Selling Issue
Summary: rjb0986 shared an issue where during an eBay auction, they agreed with a bidder to end the auction early and relist the item as Buy It Now at a higher price. However, attempting to end the listing resulted in a sale at the original $20 auction price, and the bidder has paid, asking about shipping. dbmm-media advised shipping the item as the buyer won the auction legitimately. Others like albertabrightalberta suggested understanding eBay's policies better, highlighting potential fees, and the effect of cancellations. Participants agreed that ending the auction incorrectly led to this situation and advised learning from the experience for future listings.
Hello,
I had an auction with one bidder at $20. During the auction, the bidder contacted me asking about a Buy It Now price. We discussed a price around $75-$80, and the bidder suggested I end the auction and relist as Buy It Now. When I attempted to end the listing, eBay instead completed the sale to the bidder at $20. The buyer has paid and is now asking about shipping. Has anyone experienced this before, and what are my options? Would a seller-initiated cancellation result in a defect in this situation?
luckythewinner
EBay didn't do anything "instead". - eBay did exactly what you told them to do. You just told them to do the wrong thing.
Many seller have made the mistake of selling an item for tless than they wanted. Your options are to sell the item, or cancel and take a defect.
Yes.
kensgiftshop
Should have told buyer to bid on the agreed price, then close the auction and sell to the highest bidder.
sin-n-dex
That will only work if a second buyer bids against him up to the agreed price. Putting in a proxy bid doesn't guarantee it will bid that high.
selsa84
Mistakes happen you can ship it to the buyer or cancel and relist for the other buyer that offered more
mam98031
Sorry this happened to you. You should have cancelled their bid first before trying to end the auction. However even doing that, Ebay would have charged you the selling fees for the item at $20 + shipping.
Ebay did NOT "decide" to end the auction and sell to your bidder, YOU did. We all make mistakes. Learn and move on. Do right by your buyer and ship the item out right away.
In the future if you are not SURE how to handle something, come here and ask. The Community is full of experienced buyers and sellers that volunteer their time to help fellow members as needed.
mamacassidy
I agree with the others that you ended it the wrong way, and at this point, you have to either send it to the person or cancel it and get a defect.
However, what I think also needs to be addressed is why you would end the auction at all. If this buyer thought it could go as high as $75 or $80, then you should have let it ride out. I understand that it could have ended for less money, but if this buyer thought it could go that high and there were still 5 days left, then I'd take that chance.
albertabrightalberta
@rjb0986
Not that it matters but was the buyer who won it as the $20 bid price the same one who contacted you?
It sounds like you ended it choosing "sell to the high bidder" rather than ending for another reason.
And in case you aren't aware, ending an auction with a bid will have ebay charging you a fee on the high bid price.
Per ebay policy, you are required to follow through on the sale to the buyer who won it at $20.
If this happens in the future, you should cancel bids before ending the listing.
You should also be aware that if you cancel the $20 sale, you need to be honest about the reason, choosing "out of stock" or "damaged" as the reason. OOS cancellations can impact your seller standing on ebay and can result in your being unable to sell if you do it often. (Ebay isn't transparent about what "often" is.)
rjb0986
OPYes, they were the one who contacted and asked me to end for a Buy It Now. I may have selected the wrong option, so that may have been a mistake I made. Thanks for the response.
dbmm-media
ship it, buyer legitimately won the auction
rjb0986
OPUnderstood. The auction had 5 days left when they requested this. It feels a little deceitful, but if that is the only real option available, I guess that is what I will do. I appreciate the quick response. Thank you.
monroe67
Live and learn.
If another bidder asks you, in the future, to do the same thing, you may simply tell him/her, "NO. I don't do that."
You set your auction for 7 days or 10 days or whatever period of time, and it would not be fair to other potential bidders to end the auction early.
(Besides the fact that it might not be fair to you, as the seller, to end the auction early. If there were five days left, the final bid might have been a lot more than only $20.00.)
selsa84
Legitimately would have been the auction timing out not seller error.