Ebay still doing their known return money "hold" scams still doing baltent US Postal fraud on return
Some time back I made the case with paypal that they could not take money from our paypal accounts and inject it into ebays account allowing ebay to place the supposed "hold" that is anything but a hold. Paypal agreed with me and the others who were also complaining to them requesting that they follow US state and Federal laws and stop catering to ebay but instead practice fair and ethical business. Paypal listened and they stopped ebay from doing the returns how ebay wanted it. Plus paypal had a degree of Federal oversight also in part with the credit card company and probably already was aware that they were assisting ebay in committing fraud on all the returns.
One of the things they did was stopped the "hold". Back then there was statistics available that almost 80% of returns were buyers remorse returns done on ebay as ebay money back guarantee returns. That was on pair with other venues at the time Walmart, Amazon etcetera. But ebay was the only one that had purchased its own supposed third party money transfer service and was using it to stay out of bankruptcy since the site itself had failed to make a profit in years (over 10) and was literally kept afloat at the time by the money transfer service they owned. A bit of background is I allowed Paypal to record 3 way conversations with ebay returns department without ebay knowing. at that time Paypal silently recorded them violating both ebay guidelines but also US laws using them, paypal to fulfil the fraud on their behalf. In return paypal protected me from ebay which at that time they would not allow us to open cases against ebay. They did use the recordings in board meetings and shortly after ebay would not sign paypals contract that would have forced ebay to follow the same US laws that they were forced to follow. As we all know ebay refused to sign the contract with the larger more ethical fortune 500 company and went with an overseas company to try and further overt US federal trade laws/oversight.
Return Shipping and US Postal fraud. Around that time I had sold a broken $3500 item for parts for over thousand dollars. Tt was correctly listed as broken and for parts or to be repaired. The buyer gets the item, takes it apart. Meaning disassembles it. Finds that an almost $600 part is needed to repair it, photographes the mess and uses that picture while opening an ebay money back guarantee claim as a defective item claim.
I call ebay in disbelief that they were allowed to even open that claim on a listing designated for defective items. The rep gives the famous ebay last words that I "have nothing to worry about" that it will be closed in my favor. But they do not profit the most from that. So returns decided to instead close it in ebays favor. Meaning how they profit the most. I was told that at least I was getting the item back and that I should be happy with the outcome, the outcome of them committing internet fraud to me for there personal benefit. Paypal was still involved at that time and recommended that I file a police report with ebay and brought up getting the Post Office involved along with the IC3 department with the FBI. You see they were sick of it too.
I reached out the US Post Office and eventually was working with the federal law enforcement arm of the US Post Office, the United States Postal Inspection Service (like federal marshal). After forwarding information and correspondence I was told that since ebay was not following their own guidelines and allowing the internet soft froud to go forward all the while knowingly profiting on the forced return including the label, I was told to simply refuse the shipment after notifying them the fact it was involved fraud since no US citizen can be forced into participating in known fraud. I explained that ebay will say I am at fault because I refused the item. I was given a report or reference number to give to ebay with some advice to also make a police report and forward it to the post office and to ebay as well. I did exactly that.
Ebay gave me a link to the document uploader and I forwarded the police report information that included the postal report. In the meantime I was told I had nothing to worry about from ebay once again and that they would find the appeal in my favor. Never should have even been an "appeal".
But when they saw that I did what US law enforcement advised and refused the shipment factually now involved in postal fraud, they used that to deny the fact they committed fraud to me and again find themselves not at fault even though the post office verified that ebay can not force me into participating in known postal fraud.
I opted out of ebays arbitration. I was in the first and original group to do so when ebay attempted to illegally force us all into it when they first implemented the shady policy. They attempted to force everyone into it including existing members without an opt out originally. They lost in federal court and we were allowed our right to opt out by sending the opt out letter in to there legal department. They attempted to purge us off the site after we sent the letter in. Accounts were being permanently suspended for a late shipment and stuff like that was happening to only the people that sent the letter in. The complaints got so overwhelming of all the shady things they were doing to us that ebay did away with the original forum in its entirety to help cover up the misdeeds. This is the forum that replaced the old original that they ghosted to cover years of known fraud.
So today I reached out to ebays shipping department letting them know that when a bad buyer abusing ebays returns and is forcing the return. I wanted them to pay attention to the forced return label and tracking then to participate with the US Post Office when they are turned in for forcing me to participate in known return fraud on their site since an ebay representative verified that not only was it a buyers remorse request but the item was admittedly altered by their buyer and did not qualify for the return request that they started for supposedly a defective item. Notes were already taken when I contacted ebay because they do not give us an option for turning in the buyer for admitting they altered an item then try and force a return. I have noticed that they deliberately do not allow us to turn buyers in for any reason that would prohibit the forced return.
