unfair negative feedback
Well, once again EBAY does NOTHING to back up the seller! As a twenty-year seller (TOP-RATED PLUS) who has always been blessed with 100% feedback (I go the extra mile to keep it, believe me!), I received my first negative feedback today, which at my request EBAY did not remove, and here is my story...
I ship the item, a large book, on time and USPS tracking confirms that it was delivered today, 11/23 (Saturday) at 3:42 p.m. IN THE MAILBOX. Within an hour, with NO notification from the buyer, I see that I receive a negative feedback from said buyer stating that the 'item was stolen off their front porch.' Not only did I get blindsided, I didn't even have time to send them a refund (which I did immediately thereafter) before they left the negative- but EBAY customer service or whatever it is (or isn't) would not remove the negative! What is EBAY coming too? How can an event beyond a seller's control be our fault? Did I steal the item 'off the front porch?' The buyer is probably lying anyway being a scammer, but that's not the point. The point is that this negative FB injustice is so infuriating, I don't know what to do. Its hard enough getting sales on this platform, I have to scratch and claw and use every artifice to make one measly sale, every little advantage helps, and I believe 100% feedback is a necessary tool for more sales. I personally feel more secure buying from a seller with top FB, so I assume that's the case with most buyers! I feel like just closing up my EBAY store and saying screw it, because obviously EBAY doesn't have your back and hasn't for MANY YEARS NOW!!!
vam194169
Ebay is to busy counting all the money they make from there fee's to bother with the thousands of fraudulent complaints they receive every day.Ebay has become a fraud infested paradise.Ihave lost close to $300 in the last 6 months and Ebay never makes any attempt to solve any of it.
vam194169
One more thing.You have to remember Ebay is in Calif and are probably big supports of Gavin Newscumb and they allowed 950.00 worth of merchandise to be stolen from stores without any penalty.
prbs163220
Due to eBay not removing negative feedback i am no longer selling with them. I filed an automatic request to have negative feedback reviewed and it was rejected. (Buyer openly lied in feedback contradicting saved conversation on by eBay .) After calling eBay they said they couldn’t look at it or change it because the case had been decided by AI. The saved conversation didn’t matter.
Done with eBay. They never take the side of the seller and now AI is making the decisions. I was a seller for 12 years.
jonathanbrightlight
Negative feedback is only removable if it violates policy. Nothing in that feedback stands out as a violation of any eBay policy to me. If you can point to the specific policy it violates, you can contact customer service and explain it to them and they should be able to remove it.
adamcartwright
@jonathanbrightlight
Yikes -- I've never seen such a response to positive FB.
Imagine if it had actually been a negative. 😳
mam98031
@prbs163220
Ebay doesn't remove negative feedback just because a seller feels it should be removed. It has to break one of the feedback rules. Did you review the policy, locate what they did that was against the policy and report that to Ebay? If you can prove that it broke one of the rules, you can contact Ebay again and tell them exactly what part of the policy they breached. I don't see anything either did wrong, but you have more information than we do.
On that one feedback that they say you cancelled the transaction because you were out of stock, that is a huge no no for sellers to do. If you Cancelled the transaction as you should have, using the reason that you were out of stock, then that is what you should have done. Just keep in mind, Ebay takes these types of cancellations pretty seriously.
https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/feedback-policies/feedback-policy?id=4208
albertabrightalberta
Hmm. @prbs163220 , you made this^^^^ post 2 weeks ago to announce that you're no longer selling here and that you're "done with ebay."
I think you forgot to end those 647 listings that you have up and running.
soh.maryl
That is NOT actually a negative feedback. A negative FB has a red doughnut. Your explanation of the situation is very good. What did you expect eBay to do, exactly? You handled this very well. Would you really abandon eBay because of a FB that's not even a negative.? Your FB score is still 100%.
gyp*sy
Hi, I just had someone called "jerseyboymusic" respond to me. Here is my response to him. "You did not read everything I wrote. I called eBay right away explaining the situation and they told me what to do. It wasn't my fault that the item was damaged in shipping. I also called the carrier and they told me that they would have to complete an investigation and for the buyer to hold on to the item and the packaging. I called the buyer and explained the situation and they understood and told me there was no problem. But they also said that they wanted me to refund them. I explained to them that I did not have their money and that eBay was holding on to it and it would have to be eBay to refund them. They were angry over the whole situation and took it out on me even though I followed the instructions to a T. So if you don't know what you're talking about please don't respond. Make sure when you put a reply that you understand fully what's happening."
It sounds like he's one of Ebay's people. He justifies the crap they pull. Isn't it awful that not only does Ebay remove negative comments on FB but also they pit people against each other.
glorybells
Ummm, @jerseyboymusic knows exactly what he’s talking about. eBay customer service gave you bad advice (definitely not the first time that’s happened!). We are very experienced buyers and sellers who know eBay policy, while phone support is reading from a script, and will frequently go off the script to tell you what you want to hear whether it’s correct or not just to get you off the phone to move on to the next caller.
