sales Tax of shipping from the USPS....
Once and for all, YES, ebay is ripping us off. BUT, to understand, you need to pull out your dictionary and look up 2 words.....1) shipping....2) postage......these are 2 completely different words with different definitions and these words are NOT INTERCHANGABLE. So when you are quoting me laws on taxing shipping, those laws are about SHIPPING and NOT postage. Furthermore, postage isn't a "part" of shipping. POSTAGE IS POSTAGE, otherwise the the USPS would charge you tax on the "shipping" portion of the price of a postage stamp. BUT THEY DONT. New York is one of the states that does charge sales tax on "shipping" BUT NOT on POSTAGE. So when Ebay charges me 8% on shipping, and the seller uses the USPS to "ship" who does EBAY send that 8% to? Thats what EVERYONE IN THIS ARGUMENT SEEMS TO FORGET....collected taxes must be DELIVERED to the STATES that COLLECT sales tax. A tax is not a penalty that you pay. If NYS wanted 8% sales tax on POSTAGE, every person in NY who every bought a stamp would owe money to the state of NY Dept of Taxation, "postage stamp dept"......but they dont collect it, never have never will. That why when EBAY "collects" sales tax, WHAT DO THEY DO WITH THE MONEY???? And unless you work for EBAY, you have no idea, you can only guess. I dont want to hear your guesses. Does EBAY send the collected tax money to the state of NY dept of taxation? Under what pretense? That its shipping? Postage is NOT SHIPPING...if it were SHIPPING, NY state tax law would force the post office to COLLECT tax LIKE EBAY COLLECTS TAX. So why doesnt NY states department of taxation collect tax from the post office....because its not shipping...SHIPPING is a service done by a shipping company. The USPS is not a shipping company. If they were, they'd be charging shipping sales tax. So who gets the money EBAY collects? Either EBAY gets to keep it. Or they simply send the various states lump sums and tell them this money was collected for shipping even though a percentage of that lump sum was tax free USPS postage. SO NO! dont try to say this state and that state charges tax on shipping and EBAY simply follows the law. Buyers on EBAY are getting RIPPED OFF...either by EBAY being too lazy to separate postal delivery from FedEx type delivery or the State Taxation Depts that are collecting and keeping tax money on postage that is tax exempt. Either way, the buyer loses and its wrong. Tax on shipping FedEx? Yes. On United Parcel Service? Yes. United States Postal Service? NO, NO, NO. end of rant
stainlessenginecovers
per the interwebs:
'shipping is the transportation of goods while postage is the charge for posting an item"
So 'postage' is the beef patty between the 2 buns, and when you put the 3 things together:
Hamburger
Tax is on the Hamburger.
End of lesson.
house*of*paws
Hi @koacrazy
The Marketplace Facilitator Tax laws are a new breed of tax laws that began in 2017. Each state enacted its own laws, which eBay is obliged to follow ... just like other online selling venues.
There's no need to look for consistency between what is taxed when you buy something online ... as compared to buying a similar item in a B&M store or at the post office. The MFT laws stand on their own.
If you feel eBay isn't taxing shipping correctly according to the tax laws of NY State ... you will have to contact the Treasurer of the State of New York and ask them to advise eBay about their wrongful taxing activities.
janet9988
As a buyer is paying the COST of getting the item delivered you will be charged the sales/use tax.
If you were buying the actual shipping/postage from USPS you would NOT be charged sales/use tax.
ms.rodriguez*
If you are a seller complaining about your buyers paying a sales tax, don't waste your breath. Sure , you are paying a bit more in commissions to ebay. Just raise your prices. You need to do what Macy's does. (God, I love that store.) Does Macy's complain because someone bought an item and used a Visa credit card to pay for it and ship it. The buyer lives in NY. Does Macy's complain because they have to pay additional fees to Visa because the buyer used a non-Macys credit card and also lives in NY where shipping is taxed? NO. Macy's makes sure that their prices pay for ALL of Macy's bills, the shipping, the credit card fees, the shipping supplies, etc. etc. You , as a seller , must do what Macy's does.
Also to the poster, when you signed onto to ebay, you agreed to everything ebay wanted to do. One of the things that they did was add the commission to the shipping fee because so many people where selling 100 items for 99 cents and 100.oo shipping. Those sellers were paying an ebay fee on 99 cents . They were avoiding paying fees. So now , it does not matter if the item is 99 cents + 100.oo shipping or 100.99 with free shipping, or 100.oo plus 99 cents shipping. Ebay's commission is identical. YOU AGREED TO THIS CHANGE.
