cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Sales tax

I sell from Oregon we have no sales tax. EBay adds sales tax to my sales and charges me 12.9%. We do not tax out of state purchasers. Why does EBay ?, except to charge me higher fees?

Message 1 of 53
latest reply
52 REPLIES 52

Re: Sales tax

Oh, my -- slid right over that one! Poor grammar or usage usual sets me off.  

Message 46 of 53
latest reply

Re: Sales tax

How is that accurate, though, unless it shows an average?  In Ohio, the property tax rates vary, depending on where you are.  In our municipality, for instance, we still have a school levy as well as a library levy and I believe the school levy will be on the ballot again in November.  They are also considering a law enforcement tax for fire and police services.  

Message 47 of 53
latest reply

Re: Sales tax

Before Wayfair vs Sth Dakota, most states which levied sales tax  based then on where the SELLER was, but after the decision on internet sales tax all states apparently decided to bring in a destination sales tax (based on where the BUYER lived) instead.

 

Of course most small online sellers would never have met the thresholds to have to collect and remit ST based on their own independent sales to said states anyway, hence the MFL where they made sure they could get ST from every single sale/seller based on the aggregate sales amounts made through said Marketplaces.

 

So whenever someone says "I'd rather ebay (et al) took a fee for doing the ST" just remember that but for the MFL you wouldn't have to (in most cases) anyway.

 

The collection & remittance of said Sales Taxes were not meant to be " a burden" for small sellers either, yet here we are having to pay FVF % fees on ST collected.

"If a product doesn't sell, raise the price" - Reese Palley
"If it sold FAST, it was priced too low" - also Reese Palley
Message 48 of 53
latest reply

Re: Sales tax


@maxine*j wrote:

@luckythewinner 

 

Ah!  So I was wrong about NJ, and PA is not quite as bad as I thought.  Teach me to work from memory!  😄


It's quite possible--and, in fact, probable--that there's nothing wrong with your memory.  😀 

 

According to the chart below, NJ does indeed have the highest property tax rate in the nation, and PA just makes the top ten. 

 

States Ranked By Property Tax 

 

States Ranked By Property Tax

Here is a list of states in order of lowest ranking property tax to highest:

 