Good luck finding anyone here who knows how eBay actually works to agree with you.
krazzykats
Business is business.
Business does not have a heart or soul.
Business does not have feelings.
Business does not cry.
Business is not a live breathing person.
Business is business
ᓚá˜á—¢
compscrap
When you do a feedback removal request to eBay. And I'm going by memory so I may get the terms a little mixed up. You can choose the reason of (something like) problem is out of my control and it gives examples such as weather and so forth. And when you describe the problem put in the tracking number and state that the package was shipped on time and that the tracking states the package was delivered and the feedback should be removed because delivery took pace.
If you called up customer no service you will get nowhere. You have to fill out the feedback removal request form. I had a similar problem such as yours and the feedback was removed because the feedback dealt with shipping.
gyp*sy
I sold two items. One item sold when I was away and I was never notified. When I got home I checked my items I had listed for sale and found that one was purchased. I immediately contacted the buyer and explained what happened. The buyer was angry because a few days passed and they didn't receive their item. I told them I was very sorry and would immediately get the item out to them, which I did. They had already placed an item not received complaint against me. They said in a feedback that I took their money and didn't send the item. They were new to Ebay and only had a one (review) next to their user name. They said they were new to Ebay and didn't know how the feedback system worked. They left me Negative Feedback. I contacted Ebay several times over this. They said they would only take the comment off and that the Negative would remain because I deserved it. Then another buyer received a damaged item that UPS delivered. I've received several packages delivered by UPS that were damaged badly. I contacted Ebay and did exactly what they told me. UPS said for the buyer to hold onto the package so they can complete their investigation. The buyer was mad at me for this, claiming that i stole their money, and demanding me to reimburse them. I did not have their money, Ebay did. It wasn't my fault the package was damaged. Again Ebay will not remove the Negative feedback even though it was their fault and UPS. I've been with Ebay over 23 years and never had a problem like this. It's horrible how they treat their long standing members. I'm going to leave them for good and I'm closing out my account. They are not the only game in town. Has anyone else had a similar experience like this?
powell-collectibles
You will be missed!
dryophelia
@gyp*sy
Wondering if all the sellers you have left negative feedback on also felt like your feedback was unfair.
“ They were new to Ebay and only had a one (review) next to their user name.â€
It’s a shame one of their first experiences here turned out negatively.
At what feedback level should buyers be able to truthfully rate their experience.?
pikabo-icu
@dryophelia Yikes... Nice catch..
dryophelia
@pikabo-icu
Thanks for that pikabo. I reported the error and it was removed.
albertabrightalberta
How is it ebay's fault when you chose the shipping service?
Since you buy in the same category as you sell and having had your own share of unhappy buying experiences, you'd be a bit more empathetic toward a buyer with complaints similar to your own.
itsjustasprain
Your own Feedback Left for Others shows no fewer than seven Negs - four of which were complaining about slow shipping.
Okay. Bye!
mam98031
Sometimes Karma seems to be a real thing. I can't imagine that any of those sellers they nailed with negative feedback felt good about it either. They too likely felt the same way as @gyp*sy about the feedback they received.
jerseyboymusic
@gyp*sy
You didn't check your seller dashboard... how is that Ebay and the buyer's fault?
You didn't put your account on time away... how is that Ebay and the buyer's fault?
The items you got the two negatives for recently were for two pretty good dollar items... one was for $1100.. you don't think the buyer was concerned you had their money and didn't send the item? I wonder... how is that Ebay and the buyer's fault?
There are tools these days, such as the Ebay app for your smartphone. You can check all this on the go. You even get instant notifications when an item sells!
gyp*sy
You did not read everything I wrote. I called eBay right away explaining the situation and they told me what to do. It wasn't my fault that the item was damaged in shipping. I also called the carrier and they told me that they would have to complete an investigation and for the buyer to hold on to the item and the packaging. I called the buyer and explained the situation and they understood and told me there was no problem. But they also said that they wanted me to refund them. I explained to them that I did not have their money and that eBay was holding on to it and it would have to be eBay to refund them. They were angry over the whole situation and took it out on me even though I followed the instructions to a T. So if you don't know what you're talking about please don't respond. Make sure when you put a reply that you understand fully what's happening.
jerseyboymusic
@gyp*sy
I've been on Ebay since 1999, buying and selling. I am not employed by Ebay.
I did read everything you wrote. You can't "call Ebay". Even if you request a call back, you are getting outsourced representatives that are more interested in getting paid by how many calls they handle, rather than actually helping you.
It is YOUR responsibility to pack items securely for shipping. On that damaged item, Ebay doesn't have the money... you do. Just because you are upset and can't accept the help other sellers, like me, are giving you, don't lash out.
You are aware that if your buyer opens an "Not Described" return and you refuse it, they can keep the item and you refund the money out of pocket, aren't you? I don't know why you told your customer " ...that I did not have their money and that eBay was holding on to it and it would have to be eBay to refund them." That's not how it works.
