Would you sell to a buyer who leaves 99% negatives to sellers?
This is the most recent feedback, the rest looks about the same (36 feedbacks left)
beautifulbeauty2012
57 comments
This is the most recent feedback, the rest looks about the same (36 feedbacks left)
beautifulbeauty2012
OPAnother very "interesting" coincidence: a few days ago, a brand new user was suspended on the same day of the purchase (here is the thread: https://community.ebay.com/t5/Selling/New-user-made-a-purchase-and-his-status-is-Not-registered-user/m-p/33994446#M2278324)
The package was going to Hidalgo, TX 78557. This buyer who left 36 negatives have exact the same Hidalgo, TX 78557 address (the latter is residential) and the same last name! Not mentioning it is the same item (I have multiples).
evry1nositswindy
If it is someone making an offer--no BBL
If they already purchase something--yes
robbie31415
36 negatives out of 5000 transactions?
Literally a non issue.
mam98031
I agree !!!!
36 divided by 5000 = 00.72%
So they have a less than 1% rate for leaving a negative FB.
Their rate of negs is likely lower because not everyone leaves FB for buyers either.
beautifulbeauty2012
OPWhy do you divide apples and oranges?? The buyer left 99% negatives to sellers-that is the issue here, and those probably left him all positives.
robbie31415
Your argument is just silly.
Some people only leave feedback if they have a negative experience so they could have 100% negative feedback left rate.
That rate is quite meaningless because it neglects the fact they have had over 99% positive experience as a whole.
You do you, but common sense says this is a good buyer. Out of 5000 transactions I would expect them to run into at least 36 bad experiences.
coolections
It is like 98% of the sellers who come here complaining and bashing Ebay. The 98% of the happy sellers never come here so it makes Ebay look like it is the worst thing that could ever happen to a person in their life.
robbie31415
Yeah I agree which is why I don't think eBay should ever base decisions purely based on the tears of the forum by the minority.
Because eBays forums may be a vocal majority, but are a minority as a whole. The quiet majority gets shafted.
mam98031
Not apples and oranges. It is all feedback. Have you ever taken a moment to read how Ebay calculates the percentages of everyone's FB page. It is simple math.
By clicking on the little icon to the right of anyone's FB percentage you get a box that explains the math.
beautifulbeauty2012
OPYou are talking and providing example of feedback received, while the question is about feedback LEFT. Click on Feedback left and you`ll see that I (since you posted my profile here) leave positives to sellers, as well as receiving positives as the seller.
mam98031
You are refusing to see why it is important to take into consideration how many transactions were involved.
I've tried to explain it, but you don't want to acknowledge the numbers or understand that your initial take on this is not correct. You are so entrenched in your belief that you can't see anything else.
It is completely different for a buyer that has 36 feedback received and 36 negative feedback left from a buyer that has 5000 feedback received and 36 negative feedback left. Why you can't see the difference in that IDK. And I'm at a loss as how to explain it to you in a way that will make sense for you.
I wish you well.
albertabrightalberta
🤣You can explain it to her but you can't understand it for her! 😄
coolections
No they DID NOT. They left under 1%. The other 99.9% the buyer was happy. With your stance I would think it is best to block the buyer and anyone else whoever left a negative to a seller and move on.
beautifulbeauty2012
OPHow do you know that the buyer was happy the other 99%?? Do you know how many cases/chargeback he opened? Do you? Tell us how can you be so sure!
coolections
Too easy to answer. They did not leave feedback.
beautifulbeauty2012
OPThey could of opened cases/chargebacks without leaving negatives. I bet they opened more cases, many more.
mam98031
That is a very good question. But sadly it is one that we can't get an answer for regarding your buyer in question or any other buyer we may do business with. It is information that is not now nor has it ever been available to sellers.
You just need to do whatever you feel is best for you. If not doing business with this buyer is the right answer for you, then don't do business with them. You have every right to make that decision.
My only caution is that you selectively provided info about the buyer which did not give a full picture. However we have that now and everyone should be able to move forward now.
beautifulbeauty2012
OPWhat do you mean I didn`t give a full picture of the buyer? Who did then? Nobody even knows his user id lol How do you know you have it now without knowing anything except from what I stated here?
fern*wood
It's rather unfortunate that some buyers don't realize how giving feedback in this manner appears. Had they only spread those negs out among a sea of green, they wouldn't get blocked left and right.
There was a prolific poster a couple years ago that bought tons, but decided he needed to award a seller with about 30 negs all in a red wave. It really hurt him probably more than the seller.
gloryglorygifts
I have a question that is off topic, if you don't mind. Why would someone buy an expired credit card?
beautifulbeauty2012
OPPeople collect things, the cards are collectible, same as used stamps etc. Some people buy photos of feet on ebay, most of them look just gross, but some people enjoy buying those, and that is creepy in my opinion 😄 But those who sell them do make money and don`t complain about slow sales 😄
slippinjimmy
There might be some nefarious reasons but the usual reason is that they collect them.
