Why my Ebay stores always block everyone with private feedback
Why would a legitimate buyer set his feedback to "private"? What is he hiding? Something is very fishy.
Our Ebay stores have encountered major problems with many if not most of these buyers, such as attempted extortion of partial refunds under threat of leaving fake negative feedback; cases inexplicably opened just one or two days after orders were placed; puzzling cancellation requests; returns demanded months after the return privilege had expired; or dozens or even hundreds of harassing messages.
We always look for red flags in order to avoid dealing with criminals and weirdos. Private feedback is one of them and invariably results in a block. These lowlifes are never worth the trouble, at least in our experience.
Heck, we blocked a creep today who demanded to see a coin in its PCGS holder because he did not trust us. Yet, we are supposed to trust him, an anonymous total stranger with almost no feedback? He is probably a crook himself, hence his paranoia and projection.
Some fellow coin dealers refuse to sell on Ebay due to the plethora of scammers and wackos. But our screening process dramatically reduces interactions with such undesirables.
Curiously, our biggest spending customers NEVER set their feedback to "private". Or give us a hard time in any other way.
mn467462
Don't listen to the haters. I understand your decision 100%. Once you've dealt with a bad buyer, you get so discouraged that you want to quit.
vintagecraze50
We have a selling and buying account. Many chose not have to their purchase shown on their buying account. We are avid buyers on here that pay promptly and buy a lot of stuff.
retrogames10000
I was not aware that you can open a graded coin holder - I thought the whole point of the case was that you had to smash it to get the coin so you can't swap out different grades..?
joseh1445
Very simple questions. Are you a seller or collector? That you sell items above $1,000,000, to me that's your attitude. If I was selling what you are selling, I would not be here asking the questions that you are asking, furthermore, you have a very negative attitude. Why? I don't know. But I have learn that you attract what you (I) think.
Best of luck on your selling journey. I really hope that you sell $1,000,000 of the stuff that you are selling or more.
certifiedcitynet
OPI am a full-time dealer, of course.
The point is that I want to see a buyer's "Feedback left for others" due to the many problems that we have encountered with Negative Nellies who have each left negs for many reputable sellers. This revealing feedback is not visible from those who have set it to private.
I do indeed have a "negative attitude" about crooks, wackos, and backbreakers due to the time-wasting problems they cause, hence my pursuit to weed them out in advance.
But just to be clear to anyone who is considering selling rare coins (or other pricier items) on Ebay, I estimate that 99% of buyers are wonderful. It is the unpleasant 1% whom I want to avoid. I increase my chances of doing this by not dealing with buyers who set their feedback to private.
And I agree, not every buyer who makes their feedback private is an undesirable, but most are in my experience, at least those who order expensive rare coins.
rugerskick
Anything that tweaks your gut reaction of something being off, always listen to it. Always.
itsjustasprain
Since your listings are almost entirely Buyitnow I am wondering how much screening you can really do if a buyer with feedback set to Private does not contact you in advance for any reason. Do you simply cancel his purchase?
certifiedcitynet
OPGood point! You cannot screen buyers who do not contact you in advance. You just have to endure their abuse for that purchase. But you can block them from future buying/bidding.
coolections
If I was to buy a rare expensive coins you better bet I would want my feedback private. Also you are not understating ALL buyers have positive feedback so hiding feedback is a big waste of your time. You know you are losing a protentional of 10-20% of your customer pool. Lastly your are doing BIN so regardless of any type of feedback a person has they can still buy from you as you have no choice.
certifiedcitynet
OPMost of your points are valid.
I understand that not all private feedback buyers will be trouble. But "many if not most" who buy valuable coins will be (based on my experiences), so I go with the odds and block them if they message in advance, which most private feedback people do (what do both behaviors say about their insecurities and thus mental health?).
And a buyer's private feedback prevents me from seeing their feedback left for others, the main reason for blocking them.
buyselljack2016
I suppose some may, but a real scammer has no need/reason to message you before purchasing. Just the opposite, but your account, your choice how to handle it ðŸ˜
The good scammers keep the lowest profile possible.
gloryglorygifts
I think people might put their feedback on "private" because they may feel they are protected from ads, etc. or third parties getting their buying history. They have a false sense of security from doing that on other social media sites and may think it works here too. They aren't all weirdos and scammers. Sometimes they are just people trying to stay secure in their buying.
transamcc
I set my feedback to "private" a few months ago when I got tired of the ebay cheerleaders on these forums using the honest feedback I had left for sellers to criticize and personally belittle me in the forums instead of providing constructive assistance on issues I brought here for answers. There are a few who seem to have canned answers for every post whether or not it has anything to do with a real solution. I buy only.
