What do you think would be a fair fee to sell on eBay??
Lots of folks complain about the fee eBay charges to sell in their sandbox.
What fee do you think would be fair for eBay to charge? What could eBay charge that wouldn't make you complain? Maybe even make you happy.
aeparts1
54 comments
reallynicestamps
@retro_entertainment_collectibles
We got our first Moneris account for our shop in the late 70s, and were charged fees on our customer's entire payment at that time, including Ontario sales tax and any shipping.
Since few of the posters here seem to have managed a B&M retail operation:
https://go.moneris.com/choosemonerisgo?utm_medium=cpc&utm_source=google&utm_id=Mar-23-106-1683656197&utm_key=1&utm_campaign=f2f+choose+and+save+offer+f2f+acquisition+f2f+choose+and+save+offer+won+lp&utm_content=original+products+and+services+google+search+cta+moneris+sem+ao+ma+brand+net+new+en+english&cmfc=proactive&dsch=paid&trgtaud=prospect+merchants&cstjrnstg=awareness&cstprs=+&cmpobj=acquisition&cmpfcs=product&cmpsgm=in+person+payments&cmpprnt=f2f+choose+and+save+offer&cmpnm=f2f+acquisition&cmpsub=f2f+choose+and+save+offer+won+lp&cntapp=original&cntpll=products+and+services&cntheme=google+search+cta+moneris+sem+ao+ma+brand+net+new+en+&cntlng=english&creative=658267439498&keyword=moneris&matchtype=e&network=g&device=c&gad_source=1&gclid=Cj0KCQiAqsitBhDlARIsAGMR1RjT_jmqGmd7zImZAblXnAOfann42nfhOWpVicLrAP-_EC6K96BZyFwaAsSrEALw_wcB
As for shipping costs- There are discount postage stamps sold on eBay (not the Forever booklets, those are counterfeits) which will save more money than most labels. I couldn't possibly give the names of any of the *reallynice* dealers.
retro_entertainment_collectibles
Get lessons real quick with a merchant account not to mention having to bumble through a textbook of rules and regulations. Then there is lease cost of point of sale equipment or software. We were charged $1400 annually for PC-Charge and finally I bought a copy of another called IC Verify which was about $800 only to find we'd had pay for updates.
My volume isn't enough for me worry about postal fees I flat rate at $6.50 using USPS Ground Advantage. I make a few bucks on some, loose a few on others but I hear ya and thanks, will keep in mind if I happen to slide into some other forms of items. I've not listed anywhere near what I have cuz' I keep going the rollercoaster of whether I should just send everything to Mamazon whom I basically loath or do all the work putting it on here wondering as waves appear and then dont. Honestly if someone came in and made me a good offer I'd say, "It's all yours" enjoy listing daily for the next 5 years.
retro_entertainment_collectibles
eBay's take on fee's also pays a card processor likely 2.3-2.8% per transaction and a .25 cent batch closure costing. The fee's a are more than reasonable, 20 years ago fee's on business to consumer sites such as uBid, Onsale, Auction World ranged from 20% to as high as 35% depending on categories/venue not to mention being far far more strict. The card processor doesn't work for free.
So eBay's take probably more in the area of 11% and charging on the total is nothing new. Before the Web even existed if you bought mail order the merchant paid the card processing fee based on total not just product price. So if for example sold something here for $25 and $25 shipping the charge be $50 + tax, and say 2.3% of that is card processing cost
dbfolks166mt
I doesn't really matter what I think it should be. The only thing that matters is what eBay thinks it should be to meet the profit expectations of their shareholders. The rest boils down to simple economics as to whether I can obtain, price and sell my items at a market competitive price where I can still maintain what I consider to be a decent ROI. Ideally if I can sell my items at or below the market equilibrium price and maintain my ROI all is well and I will continue to sell those items. If I cannot and I am forced into a situation where I have to sell above what the market will bear I simply discontinue selling that item(s).