For example when one of their buyers uses feadback extortion to try and scam us. This can and will happen most often in messages and not after a return request is opened. So, we should be able to immediately get ebay involved and they should immediately give us seller protection. But they do not allow us to turn the sellers in for one of the most common things they do us on ebay. Why? Because they would be forced to give us seller protection. Instead they refuse to do anything until after feedback is left. Nore will they protect us if or when the buyer opens a return request only after the forced return is done will they then turn down the appeal since they already refunded the buyer out of our funds that they according to paypal are once again illegally "holding".
That is one example and of course another is trying to turn their buyers in for altering items then opening returns. Or any other reason that would force seller protection until after the forced return. That they literally profit more from than the successful transaction since they will find themselves not at fault for hosting the fraud they are now encouraging buyers to do though the ebay money back guarantee program and advertising it everywair on ebay. In this situation the buyer had left positive feedback stating the item was in excellent condition and exactly as described just to later decide they wanted a different item and not what they purchased from me. They eventually admitted they took it apart to clean something and after reassembly that it did not work correctly. They tried to use that against me but I believe it was a lie because they just kept making up reason after reason that did not jive for the return. The ebay rep did admit it was a buyers remorse return done as an ebay money back grab.
So today ebay had a choice. Notes were taken that supposedly protect me but the stupid 3 business day cooling down scam is still in play. Ebay had originally did that because they were at that time illegally holding the money that entire time. From the time the return request was made until they forced the return and automatically refund the buyer regardless the proof of return fraud. Now they try and just get away with "holding" our money after a case is made from the request. They expect everyone to comply to what they want and for us all to agree to the return and deal with the buyers blatant return fraud after the return.
So, Ebay had a choice today. To place the fraudulent return request on hold giving me time to make the police report or they could always simply chose follow US state and federal laws but in turn be back to filing chapter 13 if they did that across the board with all of us. I was originally given a call log number and told to not accept the return then have the next representative after the "cooldown" scam the call log number to review the notes taken and protect me (no resen to force a three business day stretch when they know it is just yet another case of blatant return fraud). That was what I was previously promised when I was complaining that they intentionally do not allow us to turn the buyers in for any reasons that would cause them to not force the return and closing the return in our favor as they should.
The first rep I reached out to was with the shipping department. I was not planning on interfering with the ebay process but to allow them to do it. I wanted them to pay attention and then this time work with the Inspector General's office acknowledging that they can not force returns on us like they do using the US Post Office. The US rep with the shipping department not not care at all and transferred me after I told her not to to ebay's fraudulent arm called returns and escalations while ignored the notes and anything that I said.
The first rep with returns was asked to read all correspondence and notes taken on the transaction. This would take the average person about 5 minutes or more to do. She after about 5 seconds said she did and then proceeded in regurgitated the script she was trained and rehearsed to say. I asked her if she read it all she said yes. So, I told her how impressed I was that a person who could barely speak fluid english was such an accomplished speed treader of the language she hardly could understand and communicate with. I proceeded to ask her questions that she only would have known the answers to had she actually read the correspondence and notes previously taken. Of course she got every question wrong. I called her out for lying explaining that was the problem. The blatant dishonesty of ebay. She did then after me forcing her eventually transfer me to a "supervisor" with her "call center".
That person asked what my expectations are. I told her I expect fraud but it would be nice if they follow all US state and Federal laws. The same thing I always say when they all ask that. But I also told her she actually could not help me because as I had stated repeatedly I had a shipping issue that I needed the shipping department to take up with the US Post Office after her department forces me to participate in known fraud that they are hosting and profiting from. I also told her she has the option to place the request on hold while I file a police report against them. Both ebay and the buyer. This I have done about 7 times now.
She chose option C. She said she was going to close it in my favor. But she failed to say how she was going to do it. But it didn't matter because she knew that I did not want her to do that because I wanted them walking into a trap with the US Post Office on the label ebay provided and profit additionally on. She said she escalated it to a case. I did not want that and she new it. Nor did I request it. She then said they were "holding" the funds for up to three business day. I then explained to her that ebay had already been notified by paypals legal department that that was illegal to do since they knowingly proffit on the known fraud thay host when they take our money from our account and roll it into their day to day business which they do.
At that point she had already did it regardless what I said. But I also believe she did take what I was saying seriously because within a few minutes a second message was sent saying that the money was back in my account. I checked my account when I got off the phone and funds were taken in the process as a "sale" on ebay. But then after the next message it was like it never happened with the bank. I think it was just cancelled out.
My plan this time was to get the Post Office involved again, have the package flagged for fraud again and the postal investigation started. This time suing ebay for violating my rights when they say I can be forced by them into participating in the fraud. This time forcing them to acknowledge what they were already told by Paypal when I worked with them to get Paypal onboard with following US state and Federal laws. especially since I retained my rights when I opted out with their originally forced ebay arbitration.
All the many Ebay shills need not respond unless you are willing to admit you are being paid to shill and for how much.
