Scammed and eBay won't help!!!!
Hello everybody.
I decided to post on here since eBay will not make it right. I sold a laptop on eBay to a new buyer. When they received the item they created a return even though the laptop was working correctly. The laptop was marked delivered to me but never was delivered. I received documents from USPS that they are still in possession of the item. I created a case with eBay and submitted the documents. No answer... I then called again and spoke with an agent that told me the return should have never happened due to the buyer address being a mail forwarding location and not eligible for buyer protection. When I googled the address it pulls up another eBay forum post from the next door address with the same scam. He was returned a box of rocks. here is the link https://community.ebay.com/t5/Selling/Please-Be-Careful-Fraud-Buyers/td-p/32684275/page/2
I called eBay today to see what the status of the 2nd escalated case was and she said both of the escalated cases were denied. At this point it is clear eBay is more concerned with helping scammers than customers that have bought and sold on eBay for more the 20 years. USPS is no help either as it looks like the package was stolen and re-sent into the USPS systems as a smaller item than when it was shipped. It was shipped in the branded computer box so they probably stole it but ended up with rocks...
I posted the USPS document showing they still have it, and the email I got after creating the second escalated case where eBay says it show have never been returned. eBay never followed up after the escalated cases they just deny them and move on with out any documentation.
dbfolks166mt
You never mentioned but did eBay refund the buyer and take the funds from your bank or charge it to your CC? If so and you have documentation from the USPS showing the item was never delivered you might try opening a chargeback with your bank or CC company noting that you have never received the item.
Also use this for a lesson learned experience. Cell phones, computers and other electronics are one of the favorite targets for the scammers. I would never sell high dollar electronic items on eBay there are FAR too many other less risky ways to sell these type of items.
robbie31415
No address voids the eBay MBG.
What that employee said was incorrect, which is why it was covered by eBay's MBG.
The policy refers to services such as freight forwarding and mail redirection, not the address itself. Without evidence that the package was forwarded/redirected, which would pretty much be omission from the buyer via messages, then eBay will still allow the buyer the eBay MBG. However, if you contact them enough you might get a rep that closes the case in your favor, regardless of the actual policy.
eBay Money Back Guarantee policy
Not covered:
penquinista
Hello, this happened to me. My buyer said they returned the defective phone to me when they never received the item. The USPS label they used showed delivered to a PO Box in my home town but not to my address. I had to go to the Post Office with my id and had them write a letter to prove my residency (my address). I had to submit to ebay. Let me know if this works.
ckimodog
@since2006atl
Sorry for your situation. Never sell anything on any internet venue that cannot afford to lose. It's a different world...sadly. Hang in there. Again, very sorry.
mam98031
I would suggest going to www.usps.com , their main website and file a complaint. Why is USPS hanging onto your item and refuse to deliver it. You may be surprised as to how helpful they are on this site. I've had great success over the years resolving important issues by filing a complaint.
since2006atl
OPI’ve made multiple cases with USPS. They are automatically closed after 4 days. I have also done “find my mail†and no luck. The package is only 0.16oz now so getting it back won’t help. I believe the local mail carrier stole it.
a_c_green
The local mail carrier couldn't care less about that package or what's in it; he's not going to go stealing it. It's also got a tracking number, so he must account for what he did with it once tracking showed that it was out for delivery, and if or when it was scanned as delivered (back to you, even though we know that it wasn't), there will be a GPS location within the tracking log indicating exactly where the carrier was when it was delivered.
What you need is a statement from USPS to say that the address on that label was not yours. It appears that your scam buyer simply returned a trinket to some other address within your City and ZIP code, as it is not difficult to modify the return address label to go somewhere else instead. Once that is shown as Delivered (or at least Delivery Attempted) within your City and ZIP code (the street address doesn't matter), then eBay will enforce a refund to the buyer. You can appeal that ruling, but you will need the written USPS statement as evidence that you did not really receive the item in return.
mam98031
I don't know what the "find my mail" function is for USPS, I've never used it. And I've never had a case automatically close after 4 days unless it was resolved.
