Not Another Neutral Feedback!
I emailed the buyer of a purchase as to why a nice feedback but 'neutral'.
I do not give feedback first because it is an expensive purchase.
So the buyer does a neutral and supposedly when I give feedback they will change it to positive?
eBay does not revise neutrals...only negatives as I learned from last week with my feedback in Polish.
Should I just move on and block the buyer?
12345jamesstamps
33 comments
nyr134
Looking through the amounts you have received for the vast majority of your recent sales, I don’t see why you would block someone that just sent $21.00 your way.
Every business has confused or quirky customers whose money is good. They shouldn’t be turned away.
gurlcat
Or ship such orders without tracking. Only 16% of the listings are over $10, but go as high as $350. And I would imagine lots of the buyers get a bundle of multiple listings that could total up to an amount that I sure wouldn't risk leaving up to the buyer's honesty, and also not have any insurance on, if the envelope really does get lost in transit.
Years ago I actually did postage shipping with a few lower-value coins, like maybe 20 at the most. But sure enough, even with only that many buyers, I had one claim his coin never arrived, and another who received the envelope but claimed the coin was missing and showed a little slit in the edge of the envelope where it allegedly fell out. But it was in a cardboard window flip which was also taped inside a greeting card, so I was 99% sure he was lying.
Of course in both cases I had no choice but to refund, but that was actually the lesser of my reasons why I quit doing it. The greater one was the emotional toll. I haaaate scammers. I mean if they scam Walmart or Amazon it's one thing, but to scam regular people, FELLOW HOBBYISTS mind you, it just sours my mood for the whole day. But it's even worse with the postage stamp thing, because of the chance they're NOT lying! With no tracking and putting trust in a fragile paper envelope, there's no way to know whether you should regard the buyer as a lying scuzzball ..... or feel bad for them because they really didn't get the collectible they wanted! I just don't need that kind of conundrum in my life, LOL.
@12345jamesstamps do you NEVER get a proper label with tracking for any sales, even at the post office if you don't have a printer?
iamalwaysright
I read the feedback you’re talking about and honestly I wouldn’t even want it changed to a positive. It basically has a glowing totally positive comment and would help me push down all of my other neutrals (that don’t have comments as praising) when a buyer filters to only see neutrals. I wouldn’t even block the buyer, bring on all the glowing comment neutrals he wants to give.
This would be a different story if they were negative feedbacks or if its on a small account I have that actually needs positives to raise the feedback score.
babyers88
Having sold for a very long time I find the best approach is to leave automatic positive feedback, no matter what it is or how much it cost or anything. Grateful for the sale and some money in my pocket.
They could have just as easily, bought someone else's......
if i get a Negative or Neutral in return, then I guess I should have DONE BETTER.
dhbookds
One reason I leave feedback first....... have see buyers leave negs for no feedback from seller.
You can always respond to buyer feedback, so I don't see any reason not to leave it first......
12345jamesstamps
OPI have responded to the last 3 neutral feedbacks...one made it worse with a revision from the buyer and I might end up with another one where the revision went to the buyer and not eBay(Polish feedback)like it was suppose to.
So revisions don't work for neutrals since it can make it worse.
I don't respond to negative or neutral feedbacks anymore. Just me I guess.
gurlcat
This buyer sounds like a child, but you kinda do too: "I do not give feedback first because it is an expensive purchase."
What does the item's price have to do with when you give the buyer feedback? If anything giving a high-roller a nice positive as soon as you see the Delivered scan is your best bet for them remembering to do the same. And it's especially good to get a positive from a high-roller because the price of the item is visible to all, so in the future buyers considering spending lots of money on your items can see that you are trustworthy and deliver good quality for big investments.
Even if someone outright scams you after you left them good feedback, so what? Would your having not given the feedback stopped them from scamming you?
12345jamesstamps
OPWe kinda are different on how we ship out items.
This item has no tracking and was more expensive than most items which is why I don't leave feedback first.
If I had tracking like you always do(guessing here) it would be a different story.
Some 'stamp sellers' are a little different than other sellers.
'as soon as you see the Delivered scan'...no tracking on this lot.
We don't have tracking on everything and prefer feedback first before giving it out.
I always leave feedback first for inexpensive items.
Some buyers with little feedback, or crappy feedback or it's a weird address I usually like to get the feedback first to know everything is OK.
And I do have those 'repeat buyers' who do buy expensive items where I do leave feedback first.
I would bet my blocked buyer list is bigger than yours(just guessing).
I get some real 'drama buyers' with questions before a purchase where I know there's going to be a problem so I prefer not to leave the feedback first.
All 4 of my neutral feedbacks are from International buyers by the way.
Tracking for a registered standard envelope is like $25.00+ to another country...and it can take a long time for the buyer to receive it...weeks vs. a week and a half without tracking.
gurlcat
I don't understand. Are you ineligible for EIS for some reason? You live in San Francisco if I recall right.
12345jamesstamps
OPI have never printed an eBay shipping label and I use my own postage stamps for postage.
gurlcat
@12345jamesstamps Okay, then never mind about seeing a Delivered scan. Why not just give buyers positive feedback as soon as you ship, or after a few days to get it closer to possible Delivered date or whatever? My main question was about what difference it makes whether the buyer "did it first"? -That's the bit that sounds childish.
12345jamesstamps
OPAn example...I gave a positive feedback to a buyer lately...it was for a $2.00 item
He decided it didn't look like the item in the photo.
He decided to return it...I give free shipping..so I use a $1.70 for postage.