If you don't know how Ebay works, don't list on their site.
gyp*sy
I did pack it well. I've been with Ebay over 24 years. You weren't helping me. You were accusing me, just as you're doing now. Stop thinking in a negative frame of mind. I didn't lash out at you. I'm telling you what I did. You are assuming what was done. Unless you know for sure what was done, don't say anything. Be like a judge and look it problems from all aspects. Check to see how long a seller has been with Ebay, check their feedback etc. Then check to see how long a buyer has been with Ebay and if they sold items and purchased items, and check how much feedback they received and most importantly if that feedback was as a seller or just as a buyer (that will make a huge difference). And please, before you say anything, make **bleep** sure the person you're speaking to, has many years with Ebay as well. Remember you're not the only one who's been with Ebay for a long time. I can guess that you're now taking this message in a negative view. The only reason why you would think that is because you think you know more than anyone else and are condescending. People do not like that.
pikabo-icu
@gyp*sy
Nobody is accusing you.
They all are explaining how eBay's policies work.
It may not seem fair but that's how it works.
Seller decides how to pack an item. PERIOD So if it's damaged, that's the seller's fault. The only recourse is insurance and the shipper will examine packaging to determine IF they will pay.
eBay may have been holding your funds BUT you have to have another payment source to refund your buyer. You will recoup those funds after the case is done or eBay pay's out to you. It sucks but that is how it works.
Please put yourself in your BUYER'S shoes..
If you were the buyer, you would want your refund NOW. No?
mam98031
Will it help you better understand if I chime in and say that @jerseyboymusic and @albertabrightalberta are correct, since I have been here for about 25 year. This is NOT meant with any disrespect, it just seems to be some important stats to you. You have sold about 20 items per year. I've sold about 1,900 transactions per year. I don't typically state my stats, but judging from your previous posts it seems to be important to you and is a deciding factor in if you believe what someone else is telling you.
Refunding the buyer was your responsibility to issue as the seller. Even though the funds were on hold. YOU still need to issue the refund. I do realize that puts some sellers in a real pickle if they don't have the funds available or a credit card in which they can put that amount on, but that doesn't change the fact that the refund is your responsibility.
What I usually suggest for sellers with this issue is to get the refund issue, then contact Ebay and get the funds on hold released right away. Ebay can see that you issued the refund, so it is likely they will assist in getting the hold off those funds quickly.
gyp*sy
Everything depends on what you're selling. Sure you may have many sales, but what exactly are they? Are they big, heavy and very expensive items? Or are they light, easy to ship, throw in an envelope items. Many people sell like a store. I am not a store and I sell expensive, collectible items. Hence, my not selling in bulk. So if you fit into my category then you would know what I'm going through. Let me know if this is what you do. Thanks
albertabrightalberta
See my responses in red.
jerseyboymusic
Thanks @albertabrightalberta AND @glorybells for the back up
I will also add that I looked at @gyp*sy "About" page and they have been on Ebay since 2001?!?!?!?
And now with a FB rating of 88.2%, the future doesn't look good for this account, especially with stalling on a refund. If Ebay forces that refund, it might all be a moot point
gyp*sy
I didn't pick the carrier to ship my package. Ebay handled all of that. I always did my own over 24 years but they told me that it was cheaper and they had the label made. Of course I paid for it.
jerseyboymusic
@gyp*sy
Just because I am saying what you don't want to hear, does not mean I'm attacking you. I don't know you. I'm sorry that you are taking it that way. I am stating facts, though.
You, with every post, keep shifting blame on Ebay, and not taking responsibility. You said "I didn't pick the carrier to ship my package. Ebay handled all of that." Ebay DOES NOT "pick" the carrier for you. YOU choose the carrier.
The bottom line is this... Ebay policy requires you, via the Ebay MBG, to have that buyer return the item and you issue a full refund. If Ebay issues that refund FOR you, that very well can be the final nail in your Ebay career.
You may have been registered on Ebay since 2001, but the site has changed in the last 21 years.
Again, I'm not attacking you.. I'm trying to help you NOT to get your account into deeper hot water than it already is in
mam98031
No they didn't. You have choices. You may have kept the carrier that the system defaulted to when you went to create the shipping label, but you could have changed it if you wanted too. You had lots of options on your screen when you were creating the label. Ebay also does not auto create your shipping label. YOU have to go into the system and CREATE the shipping label. You have no choice but to pay for a shipping label created in Ebay.
fern*wood
When you list your item you are required to pick the carrier you wish to use. If something was prefilled in for you, you need to change it to what you want to use. You are totally responsible for any item sold until it is delivered. I have sold many large and fragile items. I have had a few damaged and had to refund my buyer and file an insurance claim if possible. I have no idea what you mean by ebay told you it was cheaper and had the label made.