The most common thing for me to file is a Trace on a package. That one usually gets things moving and/or locates the package and get is moving. Then if the problem seems more serious I will file a Missing Mail report. But filing a Trace usually gets me the results I desire.
since2006atl
OPeBay came and deleted the attachments showing proof of the scam. They also deleted the address off my post and the linked post. This is the most they have done this entire time and it was only to cover up the scam and deny wrong doing on their part.
mam98031
Ebay did NOT do that. The Moderators of this forum did. They are not Ebay employees.
When the moderators remove stuff you post, it is because it breaks one of the rules of the Community. Like most everything in life there are rules. I did not see what you posted, but if it had addresses, names or Ebay IDs, that is not allowed.
https://community.ebay.com/t5/About-the-Community/Community-Guidelines/td-p/26164369
duffy4444
@since2006atl:
This was your first and ultimately fatal mistake that guaranteed a high risk of loss. Coupled with shipping a laptop to a foreign purchaser via a freight forwarder as well. The risks were way up there.
NEVER, EVER sell, and especially ship, any high-value item anywhere online, particularly electronics, that you and your business model are not prepared to lose, in addition to the final insult of losing your payment for it on a forced eBay refund over which you will almost automatically lose regardless o the circumstances. It should be sold locally, in person, for cash only.
Cheers,
Duffy
dryfly5300
Bingo, my thoughts exactly, add to that selling used electronics, at that point you are doomed to many sales that are guaranteed to end in misery. Not worth it regardless of returns (double entendre intended).
12345jamesstamps
It was a 'freight forward' to Delaware...and then to another country.
And not returned to your address.
Isn't something that expensive have to be signed to accept it and also returning doesn't a return supposed to be signed to accept it?...Just thoughts here throwing out.
I would think eBay should be able to see the address of where it went....with tracking.
eBay knowing it didn't go to your address I would think eBay should not refund the buyer.
This makes no sense.
devon@eBay, kyle@eBay, elizabeth@eBay maybe they can help.
devon@ebay
Hey @12345jamesstamps! Based off all of the information provided by OP, we would recommend that they continue to work with USPS.
since2006atl
OPThe return should have never happened, that is ebays fault and you should make it right. Also why can USPS help they clearly do not have the laptop as the package that was never delivered is now only 0.16oz. I should have never had my funds removed as the package was never delivered to me as shown in the tracking info.
chevymontecarlo88
First of all, sorry that this has happened to you. No one deserves this.
How were you able to determine this was a new buyer ( i think you meant buyer not seller)?
chevymontecarlo88
Well that would mean you are correct. Sorry to hear this happened and hope you can resolve this quickly.
I guess you can call this data @brightlightbookseller on some new sellers being problematic. YMMV
Not all but clearly is an issue for some.
brightlightbookseller
Hardly. One data point does not a statistic make, nor is the data in favor of new sellers being more problematic. Please don't tag me about this in unrelated threads either, that's just being unnecessarily antagonistic.
chevymontecarlo88
It's ok. Just wanted to point this out since you were saying there is no data and that was about 15 minutes ago.
It is good for the community to understand what others actually do go through. I get your point of tagging you and was not trying to be antagonistic. I really do hope the OP does not get burned. Happens too often and really frustrating for any user trying to sell anything of value.
pjcdn2005
I don't understand how it can show as delivered and yet USPS says they are in possession of it?
Assuming that it was delivered, I suspect that it was delivered to a different address in your zip code area and was probably just an envelope, not a package. USPS will be able to tell where the package was addressed to and although they won't give you that information they should be willing to write a letter showing that the package with that tracking number was addressed to a different address, not yours. Based on what I've read here, if you can get a letter showing that, eBay may refund you from their own pocket.
since2006atl
OPMy guess is the mail carrier cut the label off the package and sent it back out while keeping the box. The label was scanned in TX later that night way smaller than when sent. The package was scanned delivered at the dollar store down the street from the GPS data. It's possible if it was delivered to the dollar that they sent the label back out but I don't see a dollar store employee that smart. Also it was probably just rocks as said in the link and they would have opened it first. The only thing I know for sure is USPS still has the label and I never got the package. eBay has all the info they need to know I never got it but they would rather not help.
