Hoyne or hill? I think hill.. But?

[dtailsgrooming]

I'm wondering if this is by hill, or the boat is John a hill?? The work isn't quite up to standard of hoye, but wanted opinions!

Thanks!! 

  

 thank you in advance!! 

[mesodude]

It's John Hill's interpretation of a Thomas Hoyne painting called "First for Home".

[maxine*j]

---

@dtailsgrooming wrote:

I'm wondering if this is by hill, or the boat is John a hill?? The work isn't quite up to standard of hoye, but wanted opinions!

Thanks!! 

 

 thank you in advance!! 

---

It says: 

John [A?]  [G?] Hill

Original by Thomas Hoynell

Why can't it be just what it says it is?  A painting done by John Hill, who copied it from a famous painting called "Heading Home," painted by Thomas Hoynell? 

Or am I missing something?

[maxine*j]

Ooops!  Cross-post.   😃   (But I do think the title is "Heading Home".)

[argon38]

---

@maxine*j wrote:

Ooops!  Cross-post.   😃   (But I do think the title is "Heading Home".)

---

I agree, it's a copy of Hoyne's "Heading Home" (last picture here):

https://www.morphyauctions.com/jamesdjulia/item/lot-2609-thomas-m-hoyne-american-1924-1989-two-works... 

For comparison, this is Hoyne's "First for Home" (last picture here):

https://www.morphyauctions.com/jamesdjulia/item/lot-1018-thomas-m-hoyne-american-1924-1989-eight-wor... 

[dtailsgrooming]

Thanks!!

I couldn't find the same one by hoyne, and as it was written I wa t sure if it was saying the boat was called John a hill by hoyne.. 

Thanks for the answers!