50% vs October.

 

I'm looking forward to the next three months!  Trying not to count my chickens before they hatch!

Message 10 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

Down 53% from October  and have not changed a thing; but I have 198 watchers which makes no sense; in fact I have had at least 180 watchers this month but still my worse month in 4 years.  

Message 11 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

Yep, October was my worst month this entire year. No doubt ebay is in serious trouble. Media reports show this platform lost billions of dollars in sales month over month this entire year vs. the previous year.

 

Here its the first of November and so far not a single sale today. I'm still going to remain hopeful that sales will pick up as the Holidays move forward.

 

Either way, the U.S. economy is not doing well, and you can thank Trump's tried and failed economic policies for running our nation into the ground. I know a lot of people like Trump, I have no problem with that, but his economics clearly do not work. That may not be what many want to hear, but that's the reality.

Message 12 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

Anonymous
Not applicable

 I have had no sales in over 31 days, So yes More like my sales are just gone....

Message 13 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

I was doing pretty good until the very end of the month when the item specific update happened. Ended up being down 25% to last month Sept. Still up to last to last year about 20%

Message 14 of 118
latest reply

Re: Now That October Is Over, How Much Were You Down? Worst Month?

Down 32.6% from last month and 64.9% from October of last year.

____________________________________

Always a newbie!
Message 15 of 118
latest reply