The importance to you of "things" -- does it affect sales?
Just read an online essay about estate sales. One line caught my eye:
"But maybe this has less to do with death, and more to do with stuff -— the way, despite its utter futility, we try our hardest to love it into life."
Reminded me of a conversation I had a few months back with some folks about the LA fires. The topic veered off into the loss of material possessions, specifically pianos -- some of those with whom I was chatting had friends who had lost their pianos in the fire. Words / phrases like "devastating," "horrible," "profoundly tragic" and "incalculable loss" were bandied about, accompanied by some actual gasping.
I was asked my opinion and observed that if the people managed to save their own lives and those of their children and pets, nothing else really mattered because inanimate objects can, in the final analysis, be replaced.
I was absolutely pilloried for my comment. Pianos are special, unique, etc. Yes, I replied, but in the end you can buy another one to fall in love with. If you lose your life, not so much.
Needless to say, no minds were changed during the discussion and I did not make any new friends.
But the conversation did get me thinking about how some eBay sellers (myself included) regard their merchandise and whether we price it as we do because we attach some value to it that may reflect a personal, if mostly unconscious, attachment, if not a desire to NOT sell it.
I have never, ever been attached to things, never tried to imbue them with any significance other than just appreciate them for the function they provided. It's why I will likely hang on to my 2011 Toyota (with 168K miles) till it no longer starts. Fancy cars are of zero interest to me since they do the same thing as my Toyota. Same with every other "thing" that I own.
In general, I price my listings to sell, and do fine here. However, have a few listings (for which I paid next to nothing to be honest) for which I am asking an exorbitant amount of money -- because I know they are literally one of a kind (a book for example, the only other copy of which -- at least as far as I can tell from extensive online research -- resides in an American museum).
They are inanimate objects... yet I am not at all sure that I want anyone to buy them.
Curious to hear from others about this. (Sorry for all the words above.)
sreu3058
When I first saw this topic, my thoughts were: I am probably the least sentimental person about material things I know, I detest clutter, etc.
However, I just sold one of my larger, higher end pieces, and feel sad to let it go. My first thought was ‘crud’ (although I do need the money) and then
‘it’s one of a kind’ ‘it’s unique, beautiful, what if I never see anything like it again’
The only thing I have ever amassed is what I sell.
It still surprises me I became a passionate collector of anything.
pickapaper
@fbusoni
Another "two thumbs up" for "The Red Violin". Highly recommended. One of my favorites; have watched it many, many times.
chapeau-noir
I tend to get fond of animals no matter what, probably because I get along with them better than people.
@gurlcat Good thing she didn't leave an elephant or a cow behind! 😮
chapeau-noir
If we circle back to "What does this have to do with sales" (?) My only response is to decide if one is running a store or a museum. People do get attached to their inventory, thinking items HAVE to be worth some sort of 'correct' amount, but I think that's more an attachment to sunk costs. Losing a cherished personal item is really not the same.
grand-and-glorious-purpose
Whether it matters or not is certainly up for debate.
Quite simply not every single inanimate object can be replaced and that isn't debatable.
Though the ones that CAN be replaced, well some have memories attached to them by the buyer.
fbusoni
OPRight, but memories are something that we are conscious of.
I am more interested in understanding and learning about the forces -- which compel us to retain inanimate objects -- that we are unaware of.
onlinecentral
In 1954, a beautiful wooden boat was manufactured.
In 1989, my friend bought it, in poor condition.
In 1998, after some repairs, we rode in the boat for the first time.
In 2002, he traded in the wooden boat and bought a brand new fiberglass boat.
The salesman told my friend he would buy the wooden boat from the dealership and fully restore it to showroom condition.
By committing to restore the boat, the salesman had given the wooden boat a 'forever home'. That was a compelling reason for my friend to trade it in on a new one. I don't know if the salesman ever bought or restored the wooden boat. I did not tell my friend that the 'forever home' boat sales technique has probably been in use for 5,000+ years.
gurlcat
Why do you see it so cynically? Wasn't your friend going to buy the fiberglass boat and trade in the wooden one regardless of what would become of the wooden one anyway?
chapeau-noir
I guess we're irredeemably in a literal, material world.
tobaccocardyahoo
My attitude about pianos is highly influenced by my experience trying to relieve myself of the burden of a lovely baby grand piano which had graced my living room.
We were relocating to a country home which was not suited for this instrument, and no one had played it for years.