Check it out!
https://www.creditcollectibles.com/credit-card-collecting/
beautifulbeauty2012
OPGreat reference to the credit card collecting hobby! Some cards are really "good looking", and I enjoy selling them.
sextons-sweet-deals
how did you come up with 99%?
I read eBay's response, but just curious on calculations, because we all know it seems to depend on time frame of feedback.
thank you
beautifulbeauty2012
OPOut of 36, one was neutral and one positive, the rest was negative-just did the estimated 99%, but it can be 98%-still the same picture.
slippinjimmy
You seem to missing the point, if the buyer received ~5000 feedbacks from sellers and left 36 negs that would be way under 1%, the 99% is the number of transactions they DID NOT leave a negative.
beautifulbeauty2012
OPWe don`t know how those 5k transactions went, as sellers could of lost money from claims after leaving positive feedback to the buyer (some have it on auto, some just leave right away after payment), and sellers can`t leave negatives in the first place, so only positives are left. The issue here that the user takes time only to leave negatives-and that is the point you are missing here.
maxine*j
It sounds to me as though you have already made up your mind, so do what feels right to you.
In my active selling days, I was of the "They pay, I ship" school and never spent time and energy trying to assess buyers or anticipate transaction results. But that was just me.
The very fact that you posted your question, and now appear to be arguing the merits of the no-ship position means you don't want to sell to this person -- so don't.
-
mam98031
Sellers can ONLY leave positive FB. But that isn't the point. The point is there was OVER 5,000 transactions that happened for this buyer and OF THOSE 5,000 transactions the buyer felt they needed to post negative FB on 36 of them. That is LESS THAN 1% of their transactions.
As much as you'd like to, you can't ignore the number of transactions when you look at how many negatives a member has or how many they have left for others. It matter and it matters a lot.
It is very different if a buyer had 100 transactions and of those transaction they left 36 negatives. That is a completely different situation that the one we have been discussing here.
mtgraves7984
The issue here that the user takes time only to leave negatives-and that is the point you are missing here.
@beautifulbeauty2012
So, if you don't give the user a reason to leave a negative, you'll receive no feedback at all. That's okay, right?
beautifulbeauty2012
OPWhy go to extreme? A typical buyer can and should leave both, mostly positives, feedback (otherwise, if unhappy, why staying on the platform?). Who wants to deal with a negative buyer who is not happy and is questionable why he doesn`t leave positives? The case/claim history is behind the scene as well, but can be partially discovered if I have more time.
mam98031
The feedback system is a voluntary system. Speaking for myself only, I get FB from about 20% of my buyers. So for me most buyers don't leave FB at all, positive or negative.
Having a less that 1 percent issues, which is what your buyer has, should drive no one from the site. It isn't perfect here. It never has been. Issue will arise from time to time. Sometimes the trading partners can work things out and sometimes they can't or don't. But the buyer in question has an extremely low rate of issues that weren't resolved when you look at how many transactions they have been involved in.
Look at it this way, the buyer in question was HAPPY 4,964 times and unhappy 36 times. Less than 1% unhappy.
albertabrightalberta
I missed seeing the feedback history but based on other posters' comments (including those who would sell to the buyer) as well as @elizabeth@ebay 's posts, I am able to conclude that this is a buyer I wouldn't sell to.
My thinking is that even if it's a high volume buyer and even if most transactions didn't get feedback from the buyer leading many to conclude that those were "smooth" transactions, I have a problem with buyers who only take the time to neg sellers when they're unhappy.
As we see on the boards, most of the buyers who post come with problems but there are hundreds of thousands of great sellers who don't get the accolades they earn. How hard is it to leave a positive feedback, even if there's no comment, especially for an experienced buyer to do?
I missed the post prior to the edit so my inferences could be all wrong, but in my mind, a buyer who leaves negs only when transactions go south is one who comes off as difficult, entitled and possibly one who didn't get their way when they worked with sellers. (Again, only my opinion but that's what it seems like to me.)
I do check buyers' feedback left for others and have dodged bullets more times than I can count by checking feedback before countering or accepting offers. I'm much more apt to sell to a buyer (and in fact had one today) who has left several negs over the years but has also left hundreds of glowing feedbacks for sellers who performed well.
gloryglorygifts
I would just process the order and ship it, because I rarely investigate my customers. 36 negs left after 5,000 purchases is not 99% btw.
monster-deals
If the question ever is "Do I block this user?"