Edit--you really should start your own thread to not cause confusion with the original poster.
mam98031
Having to select a carrier depends. For example on my listings I selected Economy Shipping because it gives me a couple extra days. I always ship via USPS, but Economy shipping does not call out USPS on my listings.
bisbeeminerals
I am so done with you rude, condescending people who have zero appreciation for how sellers are treated. Signing off.
mam98031
Make sure you look in the mirror on your way out!
albertabrightalberta
Name calling isn't nice. Not a single response called you any names.
@bisbeeminerals
We're rude and condescending? You're the one who hijacked someone else's thread!
Again, no one has been rude to you. We've only pointed out the mistakes you made that might have been the catalyst for the buyer's feedback.
brightlightbookseller
The only rude one is you. I've reported the comment before this one in which you used a blatant insult, but really I'm quite glad you're leaving and hopefully you'll stop commenting here too.
stainlessenginecovers
So now the feedback was changed to Positive, but the longwinded response now makes you look silly.
Why would you refund if something is stolen from a porch anyway?
MILLIONS of packages are stolen and HALF of them are NOT really stolen, just crooked buyers.
You jumped the gun on responding.
You jumped the gun on refunding.
Stop doing that- wait 1 full day to 'think about it' going forward.
rockinhorserevivalist
Most likely they didn't write a long multi paragraph rant which will be bumped up for "relevancy" by AI. So probably minimal impact.
bisbeeminerals
After 25 years of this crap on eBay, I just sent a request to close my store. I'll need some time to copy and transfer items over to Etsy, but enough is enough. Who wants to run a business with the constant threat of being bullied by a company that does not give a sh-t about the people who are making them money. I will lose my main revenue, but I'll have the satisfaction of knowing they will never get another cent from me. I do want to apologize to those people here who I offended with my curt responses. This is not an easy decision, and it's quite emotional, but sometimes you have to sacrifice for what is right.
Thanks again everyone and have a good holiday,
Warren
mam98031
You do not need to make a request to close your store. You can just close it anytime you want. If you are on the yearly subscription plan, you may have some early termination fees, but you can close your store anytime you want.
https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/ebay-stores/close-ebay-store?id=4091
You can close your store and close your listings anytime you are ready to do it. You just need to make sure that before you close your account that you get what you want from your closed listings. But you do not need to leave your listings and store open while you do that. You just need to make sure you can still access your account.
You have to do what is best for you. If one negative is one too many for you, then you are doing the right thing.
bisbeeminerals
I appreciate the notes. I have removed all my items and I'm no longer selling. Once more, people are confused by why the buyer left negative feedback. In our messages, he was upset with eBay and some problems he was having with their accounting system and transfer of funds. Yes, I could not deliver the item because it was broken and I issued a full refund within three days because this occurred over the weekend when I am closed. His anger and purpose for the negative feedback was with eBay and either his credit card or PayPal. The argument is that eBay bears some responsibility for angering this individual and to ignore this by harming a seller is irresponsible. Thanks again.
fern*wood
We understand your argument on this matter, but I sincerely feel that feedback wouldn't hurt that much, and probably not at all had a better follow-up been offered for future buyers to see. It would benefit greatly to clear up your anger over this if you could accept your part in it happening. Regardless of how ebay and their part in the refund delay complicated the situation and annoyed the buyer, it is a fact your part caused the situation to happen in the first place. The buyer knows this, which is why the negative ended up going to you.
I've had my fair share of negatives and survived them all. Feedback isn't what it used to be.
albertabrightalberta
Is it possible that the buyer didn't believe you? The changing excuse for not completing the sale kept changing.
bisbeeminerals
We were closed over the weekend and have a listed 5-day handling time. The item could not be delivered and the buyer was issued a full refund. He did not have a problem with that. Can you understand this or do I need to paint you a picture? The buyer was fine with this and we exchanged friendly messages, including the option of sending him a free item. What triggered the buyer was when eBay and him had a dispute over some type of issue with his funds being put back in his account. This is not something I have control over. You need to stop defending eBay, they are at fault in this case.
mam98031
Part of their problem with the buyer is that when the buyer contacted them asking where their refund was, they just blamed Ebay and threw their hands up and said that they don't have anything to do with that process. Instead of taking a moment to explain the process to the buyer, which likely would have calmed the buyer down on the issue.
bisbeeminerals
"Earlier in the year when we had some changes done to feedback removal by Ebay that were hurting sellers. I fought along side some other good members to get things changed. We were successful and we did have changes made to the removal policy of feedback."
Can you kindly explain in precise terms what was changed? I have seen nothing. The biggest issues continue to be errors on the part of eBay, e.g., the buyer did not have funds transferred from eBay back to their account in a "timely manner," which is no fault of the seller.
The entire negative feedback system needs a modern overhaul. I've recently started duplicating items over to other selling platforms to circumvent inappropriate feedback. The inability for eBay to benefit from my sales is a pleasant and relaxing feeling, like a cool spring morning.