Selling it was not possible because there were no buyers. We embarked on trying to give it away,
Had an interested individual. He brought in a piano technician/tuner to we had used in the past to service the piano. That fellow persuaded him to take a piano he was trying to unload.
We tried music schools, other places which might put it to use. No takers. Eventually we paid someone to haul it away. Last we heard he was trying to find someone to take it from him.
A definition of a weed is a plant in the wrong place. A piano you have no use for is a weed, and Ortho does not make a product to remove it.
varebelrose
I was reading this and thinking the same thing; most people today resort to paying someone to haul away and junk pianos. Very few people play any more, as well as many folks not having the room. Its a different world than it was 40-50 years ago.
chapeau-noir
"Most" "Very few" - something like 18,000,000 people in the US play piano.
adamcartwright
@varebelrose
That's very true. My friend cleaned out a deceased relative's home recently.
A beautiful old baby grand piano was eventually given away for free, when he couldn't find a buyer or dealer.
I would have taken it, but we already have a beautiful old piano.
luckythewinner
I was asked my opinion and observed that if the people managed to save their own lives and those of their children and pets, nothing else really mattered because inanimate objects can, in the final analysis, be replaced.
Some things matter more than others.
IMHO your own life and the lives of children matter more than the lives of pets.
And IMHO the lives of pets matter more than inanimate objects.
But IMHO that does not mean that inanimate objects do not matter at all.
I find that the lack of nuance, subtlety and empathy that is inherent in these sort of "black and white, all or nothing" opinions is at the root of a lot of the polarization and discord today.
fbusoni
OPOh my.
As usual, you've cherry-picked, honed in on, and pronounced judgment about a single sentence in a much longer discussion, drawing sweeping, even existential sociological conclusions whilst completely missing the import of the post.
But thanks, nonetheless.
chevymontecarlo88
@luckythewinner
Yes, all of your posts are so inspirational and tend to bring people together.
fbusoni
OP@chevymontecarlo88
Tempted to mark this as "best answer." 😂
I've asked him to refrain from commenting on my posts. I guess he forgot. 😆
chapeau-noir
Actually, this is one of the few posts where I agreed with the poster - eta: In a general sense.
gurlcat
I did too, but I also agreed with the OP that the post was not simply asking if anyone thinks sentimental value is a real thing or not; if it was it would have been a much shorter post.
But really this is almost too big a topic to chew, at least as presented. What to save from a fire doesn't translate neatly to whether to sell an item (at all), much less how much to price it.
Case in point: I am the caregiver of a gecko that my daughter left when she moved out. To me it is nothing but a burden; I have zero emotional attachment to it, nor is it worth anything really, in fact I know for a fact it would be hard to give away. I've gone round-and-round with the idea of how to get rid of it ..... but what is out of the question is killing it or even releasing it into the wild where it would surely die (if not quickly from starvation, being used to farmed insects put right in front of its face, then from the next winter cold).
And here's where the subject gets extra dicey: even though I literally wish this dumb lizard would just die, if my house caught on fire and I had only enough time (after making sure my 2 cats were out) to save the lizard or some inanimate object I deeply hold dear, and would surely MOURN .... I would save the lizard, because the GUILT of letting it die such a horrific death would outweigh my grief of a non-living object.
And that's just an emotional comparison. What really surprised and confused me @fbusoni about your post was this: the thing about your car, and also your rare books. To me there's a real disconnect there, because you started off talking about people's personal attachments to their pianos, so I thought the rest of the post would tie into that. With that framing, a person might hold onto an old car until it ran into the ground, because they loved the car, in part because of many years of memories with it. LOL there's a whole 'King Of The Hill' episode about this, where Hank has to face losing his red pickup truck, and his son cleverly rescues the knob from the gear shifter, to put on the new truck, sort of transferring the old one's 'soul.'
But this is where your definition of "attachment to material things" switches. -You don't hold onto your 2011 Toyota because you are attached to it; you just waive the chance to own a "fancy" one instead. Likewise, you don't price your rare books for high dollar amounts because you feel attached to them; you price them based on their rareness, the assessment that they are (or should be) worth that much to someone else, because of their rarity. So in both of these examples, you're kind of disassociating, for lack of a better word. You're looking from the outside in, what you believe other people value in a vehicle or book, the prestige of fanciness and rarity. Do you see how far removed that is from whether someone might feel devastated if an object they already owned and loved was destroyed in a fire?
And do you really not have any single item that is precious to you because of who owned it before you, or because of memories you associate with it? Not even something like photos or letters, that you would mourn the loss of if they were burned up and gone forever?
fbusoni
OP@gurlcat
Thanks for your thoughts and especially your insights. Always a pleasure to read your value-added and perceptive posts here.
