Wrong Error Message on Auction Sale. Citing Wikipedia link, EBAY thinks I'm trying to Sell Outside
First time this happened was about a month ago. I lower the price, and get a warning message that Ebay thinks I'm somehow trying to sell outside Ebay. Item is a rare document. I included some links, many to Wikipedia, related to the historical context and value of the item. Has been detailed like this for over a year. Some interest, but no sales yet. When I made a minor change in price or description, now Ebay flags it. I'm nearly sure it's an updated AI program. I called Ebay Customer Service. They agree with me, but said they can't do anything about it. I did an "Appeal" (which was difficult to get under word limit), and have been waiting for over a month, even though I was told it would take only a few days.
Meantime, the perfectly normal item, which has links again, to academic discussions, still has an error message. Ebay's creating a problem that doesn't exist, and doesn't make sense by human standards.
grand-and-glorious-purpose
You are the one creating the problem by insisting on having those links in your listing which is 100% not allowed no matter where they lead to
johnrj1226
When you play the eBay game in eBay's ball park and the umpires call you out - you are out whether you thinks your safe or not. If you are not familiar withe baseball. This "Stones link might clear thing up for ya' https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ef9QnZVpVd8
In summary, Mr. Gates says it best.
chapeau-noir
It's pretty easy to do an end-run around that kind of thing by writing things like "...as cited in Wikepedia under XYZ". I recall having to do that until I finally just said the heck with it and included a short-form manual in the actual listing. That would be harder to do with your item, but there are ways around it.
Calling eBay CS is a waste of time, BTW.
albertabrightalberta
@jlseagull2
Several listings still have Wikipedia links. You're going to have to revise those listings or you might have the same problem but with more severe consequences. Ebay expects you to learn from previous mistakes.
ekmadonna
Never use outside links! Period. Tell the customers they can research the item on their own. Anyone truly interested in whatever it is will already know what it is and most likely it's value.
richard1rst
I had a similar situation some years ago. I offered a jigsaw puzzle, based on a famous painting displaying graphics symbolizing about 100 famous superstitions. The point of the puzzle was "How many can you identify?" . For the sake of those who were interested (and knowing it would take way too long to explain them in the listing) I added a line:
For an explanation of all of these superstitions you will find the painting and all of the answer by doing a Wikipedia search for (then the name of the painting). NO LINK. Never had a problem with it. BECAUSE I DID NOT INCLUDE AN ACTUAL LINK.
You have to learn to be creative.
12345jamesstamps
I picked out just one item and at end of the description you put an email(yours) in the description.
Giving emails out is not allowed...especially your own.
jlseagull2
OPWhile some of this feedback is useful. (And if the item was publicly available, you could see, I basically wrote it up as a HIstory major would, with proper sources, though dumbed some of it down to Wikipedia...nothing remotely related to "selling" it off E-bay), It's still 'flagged' for nonsense reasons. The Ebay Customer Service on phone agreed with me. It also had been up, for over a year, so quite obviously, wasn't involving new info) They hoped someone at Ebay could resolve it in my favor. So I did what they suggested. I "appealed" it, expecting some human would review. When you do that, it's supposed to be resolved and a response received in 72 hours. And it's now been, about 25 days. So why is it that Ebay says there's an "appeal" system, when no one is actually reviewing it, and it's kept in "limbo" off-line? If I'm correct, which it's obvious, all I did was link to historical info sites, to ensure the buyer of it's historical value, increasing the value to Ebay, why would that be prohibited? And why aren't the "appeals" being viewed by a human being, if that's what's supposed to occur?
Responses on the appeal part, are appreciated as well.
kensgiftshop
What is there to appeal, you violated policy by adding an outside link to your listing.
monroe67
" . . . It's still 'flagged' for nonsense reasons."
As others have noted, specifically "kensgiftshop":
"What is there to appeal, you violated policy by adding an outside link to your listing."
