eBay—where hypocrisy thrives.
Want to peddle knock-offs, fakes, and counterfeits? eBay rolls out the welcome mat. But dare to deliver a second late, and you're public enemy number one. Authenticity? Integrity? They couldn’t care less. As long as the package lands on time, you’re their golden child. Miss that sacred deadline, though, and they’ll toss you out like yesterday’s trash. What a joke.
thingsbyangele
29 comments
trickcomputer
I think of eBay as “another pathetic tech firm trying to apply AI in a space where there has never been any executive or board ‘intelligence’ to begin with.â€
How can a firm have THIS little substance while having SUCH great leader**bleep** AND a 50 million dollar “Ferris Bueller†running it.
thingsbyangele
OPYou're absolutely right. Their support is ridiculous. They respond with the same canned lines every time: "Hi, I’m so-and-so, and I’ll be happy to help you," followed by how much they value us and then admit they can’t actually help at all. They even claim to use artificial intelligence, but it’s just more of the same nonsense.
thingsbyangele
OPsounds like a mockery and a taunt
Yes??
thingsbyangele (759)
Positive Feedback (last 12 months): 100%
Member since: Dec-15-18 in Ukraine
Top-rated seller:
One of eBay's most reputable sellers.
tobaccocardyahoo
If you fail to set the handling time on your listings to allow time for the creation of your products, you are not desired as a seller by Ebay.
If you chose a less expensive but slow means of delivery, which exceeds the delivery estimate, you are not desired as a seller by Ebay.
Exceeding the BBE metrics means you are undesirable. A single late shipment or delivery will not lead to closing you down. Repeated failures are required.
Ebay has many more sellers than can succeed here, and has different ways to protect against different types of undesirable sellers.
If you cannot manage to meet the requirements to export to the US you can continue to ship to the EU.
12345jamesstamps
I thought Ukraine was a blocked country where USA buyers couldn't buy from?
The reason Ukraine is a blocked country might be because of the timeframe where items might arrive late
during the crisis there.
Maybe you have others countries you are selling to...this a USA board.
crisppota34
great effort btw nice shot
simba6
eBay can check the tracking and see if it was delivered on time. But, unless the buyer files an item not described case, they don't know if it's a fake. For some high value items they do go through their authenticity program. eBay and VERO do remove fakes when they are spotted.
robbie31415
Unfortunately, international sellers were causing bad experiences for buyers and eBay decided to crack down. So their newer adapted policies are quite punishing for international sellers.
eBay isn't in the business to educate buyers, they are in the business to satisfy buyers.
This has actually been beneficial based on my experience. It has weeded out a lot of problematic international seller.
My only recommendation is to use a faster service than advertised that comes with reliable tracking.
If you use the exact service then it might not make it, but if you use a faster service then it should.
If you are unable to do that, then I would suggest adding to your handling time to compensate.
Sellers are a dime a dozen to eBay, buyers aren't.
thingsbyangele
OPUnfortunately, your message seems to overlook the fact that not all sellers operate the same way. I create unique, handmade items, and many of my buyers understand that such products take time to ship, especially internationally. Some of my customers are more than happy to wait because they value the craftsmanship and quality of what I make.
The problem arises when certain buyers begin to file complaints just a few days after placing their orders. For example, one buyer filed a complaint on the third day after shipping, received their package the very next day, and then closed the case. Despite resolving the issue, this complaint still counted against my account.
I’ve always made myself available to buyers, responding quickly and offering to resolve any issues. However, many buyers don’t reach out to the seller first; instead, they immediately escalate the issue to eBay. This leaves sellers like me vulnerable to unfair consequences.
How can I possibly influence the postal services of Canada, the U.S., or Australia? I’ve done everything within my power to ensure my buyers are satisfied, including building relationships with repeat customers and maintaining excellent reviews. Yet, despite all this, my store was closed due to just three complaints within a year.
This system is deeply unfair and could impact anyone selling on eBay, even those who work hard to provide excellent service. Sellers are not protected or valued on this platform the way they are on other marketplaces. At any moment, even you could lose your store unfairly due to circumstances beyond your control.
robbie31415
What I provided are realistic options you have.
Doesn't really matter what your items are, it matters on finding solutions to get your items to your customers in the time expected by eBay.
That's just the reality, and strong punishments if you don't meet it since you are an international seller.
