That is more or less correct but is a seller offers the option for in store pick up then Illinois tax does not need to be collected on shipping even if it is shipped.
Example 1. An Illinois customer makes an Internet purchase from a retailer who also has brick-and-mortar stores. A customer selects property from a retailer's website, clicks the "add to shopping cart" button and proceeds to "check out." The online retailer adds the price of the items in the shopping cart, for a total price of $200. The online retailer then prompts the customer to click on the box corresponding to the method by which the customer prefers to obtain the merchandise (e.g., USPS or other common ground carrier for $12.99, two-day delivery for $18.50, Next Day Air for $33.50, or the option to pick up the property for no extra charge at the retailer's store). The customer clicks on the ground carrier box for delivery to the purchaser's home. The retailer then calculates the total price of the order ($200 + $12.99 = $212.99). The cost of the property and the cost of shipping are separately identified on the invoice when the property is delivered. Because the delivery charge is separately identified on the purchaser's invoice, and the purchaser had the option to pick up the property rather than having it shipped, there is no inseparable link between the purchase of the property and the outgoing transportation and delivery charges. Therefore, the delivery is a service separate and distinct from the sale of the items and the shipping fees received by the retailer are not part of the retailer’s gross receipts subject to Illinois sales tax. The taxable amount is $200.00.
I am not sure if Ebay would be willing to split this hair.
Your quote from the VedderPrice website is incomplete. You quoted only Example 1:
"Example 1.An Illinois customer makes an Internet purchase from a retailer who also has brick-and-mortar stores. A customer selects property from a retailer's website, clicks the "add to shopping cart" button and proceeds to "check out." The online retailer adds the price of the items in the shopping cart, for a total price of $200. The online retailer then prompts the customer to click on the box corresponding to the method by which the customer prefers to obtain the merchandise (e.g., USPS or other common ground carrier for $12.99, two-day delivery for $18.50, Next Day Air for $33.50, or the option to pick up the property for no extra charge at the retailer's store). The customer clicks on the ground carrier box for delivery to the purchaser's home. The retailer then calculates the total price of the order ($200 + $12.99 = $212.99). The cost of the property and the cost of shipping are separately identified on the invoice when the property is delivered. Because the delivery charge is separately identified on the purchaser's invoice, and the purchaser had the option to pick up the property rather than having it shipped, there is no inseparable link between the purchase of the property and the outgoing transportation and delivery charges. Therefore, the delivery is a service separate and distinct from the sale of the items and the shipping fees received by the retailer are not part of the retailer’s gross receipts subject to Illinois sales tax. The taxable amount is $200.00."
Here's Example 2 from the same page:
"Example 2. An Illinois customer makes an Internet purchase from a retailer without a brick-and-mortar store. Assume the same facts as Example 1, except the customer is not given the option of picking up the item. Because the tangible personal property could not be sold to the customer without including delivery, there is an inseparable link between the purchase and the delivery, and the charges for delivery are included in taxable gross receipts. The taxable amount is $212.99."
Summary: Example 1: taxable amount is $200.00. Example 2: taxable amount is $212.99.
By the way, that link to VedderPrice that you were so kind to include -- it is dated April of 2016.
"I am not sure if Ebay would be willing to split this hair."
Actually, eBay is quite capable of "splitting this hair" and I daresay they do it all day, every day. Because all those variables are separate items that are entered in the seller's listing: Is in-person pickup available? Is the shipping cost listed separately? (meaning, Does this item not have "free shipping"?) Can the buyer choose between USPS or FedEx or other premium delivery company (and pay the premium cost)?
lacemaker3
I'm sorry, but that does not appear to be correct, not since 2016.
https://www.taxjar.com/blog/shipping-taxable-in-illinois
mmadigan
That is more or less correct but is a seller offers the option for in store pick up then Illinois tax does not need to be collected on shipping even if it is shipped.
https://www.vedderprice.com/illinois-amended-its-regulations-to-clarify-the-taxation-of-shipping-and-handling-charges
Example 1. An Illinois customer makes an Internet purchase from a retailer who also has brick-and-mortar stores. A customer selects property from a retailer's website, clicks the "add to shopping cart" button and proceeds to "check out." The online retailer adds the price of the items in the shopping cart, for a total price of $200. The online retailer then prompts the customer to click on the box corresponding to the method by which the customer prefers to obtain the merchandise (e.g., USPS or other common ground carrier for $12.99, two-day delivery for $18.50, Next Day Air for $33.50, or the option to pick up the property for no extra charge at the retailer's store). The customer clicks on the ground carrier box for delivery to the purchaser's home. The retailer then calculates the total price of the order ($200 + $12.99 = $212.99). The cost of the property and the cost of shipping are separately identified on the invoice when the property is delivered. Because the delivery charge is separately identified on the purchaser's invoice, and the purchaser had the option to pick up the property rather than having it shipped, there is no inseparable link between the purchase of the property and the outgoing transportation and delivery charges. Therefore, the delivery is a service separate and distinct from the sale of the items and the shipping fees received by the retailer are not part of the retailer’s gross receipts subject to Illinois sales tax. The taxable amount is $200.00.
I am not sure if Ebay would be willing to split this hair.
monroe67
Your quote from the VedderPrice website is incomplete. You quoted only Example 1:
"Example 1. An Illinois customer makes an Internet purchase from a retailer who also has brick-and-mortar stores. A customer selects property from a retailer's website, clicks the "add to shopping cart" button and proceeds to "check out." The online retailer adds the price of the items in the shopping cart, for a total price of $200. The online retailer then prompts the customer to click on the box corresponding to the method by which the customer prefers to obtain the merchandise (e.g., USPS or other common ground carrier for $12.99, two-day delivery for $18.50, Next Day Air for $33.50, or the option to pick up the property for no extra charge at the retailer's store). The customer clicks on the ground carrier box for delivery to the purchaser's home. The retailer then calculates the total price of the order ($200 + $12.99 = $212.99). The cost of the property and the cost of shipping are separately identified on the invoice when the property is delivered. Because the delivery charge is separately identified on the purchaser's invoice, and the purchaser had the option to pick up the property rather than having it shipped, there is no inseparable link between the purchase of the property and the outgoing transportation and delivery charges. Therefore, the delivery is a service separate and distinct from the sale of the items and the shipping fees received by the retailer are not part of the retailer’s gross receipts subject to Illinois sales tax. The taxable amount is $200.00."
Here's Example 2 from the same page:
"Example 2. An Illinois customer makes an Internet purchase from a retailer without a brick-and-mortar store. Assume the same facts as Example 1, except the customer is not given the option of picking up the item. Because the tangible personal property could not be sold to the customer without including delivery, there is an inseparable link between the purchase and the delivery, and the charges for delivery are included in taxable gross receipts. The taxable amount is $212.99."
Summary: Example 1: taxable amount is $200.00.
Example 2: taxable amount is $212.99.
By the way, that link to VedderPrice that you were so kind to include -- it is dated April of 2016.
"I am not sure if Ebay would be willing to split this hair."
Actually, eBay is quite capable of "splitting this hair" and I daresay they do it all day, every day.
Because all those variables are separate items that are entered in the seller's listing:
Is in-person pickup available?
Is the shipping cost listed separately? (meaning, Does this item not have "free shipping"?)
Can the buyer choose between USPS or FedEx or other premium delivery company (and pay the premium cost)?
ms.rodriguez*
The sales taxes are based on the BUYER'S home state. Actually, they are based on the county that a buyer lives in that particular state.