certifiedcitynet
OPYou did nothing wrong by making your feedback private. My OP was intended to alert sellers of expensive rare coins (and possibly other valuables) to the problems encountered with private feedback buyers.
certifiedcitynet
OPIn my experience, the "canned answer" critics tend to be those who buy and/or sell very inexpensive items, or even nothing at all. Those who post the most know the least yet purport to be experts about everything Ebay related.
rosszonebricks
I guess I never look at a Buyer's feedback. They pay, I ship.
postcardcountry
After looking at your listings and your feedback, I totally understand why you do what you do.
It reminded me of the stories about gem merchants in New York City who wouldn't even open the door to their business until you had an appointment and had already been vetted.
certifiedcitynet
OPBingo! When selling pricer items on Ebay, you need to have a screening process that reduces the risk of fraud and other problems.
joseh1445
I have had more issues with buyers, that are also sellers. But very few issues with people that have a private feedback, or with people that have 0 feedback. In my humble opinion, you are overacting.
Good luck on your selling journey.
certifiedcitynet
OPYou are in a different universe. You sell $10 to $50 watches, we sell expensive rare coins, whose buyers have a high rate of fraud, which is why many coin dealers refuse to sell on Ebay.
Our screening process is designed to weed out these thugs. And yes, a few might not be crooks at all but we go with the odds using our actual experiences.
44012
Some people just don't like the items they buy to be shown for the eBay community to see. Maybe they are personal items or perhaps a gift they are purchasing or have purchased. Sometimes it is not always about feedback but yes, sometimes it is. I have not had any problems with buyers who have feedback private but yes, it does make me a bit nervous.
I am sure it makes buyers nervous too when sellers have this set to private as well.
slippinjimmy
It would which is why selling accounts are not able to have Private Feedback!
44012
I honestly did not know that. I could swear I was buying something from someone and their feedback was all marked private so I moved on. Thanks I must have been mistaken 😊
nobody*s_perfect
Sellers can set individual listings to "Private," so that the feedback comments don't show any information about the listing (title, listing number, price). That's not the same as hiding their entire feedback profile.
toomuchstuffagain35
Yep, but I don't trust those either lol
cardxcraft
Sellers can set their bidders/buyers username to private...to me, those are the shadiest auctions. Yes, the exception is its allowing your bidders a certain amount of privacy, which they have regardless, the rule is the seller is up to no good. It's just too easy to shill bid.
certifiedcitynet
OPExactly! Private feedback can also be abused by dishonest sellers.
stacy_pme
I do occasionally sell rare coins, and I do sell gold & silver jewelry (which can have a high rate of scam), as well as rare video games (ditto... high rate of scam).... and so I understand your plight better than a few others might. I will say, sellers cannot set their feedback to private, the system will not let you set your feedback to private if you have any active listings.... Now if a seller gets reprimanded and loses their selling ability, they can set their feedback to private (assuming all listings were removed), and they may continue to use that account to buy with.... Or you have a buyer with a bunch of feedback from sellers that are negative (yes I know sellers can't leave negative feedback, but they can leave positive feedback with negative comments - which can get sellers in trouble.... but it does happen).... Some sellers might leave a positive feedback with a comment like "buyer never paid" stuff like that, I see it all the time. In fact I have a buyer right whose feedback score is 173 and made an offer that I accepted and still hasn't paid (it's been 3 days), with a feedback rating on their account from another seller calling them a "deadbeat buyer that didn't pay". I also have a lot of buyers with zero to less than 10 feedback score that make offers, but never pay, so I have changed my policy to only accept offers from people with a feedback score higher than 10.
Sometimes you just gotta do what you think is right, the market will correct you... it always does. If you institute a policy that isn't working, your sales will drop, and you will end up doing what you need to do to bring your sales back up. I don't see a problem with you not wanting to sell to buyers with private feedback, but there is no way to filter them out. You can't go around cancelling all sorts or orders either or your performance ratings will go down, so you will have to find your own path. It's not against ebay policy to have a private feedback. My recommendation is to set your prices high enough that you can absorb the few scammers that have private feedback and slip through. In the end it will all work out.
