08-11-2025 02:30 PM
Full screen message came from eBay today about ai answering messages for you!
There are only two choices to close the message:
1. (Maybe later)
2. (Enable eBay.ai)
I needed a third choice like:
3. (Never)
08-12-2025 08:09 AM
It would keep me awake at night thinking that
ebay AI was speaking for me with my potential buyers.
It's my responsibility to do it all. Always has been.
08-12-2025 08:10 AM
@valueaddedresource wrote:But that doesn't mean sellers shouldn't maybe disclose that use themselves and it definitely does mean that should any of the information provided in the AI answer be incorrect, it will be the seller who is deemed at fault in any disputes or claims.
No doubt. But with that process as it stands, making the seller actually read and have some interaction with the response before actually sending it, that seems reasonable.
You could probably add your own boilerplate disclaimer to the outgoing AI-generated reply (e.g. something similar to Google: "AI responses may include mistakes.") OTOH, telling your buyer to disregard your reply probably wouldn't go over all that well. 🙄
08-12-2025 08:15 AM - edited 08-12-2025 08:24 AM
More testing just for fun.
The AI also did fairly well making connections and inferences from the description - for example while the description never uses the word "boat" explicitly, it correctly answers this question by understanding that since the description says it is for marine applications and safe on fiberglass and gelcoat, it would be suitable for use on a boat.
And it also caught this attempt to throw a curveball, identifying that the item in question would not have any memory capacity.
08-12-2025 08:17 AM
I wish it would tone down that ridiculously cheerful writing style. Something does not get more exciting just because you ended the sentence with an exclamation point!
08-12-2025 08:17 AM
@dirk12955 wrote:It would keep me awake at night thinking that
ebay AI was speaking for me with my potential buyers.
It's my responsibility to do it all. Always has been.
@dirk12955 look at my screenshots above - there is no part of the process that is automated and no chance eBay AI will be "speaking for you" without your explicit knowledge, participation, and opportunity to edit the AI generated text before it is sent to the potential buyer.
08-12-2025 08:19 AM
@a_c_green wrote:I wish it would tone down that ridiculously cheerful writing style. Something does not get more exciting just because you ended the sentence with an exclamation point!
@a_c_green agreed!!!! 😂 And honestly, I would find the "Hey!" greeting a little over the top/off putting as a buyer.
08-12-2025 08:36 AM
@a_c_green wrote:I wish it would tone down that ridiculously cheerful writing style. Something does not get more exciting just because you ended the sentence with an exclamation point!
I do that, though. I worked chat support for a huge company at one point, and found that it seemed to have a significant impact on my customer satisfaction scores when I ended many (usually at least half) of my sentences in exclamation marks. I don't know the psychology behind it exactly, but in my experience it worked! (Yes, I added that exclamation mark intentionally! And that one! And... you get the picture.)
08-12-2025 08:37 AM
@valueaddedresource wrote:
@dirk12955 wrote:It would keep me awake at night thinking that
ebay AI was speaking for me with my potential buyers.
It's my responsibility to do it all. Always has been.
@dirk12955 look at my screenshots above - there is no part of the process that is automated and no chance eBay AI will be "speaking for you" without your explicit knowledge, participation, and opportunity to edit the AI generated text before it is sent to the potential buyer.
That's the biggest factor in making me actually consider it instead of just rejecting it outright. I have to see what my boss says, but I suspect we'll try it out a bit. If we do, I'll try to come back here and show some more examples of what it tells our customers. Thanks for the ones you've provided so far!
08-12-2025 08:42 AM
@jonathanbrightlight wrote:
@a_c_green wrote:I wish it would tone down that ridiculously cheerful writing style. Something does not get more exciting just because you ended the sentence with an exclamation point!
I do that, though. I worked chat support for a huge company at one point, and found that it seemed to have a significant impact on my customer satisfaction scores when I ended many (usually at least half) of my sentences in exclamation marks. I don't know the psychology behind it exactly, but in my experience it worked! (Yes, I added that exclamation mark intentionally! And that one! And... you get the picture.)
