Why don't my items remain available to buy while a slowpoke waits to pay?
I don't have auto-pay enabled. I keep hearing about buyers having "their" item snatched out from under them (meaning they had their offer accepted but then stalled paying and someone else got it). But whenever I accept an offer, it disappears from my active listings whether the offer-maker pays that day, 4 days later, or never. The only thing I can think of is I have auto-accept amounts on my items, so it's not "me" accepting the offer but the software ...... but that shouldn't make a difference. In fact if anything the buyer knows immediately that their offer was accepted so I wouldn't even feel slightly bad if they then clicked over to Netflix or whatever instead of coughing up the dough, and someone else bought.
So what setting(s) does it take for this 'remaining active' status?
wastingtime101
I could be wrong, but I believe it's precisely because you don't have auto-pay enabled within your buyer requirements that your active listing is ended when the offer is accepted.
Sellers requiring auto-pay are the ones whose listings remain active and available to others until paid for.
gurlcat
OPBut .... that .... doesn't make sense. How can an item remain available if it's already (automatically) paid for by the offer-making buyer?
wastingtime101
If anybody knows it's @ittybitnot and I believe she has also pointed out it does not make sense, but that's what the reports are all saying.
Instead of eBay forcing auto-pay, what they're doing (in some situations) is leaving the item available until paid for.
Speaking as a buyer, I am always immediately charged with auto-pay and have never seen my offer sitting in limbo.
gurlcat
OPWell here is where I better share something I just realized. What provoked me to make this post was a recent Buyers thread: https://community.ebay.com/t5/Buying/I-made-an-offer-buyer-accepted-and-then-sold-out-from-under-me/m-p/34852283#M509119
-but now that I look at it again, it's a bit more complicated than the question I asked. -Actually more than a bit; it's about a seller-initiated offer, WITH a counter-offer made by the buyer and accepted by the seller. Oy.
For fuh sake eBay, WHY did this have to become such a hairy convoluted thing, when you could have just made 'number of days to pay' a simple pull-down menu setting in Seller Preferences? WHYYYY????
tobaccocardyahoo
Because this process is unnatural to the people at Ebay who define the software functions, and the people who implement the software.
The entire Make A Offer/Best Offer process is unnatural to a portion of the US population, and perfectly natural (but poorly implemented) to another portion.
You do not make an offer when shopping at Walmart, or Macy's or Nordstrom or your local boutique, buy you might at a Souk or Flea Market.
gurlcat
OPTRUE. -But as is still (occasionally) invoked, eBay is the "online garage sale" so in that sense it is logical to enable a way let people make offers. -I don't by the way, at garage sales; I think it's tacky and awkward, unless the person having the sale says something to welcome it. But I know from having my own garage sales, some people have no qualms about asking for a lower price on every-dang-thing, even already-crazy-cheap prices.
Thing is though ..... when they make an offer and have it accepted, the garage-sale-haver doesn't have the item immediately locked in a black box where nobody else can even see it, while the offer-maker silently turns around and walks away ..... to go to their car where they left their wallet? to drive to an ATM? to go ask someone for the money? or WHAT? Just imagine if that happened in person, the utter lack of manners. I wouldn't even hold the item by my side, I'd plunk it right back out on the table, ha!
And never mind the black box lasting for FOUR DAYS. So yeah you're right, it's not like Walmart but not like a garage sale either. It's worse than either. And yes I would totally abstain from even messing with it -in fact I did for my first couple years here, nothing but BIN/IPR pricing -until the pandemic sales boom ended, and I realized I couldn't afford to miss out on those kind of people's business anymore.
ittybitnot
For fuh sake eBay, WHY did this have to become such a hairy convoluted thing....
@gurlcat
From reading, listening, and generally following this mess for over a year now, I have come to the conclusion that eBay is trying to discourage combined shipping for a reduced charge. It was "pitched" as the answer to a supposed non-paying buyer problem, but in truth it was and still is an attempt to monetize the supposed problem to increase revenue for eBay. They have posted in more than one venue that their goal is taking longer than expected because of blowback from buyers that 'need to be retrained' to not expect combined multiple items for one shipping charge.
You were here when the drama was at an all time high, with different users being shown different screens, for different actions and eBay and staff simply ignoring the questions posed the questions asked repeatedly on this forum. One day something worked, the next day it didn't, and the day after that there was a new unannounced protocol being employed.