The solution is simple. Price your items higher. If you have too many low priced items, don't list anymore of those.
richard1rst
Professor Irwin Corey, famous for nonsensical statements, would no doubt be proud of yours. He would probably respond:
We must all be aware that Protocol takes Precedence over Procedure.
koacrazy
OPmeanwhile, in the world outside of ebay, if i buy a product from the store, I pay sales tax...when i take that to the post office and ship it, there is no sales tax on the shipping....how will Irwin Corey explain that? Factually, when you combine purchase price WITH shipping, then the TOTAL price is taxed....but...when the purchase price and the shipping price w USPS are done one at a time, independently of each other, then only the purchase price is taxed NOT the shipping if the shipping is done at the USPS......what law of nature or of economics says that the purchase price MUST be combined w the shipping price? ....the fact that you dont understand the difference between the words "combined" and "separate" would make the professor very happy indeed.
monica-sells
myangelandmyprincess
When I buy anything online I pay taxes on the full cost including shipping as that is the law in my state...that's eBay, Amazon, gap, children's place, Mercari, etc I pay tax on the shipping.
If I sell something on eBay and buy a label to ship on eBay I do not pay taxes on that label.
Paying a tax on the shipping portion of a purchase is not the same buying shipping from the post office.
marnotom!
There is no sales tax on the postage, I think you mean.
You purchase “postage†from the post office.
An eBay buyer purchases “shipping (and handling)†from the seller. The seller resells the postage as a shipping service. They are not selling postage because they are not USPS or an authorized agent of USPS.
janet9988
Correct...and this is also true on ebay.
The SELLER is the one going to the post office to buy the shipping label and not charged tax.
The buyer is not purchasing the label.........the buyer just pays for it as part of acquiring the item.
monroe67
"Once and for all, YES, ebay is ripping us off. . . .
Tax on shipping FedEx? Yes. On United Parcel Service? Yes. United States Postal Service? NO, NO, NO. end of rant"
Well. I'm not totally sure, but I think the OP thinks eBay is applying New York's sales tax laws inaccurately.
Can the OP actually quote a New York State law or regulation that says (i.e., "proves" his "point")
-- the money paid by a buyer
-- to send his/her purchase to him/her in New York State (from anywhere)
-- is not subject to New York State sales tax only when the United States Postal Service delivers the item to the buyer
BUT
-- the money paid by a buyer
-- to send his/her purchase to him/her in New York State (from anywhere)
-- IS subject to New York State sales tax when Federal Express or United Parcel Service or another "shipping company" delivers the item?
BTW, who defines "shipping company"?
OP says: "The USPS is not a shipping company." OP could be right. Perhaps the USPS is a philatelic supply and support organization that delivers letters, bills, magazines, and holiday gifts as smaller lines of business, on the side.
Maybe OP is right, though. I certainly don't know every law in every state and territory. I know for sure that the state where I live does not require me to pay sales tax on the amount I pay to have my eBay or QVC or Amazon purchases delivered to me. By any delivery service. As my eBay selling ID, I trust that eBay calculates sales taxes legally and appropriately.
koacrazy
OPthe tax on shipping thru the USPS is ONLY taxable when the shipping is INCLUDED in the price of the object. If the USPS shipping were a "separate" sale, then no sales tax can be applied to the shipping.....EBAY does not allow each sale to be separate. They force the seller to combine the shipping and the sale price into one single price and tax the entire thing. If I sell an object on ebay, but were allowed to connect with the buyer and offer them a separate shipping charge at the USPS, that shipping would be sales tax free because it was not included in the sale. They use the excuse that they want to keep ebay safe with no transaction being outside of ebay but it simply is bull**bleep** and buyers end up paying 8% more on shipping for no real reason...there is no law that says shipping has to be included in the total cost of any object in the country....only in ebay world.
monroe67
"the tax on shipping thru the USPS is ONLY taxable when the shipping is INCLUDED in the price of the object. If the USPS shipping were a "separate" sale, then no sales tax can be applied to the shipping.....EBAY does not allow each sale to be separate. They force the seller to combine the shipping and the sale price into one single price and tax the entire thing. If I sell an object on ebay, but were allowed to connect with the buyer and offer them a separate shipping charge at the USPS, that shipping would be sales tax free because it was not included in the sale. They use the excuse that they want to keep ebay safe with no transaction being outside of ebay but it simply is bull**bleep** and buyers end up paying 8% more on shipping for no real reason...there is no law that says shipping has to be included in the total cost of any object in the country....only in ebay world."
