When is it time to drop a specialty?
So, when I started ebay full time I was in a wheelchair, limited to one room of the house and could barely lift anything so I started out selling cards.
I haven't restocked cards in years, but I still have over 10,000 listings for them.
A year ago I was clearing over $700 a month on those cards. Now it is down to $120 a month (all expenses included, even the higher level ebay store I have just to accomodate the cards).
Sure, I could increase promoted listings more or reduce prices (they are all 2.99 plus ship as far as I am concerned), but that would just make them less worth dealing with. As right now I clear $1.70 per card (out of that $2.99 plus shipping), that is absolutely still worth pulling and shipping. But the sales go down every month now, and dealing with cards is messy because there are card supplies everywhere.
Do I ride it out until the extra store cost makes it go negative or do I start live sale bulking them out right now? I would love to hear the opinions of someone who kissed cards, stamps postcards or something similar goodbye.
johnrj1226
Collectors are a flicked group - not certain the Z gen is into it. I preferred to sell items of higher /item in price like 45 bucks/item + shipping and handling charge that produced 46.5% average gross profit based on selling price (not mark-up) item only over 1665 items sold.
When items profit margins dropped significantly simply dropped the items and found other items to sell that met my business criteria/plan.
But to each their own,
toysaver
"Do I ride it out until the extra store cost makes it go negative or do I start live sale bulking them out right now? "
Do a trial run and see if selling them on lots works.
onefootflipper
OPThe main thing about lots is that it is going to be one of those fraction of the price thing. I might get $3 for some random "rare" magic the gathering card. But I will be lucky to get $10 for an assortment of 100. I know because I have already started bulk selling some of the cards that I never processed.
bashort
I would probably leave them listed while switching my focus to something more profitable as long as they were still producing a profit as I switched to something different.
tobaccocardyahoo
Your $2.99 cards are below the price level that I have ever sold online for, so the decision is solely what the minimum price is that you are willing to invest your time for and take the risks of having an Ebay customer. We all have our personal sense of worth which contributes to what we sell here.
My experience as someone who has bought at auction for resale is that the value of wholesale lots of low priced items is a tiny fraction of the already low price they generate in quantity one.
I have even ceased to sell complete sets of cards on Ebay because Ebay buyers want to pay less for a set than the sum of the card values.
Breaking a set brings me more dollars, which historically is not what it used to be.
IMO you should stop selling these cards when you no longer want to or the cost of a store puts you in the red.
One of my daughters recently closed her Ebay store because her sales had past that point, and she no longer had access to the sources she had been buying from. She put off taking actions until it was obvious that the status quo was unacceptable.
Its likely that you have already decided what to do, and need some encouragement to kick the habit. Ebay can be addictive.
lakefor94
Don't know squat about cards.
Though my thought would be to make as much as you can off the cards by bulk listing, as fast as you can. Turnover all the product you can and move on so the store fee does not eat you up.
For me, 2026 will be about:
I will be moving old inventory to the scrapyard and trash can. Slooooow movers won't have a place unless they don't take up much room. Over the last 8 years of fulltime selling, I have learned what moves and what does not in the networking realm. Some of that product takes up storage space.
I got my work cut out for me in 2026..... fwiw
chapeau-noir
I've had to put the stake into a number of markets (the last time it was books). My feeling is when something has run its course and you know it has run its course, just rip the bandaid off - bulk them up, sell them out and devote your energies to something with a more promising future. The first thing I did last time is arrange things so that I could lower my store cost. And don't close the door to keeping cards as a small side line, i.e., if you find some particularly good.
onefootflipper
OPI have a few better ones that I have large stock on. I had definitely planned on keeping those.
chapeau-noir
Basically what I did was keep the best of what was left and continued selling it down as I started something newer. I still sell books, in fact I sold a bunch this year, but only the best of what I had left, and I periodically find something good and just list it, but I changed my focus.
inhawaii
No advice or opinion on this matter.
Just wanted to say ... I give you credit for the whole one foot thing.
I'm currently without a foot but my situation is temporary.
Keep up the good work.
P.S. Enjoy you youtube videos.
onefootflipper
OPThanks for watching. I started making the videos because I missed having co-workers. The social media presence has indeed made up for that.
kibble-net
I sold nothing but MTG cards in the 2000s and eventually ended up asking myself the same question at the end of that decade. I ended up auctioning off my remaining inventory in lots broken up by set and moving on from Magic cards.
It sounds from your description that it may be time to convert your singles into bulk lots, so you can focus your time and energy better on more profitable things. And have more space for those things too 🙂