The New Sports Card Authentication System is Rigged
I wanted to warn as many sellers of Sports Cards as possible, as to the rigged Authentication System. It is set up to completely damage the credibility of the seller, and promote their self interests.
I just sold a high dollar sports card, pictures of the card were taken at all angles, and the condition of the card was listed as "Like New".
The Authenticator returned the card, and said that it couldn't be authenticated. After making phone calls to the people who sold me the cards as to it's authenticity, I was told that the reason it couldn't be authenticated was that they found a scratch on the rear bottom corner of the surface.
This NEVER should have happened. In this situation, the card is real, the card is authentic, and the card was sold with an accurate description.
The Authenticator is doing what they intend to do along with eBay's help. Promote the Grading Services, and to kill the eBay sellers. Non Graded Cards will be impossible to sell under these guidelines.
A Warning to those who will have to go thru this.
Jon
cardshopmd
I am dealing with this issue now, they said my card has a scratch and the corner is damaged, Hello the card is graded I did not grade the card, the only way a card with a 9.5 grade can have a scratch and a damaged corner is if the case was in fact opened , everyone knows that a dinged corner would know it would have been knocked down to a 7 during the grading the process
kh-laura
Hi everyone,
Due to the age of this thread, it has been closed to further replies. Please feel free to start a new thread if you wish to continue to discuss this topic.
Thank you for understanding.
a.j.vezina
I sold a PSA Card for $1,362.00, It was refunded by EBAY for $1,362.00, because The PSA Authentication Service does NOT have an agreement with EBAY to Authenticate for Larger Size PSA Holders.
scgo-4339
I just wrote a 10 minute narrative agreeing with you and it disappeared. I sold a 1960’s Vintage Baseball Card and I am shortening the story, they f’d the sale for $1500 and damaged my card. When returned I had to deal with eBay Authentication, which like any department is like getting ahold of the US President. They must have so many issues they don’t want any phone calls. I am wondering if anyone thinks if you complain to eBay by phone or by email or through this forum they block your account and punish you for it? I haven’t sold any cards or received any inquiries since I complained and I noticed this the last time? Back to my story, they sent my card back with no letter stating they were sorry but, they damaged my card. I had to call once again and create a complaint with authentication department. It took many phone calls, many hours, an abnormal amount of stress and they lowballed their original offer-which I said was completely unacceptable and they increased the offer. I knew I would not get really what it was worth so I said thank you and have moved in. But, I did pull, $50,000 of Vintage Cards off their website. They claim they use PSA and Beckett and CSG? I don’t know but I think they may have worked at these companies but were released, now they are working for eBay. eBay is us-posed to authenticate, not grade, and not theorize about scratches, and other unknown criteria they refuse to share with Card Owners. This is completely egregious and possibly illegal, and then have the incompetence to damage people’s prized possessions! Someone needs to create a new forum/website for trading cards. Their are a few options but eBay, although losing 12 million subscribers and having thousands of complaints may still be the best option?
joliztoyco
If you read my earlier post about "EBay's "authenticators" I think you'll find we're on the same page.
I DO think having "authenticators" is a great idea. For high end cards and athletic apparel it would really help the seller/buyer market here on EBay. Buyers pay high prices for these collectibles, and having the comfort of knowing they're getting what they pay for is a good thing.
Unfortunately, Ebay's "authenticators" are just BAD.
So the best thing a seller can do is send them off to be graded. And then try and recoup the cost.
As far as EBay curtailing sales for being critical of them?
I'm not one of the Ebay "cheerleaders" that infest this board. I'm pretty mean to Ebay, and when I post, I say so.
I'm not liking the philosophy of "squeezing more profits out of a diminishing supply of sellers". And I think it also shrinks the supply of buyers...and that's according to Ebay's OWN STATISTICS.
But my sales have been steady. So I don't think they're "retaliating" against criticism.
Otherwise, I'd be long gone!
We're just very small fish in the shallow end. I don't think they even notice us. 🙂
theteamsetguy
@bialystock ,
I know if I bought the card for $800.00 and when I got it and found the scratch I would have files INAD case. You do realize any buyer can file a INAD case and it doesn't matter whether you accept returns or not.
bialystock
OPYou are completely missing my point. The whole entire grading authentication system is wrong. If there's an issue, let the buyer and the seller work it out. As far as authenticating, if it's real, if it's the card they said it was, be done with it. If eBay wants to offer grading, let them.
antflan77
My one and only experience with AG was not good. I sold a MJ card for $60, but I believe my $250 BIN price triggered the AG.
I shipped the card to AG, then received a msg saying buyer had been refunded, authenticity could not be verified due to card description. It said the "buyer had requested return". I contacted the buyer, he said just like me he got an email saying it failed and he'd get a refund.
It is a $400 (Beckett) card, but was very clean. The buyer knew what he was getting. Ebay interfered and now I had to resist it upon return. This time I left out the BIN price and it did not flag the AG.
I will definitely be more hesitant to put any "good cards" on EB again.
theteamsetguy
@bialystock,
That is exactly what eBay is trying to eliminate. Because some but not all sellers of sports cards either over grade their cards or don't provide good pictures and item descriptions pointing out any flaws. These same sellers may also be lazy in their item descriptions and write something like "see picture and decide for yourself". The pictures don't always show all of the flaws. The buyers of expensive cards tends to be more particular on condition and I don't blame them when they are spending $250.00 or more on a card.
