withholding funds. no basis but no answers
i have a 15 year history as a seller, 100% rating. (just crossed 1k total, 87 as seller) I have an 850 credit score. My account is completely up to date, all previously requested information provided.
I sold an item, (https://www.ebay.com/itm/234972975404) buyer paid promptly. I paid several hundred dollars out of pocket for freight shipping. (ebay's profit margin in this sales is a healthy 13+%) Buyer has left positive feedback. ebay is withholding my funds for no legitimite reason. I know this topic is rehashed over & over, but can someone please tell me what legitimate, reasonable policy does eBay have to withhold my funds?
twalens
11 comments
mam98031
Ebay has had a rule for many years that pertains to New Seller and sellers that have been away from selling for 90+ days. The following is the policy that outlines why you money is likely on hold.
https://export.ebay.com/en/fees-and-payments/payments/payment-holds/
https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/getting-paid/getting-paid-items-youve-sold/payments-hold?id=4816&&redirectedFrom=4155
twalens
OPI understand that they have policys like any business. My point is their policy is absolute **bleep**. Unfortunately they don’t have any good competition as yet in the online sales marketplace. They’re raking in huge margins but don’t want to accept at least a portion of the responsibility for online sales. Why should legit sellers have to accept policy’s like this to cover the dishonest/unethical activity of the few. My item was sold/paid/shipped (@considerable additional expense to me) & delivered (with positive feedback) yet I wait for funds.I can’t wait for the eventual rise of more reasonable options to market online. Policies like this should help the competition. Disgusting.
lakefor94
Simple as you did not read the policy or still do not understand the policy if you did take a few minutes to read it.
mam98031
@twalens
I respect your feelings regarding this policy. I do however agree with Ebay's on this one. There are good reasons for this policy but that doesn't mean I can't see why those that have their funds held would feel differently. I can go into it further if it interests you, but I understand your mind is likely set on this one.
Ebay can't make separate rules for each seller, it has to be a site wide rule. That would be an impossible task.
As for your shipping during this hold period. You do NOT have to come out of pocket for those expenses if you use Ebay to create and pay for your shipping label. They will allow you to use the held funds for the shipping charges.
dbfolks166mt
About the only "policy" eBay has is their own which is nothing more than risk mitigation and a CYA move by eBay to avoid having to put their own funds at risk. Of all the things sellers complain about and threaten class action law suits over this is one that may potentially have some merit depending on how the legal system looked at the holds and the various state laws pertaining to what are considered to be escrow funds. There are a number of states that have laws pertaining to the payment of interest on escrowed funds however most of those laws are, in some cases, complex and often vague.
stevemartin60
P.S. They recently held my payment for nearly two weeks while I waited for their stupid "microdeposits" "needed" to "re-verify" my bank account. And, I have been selling for well over a decade with perfect feedback, and NO issues, ever, with my bank account.
They did this to me after turning on my views for a couple days a couple weeks ago, after slamming the lid on my listings in mid-Februrary when I started posting against this destructive "promoted listings" nonsense (so they could claim I wasn't permanently shut down, even though, basically, I have been-- except for that 2-day period during which I made one sale.)
monica-sells
but can someone please tell me what legitimate, reasonable policy does eBay have to withhold my funds?
sure, it's right on their policy page,,,,read it for yourself....
New or infrequent sellers will experience transaction holds while learning best selling practices. This helps sellers become established and build a strong selling history on eBay. New sellers typically experience holds for up to 14 days, although sometimes it may be longer.
https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/getting-paid/getting-paid-items-youve-sold/payments-hold
make a couple sales and all will be good to go....
kensgiftshop
Not sure what your credit score has to do with Ebay?
They are holding the funds because it's been awhile since you've sold much and the item sold for more then $1000.
Since they consider you a new seller, they can hold the funds for 30 days.
dnasilver
eBay's managed payments have everything to do with knowing people's credit scores, average cash balances on hand in their checking account, and so on. They use more information then most know about because of required reporting for the Fed's.
stephenmorgan
That be why I keep getting these unsolicited offers from eBay to Expand my business with flexible funding options from eBay Seller Capital.
silverstatetreasureboxes
@twalens
You've had sporadic sales this past year and ebay is treating you as a new seller. You may have the years behind you but the sales aren't consistent.
Please don't go overboard with these engines until you start to see your funds being released, red flags possible.