You can now apparently uses photos from other sellers items without permission
I found an item 167922977171 where the seller used photos from my listing 199893476668. I first contacted the seller who did not respond so I filed a report and received the following:
We looked into your report and didn’t find the listing to be in violation of our policy. This determination was made using automation or artificial intelligence.
So the AI does not work so I guess it is the wild west now where anyone can uses your photos that you took the time to create. Another eBay AI failure.
matrixmedical
64 comments
mam98031
80% of items sold on Ebay are New items. While I believe OOAK is the backbone of Ebay, it isn't as high on the list of important or fruitful things sold on the site for a long time. There is an every shrinking market for many of the OOAK items.
solarshift7
I'm always amused by the discussion of this issue. Ebay was never good at policing plagiarism claims and has finally outright given permission.
If you take pride in your work to do quality listings you can't help it getting under your skin when someone does an obvious copy and paste. One of my accounts used to be a leader in a very specific niche so I constantly watched the comps. One guy started copying a few things plus undercutting my prices so he got my attention and I watched him regularly. I made calculated changes against anything he did that competed but in watching him I got interested HIS main niche (and I believe some of his sources). In a "lemons into lemonade" way this copycat (right or wrong) led me to a little more success. I started adding things he specialized in that I saw I could make great profit on & turn fast-not to get back at him, just solid items I'd never considered. So study your copycats. You might be able to profit off them!
bennotbill
With ebay's willingness to permit sellers to use another persons pictures, and so sell something they clearly don't have. I just take the simple view of adding it to the long list of things I have to be careful about when buying items on ebay. Not much else you can do.
And as many have said, back in the days of picture file hosting this was easy to stop and often have a bit of fun at the same time. I always used to have a few suitable pictures on Photobucket ready and waiting.
leaderco_97
You’re absolutely right to be frustrated that’s incredibly unfair. You put in the effort to take and upload your own photos, and another seller simply copying them without permission should clearly violate eBay’s copyright and intellectual property policies. Unfortunately, it looks like the automated review system completely missed the issue.
You’re not wrong eBay’s current AI-driven reporting process seems to prioritize speed over accuracy. When you get that “determined by automation†message, it usually means no human actually reviewed your report. If you’re certain the other seller used your original images, I’d suggest doing the following:
File another report manually — Go to the listing, click “Report itemâ€, and choose “Copyright and trademark → Images and text copied without permission.â€
Then also submit a VeRO (Verified Rights Owner) form — it’s slower but it gets human review.
Include proof that your listing predates theirs (timestamps, URLs, screenshots).
It’s frustrating that sellers even have to jump through these hoops to protect their own work, but if you go through the VeRO form directly, you’ll usually get an actual person reviewing it rather than AI.
You’re not wrong the system needs improvement. eBay should be supporting legitimate sellers who create their own content, not letting copycats slide through automated filters.
mam98031
@leaderco_97
Ebay is not going to do anything about this as has been explained in this thread. I even posted information directly from Ebay telling us why they are not enforcing the policy. So filing another report is not going to help the OP at all.
You can't file / submit a VERO report unless you are a member of VERO. So the OP would have to join VERO before they could request help from VERO.
quicksilverdiecast
You have pretty much summed it up... the I is not necessarily Intelligent....
gloryglorygifts
I guess you have never used the "sell similar" option on a listing?
gurlcat
@gloryglorygifts You're confusing Sell Similar with Sell One Like This.




SS applies only to your own listings. When you click it, the new draft carries over every single detail of your original listing, including all the photos, title, description, price, shipping, even the promotion ad rate, if the original listing had one. From there, you can edit those features to whatever is different about the piggy-backer, before hitting 'List.'
But when you do 'Sell one like this' from another seller's listing, all that carries over is the title and item specifics, that's it. The photos, description, everything else, is blank. I don't use it, as it doesn't really save much time, and pretty often the original seller was either wrong about some of the IS's, or didn't bother with many of them that they could have.
gloryglorygifts
No, I was referring to the button under listings. The rest can be easily copied and pasted into your listing and the picture used too via copy and paste.
Thanks for the clarification though. You give a better description than my pea brain did. I was going by my memory as to what it was called as I can no longer create any templates on my desktop. Nap time.
gurlcat
Yes that's the same button I'm talking about. Is your screenshot an old one you've saved? At this time the button is like I showed^ from a current listing, saying "Sell one like this," not "Sell now."


EDIT: Well this is odd! I just found the same listing you showed, but for some reason it still shows that button saying "Sell one like this" on MY screen! I wonder why it's different, even at the same exact time.
