Fake bag case on Judge Judy

[emerald40]

On Judge Judy, fake bag - Hermes - case.  $2,900 bag. Sold on CL

Plaintiff and defendant Met at Hermes Store. - Beverly Hills

She paid.  Took the bag and they parted ways.

Plaintiff contacted defendant again and pretended she wanted to buy another bag from him.  When he met her, her dad was there to grab him, telling him it was fake.  Grabbed his keys and would not let him go until his daughter got his money back.  He did not have it so theyTook all the information - from his driver's license  so they could sue.

On Judge Judy

Plaintiff had an authenticator - My Poupette.  She pointed out some of the discrepanices that indicated it was fake comparing it to a real bag.

Defendant listed on Craig's List what he claimed was his mom's Hermes Bag.  Judge Judy dug deep asking what mom did, dad did.  Mom unemployed.  Dad worked at Boeing making space shuttles.  Judy dug even deeper and learned he was a welder.  Hard to believe they could afford 2  expensive bags.

Judge Judy did not believe him.  Said defendant committed grand larceny.  She believed authenticator.

Said if bag was real it would be foolish for plaintiff to give it back

Said plaintiff needs to go to the Police Department.  And said judgment for plaintiff $2,900.

Then plaintiff said defendant was in the process of selling a 3rd bag.  Judy said she would be turning those bags to the Police Department where defendant would have to prove they were real before he got them back.

[chrysylys]

---

@emerald40wrote:

Grabbed his keys and would not let him go until his daughter got his money back.  He did not have it so theyTook all the information - from his driver's license  so they could sue.

---

At that point, Pop gets busted for unlawful confinement or possibly kidnapping.

[emerald40]

---

@chrysylyswrote:

---

@emerald40wrote:

Grabbed his keys and would not let him go until his daughter got his money back.  He did not have it so theyTook all the information - from his driver's license  so they could sue.

---

At that point, Pop gets busted for unlawful confinement or possibly kidnapping.

_________________________________________________

Not in Judy's eyes.

---

[chrysylys]

TV personalities have no authority.  Prosecutors and police do.

Pop's lucky he didn't get shot.

[dougsue123b]

Only a fool would buy a 2900 dollar bag on craigslist.

[southern*sweet*tea]

---

@dougsue123bwrote:

Only a fool would buy a 2900 dollar bag on craigslist.

---

Well you know what they say about a fool and his money...

[emerald40]

---

@chrysylyswrote:

TV personalities have no authority.  Prosecutors and police do.

Pop's lucky he didn't get shot.

______________________________________

Judy is a real judge with authority.

When you go on her show you agree to abide by her decision.

And the poor scammer was detained for a bit until he gave up his information.  I feel so bad for him.

---

[candd205]

I'm sitting here watching this same show right now too.

[emerald40]

---

@southern*sweet*teawrote:

---

@dougsue123bwrote:

Only a fool would buy a 2900 dollar bag on craigslist.

---

Well you know what they say about a fool and his money...

______________________________________

Judy did give a dig at the Plaintiff, about her living at home and paying $2,900 for a pocketbook.

---

[sharingtheland]

---

@emerald40wrote:

---

@chrysylyswrote:

TV personalities have no authority.  Prosecutors and police do.

Pop's lucky he didn't get shot.

______________________________________

Judy is a real judge with authority.

When you go on her show you agree to abide by her decision.

And the poor scammer was detained for a bit until he gave up his information.  I feel so bad for him.

---

---

---

@emerald40wrote:

---

@chrysylyswrote:

TV personalities have no authority.  Prosecutors and police do.

Pop's lucky he didn't get shot.

______________________________________

Judy is a real judge with authority.

When you go on her show you agree to abide by her decision.

And the poor scammer was detained for a bit until he gave up his information.  I feel so bad for him.

---

---

She's not acting as a judge on her tv show; she's an arbitrator.  Both parties agree to abide by her decision.

That asking about professions and salaries and who couldn't afford the purses is pure theatrics.

[emerald40]

---

@sharingthelandwrote:

---

@emerald40wrote:

---

@chrysylyswrote:

TV personalities have no authority.  Prosecutors and police do.

Pop's lucky he didn't get shot.

______________________________________

Judy is a real judge with authority.

When you go on her show you agree to abide by her decision.

And the poor scammer was detained for a bit until he gave up his information.  I feel so bad for him.

---

---

---

@emerald40wrote:

---

@chrysylyswrote:

TV personalities have no authority.  Prosecutors and police do.

Pop's lucky he didn't get shot.

______________________________________

Judy is a real judge with authority.

When you go on her show you agree to abide by her decision.

And the poor scammer was detained for a bit until he gave up his information.  I feel so bad for him.

---

---

She's not acting as a judge on her tv show; she's an arbitrator.  Both parties agree to abide by her decision.

That asking about professions and salaries and who couldn't afford the purses is pure theatrics.

______________________________________________

IMO very germane to the case.

---

[chrysylys]

---

@emerald40wrote:

Defendant listed on Craig's List what he claimed was his mom's Hermes Bag.  Judge Judy dug deep asking what mom did, dad did.  Mom unemployed.  Dad worked at Boeing making space shuttles.  Judy dug even deeper and learned he was a welder.  Hard to believe they could afford 2  expensive bags.

---

That act alone eliminates all credibility on her part.  Though in my eyes, she never had any.

[southern*sweet*tea]

@sharingthelandwrote:

That asking about professions and salaries and who couldn't afford the purses is pure theatrics.

Not necessarily.  Our income is roughly $1800/mo.  It would be mighty sketchy for me to be buying a $2800 bag. Heck, my truck didn't cost me that much!  I'd be suspicious of me, too lol

[sharingtheland]

---

@southern*sweet*teawrote:

@sharingthelandwrote:

That asking about professions and salaries and who couldn't afford the purses is pure theatrics.

Not necessarily.  Our income is roughly $1800/mo.  It would be mighty sketchy for me to be buying a $2800 bag. Heck, my truck didn't cost me that much!  I'd be suspicious of me, too lol

---

Income?  You have income?  You got us beat, lol.

Doesn't mean we don't have more than a few things we could sell for far more than the price of a Hermes bag.  

[southern*sweet*tea]

oh heck, not my Ebay income lol  Family income as a whole.

Heck, our entire houseful of stuff wouldn't amount to $2800

I hate when threads get moved to the cafe