The "disassociation" to which you allude is, I reckon, evidence of my own lack of access to my own unconscious. 😊
And yes, photos would be something that I would save. I did not think of those because I have so few of them, but they are all in one place (on my piano, in fact).
gurlcat
Ha you really shouldn't encourage me. But if you wanted a big philosophical discussion you know I'm almost always down for it. And upon rereading that long reply I made yesterday, it actually strikes me as sounding 'meaner' than intended, and I should have included this: I DO think I get the main question you were asking, and what you mean about not putting a whole lot of value in material things. I'm also not really interested in better, fancier ones (okay I'd like a better car but only because mine has so many problems it's truly unpleasant to drive and is probably only waiting to die when I'm further from home than I'd normally dare, ha).









Many years ago I had a boyfriend who was the only person I ever met whose childhood poverty tales outdid mine, at least in one particular area (food). -Whereas my mom would prepare a 1:1 ratio of store-bought milk with rehydrated free government powdered milk, his mom would prepare a 1:1 of canned tuna and 9 Lives cat food. 🤢 But other details really wowed me, like how she made money here and there sewing custom clothes for drag queens, transgender women, transvestites, and even "adult baby" fetishists, basically anybody who couldn't find their desired attire in their size. And this I really admired: basically everything in their home was for sale, like in the Sanford & Son TV show. He said one day he'd come home and there'd just be no TV, kitchen table, stereo or whatever, until she found another cheap or free, which she always did, because she was extremely resourceful and not 'above' stuff like dumpster diving. -She wasn't on drugs either, just preferred that lifestyle over making money for someone else.
Something about that just 'clicked' with me, this idea of endlessly cycling stuff around, having and enjoying this or that item only temporarily, then replacing it with another, but almost never going out and buying a brand new one. I don't think I've come anywhere near adhering to the model as he described it, but not because I'd be unwilling to part with 99% of the things around me, just that I wouldn't be willing to let people come wander around my home to "shop" like his mom did.
And that's where eBay comes in, or at least theoretically, although it gets trickier when the "worth" of something is less than the cost of shipping it. But I have let go of many, many things here.
I told you someday I would share my little shoebox collection of jewelry pieces I've acquired in 'junk lots', and this thread is about as appropriate a place to do so as any. These are all pieces that are worth more to me than they would ever sell for on eBay. -And I want to be clear about that; I don't mean any of these would sell for (say) $200 on eBay, but I think they're worth more like $300 or $400. No-no-no-no-no, LOL. I mean none of them is worth more than maybe $20, and I find it absurd, for reasons that depend on the item.
Like the Tibetan 3-piece stone chip set, worth little because they're pretty common, same with the 3-piece 'island scene' hand-painted on real blue morpho butterfly wing set. I don't care if they're common; I think they're MAGICAL. Then there's the tiny Victorian sterling instrument -I don't even know what that thing IS, but until I find out, I'm wearing it as a pendant!
Then there are all the Russian hand-painted brooches, also common, but also I don't care; they should be worth more!
And this one just takes the cake. When I first discovered it I thought I had found real treasure -WOW, the person who threw in in a "junk" lot must not have realized it was hand-painted! And painted on shell, so it truly glows when turned in the light! And OMG, SIGNED by the artist! This HAD to be a bonafide Antiques-Road-Show-stopping kind of thing, right?
So I posted it in a jewelry group on Facebook, where it got lots of love but also (pretty quickly) a crest-falling barrage of info: the portrait is not an original work but a copy of a famous Russian painting, in fact it's one of a series of 4 (I think) famous painting copy brooches. What's more, the signature is not that of a solitary artist who decided to do these and produced/sold only the small number that one artist would reasonably want to do ... no, the signature is that of an artisan who, although obviously very skilled, was just one of many employed to mass-produce these things, for probably little pay (it's surprising they were even allowed to sign their pieces, but I have since learned this was a really common practice in Russia, for everything from wall art copies to hand-painted nesting dolls, at least mid-nineteenth century).
Incidentally brooches from this series aren't common, but they're not rare either, and so the prices I've seen were only in the $20-40 range. Just insulting if you ask me.