Buyer gets the card and tries to work it out with the seller but the seller is not cooperative. The buyer then opens a INAD case. The buyer in the mean time gets a bad taste in their mouths. I know many collectors who will not buy any expensive cards online including eBay unless the card is already graded in slab. They figure that if the card is a 9 or 10 the seller would've had it graded before listing it. Unfortunately, there are too many sellers who purposely leave out flaws in their item descriptions and hope the buyer won't notice or don't care when they get the card on purpose so they can get more money.
harafkac0
I won't disagree about ebay's authentication, but your items are sold under "No Returns" policies which makes me wonder what you mean by "let the buyer and the seller work it out..."
inhawaii
What does ebay have to gain by not authenticating your card?
You lose the sale.
They loose their cut of the sale.
amricons
eBay does not authenticate the card, a 3rd party does. Ironically, it is a con game, as they add an additional layer of risk to the transaction and often adds costs to the deal. Does it make any sense for CGC to authenticate their own cards or PSA for PSA ? Usually adds up to more fees for eBay. 3rd party companies fail, screw up or go out of business all of the time. Seems eBay is trying to satisfy buyers by making sellers look bad. But if a seller is already selling a graded/certified item, what is the point of sending the item back to the grading company so they can say, OK , yes that is ours. PSA for example, has known to have graded and slabbed defective cards and counterfeits. The sellers rep is important and AG has put that doubt in every buyers mind. In fact, some buyers are thinking , why am I buying a certified graded item from a top company and adding the additional time and handling ie shipping risks .
theteamsetguy
@amricons ,
While it is very rare occurance. There have been instances of cards sold in counterfeit PSA and CSG holders.
amricons
AG is not a well thought out program. They left out BGS and created several degrees of risk without any benefit. One obvious issue which defeats the entire concept if a seller sells a PSA graded card, how can sending in to PSA gain anything. PSA has a conflict of interest and besides PSA is not perfect as they have known issues and does not do forensics on the submitted card after original grading. Likewise for CGC card sent to CGC. LOL
joliztoyco
Interesting points, BUT PSA is one of the leaders in authentication. Both buyers and sellers worldwide use them and they are a trusted source. I'll keep doing business with a business that pretty much everyone recognizes.
Now "Becketts" service is a whole other subject....
amricons
Not our point
12345jamesstamps
A scratch is a scratch and has to be in the description just like coins and stamps...especially if it's an high end item. You be surprised how many buyers are so picky about condition. Even though you might mention like new it still has that scratch. A lot of buyers are not good at looking at photos. I go through this all the time making sure I describe everything of the item I am selling.
bialystock
OPThey called it a scratch, I didn't. It didn't have a scratch. It was exactly how I described, and the photos were extensive.
joliztoyco
One of the only ways you can avoid Ebay's bumbling "authenticators" is to have your cards graded and then sell them. I know that makes the price increase drastically, but they are making our choices much harder. After 40 years of collecting, I'm pretty confident about how to accurately grade cards, and am not willing to put it in the hands of some 14 day trained clown Ebay has turned into an authenticator. I mostly use PSA and when the time comes to sell , I won't have to deal with them.
I know this isn't a great solution, but we have little choice.
And for those of you that don't know what we're talking about REAL authenticators for a company such as PSA not only describe condition and grades of cards but a second or 3rd also. They then seal it in a "slab" with a registration # that get entered into a database. Also a QR code is sealed into it for future reference. And fakes are pretty easy to spot.
Good luck on your selling.
theteamsetguy
@joliztoyco ,
I think the authenticity program is a good idea for buyers for high dollar cards. This situation is a perfect example of why. Most dealers and experienced collectors will only submit cards to PSA, CSG, or Beckett if they think it will come back with a 9 or 10. A card with a scratch would very unlikely get 9 or much less a 10. A raw card will sell for more than a card graded 7 or 8 most of the time after the grading fees are accounted for which a card with a small scratch would likely receive assuming no other deficiencies.
Since the scratch was not visible or pointed out by the seller in the listing the buyer would not know until they received the card. In my opinion the seller should have noted the scratch in the listing. Since it was not it didn't pass the authentication process. This authentication process will for sellers do a better job of describing the condition of their high dollar cards which I totally agree with.
travelingvaz
Actually this isn't 100% correct.
Even PSA graded cards selling for higher than a specific dollar amount have to be "authenticated".
Scam/???, likely..
no-plain-white-envelopes
I have a card going thru this right now , I said ding they called it a wrinkle. Give me a break. CSG is not good and is trying to overtake others. I will never grade with these clowns!
theteamsetguy
Which card was it? The Gretzky?
bialystock
OPNo, it was a Jayson Tatum card.
simba6
Could be they just don't grade cards with any damage.
bialystock
OP...not talking about grading, talking about authenticating.
luckythewinner
Part of authenticating is making sure it matches the description. And you said it had a scratch, which did not match the description.
bialystock
OPThe description was accurate. The Authenticator is there to verify if the card is real or fake. If it's a matter of description, that's up the having the card graded or not.
bialystock
OPSo insignificant, not even spotted when picture taking. Every angle including high resolution pictures taken.
byrd69er
Just because a scratch isn't visible in multiple photos doesn't mean it wasn't there.
kensgiftshop
Was the scratch they found mentioned in the listing?