How can this be fixed for sellers:
1: eBay needs to require and confirm that the buyer has communicated and asked for a resolution from the seller. Buyers SHOULD NOT BE ALLOWED TO LEAVE NEGATIVE FEEDBACK UNLESS THERE HAS BEEN COMMUNICATION. The majority of problems could be resolved this way -- generally with a refund. Some buyers are chronic negative feedback posters who will never be pleased, like the buyer who does not read the description of an item and is mad when it's smaller than expected. Or the buyer who has a shi__y monitor and complains it's the wrong color. No one deserves negative feedback for that, but eBay will never remove such complaints.
2: Grace removals. Top rated sellers with a long history of providing excellent service with top reviews should have a couple of grace removals a year when the negative feedback is lame, like in the aforementioned examples. Excellent sellers do not usually decide one day to screw someone over on purpose.
3: Change to neutral feedback. eBay should be able to move a negative feedback to a neutral feedback for those cases which are borderline. A neutral would not count as a feedback ranking deduction, but buyers could still read the comments from the buyer and seller if they wanted.
Of course eBay will never do any of these logical and fair things because their corporate strategy is to force sellers to live under the constant fear of negative feedback.
mam98031
You aren't seeing any change because your negative feedback does not break ANY of the rules in which to get it removed. I realize you don't agree, but it is the truth.
You are welcome to look at the policy for yourself and find where it breaches the rules. If you can prove that to Ebay, maybe they will remove it.
https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/feedback-policies/feedback-policies?id=4208
bisbeeminerals
Once more, if a buyer is mad with eBay because eBay did not solve their funds transfers, it's eBay's fault, not the seller. All the seller can do is issue a refund, then it's up to eBay. A lot of buyers think the sellers handle the entire banking process which is not true.
mam98031
I understand you don't like what I've said trying to explain why the feedback you got isn't removable. I get it. It is frustrating that Ebay doesn't see it the way you do.
"All the seller can do is issue a refund..." I also disagree with this part of your post. When your buyer expressed concern in a message that they had not received their refund, as I stated in an earlier post, you could have taken a moment to explain the process to them instead of just ignoring their concern. If you had done that, the buyer would have likely understood why they didn't see the refund instantly.
Yes, I agree that buyers often don't understand how their money gets processed. However the sellers should. And you could have explained it nicely to them, but you chose not to do that, which added to your buyer's frustration with this transaction.
Your response is inaccurate too. Cancelling and refunding the buyer because you were OOS does NOT have a 3 day window to do so. You said "I issued a full refund within the required time".
albertabrightalberta
That your buyer is upset because of the time it takes for funds to transfer is secondary to the real reason your buyer was unhappy. You aren't getting that! You took 3 days to let the buyer know you misplaced the item and that's what they're most disappointed about.
If you hadn't lost the item, the transfer-of-funds time wouldn't be an issue.
mam98031
Earlier in the year when we had some changes done to feedback removal by Ebay that were hurting sellers. I fought along side some other good members to get things changed. We were successful and we did have changes made to the removal policy of feedback.
The policy has been updated and allows more reasons that a feedback can be removed. And we gained back the ability to appeal feedback removal if the automated version of removal is denied.
Sellers need to understand that their personal opinions are important but do not have any relevance to this process. If the feedback you want removed does not meet any of the removable reasons in the policy, it is unlikely the feedback will be removed. Just because a seller wants a negative removed does not mean it automatically qualifies.
If you firmly believe your negative feedback needs to be remove. Do a little homework. Find the policy that states what the buyer said in the feedback breaches one of the rules. When you appeal the removal of the feedback, quote the policy.
You have to go by the words the buyer actually says in the posted feedback, not your interpretation of them, but exactly what the buyer has stated.
Also remember there is a time limit on getting feedback removed. You have to take action in a reasonable amount of time. Usually within 30 days of receiving the feedback, but I think they will go up to 60 days.
https://www.ebay.com/help/policies/feedback-policies/feedback-policies?id=4208
june_elizabeth1971
Good luck getting eBay to back sellers. I had a hard drive a customer bought that was new and in factory package. The buyer had it for a couple of weeks and then sent me a message saying he tested it and it was at "end of life" and demanded a refund or he would leave negative feedback. My listing clearly states I have a 30 day refund policy but buyer pays return shipping. He got angry that he would have to pay shipping to return it so he went ahead and left negative feedback and said getting his almost $40 back wasn't worth the $7 he would have to spend in shipping so therefore he scrapped the hard drive. I informed him I couldn't refund anything until I received it back. Now, even if I did want to reimburse him for return shipping I can't. It made me suspicious right off the bat that he threatened me with negative feedback if I didn't give him what he wanted. I've sold lots of these new hard drives and non has ever been faulty. I tried to appeal the issue with eBay but they sided with the buyer. I let ebay know that without us sellers, they'd have no buyers and that we're paying their salary. I doubt they give a **bleep**. I just wish there was somewhere else similar to ebay to sell. Mercari is out there but their shipping service is almost double what I can get off ebay. Don't like someone holding me by the short hairs!!