Oh and one more reason I haven't listed it here: I have never tried so many times to photograph something so utterly un-photogenic. If you think it looks pretty in these pictures, you have no idea. In real life it's 10X as gorgeous. With the camera I can only capture EITHER the detail or the luminosity, never both in the same image, like what my naked eye can see. And I just hate it when I can't show people how fabulous something really is, to justify it's price. So screw it, it stays with me, for now at least.
fbusoni
OP@gurlcat
Yes, I noted the mildly acerbic tone of your reply above. ðŸ˜
Your story about the gecko was interesting to me. You're apparent fury at having had it dumped on you seems to have led you to consider only two options to unburden yourself from its care: "killing it" or "releasing it into the wild where it would surely die."
The first thing that I would do with such a creature would be to advertise it on a reptile rescue website so that someone could adopt it and give it a new home. There'd be plenty of takers.
Yet hanging on to it seems to give you some sort of satisfaction... perhaps the mix of feelings that you so graphically describe from having such a creature around seem familiar, and thus "comforting."
THAT is the sort of unconscious dynamic that I was alluding to in my original post... perhaps I should have made that more explicit.
Which leads me to my attachment to my car... when I was a child we were not exactly poor but close to it. I've told the story here before about how the big weekly outing for my family was a trip to Woolworth's for their Sunday $1 breakfast special. And heaven help you if you wanted something on the side which took you over a dollar!
I grew up with what is known as a "scarcity mindset." The fear that there would not be enough. It was pervasive, a day-to-day experience.
Thus, as an adult, now some 60 years later, the feeling that I am somehow "prepared for the worst" is very familiar to me.
Certainly holding on to an old car because I do not want to spend the money that I have saved up to buy a newer car falls into that category. It's actually borderline irrational, but for the moment at least, the forces that compel me to hang on to the old car are more powerful than those which impel me to buy something newer.
(Although now that I have acknowledged my irrational attachment to the Toyota, moving forward will be easier -- I just now ordered a replacement title so I can sell it.)
And -- get this -- you're reference to my "disassociation" was on target, as wanting to keep the old car has absolutely nothing to do with my lack of interest in a "fancy" new car to which I originally referred.
fbusoni
OPForgot to mention that I really enjoyed the insight above.
I'm not sure why, at least not yet.
But when I figure out why it appeals so much to me I will let you know. ðŸ˜
meme6253
Quite the profound conversation.
gurlcat
A few years ago I got this 16-inch baby Hyphalosaurus fossil at a church sale, for (I kid you not) $25. It even had the original sale paperwork from 1995 taped to the back, showing that it was purchased for $750 at that time.

I don't know how much it might fetch on eBay. Probably more -looking at other sales of this species, mine is larger than average and has an extremely rare presentation. If you look at listings or even google, you'll see that they usually fossilized laying on their bellies or backs, so the presentation is from above or below, not from the side like mine, and that makes a big difference in what is visible. Also the cause of death is apparent; poor little feller is a good representation of why a long neck is fine for traversing wide open places like the sky, but the busy underwater world, not so much, and that's probably why long necks phased out of aquatic fauna.
Then again, maybe it would be a hard sell, because the previous owner who had it framed provided absurdly erroneous information, that this species lived in the Miocene, only 5-23 million years ago. Ha, that was when the mammals arose; this guy actually lived in the Cretacious, over 100 million years ago. So that would have to be fixed by the buyer if they wanted it fixed. And then there's the torturous task of packing a fragile slice of sandstone framed in glass. Come to think of it, an unscrupulous buyer could break the glass themselves to try for a partial refund, since the frame would have to be taken apart to fix that info cartouche anyway.
But still, are these really reasons to waive the chance to make several hundred bucks, maybe even a bit more? No they're not. And if this was just about any other thing, I would do it.
But the thing is, I was fascinated with dinosaurs as a kid, as well as the Loch Ness Monster. And I never dreamed (why would I?) that I might someday own a baby one. So often I'm thissssclose to being unable to afford rent, and I think of this guy. He could so easily save me from eviction, I think. But then I think about how much I would hate myself later, to think I gave him up for just ONE month's rent. And so he spends at least another month on my wall. If he was worth .... I dunno .... $10k, it'd be another story; I could really do something with that much. But just scrape by with him? No. There are always other ways to scrape by.
chapeau-noir
I think it's wise to remember that objects can have a symbolic value for an individual that goes beyond their superficial 'usefulness' or even sentiment. I grew up in a family of musicians and their instruments become almost an extension of themselves (it's why the piano story struck me). A musical instrument, for instance, can embody years of work, practice, beauty, struggle, a record of the passage of time, a mode of self-expression, of creativity. It becomes in a way a 'container for the thing contained' which is non-material. It can be a horn, a guitar, whatever, but it may have the same value. Taking a hard practical view basically discounts all of this.
fbusoni
OP@chapeau-noir
Very true. I played piano for some 50 years, and one day woke up and found my right hand to be completely numb (imagine your foot falling asleep). Ultimately I had cervical spine surgery, but the damage was done.
