This might be the strangest transaction I've ever had on ebay
I buy a printer cartridge from a fairly new seller. He has a quantity of this particular
cartridge and bulk rolls of 8 paper towels (Of all things) I buy the cartridge for $31.00
with shipping included.
I just received the cartridge, Brand new in the box with an expiration date of May 2027
So far, All is well.
Dropped shipped from Staples, OK I like Staples and have a store about 5 minutes from here.
I don't buy much there since they are a little pricey.
In the box is a receipt marked "Not an invoice" made out to me as the buyer with my
info and address. Legit invoice with Order## and Customer ## this is a Staples invoice
for sure.
"Sold to" is blank "Ship to is my info"
According to this invoice (Receipt) my seller paid $67.29 for the cartridge
he sold me for $31.00 with "Free" shipping
meme6253
dhbookds Has your mystery solved, That has to be exactly what they did, Nothing else would make sense unless they are extremely bad at math!
a_c_green
Fixed it for you... 😉
That's a packing slip. An invoice is a demand for payment, but your seller already paid for it and had it sent direct to you.
I agree that it's more likely that his retail arbitrage backfired on him (more on that below); there's some slim chance that it might also be a credit-card scam, using a stolen card to pay for the Staples order, but showing a quantity available seems more likely that his listing was intended to be around for a while.
Based on my own experience recently, I'm thinking that the seller might have gotten burned by a sudden price increase. My workhorse printer for eBay shipping is an HP Deskjet 5650 which I've owned for somewhere approaching 20 years (!) now and is still working fine. However, the #56 (black) and #57 (tri-color) cartridges are no longer stocked locally in the usual big-box stores as of sometime in the past year, and the on-line pricing has skyrocketed.
I went looking for the #56 cartridge recently, which had been a little over $30 at Walmart, only to find that my current choices were now to order it on-line ($50.99 from Walmart, $54.99 from HP themselves, or $55.97 from Staples as of today). The #57 tri-color cartridge, formerly around $50, is now in the nosebleed section approaching $100 or more.
My theory at this point is that the seller wasn't paying attention to the price increases (due to either tariffs or just declining demand for older supplies), and had to eat the cost of an item that had gone way up in price behind his back.
eburtonlab
I agree that it's more likely that his retail arbitrage backfired on him (more on that below); there's some slim chance that it might also be a credit-card scam, using a stolen card to pay for the Staples order, but showing a quantity available seems more likely that his listing was intended to be around for a while.
If the seller had been burned on an attempt at retail arbitrage, the seller would not keep selling that item at that price, nor would the seller likely choose the most expensive possible source for a one-off replacement shipment.
That the seller is apparently still selling the same item and showing a large quantity available at the same price is entirely consistent with a triangulation scam.
gator08041971
And with the 10 day handling time.
Sell them for cheap, make a few bucks each, but drop ship them from whomever has them with stolen CCs. Yikes.
You would need a handling time for this, as you don't know if your sources will have it, or if your stolen CC is busted yet or not.
kensgiftshop
Looks like they are dropshipping from a few different sites.
bonanza125
This has been more common with sellers who has a lot of inventory.
bennotbill
Could they have a lot of gift cards to convert into cash?
Or would that show on the invoice.
winterpalace25
It could have been desparate fulfillment. I got into a similar situation with a book I had sold. It was a trade paperback about the Dalai Lama and the buyer messaged me that she was going to Nepal shortly and really needed it. She had paid $14.00 for my copy. And I couldn't find it after tearing my house apart and enlisting my husband to look.
Well, apparently I had the only copy. I wanted to send her one from ebay or Amazon, but there were none on the entire internet. Then, OMG, I found it new on Barnes and Noble and was able to order it for $25.00. I had it sent directly to her, letting her know I couldn't find mine. I could have canceled, but the buyer would have been sorely disappointed.
This has happened to me twice in 25 years, and both times I fulfilled the order at my expense. About 2 weeks later I found the Dalai Lama paperback, and a week later sold it again. This book had been on my shelf for several years.
gator08041971
@dirk12955 @dhbookds
I did look into that seller's info.
Bit weird, but not sure if its a fraud thing or not. Registered in June. Only sells one ink cartridge item and toilette paper.
But this right here is a clue:
10 day handling time??? Yeah. Red flag. I take back my answer from earlier. 😕
reallynicestamps
I agree with @dhbookds .
I did that once some years ago with the help of another eBay seller.
Not "retail arbitrage" in my case, the other seller was told of my problem and happily cooperated.
dhbookds
he ran out of stock and is trying to cover the sale so he doesn't get an Out of Stock ding.
buyselljack2016
Is it possible that "someone else's" CC paid Staples for the order from the "fairly new" seller, or is that a different game only done by buyers?
gator08041971
Its always possible there could be a scam going on, (credit card fraud) but its equally possible its a simple stock issue.
But the buyer here is the one in the clear. They got a legit item with an official receipt.
The one on the hook would be the seller of the item, in this case Staples, if the eBay seller bought it with a fraudulent card. And the holder of the card would be also on the hook or their finance institution behind the card.
dhbookds
I guess it could be the triangular(is that's what it's called?) scheme.......but no way to tell that I know of. Not uncommon for sellers to try to cover an OOS
buyselljack2016
agree, just tossed that out as another possible explanation of the "strange" transaction with a new seller.
eta:
36 sold, guess that triangulation thing is debunkedðŸ˜
but, but, but how are they selling so many "on the cheap"?
jbbowers12012
Nice Call! Did Not See It!
dirk12955
OPI was thinking the possibility that the seller
is an employee of Staples offering items that fell off the back of a truck.
But the invoice thing throws me off.
The listing is still active with 36 sold and 7 still available.
10 day handling what was his hurry? I never would have
noticed if it took 10 days to ship. I buy these in advance
so I have one when I need it.