I tried to respond point-by-point to this confused/confusing response to me, but it occurred to me it would probably be a waste of my time and thought and energy.
Sales taxes are determined by U.S. state governments, and sometimes also by counties and cities or other governmental entities. Those governmental bodies get to choose what types of things are taxable or non-taxable (clothing, prepared food for immediate consumption, shipping costs, etc.), and those governmental bodies get to choose how much they want to receive in taxes, expressed as a percentage. These sales tax laws vary widely and wildly across the USA, and probably also through Canadian provinces, etc., etc.
eBay is required by law to apply those taxes, based on the category any product or item is listed in and the zip code provided by the buyer for delivery.
The only eBay buyers who "end up paying 8% more on shipping" do so for two very real reasons: Those buyers choose to have their eBay purchases (1) delivered to a state which has decided that they -- that specific state -- will impose and collect sales tax on the cost of delivery/shipping/postage, and (2) that specific state imposes an 8% sales tax rate at that delivery zip code.
If the OP is concerned that some of his/her eBay buyers might have to pay more than other eBay buyers, he/she might want to remind their buyers of the simple fact that: "Some states require that sales tax be charged on the amount of postage."
monica-sells
sorry...not saying i disagree with your thinking, but the legal definition indicates your logic is flawed.......
"...Charges by the vendor or seller for preparation and delivery to a location designated by the consumer of taxable tangible personal property or of a taxable service, including charges for transportation, shipping, postage, handling, crating, and packing, are defined as part of the price for determining the tax..."
myangelandmyprincess
I'll continue with New York.
New York charges taxes on the full amount paid the merchant including shipping.
If the shipping charge is a separate bill not paid at the same time it is not taxable.
Paying tax at USPS is not comparable it's not the same thing. No state pays taxes at USPS.
ms.rodriguez*
I agree and I am from NY.
koacrazy
OPexactly, NY does not charge tax on postal services, EBAY forces a tax to be paid because they will not allow the buyer to purchase their own shipping. EBAY wants everything nice and neat and within the confines of EBAY, at the buyers unnecessary expense. If I buy an object on ebay i pay sales tax....if the shipper did shipping outside of ebay, there would be no sales tax charged on shipping is the USPS was used to ship. So the tax is not on the SHIPPING, its on the SHIPPING being INCLUDED in the sales price.
myangelandmyprincess
You are misunderstanding me.
If the shipping or postage cost is part of the initial price you pay for a purchase it is taxable in New York. So if you buy something on eBay for $200and $100 shipping you pay for all that at one time $300 all will be taxable in New York.
If you purchase somewhere and you pay $200 upfront and then are later billed paying separately for the $100 shipping you will then ONLY be taxed on the $200.
eBay is correctly charging tax on the $300 in accordance with the new York tax laws.
Buying stamps directly at the post office is not comparable no state charges tax on that.
monica-sells
"...EBAY forces a tax to be paid because they will not allow the buyer to purchase their own shipping..."
huh? What online venue allows you to designate your own tax free shipper?
myangelandmyprincess
This ^^^. Generally the only time a shipping charge ends up being separate in online purchases is with freight shipped items. And with eBay that can be the case as well...
Every online venue I've bought from it has been one payment for both the item and shipping
Unavailable member
If the buyer's state or municipality laws state to charge tax on shipping that is what ebay must do as required by law.
The buyer's state or municipality receives the tax eBay collects.
If you have a gripe about shipping tax speak to your congressmen.
When I buy anything on the internet whether it's on eBay, Amazon etc I pay a tax on shipping. It's not exclusive only to ebay.
koacrazy
OPclearly you dont know the difference between shipping and postage...answer me this...if "your state" charges sales tax on "shipping" why dont you pay sales tax when you "ship" a letter at the post office?
eburtonlab
if "your state" charges sales tax on "shipping" why dont you pay sales tax when you "ship" a letter at the post office?
Here is what the New York state government has to say about sales tax on shipping:
https://www.tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/tg_bulletins/st/shipping_and_delivery_charges.htm
"When a taxable product or service is sold, any charges for shipping or delivery that the seller includes on the bill become part of the receipt subject to sales tax."
"[A]ny charges for shipping or delivery" includes postage purchased at the post office.
There is an example that explicitly refers to shipping through the mail where the postage amount is subject to sales tax:
It seems the New York government did not write the law in such a way that postage is exempt from sales tax when a taxable item is purchased and delivered through the mail to a customer.