bisbeeminerals
You people are as dense as a ton of bricks. Do you actually read the comments? The buyer had issues with eBay after the refund, not with me. He got mad because THEY took too much time processing his refund after I issued it immediately when the item could not ship. I EVEN OFFERED HIM A FREE ITEM. HE THEN TOOK IT OUT ON ME AND EBAY AND CHANGED HIS TUNE. I DID NOT KNOW OF ANY OF THIS UNTIL I SAW THE NEGATIVE FEEDBACK. SELLERS HAVE NOTHING TO DO WITH EBAY ACCOUNTING. YOU ARE MISSING THE POINT. I do not know why his funds had trouble being put back into his account. Why is everyone here so nasty and negative towards sellers here? I'm done responding and ready to close my shop after this beating.
bisbeeminerals
Welcome to the Draconian world of eBay, where a buyer can sabotage your account right before the holidays. This also happened to me, and is one reason I sell on multiple platforms. I hate Ebay for allowing this to happen. There are bad sellers who continually rip people off by selling fake or misleading items who need to be removed but never are, and there are honest sellers who work very hard to gain trust, only to be punished because some hot head leaves negative feedback because they had a bad day. I recently received negative feedback because the buyer was not happy about how long it took Ebay (not me) to transfer his funds back into his account. I have zero control over Ebay accounting but I still received negative feedback, destroying holiday sales. I'm moving more and more items back over to Etsy where at least the criminal, hate-generated negative feedbacks are absorbed into the overall picture and a single negative feedback does not lower your score from 100% to 91%.
mam98031
@bisbeeminerals
That is such an HUGE overstatement about how much of an impact the negative feedback you received has on your account. Now your response isn't likely to help matters however. Trying to make this the problem of the buyer is NEVER a good idea. It makes you as a seller look bad in the eyes of potential buyers that may review your feedback page. A polite and professional response is the ONLY way sellers should respond. It is not the place for your personal feelings.
"I recently received negative feedback because the buyer was not happy about how long it took Ebay (not me) to transfer his funds back into his account." This is NOT the reason you got the negative. It is what you are hanging on to as the reason but the actual reason is different and it is NOT Ebay's fault, it is yours. You need to understand that an own it.
This buyer is upset because you had to cancel the transaction because you could not locate the product. Not only that it took you 3 days to do that. You should have been able to do that on day 1 and issued an apology to the buyer as well as it was your fault you were either OOS or simply couldn't find the item. This is hugely disappointing to a buyer. It is a little easier on them to know about the issue right away, but you took 3 days to even notify them. That is likely a huge reason for how the buyer responded.
When you filed your Cancellation of the transaction, did you select the correct reason, that you were out of stock? If not what reason did you select?
What is likely lowering you in the search returns is your 6 day handling time. For sellers with a 5+ day handling time, Ebay lowers them in the search returns, allowing sellers with shorter handling times to place higher.
bisbeeminerals
Thanks so much Mr. know it all. If you would read the complete post, you would see that the buyer understood and accepted that the item could not be found. He allowed me extra time to look. In addition I have a 3-day handling time. Our conversations were friendly. His problem was with eBay's refund process not me.
mam98031
Not a Mr. and not a "know it all". I get it that because I didn't agree with your point of view that the reaction is to push back on what I said. But that doesn't change anything. I provided you with correct information. It is up to you to use it or disregard it.
And NO I did not see that the buyer understood and was fine with the fact that you couldn't find their product. There first statement in the feedback was saying you couldn't find it after 3 days. I read it differently than you do. You seem to think that means they were fine with it. I do not. As I stated before, 3 days is really excessive and only increases upsetting the buyer.
Yes, they were looking for their refund in their account. You could have simply explained this to the buyer instead of blaming Ebay. Refunds are not instant, even though some buyers think they are. Ebay refunds back to whatever funding source the buyer used to purchase the item. The process can take a few days. The buyer should have received an email from Ebay notifying them that the refund was on it's way. But instead your choice was to blame Ebay and not just tell them how it works. All that did was make the buyer even more upset.
You didn't do yourself any favors in how you handled this transaction.
Sorry, on the listings of yours I looked at, they have 6 day handling times. FYI your handling time does not mean if you have an inventory problem you can take that time to try and locate it. That is not what the handling time is for.
albertabrightalberta
@bisbeeminerals
Your reply to the feedback is defensive and doesn't show that you accept that this was your error.
If that feedback is negatively impacting your holiday sales, my opinion is that it's your reply that is hurting you more than the buyer's feedback.
bisbeeminerals
Yes, it's OK for eBay (not me) to delay putting funds back into a seller's account because they had a PayPal problem. Regardless, account closing.
fern*wood
I haven't seen anyone say that, but this appears to be a personal issue with how you choose not to accept any responsibility in issues created by you rather than how ebay refunds on your behalf.
mam98031
I think you meant Buyer. And how do you know there was some "delay"? Did Ebay tell you they were delaying the refund? If so why?