But anyway I don't think the words in the button are as important as what that feature does. So why did you ask the OP "I guess you have never used the "sell similar" option on a listing?"
gloryglorygifts
Nope. I did the screenshot yesterday to attach it. I don't know why they are different. I took it on a desktop.
I haven't done that feature in a long time, as I said I was going by memory so I looked at it again with this "sell the same" thing and found that it does copy the title and the short item descriptions (even if they are wrong as is this category, type, color, etc.). It's very easy to just copy and paste the long description and use the photo. If you use that button, you aren't going to look elsewhere for another photo or description. It's right there and it's for those looking for shortcuts.
Why did I ask that question? Because it's just another example of someone not knowing that photos and descriptions, once on ebay, become available to everyone. That's why.
luckythewinner
You can now apparently uses photos from other sellers items without permission
That has been true for at least a decade.
You also should recognize that some policies are there to simply give eBay users guidance, and were never intended to be completely and proactively enforced.
While you and the buyer know where the photo originated, neither eBay employees nor eBay's AI can possible tell. Some sellers may put up a listing and take it down a dozen times over a period of years, so the date of the listing does not prove anything.
eBay is not going to hire a forensic investigator to determine the origin of a photo or determine who ownsa the intellectual property rights. I suspect they are going to assume that 'justice' for the seller who stole the photo will come if his buyer files a dispute because the item does not match the photo.
cottagehillvanilla
Good morning,
Keep moving forward, this has happened to most of us, myself currently included. Don't let that Seller take up your airspace.
dhbookds
The picture switch led to alot of "interesting" variations...........I remember one pic that featured the wording "this seller steals pictures" ending up on some listing......and stayed there for some time as the "stealer" apparently never went back to check "his" pictures...... also the "mirror" picture of the guy taking pics in the buff.......ended up on more than a few listings....
pickapaper
@gurlcat
Glad you saw this thread and clarified about that seller who "steals" photos. I had no idea that eBay has a company that liquidates their abandoned EIS items. Had never heard of it. Interesting to know.
gurlcat
It freaked me out the first time I saw one of my own photos in a search because it was a mixed lot of vintage jewelry, so unlike a single manufactured item, obviously this seller couldn't have the exact same thing. Then I realized it was a lot I had already sold a while back, to a buyer in Russia (this was actually back in the Global Shipping Program days) and it couldn't be forwarded because of any chance it might include precious metals, of which Russia prohibits import.
And besides my photos, there was my word-for-word description and title as well. Incidentally the price was a bit higher than I'd sold it for. I suspect they do that a lot, what with such a huge store, they can afford to let items sit. They do mark down prices over time and run sales too though.
broto_64
Some sellers copy the entire listing, word for word, without even proofreading.
kibble-net
I can see this having a hilarious ending. Here's an example:
Nice seller: Lists a complete board game for sale, stating that all the pieces have been counted and it's complete. Customer is satisfied.
Naughty seller: Copies text and pics word for word, despite not actually checking anything. Customer buys item, it's incomplete, seller has to eat an INR. Naughty seller is now on the hook for two shipping costs and has to refund the customer in full.
If someone did this to me, the joke's on them.
stainlessenginecovers
can NOW??? This has been a thing since the previous millennium.
gurlcat
@matrixmedical Did you ever sell a unit of that item as an EIS sale, and then had eBay tell you they couldn't forward it to the foreign country, or maybe the buyer returned it, and eBay told you they were refunding the buyer but that you wouldn't be affected?

That seller is the liquidator of non-forwardable/returned EIS items. They purchase the bulk from eBay, along with all the original sellers' listing data including photos, title, and description. Note how they have over 25,000 listings, and the thumbnails look like they were all taken by different people in different places, that's because they were.
Pretty sweet gig they have there! Big money with all the work already done for them. They don't even open or repackage the items, or at least they didn't with items I've purchased from them. Original sellers' thank-you cards and all, LOL. @pickapaper
rugerskick
Talk to ebay trust and safety. Its a violation because they are not showing images of the product they are supposed to have in possession, and it can lead to INAD situations, especially if the items they are selling are used.
pickapaper
@matrixmedical
What is even funnier about your "photo thief" is that they have sold almost a million items and currently have more than 25K items listed, so they aren't inexperienced or naive. Apparently just lazy. Wonder how many of their listings they stole photos (and maybe descriptions) for.
momtoabeautifuldaughter
Yeah it's been that way for a while. They can copy your whole listing if they choose to. It's in the User Agreement you agreed to
steve_stuff
We get around other people using our photos by taking bad photos.
stuff4divas
@matrixmedical
i've come across other sellers who use my photos and description for their listings, which obviously creates a fraudulent listing since it is my item that they don't have to sell
messed up, but this is how it's been for years
theteamsetguy
@matrixmedical ,
I have absolutely no animosity when someone uses my pictures. I have better use of my time than to worry about it.