since2006atl
OPIt had the correct address on it. USPS customer service said she could see the label from a scan of it and it was correct. My mail carrier also marks stuff delivered on some days when she is lazy and drops it off the next day but that was not the case this time. She also told me eBay can see the detailed tracking and knew it was not really delivered. But if you check tracking on the consumer side it doesn't update after it was marked delivered. The only way to get the tracking info I posted above is from a USPS manager and they are not supposed to give it out.
yuncreations
why don't you go to the post office to pick it up? if usps has it... sorry if i missed this...
stainlessenginecovers
If USPS has the item, why can't you pick it up?
Why does USPS have the item and are not delivering it?
Being a 'mail forwarder' does NOT dismiss a seller from a return. It just means the buyer needs to 'return' the item, which- per tracking- they have?
since2006atl
OPIf USPS has the item, why can't you pick it up?
The item is in a bin at the main Atlanta sorting facility. Currently I am in the process of USPS "find my missing mail" but I doubt that will ever happen. The package is also only 0.16oz now so getting it at this point won't get me back the computer that probably wasn't shipped back in the first place. The posted document shows they still have it and eBay still won't do anything.
Why does USPS have the item and are not delivering it?
idk
Being a 'mail forwarder' does NOT dismiss a seller from a return
eBay support told me that the address was not eligible for returns as shown the in the posted screenshot. Maybe it is a flagged address idk.
It just means the buyer needs to 'return' the item, which- per tracking- they have?
Per tracking it shows in a bin at USPS so that is not correct. The raw data tracking sheet is posted above.
since2006atl
OPNot true.
 
mam98031
Yes it is. What is it that you believe is not true?
since2006atl
OPThe attachment shows that if they used a mail forwarder that it is not covered.
stainlessenginecovers
Yes, and that has been overruled and changed, stated by an ebay employee 3+ years ago- simply stops a US Seller from sending a box of rocks and the buyer being out...BUT:
In an FF situation- It is the responsibility of the buyer to ship it BACK to the address that YOU shipped it to (the Freight Forwarder) and then talk the FF to ship it back to you.
since2006atl
OPtheir employees and their website says different.
mam98031
What has been "overruled and changed"? The written policy hasn't changed, so what is it exactly that you are saying changed?
That is the only way a buyer can get a return shipping label since the seller is only responsible to the address they shipped to. However once it gets shipped to another address, the seller no longer has any control on how it was packaged or handled, which is why it voids the MBG for the buyer.
a_c_green
That's a reference to a claim that eBay representative Trinton made some years ago. He said that it was not sufficient to simply show that the item was sent to a reshipper address; you had to actually prove (somehow) that it really was forwarded to the buyer elsewhere in order for their MBG claim to be disallowed. His argument was that the item might just have been purchased by someone who worked at the reshipper, in which case that would have been the final address with no forwarding occurring beyond that point.
He stuck to that argument despite it being ridiculous on its face, and was vague about how the seller was supposed to prove the forwarding, even when the buyer himself was obviously registered in another country. (I believe Trinton is still working somewhere else within eBay, but has no further contact with users.)
I don't think that he really had any power to change the rule itself, which remains clear in print, so I would just be sure that if push comes to shove, you have a stored link to that particular exclusion so that whoever you're in contact with can read it for themselves.
mam98031
I understand. If the item is actually shipped from the Freight Forwarder to any other address at all, the MBG coverage is suppose to be voided. That is my understanding of this part of the policy.
brightlightbookseller
Yes, that's a known scam. It can be hard to get eBay to do anything about it. @devon@ebay @kyle@ebay @elizabeth@ebay Do you think any of you could help this seller out? They seem to have the evidence that would usually be needed but aren't making headway.
@since2006atl, your other recourse would usually be small claims court, but since the buyer is probably out of the country, that's not really going to work out.