I sell across several venues and platforms and I set my price based on the costs to sell on those platforms and venues and there can be up to a +/- 20% difference between my price on one platform/venue and another. I may have an item price at $100 on one venue and $80 on another but my ROI is the same regardless of which venue the item sells on.
wifetrained
I think it's more important that Ebay get out of sellers and buyers affairs entirely. They stink at it.
glorybells
eBay is actually the lowest fee’s I’ve ever paid to sell my items. I have a brick & mortar shop that I pay around $300/ month for, whether I sell much or not. I once a year sell at a craft fair at a local event, and the fee is 20% of your total sales. I used to sell on another online platform, and their fee was 18% of the total collected from the buyer.
doc-holmes
It's their site.
wifetrained
True enough, but they still stink at it and it's not their money or product at risk.
inhawaii
10% Would sure be nice.
coastaltechsolution
@inhawaii
9% would be better 🙂
buyselljack2016
like it was just before managed payments (I know .............................PP)
coastaltechsolution
Or we could go back to waiting for the check in the mail and then waiting for it to clear before shipping
Oh I miss the 90's ðŸ˜
duffy4444
It doesn't matter what anyone thinks is "fair", as this is just a meaningless exercise.
It's eBay's sandbox and they make the rules and set the fees. The same as with all the other online marketplace venues.
If we wish to play in this sandbox, then we are subject to whatever fees eBay wants to charge.
If we don't wish to play here, our shoes are not nailed to the floor. We are free to walk away and go elsewhere (and complain there, too).
To keep things in true perspective, check into the fees charged by auction houses and many consignment stores, where one also has to contend with business hours and a lot of extra transportation, time, and much limited exposure.
Now, if you'll excuse me, I've got some photos to process, listings to make, and sales to get to the PO..
Cheers, Duffy
coastaltechsolution
@duffy4444
<sarcasm> Thanks for explaining all of that as everyone posting here was probably unaware of all that. </sarcasm>
What is wrong with the OP asking this question and others replying?
duffy4444
@coastaltechsolution:
Greetings!
Nothing wrong at all with the OP posting that. I'm merely adding overall perspective to a futile exercise.
Cheers, Duffy
pls-consignments
Lol.... resistance is "futile".
coastaltechsolution
@duffy4444
I can agree that the subject is like beating a dead horse ðŸ˜
maxine*j
Yeah, but if we limited ourselves to non-futile exercises, the board would be a ghost town. 😄
aeparts1
OPOne of the reasons I posted this question was to try & get some of the sellers who complain on & on about eBay's fee to comment. I am interested in seeing what they think is fair, & see if they are living in reality or fantasy land.
I don't know that I would call this exercise meaningless, no one's opinion is meaningless. Even if their opinion is wrong. ðŸ˜
I hope this discussion is more interesting than the usual topics that folks start every day, over & over, like why am I being charged a fee on taxes.
maxine*j
I think it's a perfectly fine topic.
There are a minimum of five threads a day started by people who are outraged at the fees (which they usually did not check before listing).
So to discuss what acceptable fees would be, in the opinions of sellers who pay them, is reasonable.
Anyway, it's a nice break from ALL CAPS RANTS!!!!! about how awful eBay and its fees are.
-
soh.maryl
Have you noticed, though, that a lot of the sellers who complain about the fee structure are either (a) experienced sellers who apparently never read the fee schedule, and just now noticed it or (b) sellers who, when they complain about high fees, are counting other things as part of the FVF when they are not?
tobaccocardyahoo
The Internet has created a lot of merchants who do not know what to sell that allows them sufficient margin to be profitable.
The Ebay fees, Amazon fees and Walmart fees create a fundamental conflict with these sellers who are just hanging on. A lower fee will just motivate some of these sellers to lower prices, and continue the price reduction pressure, because the competition is already at insane levels.
No level of fee changes will make it easier to make a profit, given the marketplace pressures associating many items which sellers try to sell.
Everyone wants to sell the bestselling items, and so long as everyone tries, the fees will be too high.
bennotbill
The fee has been rendered into poor value because of the ad littered item pages, and the lack of a functioning simple title search.
It wouldn't matter if the fees went back to 5% as you would still have to contend with all that junk.
baangell
15% on total amount of the sale is my max, I will drop any category that goes beyond.
doc-holmes
If it was only 5% people would still complain, saying it should only be 2.5%
dhbookds
I'd like $1.25 gas price.........
reallynicestamps
@dhbookds
Wanna make people happy about the price of gas?
Make the gas business go metric.