I also wanted to add.... If you sell properly and you develop a good reputation, in the event that a problem does arise that is a bigger deal, eBay will back you up. I have had a few occasions of things going sideways that were semi-big deals, and eBay backed me. It helps if you develop a good reputation, because 9 times out of 10 the person in the wrong will have other wrongs on their record...
certifiedcitynet
OPSome sellers do indeed mark all of their feedback as "private". But you can still see their buyers' feedback, just not what item was purchased with each feedback post. And you can still see what the seller actually sold within the prior 90 days:
> See other items
> Show only
> Sold items
certifiedcitynet
OPAgain, we do not sell personal items, we sell expensive rare coins, whose sales have a high rate of fraud as noted in my OP.
stuff4divas
nvm already addressed
ms.rodriguez*
People do this because they don't want a spouse or family member to know what they bought. It does not have to be a porn item. Years ago, the buyers IDs were not hidden. So a wife could check to see what hubby bought and vice versa. That is not that much of a problem now . I have not had an issue with any buyer with a private feedback.
stuff4divas
@certifiedcitynet some people think it's nobody's business what they buy
i think there would be more private setting accounts if it was more well known to do so
personally, i never had a problem with a private setting account buyer in the 14 years i've been selling
certifiedcitynet
OPOur experiences differ. You do not sell rare coins, as we do.
luckythewinner
Why would a legitimate buyer set his feedback to "private"? What is he hiding? Something is very fishy.
Because he is incontinent and bought adult diapers and some seller mentioned the item he bought in his feedback.
Heck, we blocked a creep today who demanded to see a coin in its PCGS holder because he did not trust us.
Why would you not show a picture of a PCGS graded coin in its PCGS holder? What are you hiding? Something is very fishy.
certifiedcitynet
OPYour answers are pure guesses. I doubt that we would have gone to the trouble to list $8 million worth of coins (auction value) just to attempt to cheat someone out of $1,000. And risk losing our membership in the CDN Exchange and their status as the third highest bidder in dollar volume.
Rare coins do not photograph well in holder shot, genius. Such photos make coins look much darker, duller, and uglier than they are.
luckythewinner
Your answers are pure guesses
My answer was simply an example of an reason why a buyer might not want his feedback comments exposed.
You sell $5 "adult diapers", we sell expensive rare coins
I do not sell adult diapers. And expensive coin buyers do not only buy expensive coins.
Rare coins do not photograph well in holder shot, genius. Such photos make coins look much darker, duller, and uglier than they are.
You can add a photo in the holder in addition to your detailed photos. The two are not mutually exclusive.
Plus, I googled "PCGS graded coins" and saw plenty of beautiful, bright, clear photographs of coins in holders. Maybe the issue with those dark, dull, ugly photos of yours is not due to the PCGS holder?
we sell expensive rare coins, whose sales have a high rate of fraud as noted in my OP
All the more reason why a buyer would want to see the PCGS graded holder.
certifiedcitynet
OPYou know everything about selling rare coins on Ebay yet I know nothing, even though you do not sell any but I have $8 million listed in one store alone. Got it!
My OP applied to my actual experiences with selling rare coins, not your speculation and guesswork based on your zero experience thereof.
You do not sell expensive rare coins, I do. Going with the odds, you sell inexpensive items for which there is little to no risk of fraud.
Our slab photos impede sales in my experience because they make coins look much darker, duller, and uglier than they actually are, hence our use of only closeups, which tend to be more realistic.
We are not professional photographers. But yes, experienced pros can take more attractive slab photos than we can.
In my experience, people who ask for full slab photos usually turn out to be crooks, fraudsters, and or backbreakers.
But again, you know everything about Ebay rare coins sales yet I know nothing.
buyselljack2016
Mine is not a "pure guess".
My feedback is set to private, because it is absolutely no one's business what I buy on eBay, or anyplace else.
Nothing nefarious, just nunya.
certifiedcitynet
OPI did not say the YOU are nefarious. I said that, based on my experiences selling expensive rare coins, "many if not most" buyers who have private feedback turn out to be scammers, nutcases, and/or backbreakers.
I am speaking from my perspective. If I sold $5 adult diapers, I would no doubt have a different slant.
certifiedcitynet
OPYou sell $5 "adult diapers", we sell expensive rare coins, whose transactions have a high rate of fraud. Many coin dealers refuse to sell on Ebay because of it. Hence, our screening process.
Coins do not photograph well in full slab shots, which make them look dull, dark, and ugly, and thus discourage sales.
movieman630
Honestly, some people just like privacy.
hartungcards
Buyers who set their feedback to private are "criminals, weirdos, creeps, scammers and wackos?" Sounds like your screening process dramatically reduces interactions with potential buyers.
certifiedcitynet
OPI said "many if not most" buyers, not all.