The bizarre and ever-changing 1.65% International Fee, even if you're enrolled in eBay's program
I am enrolled in eBay International Shipping and have, over the years, sold many items to overseas buyers. I love the program, eBay takes care of everything, from customs, to shipping, to complaints.
I recently sold two (expensive) items to buyers with shipping addresses IN the U.S. The problem arises because the buyers are registered outside of the U.S., and eBay slapped me with a 1.65% seller fee. I complained to customer service and eventually was transferred to a supervisor who reversed the (first) fee and sent me a SR with the following statement:
The fee was incorrectly applied because the buyer's registration address was outside of the U.S., but as a registered eIS user, this should not result in an international fee for you. I have also ensured that this issue is noted internally to prevent future incorrect charges for transactions that fall under the eIS program.
A few weeks later, with the second item, I was told that only eBay's IT department (?!) can process such refunds, even though there is a known glitch in the system, and the 1.65% International Fee should be imposed on the buyer who is registered outside the U.S., not the U.S. seller who is simply shipping to another U.S. address. I'm still waiting, as anyone who has dealt with an IT dept. understands well.
Ebay has gotten so complicated now that IT is charged with figuring out refunds. What a world!
albertabrightalberta
@mdhavey
It's not just that you offer EIS that avoids your having to pay international fees. The buyer has to choose that option as the shipping service.
dhbookds
Despite being in EIS for years, I've always been charged the l.65% fee when the item is shipped in the US from a buyer registered outside the US.......and happened again the last wks.....one to Uk via EIS (not charged), one to FLA (charged), registered buyer in the UAE. I agree with Lacemaker that you perhaps got a courtesy refund on one of yours.
@devon@ebay
@kyle@ebay
Could we put this to rest? If the internationally registered buyer has an item mailed to the US...and the seller is in EIS.......is the seller charged the international fee?
Also, can we put in our listings......."If the buyer is registered overseas we add 1.65% to the hammer price, which is what eBay charges us."?
mdhavey
OP"If your registered address is in the US and you offer eBay International Shipping for your eligible listings, you won't be charged an international fee when your eligible item sells."
Seems pretty cut and dried to me.
slippinjimmy
It is cut and dried but your interpretation is faulty.
An order with a ship to address within the Lower 48 of the US is NOT an "eligible listing".
kyle@ebay
Hey @dhbookds I'll be happy to help clear this up.
Actually, I'll let @albertabrightalberta clear it up since they hit the nail on the head with their response here in message 45.
dhbookds
Thanks @kyle@ebay (and Alberta......) hopefully that will clear it up for the op.... @mdhavey
How about the statement ..........can that be added to a description????
edit: my English teachers would not approve of "can".........obviously it can be added.....but is it ebay "legal" to add it and then charge it to an international buyer who doesn't use EIS?
dhbookds
marnotom!
So, let me get this straight. If I were to purchase an item from this seller and have it shipped through eIS (which appears to be offered by the seller), I’d be charged an additional 1.65% simply because I’m registered in Canada?
mdhavey
OPIf you're a buyer registered in Canada and the seller sends your item TO CANADA there is no extra fee as long as the seller is signed up for eBay's International Seller program.
But weirdly eBay charges the seller a 1.65% fee if, and only if, the buyer is registered outside the U.S. AND the item is shipped to an address IN the U.S. I'm simply trying to recoup that 1.65% fee that eBay charges me, since it's the buyer who has caused the fee to be charged me in the first place. As you can see from the OP, the fee was refunded me on one occasion, and not on another.
I know, it doesn't make sense. Much about eBay doesn't make sense.
albertabrightalberta
No, @mdhavey
You don't understand how EIS works.
You offer EIS to international buyers but it's an expensive service for them because of the fees and taxes ebay charges the buyers. (You don't see the additional charges that the buyers pay.) If the buyer chooses EIS, you don't pay the international fee.
You also offer domestic shipping to the US. If the buyer (with an international registration) opts to use a different (not EIS) shipping service (a freight forwarder, their college dorm or a relative in the US) to have the item shipped to, you WILL be assessed 1.65% international fee.
"If you're a buyer registered in Canada and the seller sends your item TO CANADA there is no extra fee as long as the seller is signed up for eBay's International Seller program."
No, this is wrong. If you're a Canadian buyer and the seller sends your item TO CANADA, the seller DOES pay the fee because the seller isn't sending the item to the Glendale Heights, IL location. When the seller ships directly to the international buyer's country, there IS a fee.
marnotom!
The message in the listing says that if my registered address is outside of Canada, I’ll be charged another 1.65% by the seller. No matter how the item is shipped. None of what you’ve (largely erroneously) stated here, um, addresses that.
monroe67
"But weirdly eBay charges the seller a 1.65% fee if, and only if, the buyer is registered outside the U.S. AND the item is shipped to an address IN the U.S."