The price on the pump promptly drops by 300%, because a litre is smaller than a gallon.
fern*wood
I doubt anything other than free would make everyone happy.
maxine*j
To make everyone happy, eBay would have to be more than merely fee-free. It would have to pay people to sell here, perhaps X amount per listing. 🙂
-
maxine*j
All things considered, a total "take-out" of 20% in eBay fees would be fine with me.
I base that on having run brick-and-mortar stores, used auction houses, and consigned a few things -- thus knowing the costs involved in all those.
But I am sure the figure is not the same for any two sellers.
-
allthings-collectible
I would agree with maxine*j. 20% is the number I would comfortably expect to pay to achieve my desired margin. That is about what I'm currently paying with the minimum PL rate of 2-3%, which seems to be just as effective as 10-15% in the collectibles categories. Unfortunately, it took me most of last year to figure it out 😞
With that said, I'm doing "OK"
asset_liquidators
The difference though between ebay and an auction house is that once you get paid out by the auction house you are done. There is no need to wonder for the next 6 months whether you will receive a CC chargeback.
coastaltechsolution
Oh good 'ole CC chargeback, our dearest friend ðŸ˜
Make it to that 5 1/2 month mark and all of a sudden get a message of charge not recognized
reallynicestamps
Since I started on eBay in 2001 (we had a shop account in1998, but I started my own account later), I have always allowed 20% of the customer's payment as eBay fees.
And it has always been slightly to noticeably less.
The 30c service fee is one item that low price sellers get caught with.
Thirty cents on a $50 sale goes unnoticed.
Thirty cents on a $5 sale is a profit killer.
And.
Many sellers don't pay themselves even minimum wage.
Here in BC the minimum wage is 27cents a minute.
If it takes 10 minutes to photograph, describe, and list a $50 item, the $2.70 I pay myself is unimportant.
For a $5.00 item, a profit killer.
If you are selling things at less than $10, you should expect to sell multiples to each customer to actually make money.
stainlessenginecovers
Although there has NEVER been ANYTHING 'FAIR' about Business (and like anyone, I would LOVE a 1%, 5% even 10% fee but..), being 'in business' even on the internet is:
1.) ALL optional (just get a 9-5 if you want a steady paycheck)
2.) It IS what it IS. Make it work, or see #1 above.
But, considering that anyone selling could just lease a store and wait for local walk-ins at a cost of $2000+ a month before selling 1 thing..
I would think that the 'fee' in the range it is now is 'fair'.
After all, what job is out there where you can sit in your PJ's at 3am and sell things while you sleep?
Oh, and the 'old school consignment shops' used to sell your stuff for you at a 35-50% fee.
So, 15% including the 2% min Promotion is still a bargain.
petes_toy_den
Ebay is a billion dollar company that hires cheap csr's in the Philippines and here you are saying 15% plus promotion fee is a bargain? Smh.
coastaltechsolution
eBay should pay us sellers 19% when we make a sale ðŸ˜
OK morning sarcasm over
I thing it will always be a mix of feelings but I'm also interested in hearing what others have to say
aeparts1
OPPerhaps a buyer paid premium of 15% would be to your liking. Or, a step in the right direction. There is an online auction site that does that. The fee they charge the seller varies according to who you are & how much you sell.
adkhighker
Whatever the fair fee might be, I think that fee should be a fee that does not include shipping and sales tax for sellers who charge only the calculated shipping cost and also for sellers who do free shipping, even though we all know there is no such thing as free shipping.
stainlessenginecovers
So a seller that uses the $10 plus $5 shipping format will ONLY be charged FVF on the $10...
But the Seller that uses the "$15 Shipped (Free shipping) will get charged FVF on $15??
or #2, if they charged 20% FVF on 'just the item' then it would look like:
$500 plus $40 tax plus $100 Ship, charged $100 FVF
vs.
$500 plus $40 tax plus $100 Ship, charged $84 FVF (at current 13.25%).
I'd say, careful what you wish for.
jerzee908
Ebay knows what we spend on shipping labels purchased through Ebay, so they should deduct the shipping label cost from the total sales, THEN charge their FVF. Ebay fees are fine with me seeing how much it would cost to open up an antique store or to be in an antique mall, but I've always had a problem with them taking money I charge for shipping costs.
stainlessenginecovers
Many sellers do NOT use ebay labels; they purchase labels from their Fedex Account, their UPS account, Pirateship, Stamps.com and more.
hartungcards
"Ebay knows what we spend on shipping labels purchased through Ebay, so they should deduct the shipping label cost from the total sales, THEN charge their FVF."
