Scammed by eBay labels????
Summary: studiopointmonarch expressed frustration over eBay charging an additional shipping fee due to discrepancies in box measurements and weight calculation. They argued this was deceptive as the dimensions on the eBay-branded box did not match USPS's requirements, leading to unexpected charges for dimensional weight. Several participants explained that USPS's pricing changes, not eBay's practices, were responsible, emphasizing the importance for sellers to measure boxes personally and round up dimensions to avoid such issues in the future. Some suggested that the misunderstanding arises from industry standards regarding box dimensions. The discussion highlighted a broader need for sellers to stay informed about shipping protocols to prevent additional fees.
EDITED TO THANK ALL THE SMARTY PANTS FOR THEIR SNARKY LITTLE COMMENTS VERY HELPFUL !!!! MAYBE Y'ALL SHOULD CHECK OUT THE WORD"COMMUNITY " SMH
I shipped an order in an eBay 16" x 12" x 8" box. eBay provided the discounted label. Item inside weighed under 5lbs (fur bootees) A few weeks later eBay hit me with an additional $20 in shipping fees claiming USPS showed an item weight of 14lbs. I appealed to USPS who denied - and here is why:
A USPS counter agent I spoke with confirmed that sellers should not rely on the dimensions of the boxes PROVIDED by ebay. The printed dimensions of the official eBay box are 16x8x12, INNER dimensions. The automated USPS hub laser scanners round the external dimensions and overlapping flaps up to 17x9x13. This minor cardboard thickness difference automatically triggered the 14 lb dimensional weight calculation.
Because this was an official, standard eBay-branded box and the item inside physically weighed under 5 lbs, this overcharge is an unavoidable technical billing trap for us sellers using official EBAY supplies.
What a joke. eBay just gets greedier and greedier. I am currently looking into whether this is even legal - or a deceptive business practice. I'm in CA who are incredibly tight on these kind of dishonest tricks
ruby_c_took
I'm going to throw this out there: yes, some comments could have been kinder, including mine, and I knew when I was typing it that I should tone it down but your exclamation marks were wearing on my brain; I could blame it on my cold but it's more likely it's just me needing more patience. That said, if your post had omitted the last two paragraphs, I suspect the response you would have gotten would have been very different. Especially where you used the word unavoidable--many responses were telling you that it wasn't unavoidable.
I personally think that the change in rounding up starting at a 1/4 inch over is counter-intuitive and unfair, but sadly that doesn't change the fact that's what all three carriers do now (I believe the USPS was the last to not do that), and that's not on eBay. The adoption of dimensional pricing is fairly new, not this year but in the last two (I think), and really does change how you want to pack large lightweight items to ship.
I think there are still some places on eBay where you can leave comments, and you could leave a comment saying that you think it would be helpful since the charges can be so high to not just have the reminder about your dimensions and weight being correct, but having a mention that you need to physically measure your box and not rely on printed measurements. I doubt they'll change anything, but that's something you could do. You could also suggest that when you order eBay boxes that they include a message about measuring the box after it's packed, or specify that it's the interior dimensions if that's not specified anywhere.
I personally didn't know that the measurement printed on most boxes was the inner measurement, I always assumed it was the outer measurement. I measure all my boxes once packed, though, as I mentioned, because I reuse boxes and they tend to expand.
kensgiftshop
The charge wasn't unavoidable, measure your boxes.
adamcartwright
All boxes I've purchased state the inside measurements.
You have to measure your boxes yourself.
chapeau-noir
eBay does not 'provide' the labels - they provide the portal so that the USPS, UPS, etc., can issue a label. It's a convenience only.
I got caught with an undercharge due to measurements for UPS, NOT using eBay labels with a box NOT issued for eBay and which was printed 20 x 20 x 8". The recent changes got me BECAUSE I WAS NOT THINKING. Had I been, I would have double checked by measuring the box, knowing that this had been tightened up.
OK, so you want somebody to be at fault here, but it was a simple mistake. I don't think a class action law suit will get you anywhere on this.
duffy4444
It was years ago that UPS and FedEx began calculating box dimensions up to the next outside measurement inch, even if the actual dimension was only 1/10th of an inch over the dimensions printed on the box. Within the last year or so, the USPS began doing the same thing, where before their delineation was either under or over the next 1/2 inch .
So the printed box dimensions don't mean a thing anymore and haven't for at least a year, because they mostly correspond only to the inside dimensions, no matter who makes the box. Shippers upgrading the dimensions of the box often bump the shipment into a higher dimensional weight situation. All of this has been common knowledge for quite a while to those sellers who are on top of their business practices. The last couple years I've been automatically calculating to the next inch and haven't had one extra shipping charge after the fact. For instance, I calculate my 7x4x4 boxes as 8x5x5 when I make the listing, just to be on the safe side... never had a problem with any shipper.
This has been common knowledge for those sellers who are awake and current on shipping news, and has NOTHING to do with eBay. There is no "scamming", "greed", "deception", or "dishonest tricks" on the part of eBay. It is the seller's responsibility to be aware and up to date.
Cheers, Duffy
caldreamer
Seller is responsible for providing correct weights & measurements.
As far as additional charges from USPS, that has nothing to do with EBAY.
dbmm-media
not ebays fault if there is someone you want to blame, blame yourself. its seller error
skitchtorch
To prevent this from happening to you in the future, I suggest you personally measure the size of each & every box you use to ship an item. You'll want to do this when you write the listing.