Selling my piano after that was easy, relatively speaking, as I had something more immediate to lament.
But in very short order I managed to channel my creative energies elsewhere.
For all the reasons you cite, I would never, ever conceive of depriving another person of their right to mourn the loss of a material possession.
pickapaper
@fbusoni wrote "Hope you did oil changes every few months... short drives are hardest on the engines because they never get up to operating temperature and thus do not burn off contaminants in the oil."
My husband is adamant about changing oil in vehicles. We have a 2007 Ford F-150 with 162K, bought it new. That baby gets the oil changed every 3,000 miles come hell or high water.
The problem with some of these older vehicles is things wear out, they are getting harder to have worked on and it's getting harder to find parts for them when something goes wrong, thus more expensive.
fbusoni
OP@pickapaper
Please give your husband my regards... I share the same view about maintenance.
How long does it take for you to put 3,000 miles on the truck?
If it takes more than 3 months, then ideally you should be changing the oil at 3 months, and not / not wait till you hit 3,000 miles.
Doing so will reduce the likelihood that internal parts will wear out. Happy to chat offline if you want to pursue this. 😊
mommaknows
I have a '98 Toyota Tacoma 4x4 that has 361,000 miles and have had a plethora of notes on my windshield with offers to buy. Nope.
It's my ride till I die car.
Not everything has a price.
house*of*paws
I purchased a ‘98 Acura Integra Hatchback in ‘02 with 69k miles on it. It was absolutely PERFECT for me … and still is today with 142k miles. [Okay, I’d prefer having more convenient cup holders and a built-in GPS … but I’d be giving up way more than I’d be getting for those.]
I also get numerous offers to buy it … often considerably over Blue Book … but no way! It’s PERFECT. 😸
And thanks for the movie suggestion @chevymontecarlo88 , which I’d never heard of. It’s free on YouTube … and I’ll be watching it this afternoon. 😸
chevymontecarlo88
Props to @adamcartwright for the movie reminder.
Get some popcorn @house*of*paws , it's a good one.
adamcartwright
@fbusoni
I have to say that's a very strange conversation you had -- to be pilloried for your common sense point of view.
Maybe these people view every piano as a sort of "red violin."
Seems a good thing that you didn't make any new friends, IMO.
chevymontecarlo88
Great reference and great movie to watch if you are a music/instrument lover.
A must watch if you have not seen it @fbusoni !
The Red Violin
fbusoni
OP@chevymontecarlo88
Thank you, I will have a look.
gurlcat
I've watched that movie at least 3 times (maybe more), and that's despite having no background in music or instruments. It's one of those movies that 'haunts' you after you've seen it. It comes to my mind all the time.
chevymontecarlo88
The mythical obsession players/musicians have with instruments can be an out of body experience. Years ago, when some of my customer would ask what it is like finding some rare/historical pieces. My response would be, "watch The Red Violin". I have had some incredibly rare and historical pieces in my hands and sometimes they do haunt you. (Especially when you don't buy them. 😀)
adamcartwright
@chevymontecarlo88
I'm glad you caught that!
A fabulous movie.
house*of*paws
@adamcartwright
It probably depended upon which ‘stage of grief’ the person was experiencing when @fbusoni offered their words of wisdom. It takes time to recover from sudden loss and regain perspective. 🙂
adamcartwright
@house*of*paws
You're so right about that, but it sounded to me like @fbusoni was talking to people whose friends lost pianos, not to the victims themselves.
I get it -- some objects would be really hard to lose. We face that every time we pack up to evacuate. While we would greatly mourn the loss of family heirlooms and our beautiful pianos, I would reserve "incalculable loss" for a human or animal.
For me, this thread highlights how certain objects can have very special meaning, which is part of the fun of buying and selling here on eBay.
fbusoni
OP@adamcartwright
I was joking about the "friends" part. 😊
But as others have pointed out rather eloquently, there is for many people something special about a musical instrument as a "vessel" or "container" of years of feelings and emotions. (For others, it's their cars, boats, homes, etc.) I understand that and would never in a million years deny anyone the right to such a perception.