I can hand hold, and say I'm very sorry, but that isn't going to change the standards eBay expects from you.
thingsbyangele
OPDo you even hear what I’m saying? Production deadlines were met. Delivery deadlines were met. I’m tired of explaining that the eBay system doesn’t care about deadlines. A buyer files a complaint, and it’s a strike against your account. The buyer has no clue how this affects the seller—and he doesn’t need to. He doesn’t read the terms and conditions. He just buys. But buyers make mistakes all the time. And eBay doesn’t care—the seller has no way to appeal. Out of my four complaints, three were filed before the delivery date, and one was a mistake. The buyer confused the order processing date with the delivery date. Now, I hope I’ve made myself clear.
kensgiftshop
If delivery dates were met, there would be no reason for the buyer to file an INR.
They can't file an INR until after the estimated delivery date has passed.
thingsbyangele
OPYou're not making any sense. Try it yourself, and you'll see that anything is possible. Here's a real story about my friend. Someone bought a 6-strap from him, and after four days, they canceled the order. He tried to refund the money, but there was another software glitch on eBay. A few days later, the buyer was somehow able to open cases for non-delivery of goods, even though they had canceled the orders.
In this situation, eBay ended up siding with the buyer. eBay closed these cases themselves, without the seller's involvement (which, as you know, is a big problem), and they ruled in favor of the buyer. This left several strikes on my friend's account, putting it on the verge of being shut down.
Only a phone call and lengthy negotiations with eBay support resolved the issue. eBay's software has a ton of bugs—I've seen it happen many times over the years of working with them.
kensgiftshop
How long does it take you to get the orders shipped?
Your listing says you ship within 4 days.
thingsbyangele
OPI make leather products, and each one takes a few hours to complete. However, since I usually have multiple orders at a time, I set my order processing time to 4 days. Shipping is done via international mail with a tracking number, and delivery typically takes up to 2 weeks.
That said, I usually ship products earlier than the stated timeline. You can check my reviews—there are no complaints about delivery delays.
lacemaker3
@thingsbyangele, I'm sorry this happened to you.
I wonder if you have checked your CBT (Cross Border Trading) Seller Dashboard? I see that you are registered in the Ukraine, even though your items (and presumably yourself) are located in Spain. Ukraine is considered by eBay to be in the HIPO region, so the CBT dashboard, including BBE (Bad Buyer Experience) and stricter INR (Item Not Received) standards are applied.
https://export.ebay.com/en/regulations/ebay-policies/shipping-performance-policy-item-not-received-rate/
https://export.ebay.com/en/hipo-region/
More info about the CBT dashboard and BBE:
https://export.dashboard.ebay.com/
https://export.ebay.com/en/regulations/ebay-policies/bber/
It seems that your issues were caused by shipping delays, some of them while the packages were being transported by USPS. I looked at your listings, and it doesn't show what shipping service you were actually using, just International Economy. Just US$8.99 for the watch strap I looked at, which is very cheap.
By any chance, were you using registered mail to send them? I know that using registered mail is common in other countries, but it is very unusual here in North America. The USPS does not provide tracking, so this shipping service does not meet eBay's requirements for tracked shipments (integrated with eBay, so the tracking is displayed and viewable on the eBay site) which is required for sellers to have seller protection for INR.
Also, registered mail in the USA is very slow, because the packages have to be stored in a secured location and processed by hand. They are supposed to get a signature when they are delivered, but I know from experience that this is not always done. The signature for registered mail does not meet eBay's requirements for proof of delivery (not integrated with eBay). It also contributes to delays and makes it inconvenient for buyers to receive their packages. Other sellers have reported that their issues with the INR rate on the CBT dashboard were for packages that were shipped to the USA with registered mail.
If your CBT dashboard shows issues, please share a screenshot so that I can see what you could do about them and try to help you with this.
tobaccocardyahoo
If the tracking on the shipment shows the delivery was on time, the buyer is not likely to be believed.
If you shipped without tracking you should not expect to win a dispute.
thingsbyangele
OPmy data. But I still don’t suit them
Past seller level
Top Rated
As of Nov 20, 2024
Current seller level
Top Rated
As of Dec 20, 2024
If we evaluated you today
Your seller level would beTop Rated
Next evaluation on Jan 20, 2025
Transaction defect rate
0.00%0 of 200 transactions
Late shipment rate
0.00%0 of 199 transactions
Cases closed without seller resolution
0.00%0 of 200 transactions
Tracking uploaded on time and validated
100.00%43 of 43 transactions
robbie31415
You seem to contradict yourself, so you may have to repeat yourself.