Pictured is the handy tool I use.
inhawaii
Definitely a eBay scam.
eBay is counting on sellers not to measure boxes properly, that way the USPS will charge the sellers for the underpayment . Quite a scam.
thriftyfiftyfifty
Why any Seller on the edge of Dimensional Costs would rely on either OD or ID Printed on the box is baffling to me after packing. Just measure (or read better) and save yourself some heartache instead of labeling it (no pun intended) a "scam".
christworks
Laziness.
Assuming.
Thinking that reselling is "easy" money and there is no work involved.
thriftyfiftyfifty
...and then claiming "scam"...typical.
christworks
@studiopointmonarch You indicate that eBay "provided" you with the dimensions. In what world does eBay provide you with the dimensions? How do they know what size box you will use?
The box size printed on boxes is almost always the inner dimensions. If you aren't sure, take a few seconds and measure. You always around up to the nearest whole inch when buying the label. A 12.1 x 5.9 x 9.4 inches box would be entered as 13 x 6 x 10 inches. Round up weights as well. 4.3 pounds would be entered as 5 pounds. 9.8 pounds would be entered as 10 pounds.
Nothing illegal has happened here and there has been no deception. You didn't understand what you needed to do, and that's not eBay's fault.
studiopointmonarch
OPso when eBay sent a message claiming the 4lbs package was actually 14lbs that's not deception???? You clearly don't understand but that's ok maybe you are just bored on a sunday
dhbookds
That's how ebay/USPS/Fedex, etc figures rates.........when the dimensions kick the price up, it's expressed as more ##s.
thriftyfiftyfifty
You clearly don’t understand “Billable” Weight based on Dimensional Shipping…
ruby_c_took
I'm confused as to why you are confused. You went to the post office and you were told it was 14 lbs dimensional weight. There is no deception in eBay telling you the weight was wrong when it clearly was. If they didn't mention that the correct weight was dimensional, then perhaps they could improve their automated e-mails, but I would also point out that you were able to figure out the reason for the higher charge.
So here we have a situation where: you may have been unaware of the very existence of dimensional weight rules; whether you were or not you were unaware they applied in your situation because . . . you didn't measure your box. All I can see here is that you would really be doing yourself a favor to read up on some of the more strict rules the USPS has enacted in the last year or so and avoid a future extra charge.
chapeau-noir
That has nothing to do with eBay - it has everything to do with the USPS (and UPS) changing their pricing scheme so that even 1/4" increments over the stated box size have to be increased to the next inch. It's catching a lot of people.
The most eBay can do is start emphasizing (which is what the USPS does) outside dimensions as well as inside dimensions.
I got caught on this for $8.50 so I understand how startling it is. But it's not eBay.
ETA: I don't even use eBay labels.
studiopointmonarch
OPI disagree that it has nothing to do with ebay. Where does Ebay explain that the box measurements are for the inside only? An important piece of information is deliberately missing - that's is not accidental. eBay provided the labels The onus is on THEM to fully explain.
christworks
@studiopointmonarch eBay directs sellers to measure all sides of the box. You didn't do that. The reason eBay does not tell sellers that the printed size on boxes is for the inside dimensions is for two reasons:
1) Not all boxes have measurements printed on them, and;
2) Not all box brands that print measurements on boxes print the inside measurements. Some brands do print the outside measurements.
eBay has no way to know what box you are using to send your items, which is why they tell you in multiple places to measure each side. You failed to do that and it bit you. Not eBay's fault, it is your fault for not following what eBay says to do.
ryry-jj
Industry standard on a n RSC, regular slotted container, what we all think of as an official shipping "box", will always be the ID. A custom box designed for a specific product, we sometimes may print the OD, but it will also come with much more printing, sometimes even the pallet layout grid or internal pack. But if a standard RSC it will always be ID that is printed
inhawaii
studiopointmonarch
OPSize is printed on the box in fairly large number - at least 2-3 inches - and I used ebay's "Chosen" carrier. I entered under 5lbs and they claimed it was 14lbs. i.e. The weight was 9lbs over the actual weight
ruby_c_took
The size printed on the box is irrelevant.
I reuse a lot of boxes. After they've been used at least once, even the ones that print the outside dimensions are no longer the same as the printed dimensions when empty. Then you put something in them and tape them and it changes even more. Why are you so determined that you shouldn't have to measure the box you're using?
If you had actually measured it yourself but fallen afoul of the new rules on rounding up, I'd be a lot more sympathetic.
ryry-jj
Ebay doesn't mention it, but it is industry standard unless a bulk container or cargo freight, then it will say O.D. next to the size.
One of the reason shipping is so by the book on eBay, is because we all suppose to know this as we are "professional sellers". I still believe if you hand write a label and take it to the USPS, many of these charges would not apply as we are then thought of as novice shippers sending a package to family or friends.
Your box was 14# dimensional weight based on the OD
studiopointmonarch
OPFinally - a sane comment
By saying: "The math is technically correct based on the outer edges of the box, and eBay expects online sellers to know this rule." implies that the automated 14-lb up charge triggered purely by the cardboard thickness and flap-rounding of their own product is acceptable. Its not. Maybe time for a class action.
dbmm-media
Maybe time for a class action.
let us know how that works out for you
kensgiftshop
We hear that a lot, but they never come back to let us know how it went.
ruby_c_took
You know, this thread and your comment made me realize that I have a few older listings that I had better double check the rounding on!