I think moreover what happened is your buyer thought the refund would be instant, but that isn't how it works. Had you of explained the process to them as I suggested in an earlier post, they likely would not have been upset about the refund timing.
badgerfan1
I too recently received my first negative feedback. A buyer purchased two raw trading cards from me, then claimed one of them was damaged (a small dent in one corner of the front). My pictures did show a tiny mark on the back of the card in that same corner. I suspect that when he received it he attempted to fix the back dent and damaged the front in the process or totally switch out cards on me. He claimed no damage to the packaging or to the other card at all. Yet Ebay allowed him to leave negative feedback on BOTH items that he purchased and they are refusing to remove the negative content. He called me a scammer and a fake. Ebay sided with the buyer and I was forced to refund. I am now awaiting the return of the card and hopefully I'll be able to get rid of it at a card show. Right now I am chalking this up to the cost of doing business on Ebay because the rest of my sales have been absolutely fine. Don't let one person ruin it for you.
Ebay needs to have an option for sellers to give buyers negative feedback. I fear there are MANY buyers out there who try to get something for nothing and unfortunately Ebay is buyer friendly, not protecting sellers at all!!
fern*wood
Some buyers are getting something for nothing because some sellers are refunding without requiring a return as soon as they get bad feedback. I see you are at least supposed to get your item returned, so I hope you haven't already refunded.
soh.maryl
Original message from 11/23/24. OP still has quite a few listings up, so guess all's well in Oz.
glorybells
For several of the posters here:
tsme35
I got a negative removed this week "never got it". I filed though ebay and marked the one stating "beyond my control", also included they said it was not delivered and the tracking number showing it was. It was gone in less then 3 minutes.
I'd go the face book route now, phone reps are useless, they act like they care but nothing gets done. One call I heard a baby crying and another there was a rooster crowing in the back ground.
I agree with you, I believe bad feed back hurt sales, at least when I'm buying.
jerseyboymusic
@vanpatrick2005
No offense... but if I was going to order something from you, all I need to do, according to your reply on the feedback, is just say in my feedback to you is that the package was stolen, and I would get a refund from you automatically.
Your reply SHOULD have been something like "Tracking shows package was delivered. I'm willing to work with buyer to the best of my ability to assist) or something like that
vanpatrick2005
OPI was so angry in the moment, that I did what I did... I have been lucky in my 20 years of selling here on Ebay that I have had few if any scammers... this negative feedback incident was like the straw that broke the camel's back. I was seeing red, not thinking things through. You know, in all my years of buying on this site- since 1998- I have NEVER left negative feedback! Neutral, yes... but I agree with you, thank you for your input.
soh.maryl
Your reply to that FB was excellent. Why would you abandon your very successful eBay career because of one numpty?
Why not just contact eBay, give them the tracking info and ask for removal of the FB? Why call the buyer a scammer and accuse them of lying? Your post here appears to have been made in the heat of the moment. Perhaps theirs was also.
Not exactly sure why you'd immediately refund. Not sure why you think a buyer is required to contact the seller before leaving neg FB.
trickmusic
You are talking like eBay has functional customer service. They don’t.
You are talking like an accessible feedback department. They don’t.
The culture of eBay is a mold. It’s “screw your efforts to maintain your feedback ratingâ€. It’s community apologists and shills waving off someone’s care for their account along with eBay’s “inability†to help.
the culture of eBay is mismanagement, screwing sellers (now offsite, for even LESS accountability) and maintaining their bloated stock price. eBay is a benchmark for a Silicon Valley corporate dirge.
But who doesn’t love “Brock Allen Turner�
https://sanjosespotlight.com/infuriating-how-a-silicon-valley-insider-steve-wymer-got-away-with-ebay-scandal/
mam98031
There isn't anything new in that link. Most know about this from the summer of 2019. And as the article says, most are serving prison time for their actions. What does this horrible piece of Ebay history have to do with now?
johnrj1226
Why don't you just drop out of eBay buying and/or selling if you are so miserable? - guess you like the company.as in fellows that think the same.
vanpatrick2005
OPWell, the negative feedback was like the straw that broke the camel's back... I have been selling on here for 20 years and have been lucky with not having scammy buyers, but I saw red yesterday- I wasn't thinking straight. With all the issues all of us have been having on this site, sometimes it makes you think "Is it worth it?" I am more angry with eBay not taking this stupid feedback off, and I stand by my statement that sellers are getting screwed right and left. I shouldn't have refunded this buyer the money, but in my listing description it states "I will do everything in my power to absolutely satisfy my customers". This refund is a one timer, believe me- it won't start a trend, because I 'got my dander up' and am fighting mad-- CAVEAT EMPTOR--
BUYERS BEWARE!!
johnrj1226
Unless a buyers opens a case against you for non delivery keep your hands in your $ pocket. Then when or if they do, you attach the a copy of tracking number to the case and poof the case is closed and eBay would remove the red hickey and you would have the money. from the sale. You will have to work with eBay to get it removed. Start by going to the Help & Contact link at the bottom of this page RH side and get to work to get this hornets nest unwound.
eBay system doesn't not & cannot scrub every negative FB posted to see if it legit or not even for TRS+ folks. It is up to the seller to follow proper protocols . Welcome to the realities of cyberspace world where every dot imust be placed in the proper order & t must crossed for everything to work smoothly.