Last time I posted was about them admitting in a recorded conversation that they allowed additional time in auctions when snypes were still coming. Even though I had the proof and a rep on the phone did see that they added a coupe additional seconds to the listing while the snipes were coming in and had filled a complaint about it with the higher ups that we are not allowed to speak now, they, the shills AKA moderators took the post down regardless of the proof calling it deliberate misinformation. It was not, I had the proof, nore could I get them to even acknowledge what they did. They just simply acted like it never happened.
kh-cathy
Hi everyone,
This discussion has gotten a bit heated. Please remember that, while it is fine to disagree with others, discussion should always remain friendly and respectful as required by the Community Guidelines.
Thank you for your cooperation.
gator08041971
I think ultimately, its not so much they are actually planning and scheming for these loopholes as a goal. Its more of a matter of they simply don't care.
They won't take sides. They won't take seller's or buyer's word. So its less of an intent and more of non-importance. To them anyway. (eBay)
The cases where they refund both parties is probably rare. Most often, you are going to see the buyer get their money back, even keep the item and the seller ends up eating most if not all of it.
*shrug
bonjourami
"We really do need to know how much you people get paid to shill for and pretend that ebay is not one of the most corrupt businesses based out of the united states.
pathetic shillig moderators won't remove the disrespectful replies that they make shilling for ebay then remove mine for asking the simple question how much they are getting paid. "
"You are you are getting paid to bald face lie for ebay and protect a corrupt failing company. So how much did it take for you to sell what some call a soul? Probably isn't really that much. SHAME that's all that every ebay shill called a moderator should feel every minute of every day of their lives."
You seem to have a problem with those that state the facts, probably because thats not what you want to hear. You have your own agenda,and thats your perogative.
jimmy1000000
I love the responses. What a great post.
27teamswords
Dear Biggest_Little:
What is the summary of your post? I spent 5 minutes reading and skim reading it, but I have been unable to Glean what your advice to everyone else is as to how to avoid or solve this same situation should they be in it?
Are you saying you're quitting ebay or? What is the "final solution" here?
jimmy1000000
It is to remind ebay and inform others that they are acting outside of US laws and they are aware of it and others are as well.
I also had reached out to the IC3 department with the FBI and sat down with an agent and discussed ebays return fraud. He agreed that if what I stated was true and from everything I presented that ebay is in violation but also stated that not enough people had complained for them to act and do anything about it. I was a little miffed that it wasn't taken more seriously but instead he passed the buck to the Postmaster General's office that he knew I was already working with.
For people tired of getting scammed by ebay report them. They should not make a penny on the return fraud they knowingly host and profit additionally from while forcing us to participate on it. For ebay to be more legitimate again they would have to go back like they were 6 or so years ago now back when they had a real Trust and Safety department that had total oversight over the returns department and would intervene and make it right. Now returns runs ebay since that is what is keeping them afloat.
https://www.ic3.gov/Home/FileComplaint
r_lresale
I quit reading after it was stated that a recorded 3 way call was conducted with ebay and paypal. In the US recording someone without their knowledge is not legal and certainly not admisable in court. Surely a US law enforcement officer didn't advise someone to break the law especially knowing they couldn't even use such "evidence". 🤔
jimmy1000000
Blatantly Incorrect. The state I live in, like half the other states in the US as soon as one side states that the phone call is being recorded it becomes a public conversation and is no longer private. Meaning anyone can record it regardless if the ebay rep preteds that it can not be. The fact is they know we are allowed to record them. I advise that everyone does. But even that doesn't matter in this situation since they were owned by the same parent company. Derp.
andreyprince
So why are you making such a big deal out of this?
lakefor94
Great job at the attempt of paragraghing. Still rediculous as far as a post,
Remains a wall, of text.
Best to you moving in the best direction.
lakefor94
For sure, it is not enough.....
bonjourami
"You forgot to include how much you are being paid to shill."
I want a raise.
bonjourami
To think that Ebay would actually hire and pay 'shills' for the boards when they dont give a rats behind what sellers think has always struck me as hilarious. And since Ebay doesnt monitor the boards, Khoros does, what would the benefit to them be? Just shows how far paranoia can go.
dryophelia
I need to reschedule my nail appointment this week.
biggest_little
OPIn all that I forgot to mention that they refunded the bad buyer anyway and found me not responsible. The buyer now knows for a fact they can get away with ebay sponsored return fraud.
bonjourami
You may want to read up on the board guidelines regarding hate speech and name calling(its not allowed) As far as the Steiners, old news, since those that were involved have been in jail for quite awhile now.
bonjourami
"Remember that time you guys stalked the Steiners"
I just want to remind you that you are not speaking to Ebay in here, but to Kouros, who moderates the boards.
bonjourami
Actually moderators are rarely in here and are easily identified as a mod..why shouldnt they get paid for their job.. by Kouros? After all, they are employed by them.
gator08041971
Maybe its time for you to step away from the keyboard, go outside, breathe a little.
Just saying.