You may think it's nonsense, but every time you list an item to try to sell on eBay, you agree to be bound by eBay's terms and conditions.
One of those T&Cs that you agreed to is not to add any outside link to any of your listings.
You may consider it harmless. You apparently consider that you have done all the academic research your buyers might otherwise not have time to do, and you are providing accurate historical context for your item.
But you're figuratively playing on eBay's field. And you're breaking one of eBay's rules.
eBay has the right, again figuratively, to send you home.
luckythewinner
why would that be prohibited? And why aren't the "appeals" being viewed by a human being, if that's what's supposed to occur?
They are prohibited because eBay says they are prohibited.
Links policy
"To protect our members, listings or products can't contain links that direct customers to a site other than eBay, even if the link is not clickable. While there are some exceptions, listings or item descriptions can't contain links that direct customers to any other site."
https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/listing-policies/links-policy?id=4248
The only exceptions are clearly noted, and there is nothing on the policy page that suggests appeals are available.
eBay is not going to grant you an exception to a clearly stated policy just because you don't agree with the policy.
jlseagull2
OPSorry to point out again. The Ebay Reps said I should, and the system itself, has a link, where you can do an "appeal" if you challenge the claim that your ad is trying to "sell outside ebay".
You get a notice, after filing it out for a few hundred words, that a decision will be issued within 72 hours. It's been a month. I don't agree, anything in my advert suggests anything. (And BTW, I "guessed" it might be links to Wikipedia or similar. I've not been told that, though the ebay Reps seemed to agree that's probably what the AI system saw).
Again, what should I do when the "appeal" button that I pushed, challenging this determination, seems to go nowhere? It appears to just be in "name only" . Is everyone on Ebay, just so cynical? Why not challenge it, the links to government historical web sites (like on miltaralia documents), or even Wikipedia, are not a real concern, and I don't believe violates anything.
jonathanbrightlight
You can not believe it all you want, but @luckythewinner posted the policy verbatim and you're just choosing to ignore it. Nothing will change the fact that you broke the rules, knowingly or not originally, but are now trying to continue to break the rules despite knowing them.
Again, this is the exact policy:
Links policy
"To protect our members, listings or products can't contain links that direct customers to a site other than eBay, even if the link is not clickable. While there are some exceptions, listings or item descriptions can't contain links that direct customers to any other site."
https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/listing-policies/links-policy?id=4248
kensgiftshop
Again, there's nothing to appeal, policy says no off Ebay links, doesn't matter where the links go.
chapeau-noir
All the reviewer or AI sees is the linking code - they don't care if it's an attempt to sell or not, and as said above, there are not the resources to investigate every single link millions of sellers might include, so no links allowed at all. That ruling has been in place since before all the AI ballyhoo, so I'm surprised you've been able to continue with these informational links in your listing, but evidently it was caught on revision. I used to have informational links in my computer peripherals listings and have not been able to include them for years.
Also important that if you have messages from prospective buyers about this piece, not to try to send them any links concerning it in messages - try to find some other way to convey this.
ittybitnot
..... and doesn't make sense by human standards.
@jlseagull2
While links to outside informational sources are considered a desirable SEO component (if you have your own website) it is no longer allowed here. The more functions that are turned over to AI bots, the less "human standards" are allowed to play a part in the said action.
It used to be that on eBay you were allowed a link to 'more informational pages' so long as there was nothing for sale at the destination page. That is likely beyond the scope of any AI eBay employs, and humans cost too much so the links have been axed.
Not that it is any consolation, but at least you are told which listing had a violation and what that violation was about. Some sellers are not so lucky, and are just told "one of your listings has a policy violation" where neither the product nor the listing is mentioned at all. Good luck finding it when you get that message!!!!
kensgiftshop
It's a policy violation to have any outside links in your descriptions.
jonathanbrightlight
eBay's stated policy does not allow any outside links, even Wikipedia.