QUESTIONING THE RECENT DENIAL OF MY EBAY LISTING
Summary: cat2face shared a frustration about having an eBay listing for antique shotgun shell hulls removed for policy violations, despite similar listings remaining active. They argued that their items were non-usable collectibles, unlike others that were actual ammunition. luckythewinner inquired about how the listing removal affected cat2face's seller rating, which dropped from "TOP RATED" to "ABOVE STANDARD." simba6 and kensgiftshop suggested that keyword detection and eBay's policies contributed to the listing's removal, regardless of the item's age or historical interest. tobaccocardyahoo noted that eBay rarely deviates from its policies, while zzzz-0-zzzz attributed inconsistencies in enforcement to eBay's AI-related operations.
I RECENTLY HAD AN ARTICLE FOR SALE ON EBAY THAT WAS DESCRIBED AS UNUSABLE FOR COLLECTORS ONLY FROM THE 1800'S AND EBAY REMOVED IT FOR VIOLATING THEIR LISTING POLICIES. ANY KNOWLEDGEABLE PERSON OF HUNTING AMMUNITION ARTIFACTS KNOWS THAT THE EMPTY BRASS SHOTGUN SHELL HULLS OF THE LATE 1800'S ARE UNUSABLE BUT GREAT COLLECTOR PIECES FOR THOSE INTERESTED IN SAME. I HAD TWO IMMEDIATE BIDS ON THESE AND THEN EBAY CANCELED MY LISTING.
I DID A FEW MINUTES OF RESEARCH AND FOUND ITEMS NO.: 267623793217, 327143626663 ANS 318431924316 THAT ALREADY SOLD AND WERE MODERN SHOTGUN SHELL HULLS. THERE IS ALSO A CURRENT LISTING NO. 168319190267 THAT ARE ALL USABLE SHOT SHELL HULLS AND STILL RUNNING.
I MESSAGED EBAY'S LIVE CHAT "EXPERT" AND WE BANTERED BACK AND FORTH FOR SEVERAL MINUTES ON WHY MY TOTALLY SAFE HULLS WERE REMOVED AND ALL I GOT AS AN ANSWER WAS MY LISTING VIOLATED EBAY POLICIES. MY LISTING DID NOT VIOLATE ANY SINGLE ONE OF THEIR AMMO POLICIES YET ALL FOUR OF THOSE LISTED DID AND BLATANTLY.
ARE ALL OF EBAY'S "SPECIALISTS" WORKING ON TRUMPS STAFF?? SURE SEEMS LIKE IT. NOT ONE ANSWER TO ANY SIMPLE QUESTION THAT I HAD OR ANY EXPLANATION AS TO WHY MY LISTING WAS REMOVED AND THE OTHERS LISTED WERE NOT AND ALL FOUR ARE OBVIOUSLY IN VIOLATION OF THEIR POLICIES.
THEIR, EBAYS, DECISION AFFECTED MY SELLER RATING AND IT WAS ALL EBAY'S FAULT AND NOT MINE. I HAVE BEEN SELLING VINTAGE ITEMS ON EBAY APPROACHING 25 YEARS WITH NO REAL CONCERNS EXCEPT FOR THEIR FEES FOR DOING NOTHING WRONG WHILE THOSE OF US WHO SPEND THOUSANDS OF HOURS AND MILES SEARCHING FOR AND FINDING COLLECTIBLES FOR THOSE WHO CANNOT ACTUALLY GET THE CHANCE TO DO SO. AN 82 YEAR OLD VETERAN OF PICKING AND SELLING FOR 70+ YEARS(long before the fake TV pickers were born)!!
zzzz-0-zzzz
AFAIK ebay's "cops" (& judge & jury) is the AI which is "Kafkaesque". It seems to almost be ""random". The humans "just cope".
tobaccocardyahoo
Ebay does not often make exceptions from its published policies. No matter what ANY KNOWLEDGEABLE PERSON OF HUNTING AMMUNITION ARTIFACTS knows. They do not know and do not care.
kensgiftshop
From the Not Allowed policy: "Ammunition for firearms, including bullets, cartridges, casings, shells, and hulls "
Doesn't matter how old it is.
simba6
It's done by key words they detect. Your wording just got caught and others did not. eBay is very touchy about anything to do with pew pews.
luckythewinner
How did this listing removal affect your seller rating?
cat2face
OPMine went down from TOP RATED to ABOVE STANDARD.
Unavailable member
not because of the removal, there's some other reason for it, you should be able to look at your seller rating and it should tell you which metric is causing the above standard vs top rated.
ryry-jj
That doesn't effect your seller rating...something else has happened