USPS lost my package for a month, delivered it to the wrong address, and eBay still gave ME the defect
Summary: peepsnporgieco shared their experience of selling a pair of shoes which were picked up by USPS but not scanned for a month, eventually being delivered to the wrong address. Despite explaining the situation, eBay denied their appeal for a late shipment defect. Other participants suggested that the responsibility lies with the seller to ensure packages are scanned at acceptance to avoid such issues, with some agreeing that the problem was with USPS, not eBay. The conversation focused on whether there are reliable methods to escalate such disputes when the carrier is at fault.
Sold a pair of Nike Pegasus 39 Steelers on Sep 1. Shipped Sep 4 — USPS picked it up from my porch, inside my handling time (deadline was Sep 9).
Then nothing. No scans for a full month. October 3 it finally pops up in Trenton, NJ, and on Oct 9 it shows delivered — to the wrong address. Buyer never got his shoes. I refunded him 100% out of my own pocket.
eBay hit me with a late shipment AND late delivery defect. I appealed under "disruption outside my control" and explained the whole thing. Denied. eBay's reason: tracking shows shipped Oct 3 vs a Sep 9 handling deadline, delivered Oct 9 vs a Sep 12 estimated delivery. Their system only counts scans — my Sep 4 porch pickup doesn't exist to them because USPS never scanned it for a month.
So the carrier loses the package for a month, misdelivers it, and the seller eats the defect AND the refund. And here's the kicker: that same month burned 53 of my 60 days to file a USPS claim.
Anyone else had a defect stick even when the carrier was clearly at fault? Is there any escalation past the appeal that actually works, or is the scan the final word?
gurlcat
@peepsnporgieco I do scheduled pickups, have had a long and mixed history with how it works, but suffice it to say I'm a TRS with 1-day handling so I have it fairly well-ironed at this point. So here are my questions for you: have you done pickups before this one? Do you have a regular neighborhood carrier? Have you talked to them about your eBay business, and whether they're willing to scan your bar codes each time? Also if they don't work M-F, does the same substitute cover their day(s) off, or are those randomly-assigned?
Schedued pickup MAY be a viable option, but not for everyone, and the details matter a lot.
shado-x
There's the problem right there, go to the Post Office, wait in line (or use a Kiosk), get an acceptance scan as a written receipt.
albertabrightalberta
I hate to add salt to the wound but ......
Unless you know your mail carrier scans items at pickup (as accepted), don't leave them on your porch. Instead, you should take them to the post office, hand them to the clerk and get a receipt showing an acceptance scan.
Unless there's an acceptance scan or movement scans within your handling time, ebay has no way of knowing whether you shipped in a timely fashion or not.
While most cases in which items are picked up (but not scanned) result in subsequent scans, your case was the perfect storm of no acceptance scan and no further scans for a month. Though it doesn't usually happen that way, you're the sender and it's your responsibility.
kensgiftshop
You said you appealed as outside of your control, but it wasn't.
You could have taken the package to your PO and had it scanned, so it was under your control.
dhbookds
Your beef is with the carrier.......not with ebay........
peepsnporgieco
OPno its with ebay the post is about getting hit with a defect and paying a higher % in fees
kensgiftshop
It takes more then one defect to get hit with higher fees.
inhawaii
You got the defect because of the carrier.
Example:
Your paycheck got lost in the mail so you were late paying your rent on time and was penalized.
Your landlord doesn't care WHY it was late, just that It was late.
Your beef is with the USPS not the landlord.
peepsnporgieco
OPthats a terrible anaology
inhawaii
Perhaps ... but you get the point.