False. eBay's 1.65% International Fee applies in two situations. One occurs, as you well know through this experience, when the buyer's registered address is outside the USA regardless of what the delivery address is. The other is when the buyer's delivery address is outside the USA.
eBay's User Agreement states directly and unambiguously that eBay charges their fees to sellers. Period.
There are very few and very specific exceptions in which an eBay buyer will pay a fee to eBay. The situation in this thread does not fall into any of those exceptions.
"I'm simply trying to recoup that 1.65% fee that eBay charges me, since it's the buyer who has caused the fee to be charged me in the first place."
You cannot recoup this 1.65% fee from eBay or from anybody else. The total dollar amount of the fees you have paid to eBay -- which eBay has retained (kept) from your eBay sales -- that total dollar amount of eBay fees are potentially deductible as business expenses when you are filing your federal income taxes.
You could try to "protect" yourself financially from this dreadful, burdensome, oppressive, odious, onerous, weird, and "illogical" international fee by increasing your prices by at least 1.65%. Maybe a nice round number like 2%.
mdhavey
OPLatest suggested solution, given to me in a DM:
"This only works with auctions, but if your high bidder is registered in a foreign country and requests a U.S. shipping address, immediately after auction close send them an invoice with the 1.65% added. I've done that in the past and it's worked, thus the buyer pays for eBay's absurd "international fee" on items that are not being shipped iternationally.
gone.c-33
That is against eBay policy, you cannot charge anything that is not included in the listing.
Whoever you talked to was either misinformed or didn’t understand the question.
If a buyer registered outside the US purchases an item to be shipped through the EIS, you don’t get charged the 1.65%.
If a buyer registered outside the US purchases an item to be shipped to a freight forwarder, their dorm room where they stay while studying in the US, to their relative who lives in the US or to one of the thousands of depots in the US that receive purchases for the hundreds of thousands of Canadians who live close to the border, you will be charged the 1.65% fee.
mdhavey
OP"That is against eBay policy, you cannot charge anything that is not included in the listing."
I am now putting a statement in my listings that I will charge a buyer who is registered overseas whose address is in the U.S. the 1.65% International Fee that eBay charges me. That should cover it.
slippinjimmy
How do you plan to do that? Whatever scheme you have in mind will eventually end up with your account permanently suspended.
jonathanbrightlight
It does not, in fact, cover it. Nothing typed into your listing will allow you to override or violate eBay’s stated policies, which always take precedence.
monroe67
"I am now putting a statement in my listings that I will charge a buyer who is registered overseas whose address is in the U.S. the 1.65% International Fee that eBay charges me. That should cover it."
That could be a nice exercise for your typing skills but it will mean absolutely nothing. It will be non-enforceable.
To borrow from William Shakespeare, those words would be
"a tale / Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, / Signifying nothing."
kensgiftshop
No, you can't charge the buyer more then what's in the listing, or their bid.
mdhavey
OPSending an invoice with an adjustment only works for auctions (which is mainly how I sell). You can reduce the hammer price for combined shipping, or increase the price for other reasons, like the 1.65% international fee. Doesn't work for Buy It Now, since the item is already paid for.
kensgiftshop
It won't work for auctions either, when buyers start reporting you for trying to charge them more.
lb23cavaliersmvp
I only ship international using EIS and this weekend was charged the 1.65% fee on 2 different sales due to the buyers being registered outside the US. In general, if there are monitors of this site with the authority to edit content why aren't they also facilitating issues like this directly to ebay for clarification and resolution? I recently was asked to complete a survey as a seller on ebay, not the one regarding this feature, and like every other time indicated the fact that ebay shows no interest in addressing what seems to be relevant problems of unequal enforcement of policies. As I also stated previously in this forum my Top Rated Seller book/CD/lp discount continues to be applied randomly; 1 book sale it was credited and 2 others it wasn't (all 3 items were listed with identical criteria).
tobaccocardyahoo
You have parsed the policy statement in a way that does not agree with the common understanding of the Ebay policy, which is if the order ships via EIS there is no international fee.
It is extremely common for sellers who parse Ebay policy in a manner which is other than the obvious intent of the policy, which is shared by most other sellers, to be disappointed with the way the policy is enforced.
You are not going to win this battle, because the IT department is not going to process a refund. That was **bleep** by the customer service rep to get rid of you.
mdhavey
OPIt's not me "parsing" eBay policy. Once again I will post the written reply I got after receiving the refund, referencing their internal SR number, and yes the item was shipped to an address in the U.S.:
As we discussed, you will not be charged an international fee for eligible items when using the eBay International Shipping (eIS) program. I apologize for any confusion and the misinformation shared previously. The fee was incorrectly applied because the buyer's registration address was outside of the U.S., but as a registered eIS user, this should not result in an international fee for you.
marnotom!
