Why oh why do so many clothing sellers not put dimensions in their listing?
Summary: sin-n-dex expressed frustration over online clothing listings that lack measurements, highlighting the risk of expensive international purchases without the ability to return items easily. chapeau-noir and others agreed that generic manufacturer size charts are unreliable, especially for pre-owned clothing. Participants discussed the inconsistency across brands and the importance of knowing garment measurements rather than relying solely on size tags. Several contributors, including fm2000, emphasized the necessity of measurements in listings to ensure proper fit. The discussion acknowledged the challenging nature of online clothing shopping due to these sizing issues.
To start with, I use a computer, not a smart phone. So I can actually easily read the description.
I was shopping for a skirt, found some I liked, they put the size, but no dimensions. How am I supposed to know what waist size an 8, 10, 12 or whatever is if there's no dimensions in the listing? How long is it? Will my butt show when I bend over? Dimensions would help me figure this stuff out.
They don't take returns, and even then a remorse return has shipping both ways. I'm in Canada, it costs me more to pay for postage than the items I want are selling for. Then I have to pay 1.40 on the exchange into Canadian dollars. A $25 dress easily costs me $73 CAD once everything is added, and there's still import fees on top of that. It's an expensive risk to take, to be buying stuff and not knowing the actual dimensions!! At least if I knew and it didn't fit, perhaps I measured myself wrong or am not the size I thought I was.
I'm seeing this on lots and lots of listings... I looked at 10 listings today, and only 2 had dimensions. I back arrowed out of the ones that don't have dimensions and move on to another listing.
I might not get great deals, but I think I'll just buy at the consignment shop in town... at least there I can try it on and see how big it is.
C.
reallynicestamps
"They don't take returns, and even then a remorse return has shipping both ways."
Once again, No Returns does not mean No Refunds.
However, if the manufacturer's size is given, there should not be a Not As Described claim, even though there were no measurements.
pickapaper
Just because a manufacturer's tag is given doesn't mean it is correct. Apparently you have never bought a garment that had a manufacturer's tag that was incorrect. I buy many of my clothes at online upscale stores and I can't tell you how many times I have received things that were clearly tagged incorrectly. It's not just one or two; it's several over the years. And it's not that they just don't fit me, it's that they are ridiculous-to-the-extreme don't fit. I wear a size medium. I have received things that would have fit an elephant and I have received things that would fit a 10-year-old.
Oftentimes that is why things end up never selling in stores, nice things that are deeply discounted but are still sitting there, because they are damaged, defective, or sized wrong. Usually when I go to a B&M store and go through the sale racks at the end of the season, I always look at the sizes above and below mine and it's surprising how many things I find that fit me that are not my usual size.
reallynicestamps
I agree with your premise. But that's vanity sizing for you.
If the seller gives the manufacturer's size and the buyer receives the manufacturer's size, it is not the seller's "fault" that the manufacturer is a gibbering idiot.
But.
That's why measurements are a sign of a professional approach to selling clothing and worth watching for.
pickapaper
I agree with the vanity sizing thing as it is a reality. However, I was addressing your comment "If the manufacturer's size is given, there should not be a Not As Described claim, even though there were no measurements." Even though the manufacturer's tag size is given does not mean that tag size is correct.
I am talking about true mismarks. I have an expensive jacket that I bought at Saks online last year. It was a "final sale" item but it was a brand that I owned pieces of so I was confident buying it. When I got it, I couldn't even get it on my arms; it was teeny tiny, probably an extra small. I called the store and they refused (of course) to do anything because they sent the "size I ordered". In this case, it was the manufacturer's fault, but I imagine manufacturers have some kind of clause about not being held responsible for their mistakes and the stores just pass these mistakes on to unsuspecting customers as a "final sale".
Clothing is a tough category to sell in. I understand about sellers not wanting to take returns but I also understand that manufacturing mistakes are made that are neither the buyer's nor the seller's fault.
adamcartwright
Gotta strongly disagree.
A manufacturer's size tag is an arbitrary designation based on the manufacturer's own size chart, how the particular pieces of fabric were cut and sewn, how the garment is intended to fit (slim, relaxed, oversized, etc.).
