cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Offensive Materials? Huh?

Today I received two notifications on two items which I have had listed for months/years- a folk art art doll of a Black American man (not a caricature) wearing a tie, and an antique photograph of a Black American maid holding a White child. Neither item depicts any possible characteristic of racial mockery or denigration. I must say that I find it personally offensive that ebay would even suggest such a thing about them. What on God's Earth is happening? I'm 60 years old and have been an ebay seller for 19 years with a 100 percent rating. Has the world lost its mind?

Message 1 of 122
latest reply
121 REPLIES 121

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?

It looks like they're slashing and burning the entire black Americana category. I got something taken down too. It's absolutely insane. eBay hates us, that much is clear.

Message 2 of 122
latest reply

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?

Updated policy due to recent national events-

https://community.ebay.com/t5/Selling/Offensive-Materials-Policy-Update/m-p/31015263#M1609128

 

The published policy leaves room for plenty of subjectivity on eBay's part about what's considered offensive so let's try to figure out what parts of it caused your listing removals.

 

The announcement mentions dolls specifically, and the policy says no photos that portray racial stereotyping- I think those two areas are where your listings got caught up.

Message 4 of 122
latest reply

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?

Anonymous
Not applicable

So they just removed the whole entire Black Americana category?  So Ebay thinks Black American history is offensive? Should I remove my Vintage Avon Black American Barbie as well?

Message 5 of 122
latest reply

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?

It is absolutely absurd that eBay has the nerve to decide what else is now "offensive" when they literally are in a scandal where people were sent pig's blood. 

Message 6 of 122
latest reply

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?


@fern*wood wrote:

Looks like the policy changed today.

 

 
 
 
 

It appears that history can be changed or at least hidden merely because it is deemed offensive by someone.  I remember my Polish mother telling a joke about why some Polish people wanted to be buried face down so that people that tell dumb Polish joke can kis their posterior.  Frankly, I think she thought it was humorous but I suppose there are those that would take offense.

 

Of course, as a Vietnam veteran I suppose I've been a bit desensitized from the treatment received when I came home.  I guess it's a good thing that I didn't run off to Canada to dodge the draft so that people today still have the right to be offended.  Of course, if we get to the point that we hide and deny history, successive generations may think that it never happened.    

"It is an intelligent man that is aware of his own ignorance."
Message 7 of 122
latest reply

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?

Can we still sell Aunt Jemima pancake mix? lol.

 

This is so stupid.

Message 8 of 122
latest reply

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?

In Santa Barbara, the original (1957) Sambo's (restaurant and pancake house) - the first and the only one left - is changing it's name because people found it offensive, after 63 years.

Not saying 'NO' doesn't mean 'YES'.

The foolishness of one's actions or words is determined by the number of witnesses.

Perhaps if Brains were described as an APP, many people would use them more often.

Respect, like money, is only of 'worth' when it is earned - with all due respect, it can not be ordained, legislated or coerced. Anonymous
Message 9 of 122
latest reply

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?


@voguevintage wrote:

Can we still sell Aunt Jemima pancake mix? lol.

 

This is so stupid.


I'm not sure for how long.  With "Gone With The Wind" being removed from HBO's Vaults and cartoon characters being disarmed who knows.  Of course, I'm wondering if they're going to get around to banning video games like "Mortal Combat" anytime soon?!

"It is an intelligent man that is aware of his own ignorance."
Message 10 of 122
latest reply

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?

Hattie McDaniel was the first black woman to win an Oscar for her role in Gone with the Wind.

 

When they go full PC cancel culture, they end up hurting the very people they think they're protecting.

Message 11 of 122
latest reply

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?

Short answer - yes it has.

Message 12 of 122
latest reply

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?

@unimay1 

 

...no Sir./Maam.,  only America has lost its mind as US history is about erasing and re-writing just how it happened in China, Vietnam, North Korea, and many socialist and communist countries...

Message 13 of 122
latest reply

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?

@7606dennis 

 

...on behalf of my other side, the Vietnamese families, friends, co-workers, whom escaped the socialist and communist North Vietnam after the fall of South Vietnam on 4/30/1975, I greatly appreciate your sacrifice during the Vietnam War...it will never be forgotten...

 

...our Americans are too naive to embrace the socialist and communist philosophy...one day when our people realized the truth then it's too late...

 

...May God bless you and yours...

Message 14 of 122
latest reply

Re: Offensive Materials? Huh?

What is sad is how eBay picks and chooses what is offensive as it suits their interests. Why pretend to care if you aren't going to be proactive? With all of the recent news about "Gone with the Wind" is everything related to that movie gonna get pulled? Somehow I doubt it. What about other items that are portray an offensive depiction of other minorities? Granted with most major corporations it is all lip service to keep good in the public eye. It would be nice to see eBay produce a manifesto of some sort of what their ideals are.
Message 15 of 122
latest reply