Rank

State

Real Estate Tax Rate

Average Home Price

Annual Property Tax

1

Hawaii

0.28%

$615,300

$606

2

Alabama

0.41%

$142,700

$895

3

Colorado

0.51%

$343,300

$1,113

4

Louisiana

0.55%

$163,100

$1,187

5

District of Columbia

0.56%

$601,500

$1,221

6

South Carolina

0.57%

$162,300

$1,238

7

Delaware

0.57%

$251,100

$1,240

8

West Virginia

0.58%

$119,600

$1,269

9

Nevada

0.60%

$267,900

$1,310

10

Wyoming

0.61%

$220,500

$1,319

11

Arkansas

0.62%

$127,800

$1,358

12

Utah

0.63%

$279,100

$1,362

13

Arizona

0.66%

$225,500

$1,446

14

Idaho

0.69%

$212,300

$1,492

15

Tennessee

0.71%

$167,200

$1,548

16

California

0.76%

$505,000

$1,644

17

New Mexico

0.80%

$171,400

$1,740

18

Mississippi

0.81%

$119,000

$1,751

19

Virginia

0.82%

$273,100

$1,779

20

Montana

0.84%

$230,600

$1,818

21

North Carolina

0.84%

$172,500

$1,833

22

Indiana

0.85%

$141,700

$1,853

23

Kentucky

0.86%

$141,000

$1,866

24

Florida

0.89%

$215,300

$1,934

25

Oklahoma

0.90%

$136,800

$1,952

26

Georgia

0.92%

$176,000

$2,006

27

Missouri

0.97%

$157,200

$2,111

28

Oregon

0.97%

$312,200

$2,116

29

North Dakota

0.98%

$339,000

$2,138

30

Washington

0.98%

$193,900

$2,134

31

Maryland

1.09%

$314,800

$2,370

32

Minnesota

1.12%

$223,900

$2,429

33

Alaska

1.19%

$270,400

$2,599

34

Massachusetts

1.23%

$381,600

$2,667

35

South Dakota

1.31%

$167,100

$2,857

36

Maine

1.36%

$190,400

$2,953

37

Kansas

1.41%

$151,900

$3,060

38

Michigan

1.54%

$154,900

$3,343

39

Ohio

1.56%

$145,700

$3,390

40

Iowa

1.57%

$147,800

$3,407

41

Pennsylvania

1.58%

$180,200

$3,442

42

Rhode Island

1.63%

$261,900

$3,548

43

New York

1.72%

$313,700

$3,749

44

Nebraska

1.73%

$155,800

$3,754

45

Texas

1.80%

$172,500

$3,907

46

Wisconsin

1.85%

$180,600

$4,027

47

Vermont

1.90%

$227,700

$4,135

48

Connecticut

2.14%

$275,400

$4,658

49

New Hampshire

2.18%

$261,700

$4,738

50

Illinois

2.27%

$194,500

$4,942

51

New Jersey

2.49%

$335,600

$5,419

 

Please note: this data is based on WalletHub’s 2021 findings; however, the numbers pull from the 2019 census. So, you may see some fluctuation between the numbers mentioned above and other reports, particularly the median home value. Prices may also change depending on market influences.

Message 49 of 53
latest reply

Re: Sales tax


@toomuchstuffagain35 wrote:

Before Wayfair vs Sth Dakota, most states which levied sales tax  based then on where the SELLER was, but after the decision on internet sales tax all states apparently decided to bring in a destination sales tax (based on where the BUYER lived) instead...

 

 


No.  Sales tax is a type of consumption, or use tax;  therefore, the tax is at the point of consumption or use -- not at the point of sale.  (Of course, sometimes they are the same;  i.e., brick-and-mortar in Indiana charges anyone who buys something there the Indiana sales tax.)

 

When people bought from sellers who were either outside the state or within the state but not registered to collect sales tax, the buyer was supposed to report the purchase and remit the sales tax to the state. 

 

Of course, almost no one did.  And that was not considered too much of a loss until on-line sales grew into the many billions of dollars and that states were losing substantial sales tax revenue.  Thus, South Dakota vs Wayfair, et al.  Thus, marketplace facilitators must collect and remit sales taxes.

 

Wayfair, eBay, Amazon, Etsy, et al, all fought it for two reasons:  First, they knew that evading sales tax was one of the great drivers of e-commerce.  Second, they did not want the expense and responsibility of collecting and remitting the taxes.

 

-

Message 50 of 53
latest reply

Re: Sales tax

i reside in an 8.5% Sales Tax County......

2 miles South the auto dealership is in a 5.0% county....

If I buy a car there I am charged the 8.5% rate (my residence)

yet, if I buy a set of tires or virtually any other commodity like a high end home theater system or other 'big-ticket' item, I am charged 5.0% (location rate of car dealer)

 

my point is.....(particularly those who claim they wouldn't meet state thresholds to collect sales taxes)

don't think for a minute that if they did not come up with this "facilitator" law for sales tax collection, they wouldn't come up with a method/exception to collect/extract tax from your sales online.......

 

I will take this system (the lesser of two evils) that ebay handles it....

 

Message 51 of 53
latest reply

Re: Sales tax


@monica-sells wrote:

...  my point is.....(particularly those who claim they wouldn't meet state thresholds to collect sales taxes) don't think for a minute that if they did not come up with this "facilitator" law for sales tax collection, they wouldn't come up with a method/exception to collect/extract tax from your sales online.......

 

I will take this system (the lesser of two evils) that ebay handles it....

 


Absolutely.  And it's easy to see why, given what they states were losing. 


In 2019, Pennsylvania, the state I live in, started collecting sales tax from "marketplace facilitators" at the beginning of the fiscal year in July.  The estimate was that they'd see about $50.5 million in tax revenue a year.  But by the end of March, just seven months later, they'd already collected $151.4 million.  So they changed the projection to $200 million a year and, in fact, have done even better than that.  Other states experienced similar. 

 

At a time when more and more people are demanding more and more services, states could not continue to bleed away that much revenue.  In fact, there were two bills before the U.S. Congress to address the collection of sales taxes on-line, but they were allowed to die once the Supreme Court decided in favor of South Dakota.

 

-

Message 52 of 53
latest reply

Re: Sales tax

Good thing James Taylor isn’t  from Pennsylvania. “You Have a Friend” never would have been a hit.

Message 53 of 53
latest reply