It's just that I personally (at least as far as I know, "consciously" I mean!) do not imbue inanimate objects with my thoughts and feelings, nor do I attribute to them any magical or sentimental significance. If my home was threatened by fire I'd save my family members and pets and if possible any old photos that were developed on paper before everything was stored in the cloud.
mantle1951
We have a 2011 Nissan Sentra with 53,000 miles, was my wife's car she worked 5 blocks away for 10 years!!!
fbusoni
OPHope you did oil changes every few months... short drives are hardest on the engines because they never get up to operating temperature and thus do not burn off contaminants in the oil.
44012
So interesting! I still have my 2008 Maxima with 53K miles and I am not interested in buying a new car.
I love my car â¤ï¸
tarotfindsandmore
I like everything I sell. I actually buy on the basis of my response to a thing in about 90% of the cases. The other 10% are usually things someone else (my kid, my sister) has suggested or asked me to sell.
That said, I like the things I sell the way I like other people's children. I have no desire to keep them. At most, I like them like I like my own grandchildren. I love them and I love having them around, but it's fine when it's time for them to go home.
Some of my attitude probably stems from having made so many large geographical moves over the course of my life. I've probably moved over 100,000 miles in my life (CA to HI to WA to UK to CA to WA, and several moves within those states and countries), so I've learned to hang on to just to the essentials. I have a mantel and few shelves in my house that are home to the treasures I've accumulated from my children, other family, and dear friends over the years but all of it would easily fit in a couple boxes. When I go, my children will get those items, my homes, and my inventory so they can decide which "stuff" they can't live without.
chevymontecarlo88
With musical instruments I see emotional pricing all of the time. Every person is different, and their reasoning will vary depending on their circumstances. I see this at estate sales as well where those who are selling may have an emotional attachment to items that belonged to someone special. (inflated prices) Most of the time these items can be purchased with conversation/education and with establishing a repour with them. Generally speaking, everything has a price, and it is interesting to find out how some explain how they value it. Sometimes it only takes a few minutes learning/listening to a story from them to understand why. Sometimes you will find that the attachment is too strong where they are not ready to sell it.
I do price items that i do not want to sell for a price that would allow me to devest any emotional relationship that i have with them. But those are items that I am not specifically targeting to sell.
fbusoni
OP@chevymontecarlo88
Thanks, that is the sort of insight I am curious about. In your case, the decision is a conscious one.
What is more intriguing to me, personally, is whether sellers do this without being aware that they are doing this. 😊
Of course, on the surface, no one is likely to know. Which makes it all the more interesting.
bonjourami
When I sold fine jewelry here for many years, I did keep some great pieces..not for myself, but for my daughters. But I did find that some pieces that I loved were very hard to part with,I believe I only kept two or three during all those years. One was a Cartier tank watch that I picked up at a high end estate sale, and one was a vintage Gucci watch..I still have both.They will go to my daughters too, some day.
pickapaper
Funny thing about the sentimentality of pianos. We have a friend whose mother was a classically trained pianist, played concerts all over the world, even played for a pope one time, decades ago. When it came time to sell her mother's estate, the friend sold literally everything except her mother's beautiful concert grand piano. She put it in the sale but put a huge dollar amount on it so that no one would buy it. She had no use for it herself but was going to keep it anyway. The friend moved away and we lost track of her so don't know whatever happened to the piano but if I were to guess, I would guess she still has it. She was unmarried, no children, no one to pass it to, so it will probably get sold someday. Many years have passed so that the piano's value now would exist only in the friend's mind; it would mean nothing to anyone else and sadly, when it sells it will sell for a fraction of what the friend thought it was worth.
susanb1872
So there is no one comprehensive answer to your question. Some "things" become more important because of the sentimentality we attach to them. They become a visual manifestation of our sentimental feelings. For example, if I had a piano, maybe I would look at it and remember that my mother and I played duets together on it. If the piano was lost in a fire, of course, the piano can be replaced but not the sentimental attachment.
jg.mason
If I buy stuff to sell and I find something I like or want, it doesn't go up for sale I keep it. Sure material things aren't as important as the lives of me and my loved ones. That doesn't change the fact the most people after surviving a fire will than start to feel great sadness about losing all their possessions. Most things can be replaced but not all things.
an-57470
If I have an item that I really don’t care to sell, then I list it at a “crazy†price.
Sometimes, the item is irreplaceable (I sold a solid silver Spanish button recovered from the wreck of Atocha a few years back). If it then sells (and it did sell), at least I have the comfort of a large financial gain.
I can think of only a few items in our home office/hobby room that are absolutely 100% off limits.