What does “eligible†mean in this context?
dhbookds
I always thought "eligible" listings applied to the EIS program.........never occurred to me that it would include listings delivered in the US........
kensgiftshop
Were the items shipped EIS or did the buyer use a freight forwarder in the US?
mdhavey
OPAll I know is I bought the shipping label from eBay, sent to addresses in the U.S. When I sold the items I didn't even know the buyers were registered outside the U.S. What difference should that make, and why is the fee my problem, other than "well, it's always been that way since PayPal"?
kensgiftshop
The difference is:
If it's shipped EIS, you don't pay the fee.
If it's shipped to a freight forwarder, you do pay the fee.
janet9988
Why does that matter? Ebay clearly explains that if you offer EiS then you will not be charged the fee.
If your registered address is in the US and you offer eBay International Shipping for your eligible listings, you won't be charged an international fee when your eligible item sells.
https://www.ebay.com/help/selling/fees-credits-invoices/selling-fees?id=4822&st=3&pos=3&query=Selling%20fees&intent=INTERNATIONAL%20FEE&lucenceai=lucenceai&docId=HELP1456
kensgiftshop
Wouldn't the buyer have to choose EIS?
They can offer EIS, but buyer can still ship to a freight forwarder in the US.
an-36344
No.
kensgiftshop
Are you saying that I can offer EIS on my listings, but have the buyers use a freight forwarder and I wouldn't have to pay the extra fee, just because I offered EIS?
janet9988
Ebay clearly states the the seller just has to OFFER EIS .......
International fee
If your registered address is in the US and you offer eBay International Shipping for your eligible listings, you won't be charged an international fee when your eligible item sells.
marnotom!
But does eligible mean “eligible to be sold with eIS as an option†or “eligible to be shipped through eIS� There’s a difference, and I’m probably doing a lousy job of trying to distinguish the two interpretations.
fern*wood
My listings offer eiS and if used by the buyer, I'm not charged the extra fee. If they decide to use a freight forwarder instead, then I'm charged the fee. Both are delivered to US addresses.
lacemaker3
@janet9988 and @mdhavey,
But, the next sentence says that it does matter. It explains why OP is being charged the international fee: because the item in question was not shipped with eBay International Shipping:
janet9988
Then ebay just needs to get rid if the first sentence completely as it is deceiving.
marnotom!
I'll re-state this one more time and then let it drop: I think your interpretation of "eligible listing" and "eligible item" is different than eBay's.
mdhavey
OPWhat you've overlooked, lacemaker, is the response, in writing, from ebay with my refund:
The fee was incorrectly applied because the buyer's registration address was outside of the U.S., but as a registered eIS user, this should not result in an international fee for you. I have also ensured that this issue is noted internally to prevent future incorrect charges for transactions that fall under the eIS program.
It's the second refund I'm asking for which is currently tied up in, of all things, their IT department. Go figure, I admit none of this makes any rational sense, but that's eBay for you.
fern*wood
Did your buyer purchase through the eiS program? Or are you saying being opted in to eis and a buyer registered in another country uses a freight forwarder, I am not to be charged the fee. If true, then eBay owes many of us a refund.
kensgiftshop
Was the item shipped to the EIS hub or a freight forwarder?
mdhavey
OPIt was shipped to a street address in Oregon, not a box number, and I have no idea if it's a freight forwarder.
kensgiftshop
That was probably a freight forwarder.
If so, that's why you were charged the International fee.
fern*wood
There are no eiS hubs in Oregon, so that was a freight forwarder. As I mentioned, I use eiS, but if my buyer doesn't, then I am always charged the fee. If that isn't the case, then lots of refunds are due to other sellers. We need some clarification on this.
ebay@devon
lacemaker3
The eIS does not have a shipping hub in Oregon, so whether it was a freight forwarder or not, it was not shipped with eIS. If buyer was registered outside the USA, even if it was shipped within the USA, then the international fee applies.
albertabrightalberta
That was a freight forwarder.
Although you us EIS for international buyers, your buyer chose not to use it and instead chose a freight forwarder. Your sale WAS subject to the 1.65% international fee and correctly charged.
lacemaker3
This would not be the first time an eBay CS rep made a mistake in what they told an eBay user. Most responders around here can tell you that.
The first refund they gave you may have gone through because it was a one-time courtesy refund, not because it was actually supposed to.
householdrecycle
This is nothing new. These people have a registered address in the US and use a mail forwarder. There is literally no way around it unless eBay flags that and forces them to re-register there account address. I hate this term, but this one is the "cost of doing business"
mdhavey
OPThe point I'm making is that eBay itself doesn't seem to know. From the SR that the supervisor sent to me with the refund:
The fee was incorrectly applied because the buyer's registration address was outside of the U.S., but as a registered eIS user, this should not result in an international fee for you. I have also ensured that this issue is noted internally to prevent future incorrect charges for transactions that fall under the eIS program.