Just ask any woman who's purchased a Free People XS, which looks like it's a 3XL because it's a very oversized cut.
I mentioned below about two identical Ralph Lauren men's shirts I sold last year. The Medium had a 1-2" larger armpit measurement than the Large.
In my own closet, I have sizes ranging from XS to XL.
Without measurements, you cannot know if the item will fit you. You can only take an educated guess, on a wing and a prayer.
adamcartwright
My biggest complaint about shopping on eBay, hands down.
I have campaigned for measurements to be required.
I don't even ask anymore, when measurements are not included.
Just move on and find a seller who's more interested in selling.
P.S. For those who say sizes are always standard within brands -- False.
I've sold two similar Ralph Lauren Polo shirts. The Medium had a larger underarm measurement than the Large.
Obviously different cuts, but that info is rarely included in the listings.
chapeau-noir
Absolutely - I wear Nike Golf shirts mostly, and size medium is anywhere from 36" bust to 40" bust - even in-brand items have no standard sizing because they decide of it's 'athletic cut' or 'regular cut' (but don't indicate it on any labeling). For someone who's a tailor's nightmare to begin with, clothes buying is frustrating - one reason I hate shopping for clothing.
luckythewinner
There are millions of sellers on eBay, and they are all different.
Some are short; some are tall.
Some are nice; some are mean.
Some are happy; some are sad.
Some support diversity; some cheer bullies.
Some add measurements; some do not.
chapeau-noir
Only we're talking about specs for a specific market. I guess that would be:
Some like to sell and some do not.
luckythewinner
There are plenty of sellers who get sales without adding measurements. My guess is that they have chosen listing volume over listing completeness; i.e. "many listings with no measurements" over "fewer listings with measurements" because taking measurements and adding them to a listing takes time. I'm not defending the practice, just offering a possible explanation.
chapeau-noir
Oh, definitely these sellers have decided that the time saved not listing measurements is somehow compensated by being able to list more, or take less time listing. My feeling is that they're leaving money on the table, but yeah, that's their equation and I assume they ran the numbers. One odd explanation is that it gives a buyer an 'in' to disputing measurements - the seller against the buyer and so getting a free try-on and return if it doesn't fit with an NAD, but I refuse to take such an adversarial position (even though it happened to me once).
adamcartwright
Yes, a lot of slapdash listing.
I had to return something once when the "measurement" shown in the photo was just the end of the yardstick under the armpit.
When I got it home, that measurement shown in the photo was actually 2 inches larger than reality.
I was swimming in the thing.
policequilts
This has been brought up on the forums a lot.
I know that you see something you really like, and they don't put the full description, just pass by.
Shop the sellers who provide both "manufacture sizes" and gives measurements.
A manufactured size varies from each manufacturer.
You have the vanity sizes: Jeans may say 32 inch waist and the actual measurement size is a 34 inch waist. ( American Eagle is one of them )
Then you have what the fabrics is. Then tied this in with : is it NEW or Used.
Used, depending on the previous owner's way of washing . . . shrinkage.
I always wash my jeans in hot water and they are cotton. ( I sanitize them from the work I do ) They shrink. I always buy a larger size (NEW) because of what I do.
BUT, if you really want the item, then message the seller for actually measurements.
sin-n-dex
OPFortunately I found the size 10 and size 12 measurements on another seller's listing (not for the specific skirt, but that brand). Turns out I need a size 14. The bigger the size, the less cute clothes that are available. I'm not overweight, but shaped like a pear, so I need to consider my bottom sizes might not be the same as dress sizes that have stretchy fabric and lots of "give".
fm2000
Anyone who wears dresses will know their measurements, it is critical for proper fit. Womens clothing tends to be more complicated and women come in a wider variety of shapes and sizes at a given height and weight. It is simple math and engineering. Measurements are vital.
And clothing sizes are completely unstandardized, which drives my scientist mind absolutely crazy. Forget all sizes, go by measurements. And these faux-standard sizes have changed over time. And some clothing can shrink with washing too. Imagine a lumber yard selling boards with some usually-fits-but-only-an-approximation size system, or jugs of milk being sold in "vanity" sizes instead of an exact amount.