Here are a few things you said....
"But dare to deliver a second late, and you're public enemy number one." - This implies your packages are arriving late.
"As long as the package lands on time, you’re their golden child." - This implies that if your package arrived on time there would be no issue.
Now you are saying "Delivery deadlines were met.".
It really is quite confusing to me.
Shouldn't be considered their 'golden child' since your delivery deadlines were met?
thingsbyangele
OPI compared eBay's lack of response to the presence of counterfeit goods on the platform with their immediate, shark-like reaction to a customer complaint about allegedly undelivered items.
I hope you understood
kensgiftshop
Right, Ebay is all about the buyers, which they need.
They loose 1 seller, 50 new ones sign up.
soh.maryl
So, as a buyer, you're not at all familiar with the Money Back Guarantee?
thingsbyangele
OPI am indeed familiar with the Money Back Guarantee, but my concern is not about that. My issue is that some buyers open claims or complaints against sellers prematurely, without first reaching out to resolve the issue directly. For instance, when shipping delays occur—which are sometimes beyond my control—some buyers choose to file a complaint instead of contacting me.
As a seller, I’ve always worked hard to address buyer concerns, refund promptly when necessary, and ensure satisfaction. However, when claims are filed prematurely, they negatively impact the seller's account, regardless of whether the issue was resolved fairly. I hope this clarifies my perspective.
crisppota34
yes indeed
chevymontecarlo88
With fakes and counterfeits, buyers are well protected here in the US with the eBay MBG (money back guarantee). Yes, it is annoying (fakes), but the MBG protects buyers that understand the policy and how to use it to their advantage.
From your feedback, only a few buyers have mentioned longer shipping times because it was shipped from Ukraine, Poland or Spain. Your stats look good so what is the issue?
thingsbyangele
OPThat's exactly what I'm wondering too—why my store was closed and for what reason. I dedicated all my time to creating high-quality, handmade products. I even worked on weekends to ensure orders were shipped as quickly as possible. I responded to messages promptly, often even in the middle of the night, and treated every customer with the utmost care. If a buyer requested a refund, I issued it immediately, no questions asked.
Unfortunately, some buyers didn’t contact me directly when their packages were delayed; instead, they filed complaints on eBay, often prematurely. It’s unrealistic to expect a package to arrive from Spain to the US or Australia in just three days. Despite my best efforts, my store was unfairly shut down.
It feels like on eBay, it doesn’t matter if you’re selling high-quality, handmade products or something of lesser value—as long as it’s delivered quickly, that’s all that seems to matter. eBay’s reputation as a "dumping ground" for low-quality items speaks for itself, and this is one of the reasons why people are choosing other platforms—not just because their packages were delivered a few days late.
chevymontecarlo88
When selling internationally, one is to expect some complications that are beyond the control of eBay, buyer or the seller. If you decide to continue or start up again, you may want to communicate with your buyers more closely to insure they understand shipping times (not guaranteed) and open the lines of communication.
If you have a good relationship with your clients, many problems/issues will get resolved before it gets out of control.
-Good luck
thingsbyangele
OPThank you for your response. I completely understand the importance of communication and always make an effort to keep my buyers informed about shipping times and any potential delays. However, the issue I’ve faced is not due to a lack of communication or effort on my part.
As much as I strive to build good relationships with my buyers, some individuals choose to file complaints with eBay rather than reaching out to me directly. This often happens prematurely, even when shipping delays are reasonable given the international nature of the delivery. Unfortunately, these complaints negatively impact my seller account, regardless of whether I resolve the situation quickly or not.
I believe eBay could do more to educate buyers about realistic shipping expectations, especially for international orders, and encourage them to communicate with sellers before escalating issues. I’ve always prioritized excellent customer service, but not all situations are within a seller's control, especially when shipping across borders.
I hope this helps clarify my perspective, and I would appreciate any further advice or support.
varebelrose
"...some individuals choose to file complaints with eBay rather than reaching out to me directly..."
That is exactly what buyers *should* do. As a seller, that is certainly what I wanted them to do. If they tried to reach out to me directly, 9 times out of 10 they were partial-refund seekers, looking to renegotiate a sale, or trying to take business off e-Bay. If everything goes through the eBay MBG, it is documented, on the up-and-up, and ensures both parties are treated in a consistent and reliable manner (I wouldnt say fair, but at least consistent).
YMMV.