Ya' learn something new every day-EH?.
GL in unwinding a backlash on your bait casting fishing reel.
vanpatrick2005
OPI appreciate your input- spot on! Believe me, I 'got my dander up' and am ready for any more scammy buyers- CAVEAT EMPTOR- BUYERS BEWARE!
toysaver
It could have been delivered to the wrong address. The PO can confirm the GPS location of the delivery. I wish USPS would up their game and take a picture like FedEx. It gets embedded in the tracking. Either that or make the GPS location part of the tracking.
vanpatrick2005
OPOf course, the automated appeal process denied my request for removal of the stupid feedback, as the feedback 'did not violate EBAY policies'. Well, it sure violated my policy of fairness and of common decency! Now I expect my listings will get kicked down the ladder as I have often heard negative feedback screws with the visibility of the listings, which I can believe. Maybe all buyers should leave all sellers negative feedback as the feedback system is a piece of sh#!t!!!
erkosuniverse
the same thing happened to me this week,i have picture proof in a listing,the buyer lied about and gave false statement negative feedback to me,i filed a removal and received automated response that it does not violate policies,a blatant lie from a buyer when i have picture proof and i am stuck with a negative
mam98031
What rule does the feedback they left violate? Be specific. If you can locate that, contact Ebay and appeal the decision to have it removed. But approach them with the evidence in hand.
Your response to the feedback doesn't make sense to me. Why did you say "...16 GAMES WORKING! PLUS ALL OTHER GAMES WORK..." If they all work, why specifically say 16 work and the others work. Why not say that all 53 games work?
vanpatrick2005
OPI am sorry for you, and I am still sorely angry myself and feel extremely violated. It would be like someone accusing you at your job of something you never did and upper management and HR wrote you up... the unfairness riles me but I have done all I can do- opened a case on eBay (denied!), went on Facebook, e-mailed the buyer, talked to Customer Service (they called me on my cell phone)- a nice woman with a thick accent who reviewed my case and said I did everything right, even asked if I refunded the buyer which I did and she was very pleased with that and said that it should expedite the feedback removal process... but I am not holding my breath, I seriously doubt any action will be taken. Basically I paid for a book and its shipping costs to be stolen from me AND GETTING BLAMED FOR IT!!!
trickmusic
There are countless examples of criminal executives at eBay, not following their own policies.
mam98031
@trickmusic
Examples please.
trickmusic
You really need examples? I heard there was a book in the works that was just a list. It’s 9,657 pages long.
https://www.twingate.com/blog/tips/ebay-data-breach
mam98031
That was a DECADE ago. They didn't get any financial info. I'm not sure of your point. I don't live in the past.
Do you have examples of current issues, not that this particular issue has anything to do with bad behavior by Ebay employees that you were talking about in the post in which I responded too.
momtoabeautifuldaughter
Contact eBay through Facebook and explain the situation clearly and calmly.
I have gotten lots of feedbacks removed that way
vanpatrick2005
OPThats what I did, went through FB so we will wait and see... no holding my breath
trickmusic
Yeah. They can fix it on Facebook, Instagram, or X according to some sources here.
Lucky you, to have the opportunity to facilitate the full Silicon Valley circle jerk.
Actually, executives at eBay are working on a forum in Twitch where you can get the feedback removed. Pretty soon we might have the opportunity of improving our eBay experience at TikTok. After that, they are going to send us to Pornhub to remove the feedback.
Dont worry though, the feedback “engagement†department costs eBay and the Form 4 fillers at this dirge more than they could ever imagine. The broken feedback system is one of the biggest tells for exactly how out of touch, inbred and pathetic eBay management is.
If you add the resourcefulness of every executive in the eBay Hamilton Ave C Suite, they don’t have half the intelligence of big sellers on eBay using zero feedback burner accounts created just to leave targeted feedback for competitors.
These people are disgusting, but it’s ok. Sellers can leave feedback for eBay EVERYWHERE.
fbusoni
But since -- according to the conventional wisdom here -- no one bothers to read feedback, what difference does it make?
mam98031
That is an overstatement. There are many people that read the feedback of a seller. Most will not care about a little bit of bad feedback unless the response from the seller is unprofessional, name calling, etc.
I'm not aware of what the other poster is talking about with throw away accounts. I'd need more info.