Well that's a fine idea. So people who don't purchase their shipping through eBay pay a FVF on their shipping cost, but someone who purchases shipping labels through eBay doesn't pay a FVF on shipping? Yeah, that seems fair.
mybigsale
@jerzee908
@doc-holmes
Actually, there is an easy solution (that eBay does not want to implement). Pirate ship and other services already automatically update your eBay account with tracking numbers. Online shipping services could easily update eBay with the shipping cost along with the tracking number, if eBay desired.
eBay would just need to work out a credit for sellers that ship from a physical location.
eBay was outraged when sellers took advantage of eBay by charging high shipping and low item cost to get around eBay fees. Now that eBay is doing the same thing to sellers, the outrage is gone.
Instead of eBay choosing to not profit off of sellers shipping (charging more than just a transaction fee), they chose to go the other direction and charge the eBay fees on State Tax and seller Advertising Costs as well.
jerzee908
I didn't realize I'd rile up people that do not use ebay shipping labels with my idea, but I should of added that EVERYBODY shouldn't be charged FVF on their shipping costs. I'm fully aware my idea would never come to anything, but this whole thread isn't meant to be serious in my opinion.
I've been on here for over 20 years, so I saw how much this site was like the Wild West with people charging $100 to ship something that they wanted $1 for and was worth around $100 to skirt around fees. I knew that something would be done eventually.
doc-holmes
I don't buy labels through ebay. Why should I then be charged a higher FVF?
jerzee908
Then I guess figure out a way for people like you that don't purchase labels through ebay?
kenneth686321
Thats a fantastic idea! Ebay should just charge FVFs on the item price and force all sellers to use Ebay labels
BTW be careful what you wish for Ebay might just do that to screw us sellers even more. Charge FVFs only on item price but raise it to 17-20%. Best case, you pay roughly the same as 13.25% on price + shipping + Tax. Worst case (more likely), you pay even more in fees to Ebay.
Would that make you happy? Probably not.
Example $80 Item Price + $12 Shipping + $8 Tax = $100 Total Buyer Payment
Fees 13.25% on Item price + shipping + Tax = $13.25 + $0.30
Fees 17%-20% on just Item Price = $13.60 - $16 + $0.30
I vote that fees stay the same
mybigsale
I vote eBay raises the fees to 20% so they don't have to lay off their staff. It won't affect me; all I have to do is raise the cost off all my items to cover the increased fee. Hopefully that wouldn't affect my sales so eBay would actually see an increase in profit (and not have a negative impact on their actual profit from a drop in sales)? 🙄
adkhighker
I didn't say that. Read it again, more slowly next time.
stainlessenginecovers
I did read it again and what you said is exactly what you said and what I was referring to.
If you are under the impression that ebay would have ANY clue as to what I spend on labels when items are 'free shipping'- you are sorrily mistaken as Many use 'other places' to purchase their labels...in fact, most large companies have a UPS or Fedex account and they print from them direct.
adkhighker
Oh for crying out loud here is what I posted:
"Whatever the fair fee might be, I think that fee should be a fee that does not include shipping and sales tax for sellers who charge only the calculated shipping cost and also for sellers who do free shipping, even though we all know there is no such thing as free shipping."
Here is your reply to me:
"So a seller that uses the $10 plus $5 shipping format will ONLY be charged FVF on the $10...
But the Seller that uses the "$15 Shipped (Free shipping) will get charged FVF on $15??
or #2, if they charged 20% FVF on 'just the item' then it would look like:
$500 plus $40 tax plus $100 Ship, charged $100 FVF
vs.
$500 plus $40 tax plus $100 Ship, charged $84 FVF (at current 13.25%).
I'd say, careful what you wish for."
Now, for the last time, if you can't get it then I don't know what else to tell you, other than stop wasting people's time running around the forum finding posts to try and pick apart over virtually nothing.
ryanrobyn
Problem is the treatment of sellers in relationship to fees. Constant changes without notice to sellers, lack of customer service, feedback has to be positive only, buyers are always right, changes are made to sellers listings, total reliance on USPS, UPS, FEDEX even though poor service, terrible search, Ebay decides what is seen and when, being a TRS means nothing, calling postage and buyer's taxes as money made and many more.