Not counting all the ways the "request total" could malfunction and has for years, the new combined shipping killer was the "Buyer Requirements" renamed the BUYER RULES with the default set to YES.
These require the buyer (once forcibly enrolled by eBay) to put up a payment source in order to make an offer or place a bid. Payment options are limited. Offers made this way are BUYER GENERATED OFFERS. If you retain the buyer rules and the buyer is stupid enough to make offers on multiple listings, as soon as the seller accepts an offer the buyer is auto billed (aka auto-pay program) for each item separately at full shipping price for each. Invoicing/combined shipping charges are not allowed.
If you as a seller, have dispensed the the "Buyer Rules" your buyers will not be auto-billed, but can make offers or bid on multiple items and request a total for combined shipping. You pay ONE .40 cent fee, instead of a 40 cent fee on each product.
When you send offers (to people you have no clue about that eBay tells you are interested buyers). These are called SELLER GENERATED OFFERS. eBay declared that ALL SELLER GENERATED OFFERS will be immediate payment required. The buyer no longer has an accept button, can no longer combine items for one shipping price, and has to pay the full amount in separate transactions. THIS is for everybody and is NOT affected by the buyer rules. These remain for sale until somebody pays.
Then comes the complication of a "COUNTER OFFER". For a "counter offer" it doesn't matter about the buyer rules either. If you 'accept' a counter offer, it is treated like you sent and offer. Immediate payment is required for each separately paid for transaction (or the buyer doesn't have to pay at all). I don't know for sure if it has changed, but buyers cannot be invoiced for 'counter offers' you accept, nor can you file the cancellation for non-payment and award the buyer a strike. They remain for sale, until paid for just like offers you send. This does nothing to cut down on non-payers, but is effective in eliminating another way of combining orders.
Treating all buyers like non-paying deadbeats with all this nonsense does not provide a buyer friendly experience. A good buyer experience is cast aside in favor of making more money and counting more transactions for eBay's GMV.
Yes, others that have retained the "Buyer Rules" that should result in their buyer being auto-billed are confused as to why their buyer is not auto-billed and their item remains for sale. I think they are confused with offers they SEND, or counter offers they accept as these will not be affected by the auto-pay/auto billing program.
For seller generated offers, there is no "accept" button for a buyer. They pay or don't. Same for counter offers be they originated by the seller or buyer, and I think that is where a lot of the confusion comes in...I believe if it was the eBay blue @kyle@ebay that confirmed that nothing had changed with the auto-billing/aka auto pay system, and sellers that retain the buyer rules should see their buyers being charged separately for each transaction....UNLESS A COUNTER OFFER IS INVOLVED...LOL.
gurlcat
OP😥When you were tagged, I was afraid your answer would be about combined shipping because I know that's your main issue with this auto-pay stuff, but it is virtually a non-issue for me. I get repeat buyers but multi-item orders are maybe 1 out of 50, at most.
femmefan1946
Do you have the automatic 96 hours to pay or eBay gives your deadbeat a Strike and releases the "sold" item?
And I highly recommend the automatic Accept/Reject parameters that are available, because the buyer is told immediately that their Offer is Accepted (when they offer the Accept amount or higher) and can then just pay, as if it were a Fixed Price purchase.
Because my items on all my accounts are longtail, I make a difference between automatic rejection and automatic acceptance, to allow for time in stock, but it is entirely possible to make that difference a penny. (eg- 98c reject/99c accept. )
gurlcat
OPYes, 96 hours to pay or they get an automatic strike. Also I have my settings pretty strict on blocking buyers with deadbeat history. As for my auto reject/accept amounts, I set them identical each time. I figure if an offer is enough to consider, it's enough to accept, then I don't have to ever bother considering, lol. When I get a notification that I sold an item, it's just a matter of whether they bought at the full listing price (in which case they've already paid because I have Immediate Payment Required checked for that), or if they made an offer at or above my auto-reject/accept amount. -Then it's a matter of waiting for them to pay.
But when that happens, the item is no longer visible in search results or available for anyone else to buy. According to lots of posts I see here, within the past couple years some sellers' accounts keep those items active -so the buyer can't get a discount AND exclusive right to buy at any price. THAT'S WHAT I WANT TOO. It would be the biggest Christmas present to me.