I look at it this way. Like the saying goes, imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. I create my photos in batches and it averages me less than a minute for each one. I save the pictures and reuse them if I sell out of something and restock.
meme6253
It has been that way for awhile now, I don't think it is proper at all but it is what it is!, We don't have to like it, But we do have to accept it!
steve_stuff
Have said before, we get around this problem by not just taking bad photos, but by mostly selling odd, weird, different strange stuff. If you find another left handed shoehorn you're welcome to use our photos. Just make sure it's the same brand or model.
loose_goose_garage
A couple weeks ago I had someone copy one of my listings word for word, all they did was change the photos. Title, description, item specifics, everything.
This is an item I sell for $120-$130.
They listed it at Auction for $9.99 Starting Bid with Free Shipping
I bid and won it for the Opening Bid.
Now I can do sell similar on their listing, which will then pull in all the info from my original listing, and just upload my own photos.
Everything comes full circle.
dirk12955
I have another Seller (New) on ebay copying my listings and using my
photos. He even uses my photos that clearly show my inventory number.
Plus, He copies all my other descriptions and item specifics including spelling errors.
As noted above, Nothing I can do about it.
mam98031
Except you can watermark those pictures if you wanted to.
dirk12955
i really don't want to add a watermark to 4,000+ listings.
I really don't give a fat rats rear end if he uses my pics if he'd crop the inventory #s
when he does it.
mam98031
It was merely a suggestion. You have every right to decide for yourself.
powell-collectibles
Absolutely – adding a watermark to thousands of pictures Seems like a massive amount of work. And against eBay policy. I did see that eBay was experimenting with how to remove watermarks from photos.
stuff4divas
yes, this taken from> https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/listings/adding-pictures-listings?id=4148&st=12&pos=1&query=Adding%20pictures%20to%20your%20listings&intent=photo%20revisions&docId=HELP1031
mam98031
Yes, but they do not enforce this as said in the announcement I just posted.
mam98031
You are correct. It is against Ebay's policy however Ebay does not enforce the policy by their own admission.
https://community.ebay.com/t5/Announcements/Watermark-Removal-Policy-Enforcement-Update/ba-p/27803744
https://community.ebay.com/t5/Selling/Are-watermarks-allow-or-not-Can-someone-from-eBay-respond/td-p/31241131
powell-collectibles
That doesn’t mean that they won’t enforce it at some point. Seems a reasonable risk that they would. Leaning on a message from 2018 doesn’t seem to me to be a blanket assurance that’s they won’t enforce right when OP goes through the massive chore to add watermarks to all of his photos.
kibble-net
Don't use a watermark. That may violate TOS.
Instead, write your ebay store name in BIG BLOCK LETTERS on a piece of cardboard, and include it in the foreground of every photo.
There is a board game parts seller who does this, and now I see why. This seems like a clever workaround for the issue OP is describing.
dirk12955
That's a good idea. Might be an option for me
instead of the forbidden watermark.
mam98031
@kibble-net
Please see the announcement from Ebay I just posted regarding this subject.
kibble-net
I'd rather not use watermarks, than rely on their word from 2018 that they aren't going to enforce this rule.
Less work, less risk. Reusable cardboard + sharpie is a lot less work than loading up Photoshop each time you take a photo for a listing.
inhawaii
You can now apparently uses photos from other sellers items without permission.
Old news.
It's been that way for a long time.
pickapaper
@christworks
What you did is similar to what eBay sellers used to be able to do (with the photo hosting eBay used to use): replace photos with some "less desirable" ones so when someone stole photos, a really gross "Bubba" guy or other offensive photo or a "Free Shipping" banner or some other similar ones would pop up on the offending seller's listing. Those offending sellers would get really upset but when they found out what happened, they didn't steal photos again.
I think eBay figured out it was a losing battle to fight all these photo/text thieves so they just went with the "if you can't beat them, join them" and so they started allowing everyone to do it.
christworks
If someone wants to copy my listing, have at it. I can't control it and I don't have the space in my brain to stress over it.
This does remind me of something funny from back in my former life a long time ago. Way back in the day I had a co-worker who was notorious about copying my work - work that I put a lot of effort in as it involved giving presentations to clients. Rather than make his own presentations, he would copy mine and maybe slap one or two extra slides in it. He did the same thing to our supervisor, but she never said anything because nothing was going to ever be done with this guy. To make matters worse, he never took the time to actually review the presentation beforehand. He would wing it once he was in front of clients.