The answer is ALWAYS "Yes."
elizabeth@ebay
Hi @beautifulbeauty2012. I just wanted to provide our perspective too, if that's okay. A couple callouts from what I see is that the buyer has an extensive buying history (thousands), and only 36 negative feedbacks were given. While 36 stands out for sure as they're negative, it is very minimal considering the overall history. Also, one last thing I noticed is that they have not left a negative feedback in over a year, despite having a constant recent purchase history.
I completely understand being cautious, and taking notice of things like this! I just wanted to provide our perspective to hopefully encourage you to not miss out on this sale 😊
netbestdeals
Oh dang chronic entitled complainers suck. I've been buying on ebay pretty much forever and there have only been a couple times that negative feedback was necessary. Unfortunately there are people like my ex wife that you can give them the world and more and they will still b*tch. I say block them. Nobody should have to deal with a customer like that.
brightlightbookseller
I probably would never have checked, but if I happened to, it would depend on the content of those negatives. They may just buy a ton of stuff, and only bother leaving feedback on the small percentage of sales that legitimately go wrong. Or they may be a real problem buyer. I wouldn't waste a cancellation on it probably, I'd just try to make sure there was no reason for a neg, and shrug it off or try to get it removed if it did happen.
mam98031
No I sure wouldn't. The risk would not be worth it.
I would go the extra step and report them too for FB abuse in the hopes to get them on Ebay's radar and protect other sellers. It is important that we all work together on these types of things.
https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/resolving-buyer-issues/reporting-issue-buyer?id=4084
mam98031
Upon getting more information from Elizabeth I would like to retract what I stated above.
@beautifulbeauty2012 left out some important information about the buyer that changes the initial impression. I should have asked more questions before rendering an opinion as I know many members often mis-read the feedback stats. The fixate on the number of negatives without taking into consideration how many other feedback a member has, which as we all know is only part of the total transactions for any given member as many don't leave FB at all.
So I apologize for jumping to a conclusion I should not have. That is on me for sure. I should have sought out more info.
inhawaii
I would sell to this buyer ... because chances are I would have never looked at the buyers feedback.
I rarely do.
stainlessenginecovers
Yes- this reason for me as well!
stainlessenginecovers
Sounds like the buyer COULD have left 1000's of POSITIVES but decided they ONLY want to 'leave feedback' when there is something NEG to say.
Doesn't mean they are 100% NEG leavers.
byrd69er
You need to ask?
ten_o_nine
Sometimes I have no choice if the sale is not thru best offers, so the answer is yes.
rosszonebricks
In my general workflow, I feel it's a waste of time to bother doing a deep dive into a buyer when they buy from me.
Do I Google their address to make sure the name matches public records? No.
Do I look at the feedback given/received? No.
Do I search social media for hints if they are a 'good person' worth my item? No.
They paid? They provide a valid address? I ship.
mtgraves7984
I'd not if I could prevent it. Has it gone so far that the user has purchased an item?
legalbeagle52
@meme6253 took the words right out of my mouth ...
NO, NO & NO!!!
Why look for trouble , when the red flags (or in this case dots) are right there?
AVOID! Save yourself the headache.
meme6253
NO, NO, & NO!!!
m60driver
Just another mystery of the cosmos as to how Ebay allows such a buyer to remain on the platform.
beautifulbeauty2012
OPJust to be completely clear, the user has been on the platform for 13 years and received almost 5K feedbacks as a buyer (haven`t checked the times when negatives were allowed to be left for buyers, as well as we don`t know how those transaction ended in the reality after sellers left positives-with cases or went smoothly). But out of 36 feedbacks he left, 99% are negatives.
buyselljack2016
Just a buyer that does little feedback (1%) for items that they are OK with the actual %age of negs left vs the # of purchases, even though it seems like a lot is a very, very small %age
Some of that looked like, for sure, seller faults.
My general thought is I don't care if I sell an item or not, so even with that thought, if it wasn't huge $$ amount (differs by seller perspective), and I was confident in what I was selling I would not be overly concerned, but my COG is low, so my outlook may differ from others.
slippinjimmy
If the buyer has feedback of 5,000 as a buyer and has left 36 negatives that would mean that at least 99% of their purchases did not result in a neg for the sellers.
I've run into a few buyers over the years that never leave feedback unless it's a negative/neutral, when I see that they have bought hundreds of items and left 1 or 2 negs I do not worry about it at all.
coolections
Yes I would sell to this buyer in a heartbeat. You said they have over 5,000 purchase feedbacks meaning they probably bought more like 7,000 items on Ebay and have only left 36 negatives. I actually am very surprised they only had 36 negative experiences. I think you have to ask yourself do you put trust into your descriptions and do you feel confident that buyers will not have a negative experience for what you are selling them.
kickin.assets
No ... definitely not.
redlinear
NO! Block that buyer. Cancel any transactions.
And when that feedback arrives? You CAN get it removed.
(I think I know that account 😂