@jonathanbrightlight you just reminded me of my very first ecommerce job in 2007. I was the only woman out of 4 employees who handled incoming customer service via emails and live chat but they assigned female screen names to the guys because A/B testing showed the company's customers were nicer to the rep and more willing to accept whatever answers/resolution were offered if they thought they were talking to a woman. 😂
08-12-2025 09:07 AM
@valueaddedresource wrote:@jonathanbrightlight you just reminded me of my very first ecommerce job in 2007. I was the only woman out of 4 employees who handled incoming customer service via emails and live chat but they assigned female screen names to the guys because A/B testing showed the company's customers were nicer to the rep and more willing to accept whatever answers/resolution were offered if they thought they were talking to a woman. 😂
I worked technical support, so it was often the opposite according to my female coworkers. They had customers that would ask to be transferred once they heard a woman's voice (while I was working phone support) or saw a woman's name (on the chat support). Or even would get crude or abusive in rare occasions. None of that was super common, but it did happen.
08-12-2025 09:36 AM
Nothing says "good customer service" like an AI-generated response to a buyer's message.
08-12-2025 09:37 AM
@jonathanbrightlight wrote:
@valueaddedresource wrote:@jonathanbrightlight you just reminded me of my very first ecommerce job in 2007. I was the only woman out of 4 employees who handled incoming customer service via emails and live chat but they assigned female screen names to the guys because A/B testing showed the company's customers were nicer to the rep and more willing to accept whatever answers/resolution were offered if they thought they were talking to a woman. 😂
I worked technical support, so it was often the opposite according to my female coworkers. They had customers that would ask to be transferred once they heard a woman's voice (while I was working phone support) or saw a woman's name (on the chat support). Or even would get crude or abusive in rare occasions. None of that was super common, but it did happen.
@jonathanbrightlight yeah I got that when I worked for a company that sold boat parts. Some guys had a difficult time believing a girl could possibly help them....until I pulled rank and told them I had my "6 pack" captain's license. 😂
08-12-2025 11:20 AM
You've given me some food for thought.
I don't use many exclamation points in this type of writing unless I'm particularly enthused to thank someone for great service.
But I can see how it may soften the conversation and convey a sense of enthusiasm and maybe even warmth. Maybe it's time to up my exclamation point game.
Or should I say, Maybe it's time to up my exclamation point game!
08-12-2025 01:07 PM
A problem I have with AI is that it basically gathers data and stores it. To my knowledge there's never been advancements in technology that haven't been abused by someone.
Where does this data all end up? Who will have access to it in the future? Will they use it for nefarious purposes?
These questions give me pause when willfully having contact with AI. It's one thing to get burglarized but another to leave your doors unlocked all the time. If a burgular wants in bad enough they will but I don't want to make it easy for them.
Just my take in general on AI.....................
08-12-2025 04:49 PM
@adamcartwright wrote:You've given me some food for thought.
I don't use many exclamation points in this type of writing unless I'm particularly enthused to thank someone for great service.
But I can see how it may soften the conversation and convey a sense of enthusiasm and maybe even warmth. Maybe it's time to up my exclamation point game.
I have to say that exclamation points in business communications simply drive me in the opposite direction. I don't know this person and I don't believe for a minute that they're genuinely thrilled, or something, to be communicating with me about my problems with my washing machine drain pump. Just give me the help I requested and stop fawning over me.
On a similar note, I loathe those scripted responses from people who want to congratulate me on how long I've been a customer! Especially when they then regret that they cannot help me! I am reasonably sure that they did not spring out of bed that morning, hoping that I would call.
And finally... (don't stop me; I'm on a roll...) do not open your voicemail system greeting by
Um, where was I? Oh, yeah, exclamation points. I'm against them. Thank you!