Unfair eBay Practices | Trading Cards

jefhols-48 · 2026-01-07T03:15:33.701000Z

I had 2 2019 Epoch Shohei Ohtani One & Only cards that were a Numbered Limited Edition of Only 11 of each card. Now, both of these cards were Professionally Graded By PSA & All Certification Numbers were Verified. There was Only 3 of these 11 cards Graded By PSA; (2) PSA8'S & (1) PSA9. I had (1) of the PSA8'S AND THE ONLY PSA9. I sold the PSA8 that I had; 2 weeks later, I sent a message to the buyer and offer to buy the Only PSA9 of this card for $100 more than what he paid for 1 of the 2 PSA9'S that he already purchased. He in turn didn't hesitate a minute for that offer. Both transactions were handled through eBay, so they got payment for their selling fees. All honest & straight forward. Under the eBay Authenticity Guarantee, they ALLEGEDLY found an issue with a PSA Graded baseball card, but would NOT revile the Reason. My buyer received a FULL REFUND on a $750 purchase, and as the seller; I kept my income that I made from this purchase. I am so frustrated and confused. My buyer Never received or requested a refund on this Extremely Rare & Expensive sports card. I keep my money from selling it, the buyer received a full and complete refund; & eBay TAKES POSSESSION OF IT!! I don't care whether you are an eBay seller, an eBay buyer, or both. I don't care how you look at this situation, eBay took over control of this rare sports card by false pretensions, and that is Totally Unfair to My Repeat Customer, & Makes Me Look Bad as a Seller. My buyer is just as confused as I am about the decision by eBay. I want any kind of response from the eBay community about their thoughts. But, I believe that eBay is using unfair tactics, I completed 2 fair and honest transactions on a rare graded sports cards to the same buyer within a 2 week period; and eBay pretty much TOOK POSSESSION OF THE 2nd ONE, My Buyer Should File A Complaint Against eBay, I would. What Are Your Thoughts???

Discussions

Unfair eBay Practices | Trading Cards | eBay Community