Canadian buyer by the way, he figured in the cost of shipping it back, tax, and item cost and what he wanted for the return of it...it was only 2 dollars...I said keep it and moved on!
I had another buyer who couldn't see 2 stamps of a set their watermarks so he said I should give him a partial refund. Didn't do anything until he comes back he bought the 2 stamps from another seller and stated what I should give him without the 2 stamps returned from a set. Waiting on a feedback from him...probably on the last of the 60 days.
I had a buyer showing photos of stamps saying my stamps were damaged that I sent.
I sent the photos in the listing and told her the 'perforations' of the stamps in her photo do not match the photos in my stamps of the listings. This buyer ended up 'ghosting me' because I caught her lying.
I could go on and on...so these buyers deserve positive feedback...
I sell a lot...I can afford to eat the profit of a stamp(s)...I have a lot.
It's the fact some buyers nit-pick about something and send that dreadful email in the morning of my wake-up with coffee and I have to respond.
I am currently holding my breath on a stamp I sold for $100.00 which was stated damaged before the purchase and hoping the buyer read everything about it...it's only one stamp repaired...no return or feedback yet on that.
That was sent without tracking to a Canadian buyer...isn't that scary?
gurlcat
@12345jamesstamps So my guess was correct, that you don't want to give buyers positive feedback until you know whether they "deserve" it.
That would make logical sense if positive feedback was some tangible good that you have limited stock of, so each time you "give" it, you have less remaining in your stockpile, therefore you wouldn't want to "waste" any on buyers who don't deserve it, when other buyers will deserve it. But that's not what it is! It costs you nothing except a few seconds of your time, and it's not like some great prize that the buyer can do anything with, either.
On the other hand, a really good buyer might have a strange interest in receiving positive feedback, and your withholding it can only cause them to decide not to buy from you again.
Or in a case like your Mike P. buyer, withholding it got you a neutral from him!
Does it make sense? No. Is it weird and manipulative? Yeah. But the simple fact is, only buyers can give neutrals and negatives, so why no do everything you can to avoid getting those, including giving positive feedback to buyers (ALL buyers) quickly, even though you don't know if they're going to complain about the item or whatever?
chapeau-noir
He sells smalls, and postage with tracking for that kind of thing can cost more than the item. When I ship something like a little mouse receiver or a bit of hat netting I also don't use tracking, just either first class or first class large envelope.
gurlcat
@chapeau-noir Just because something is small means it doesn't have to go through a country's customs? Sorry I've never shipped anything internationally without EIS so I'm definitely in the dark about that. But regardless of whether it's domestic or international, doesn't shipping without tracking set you up for INR's (real and scam) with no recourse???
chapeau-noir
It depends on the 'small' - for something like stamps, or cards (I used to sell old cigarette cards sometimes), for flat things like the hat netting I sold a bit ago, just regular first class mail will do - it can go as a flat, either plain envelope or first class large envelope. You take your chance doing it because there's no tracking, but customers appreciate the very reasonable rate for something so small, and are generally great about it. This goes for international as well as domestic.
inhawaii
Bummer James.
I know people will say not to respond to it, it's only a neutral, you don't want to draw attention to it.
But honestly, if it were me, I couldn't resist but respond with something witty. 😉
meme6253
I would just move on & forget about it, But it was a little on the blackmail side the way this customer chose to leave feedback!
1786davycrockett
Possible feedback extortion?
The buyer will change the neutral feedback to a positive, as long as the OP provides positive feedback to the buyer.
And, of course, sellers can only provide positive feedback to buyers -- no matter how slimy the buyer may be.
fern*wood
Sounds like both parties are playing games over feedback. What a waste of time.
12345jamesstamps
OPI did not leave feedback.
pickapaper
@12345jamesstamps
So the guy left you a neutral because you didn't leave him feedback first? But now that you have left him feedback, he is willing to change it to a positive? What a dum-dum.
12345jamesstamps
OPI left no feedback.
pickapaper
Sorry, I assumed you did because of the screen shot you posted in which he indicated "now that I have feedback from you, I can upgrade my feedback to a positive".
chapeau-noir
The buyer won't leave green FB unless they get their green donut? I wouldn't even bother wasting a revision and I definitely would not mention mistaken feedback in any response if I left one at all (you could say 'thank you for your purchase' or something). This just shows what a game feedback is.
kibble-net
If the buyer is willing to change it to a positive, request a feedback revision and let them.
Easy. Peasy.
bonanza125
I would move on from it. Just reply to the feedback that the buyer agreed it was a mistake. I wouldn't block them however that's your choice.
speedystarnotes
honestly see about getting it changed. I got a neutral feedback from an incompetent buyer (who didn't understand the description) and I swear it seems the eBay algorithm doesn't like that because my sales totally stopped for that listing. Hope that won't be your case, but better safe than sorry.
18704d
I didn't think a buyer can change their neutral to a positive without going through a formal feedback revision request?
Either way, it sounds like the type of buyer I'd add to my blocked list.
tarotfindsandmore
The feedback itself is perfectly nice, I wouldn't bother doing anything with this one. It just looks like an incompetent new user didn't realize that a neutral wasn't the correct button. It reminds me of when someone accidentally leaves a single star review for an item on a retail site but a rave review accompanies it.
No one looking at that feedback is going to think it was anything other than a positive.
caldreamer
James, you are a perfectionist. Customers do not bother to read neutral feedback, so you don't have to worry. I just viewed your items, and EBAY only shows "positive feedback". Unless, you specifying click on show "neutral feedback" it appears to be hidden.