Plenty of us do include measurements, buy from someone who does. No measurements, no sale.
inhawaii
Just speaking for myself (and I'm sure I'm not alone) I have no idea what my measurements are. I know what size I am and that's all I know. Is this a typical guy thing?
sin-n-dex
OPSome guy sizes for things are the measurements... like my partner wears size 32 jeans because he has a 32" waist. I know my waist measurement, but I don't know how that translates into sizes like 8, 10, 12... I do OK with small medium and large categories for sizes, I've gambled a few times that I needed a specific size, also that seller put measurements, I compared the measurements against clothes I knew fit.
fabrics24
I despise the way most brands do women's sizes; these size numbers correlate with nothing (or if they do, nothing that's applicable while I'm shopping), and therefore mean nothing to me. I wish it was like with men's sizes where it's the hip width and leg inseam; it seems so much easier to me, especially after mending and resizing men's clothing for a few years.
monroe67
Many higher-end women's clothing lines have engaged in "vanity sizing" for eons.
A size 12 at Sears might be able to buy and wear a size 8 from Saks Fifth Avenue.
chapeau-noir
No - my DH knows his sizing and purchases clothing that fits that sizing.
That men's clothing sizing is consistent is a huge myth - I wear men's pants and they range anywhere from a 31" waist to a 34" waist. It's nuts.
fabrics24
Fun insider fact: a lot of the measurements are technically more accurate for industrial clothing, like work pants and suits issued by companies, rather than what most people are buying in the store. However, the measurements aren't always correct on those either, because instead of buying new clothes all the time, several companies pay to have their leased clothing resized and mended, which can alter the size and fit entirely.
I used to resize men's pants all the time at my old job; what was listed on the tag often didn't apply anymore by the time I'd altered the garment to fit its current owner, and I'd alter it again if the owner either left the company or gained/lost weight.
chapeau-noir
Military surplus works pretty well.
adamcartwright
You don't need to know your measurements.
You just need to know the measurements of garments that fit you well and compare those to the listing -- underarms on a shirt, Shoulder seams, length on a shirt, pant waist, inseam, rise, etc.
tobaccocardyahoo
Many sellers do not put measurements on their listing because they NEVER think of it being important.
They buy for themselves in person and try on the clothes or they return that which does not fit.
I rarely buy clothing on line, and when I do, I buy brands I know the fit of.
sin-n-dex
OPYeah I do that too (buy brands where I know the fit). This was a little tricky because I knew the brand, but I was buying a skirt not a dress, I know what size dress I wear, but I want to make sure the skirt fits over my large behind before I buy it.
If I get a chance to try on that brand at the consignment shop, I can probably have a better idea of what size I need. I'd gamble, but it's a lot of money to throw away if it doesn't fit (even if they do take returns, I'm out shipping both ways which is way more money than the item costs).
msha3839
Indeed they never think…🤯….in my case, 99% of my communications with sellers is due to luck of measurements for items in the listings …it can be paintings, vases and much more…
chapeau-noir
That annoys me, also, when I shop online. And before someone says "But...but...but...you can just look up the item on the manufacturer's size chart" - preowned clothing may have a different fit, and manufacturer's size charts are often accurate only within about 1-2 inches, depending on the cut and style. Fine when you're dealing with a seller who takes returns (be it personal seller or company), but someone who doesn't take returns on pre-owned clothing is a little more dicey.
pickapaper
I agree about those manufacturer's size charts; a brand uses the same chart for all their garments and some of those are horribly wrong because they don't take into account cut and fit.
A while back I was looking for a particular blouse in a brand that I know. Three sellers had it in my size. But the blouse was oversized fit and I wasn't sure if I should go down a size or not, which I sometimes do. Two sellers listed measurements, one did not but provided them when I asked. All three sellers' measurements for the same blouse in the same size were different (they had measured a little differently) so I couldn't tell anything by that. So, I went with the one seller who offered returns and luckily I was very happy with the blouse, no need to return.
adamcartwright
Size charts are baloney, IMO.
A manufacturer will use the same size chart for different cuts -- slim, oversized, relaxed, etc.