Finally, one day before I left work, I copied my presentation to a thumb drive so I'd have a copy saved. I then significantly edited the copy that was saved on our main office computer, which we shared. The guy came into work the next day and followed his usual pattern of copying my work, adding a slide in, then headed on to his presentation. Imagine the shock he had when he got about four slides in and a pair of giant boobs appeared. I was told by someone who was in the room that he shouted "woah" and clicked on by.
He never copied my work again. 🤣
richard1rst
There is an old New England joke/life lesson the punch line of which is"First - you have to get his attention" - well done.
chapeau-noir
If their widget is not the same as your widget then they can be liable for not as described, anyway.
mam98031
@matrixmedical
This is not a new thing. We have been able to do that for years. It is stated in the User Agreement for the site that you agreed to in order to sell here. Which is why you were told there was no policy violation.
mtgraves7984
You can now apparently uses photos from other sellers items without permission
@matrixmedical
Yep. It's been that way for like forever now. Bums me out, too... but it is what it is. Hang in there...
Unavailable member
Now ? That policy has been in place for a while.
https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/listing-policies/images-videos-text-policy?id=4240
mustang707
This is a common complaint in this forum. Some sellers will say it's a compliment if someone copies your work. I, however, am extremely annoyed by it since I take a lot of time to produce quality photos. My only hope is that their item listed has flaws that are not shown in my photos and the seller gets a "not as described" return.
sin-n-dex
I trademark my photos with a loud background. Someone might take the photo and delete the background, at that point I don't really care, the background is what makes it my unique image. (And I picked a background that few people would want to copy for their listings). It also makes me stand out in search because my customers recognize my photos. Lots of sellers in my category do something similar.
C.
ittybitnot
.....where anyone can uses your photos that you took the time to create.
@matrixmedical
It used to against the rules to copy photos or text from another eBay seller. Now such plagiarism is allowed on eBay. This is likely because it was too costly to enforce. Your product need not be in the eBay "Catalog", but rather once you post it to this site anyone can use your work product.
eBay will not entertain VERO takedowns from eBay sellers once the listing is posted on eBay. If, however, another seller lifted them from your personal WEBSITE, (and they were never posted on eBay) you can become a VERO member and eBay will remove the listing.
the_fancy_fox
I miss the good old days of when someone stole your photo. You could change the picture that was being Displayed. My favorite to use was a very dirty kitty litter box on that URL and change my picture in my listing to a different one.
Got kind of crazy with people changing their photos to pornographic ones and then reporting the listing for being against policy, some people would post signs saying this person sold my photo Can you trust him?
And then there was a way to protect your photos by doing a clear overlay that unless somebody was knowledgeable, they wouldn’t realize why they weren’t grabbing the picture instead of a blank.
gurlcat
I don't understand. Are you saying you could change another seller's photos without their login/password? HOW???
lacemaker3
Not exactly, but they could effectively do that.
It was possible when sellers could self-host their own pictures, which meant storing their pictures on a picture hosting site, or on their own website. That could cost money, but you could save money over paying eBay to host the pictures. Then you linked to the IP address of your picture that you wanted to use in the listing.
That made it easy for other sellers to use your pictures. They didn't even have to copy the picture or host it themselves at their own cost. They could just copy the IP address and link to the picture that the first seller was hosting at their cost. This might even increase the cost for the first seller, because sometimes the cost for hosting was based on how many times the picture was used/viewed.
If the first seller found out about this bandwidth theft, then the recourse was to move the stolen picture to a different IP address, revise their own listing to the new IP address, and replace the stolen picture with another picture that was not so nice, at the original IP address. Which would then show up in the listing of the seller who had stolen the original picture.
This was one of the reasons why eBay changed their code to require that all pictures have to be hosted by eBay (and stop charging extra for hosting pictures), and to not allow any links in the description, except to eBay pages.
richard1rst
Down load it to your own computer, save as ...com, then open and edit it as you se fit. Then use that pic in your own listings.
Kinda sleazy but why do now expect anything different after all these years of all the folderol we have already seen.
kensgiftshop
Another seller can copy your whole listing and use it, and it's allowed.
mozartbach1971
I've had someone do something like this to some of my items a long time ago.
animal-house-8
Was the item in product catalog?
When you create listings you give eBay and its customers permission, through our User Agreement, to use your images, videos and product details. Your content may be added to the eBay product catalog, and may be used by other sellers in their eBay listings.
You may contact the seller and ask them to remove your image or text if it is not part of the eBay product catalog.