New GPSR rules for Europe in the Summer Update - Goodbye EU Sales?
Reading through the Summer Update, and the General Product Safety Regulation (GPSR) rules that the EU and Northern Ireland are requiring ...
- "Time consuming" doesn't begin to describe how burdensome this is to eBay sellers. At best, it would take 60 minutes to gather all that information for each product listing.
- It would be impossible for small sellers to identity an EU or NI point of contact if the manufacturer is not based in the EU or NI.
- Providing product safety language with the listing in each EU country's native language? That is 24 languages ... most product literature doesn't come close to that.
- It isn't practical for selling anything other than multiple quantities.
Unless EIS gets some sort of waiver for eBay sellers (or there aren't any real consequences to avoiding the regulation), I don't see any other option than to block sales to the EU and NI.
Thoughts?
orangehound
29 comments
fbusoni
There is another pie-in-the-sky EU law set to come into effect at the end of the year -- the Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation (ESPR). You can read the text here.
My understanding is that if you ship an item in a cardboard box to the EU, you have to be able to testify that the cardboard came from a forest where sustainable environmental practices are enforced.
If you sell toothpicks on eBay, you might as well forget about shipping to the EU. 😅
From the relevant EU website: "Products and the way we use them can have a significant impact on the environment. Consumption in the EU can therefore be a major cause of climate change and pollution."
1786davycrockett
@fbusoni
So not only do we have to provide an Ancestry.com breakdown for every item that might be shown to a prospective buyer in the European Union & Northern Ireland, but we also need to supply the equivalent of a birth certificate for any cardboard boxes in which the items may be sent.
Right.
Guess I'll be waving goodbye to the EU and NI in December.
fbusoni
@1786davycrockett
I have read through the legislation in question... if I recall correctly, enforcement is left up to individual EU member states. Which is another way of saying that the EU as an entity has no power and each member state can decide what is in its best interests.
And if you know the history of and contemporary political alignments in Europe, you will know that those interests diverge significantly -- often 180 degrees apart.
Like all such legislation (thinking here of the rubbish that is promulgated by the "United Nations"), I suspect that its is aimed at domestic EU audiences (the "green" political movements and other marginal political forces who are becoming more important in coalition politics) for political purposes and will have no great effect on individual US sellers.
Personally I am not the least bit concerned, but did want to mention this other piece of nonsensical legislation.
deltilogical
"Or at least charge an additional "international" fee?"
They already do!
dbfolks166mt
It will also be interesting to see what the impact is on the buyers that utilize US based freight forwarders which is basically what EIS is. The difference being the seller is aware of international sales when they go through EIS they may not be if they go through a freight forwarder.
wastingtime101
Hope you don't mind I'm piggybacking on your thread @orangehound. I never got an answer to this question asked on the seller update board here.
Can you find out the answer please @devon@ebay @kyle@ebay @elizabeth@ebay ?
kyle@ebay
Hey @wastingtime101 I've reached out to get some info on this, and I'll be sure to let you know any updates we receive!
kyle@ebay
Hey @wastingtime101 I have received a response on this from our shipping and legal teams:
"Sellers need to determine for themselves whether they need to add this information to their listings when shipping is offered to the EU. Unfortunately, eBay cannot provide legal advice and the answer may depend on different factors particular to the seller and the item. All Sellers can provide GPSR specifics in the item disclosures section and in their item description."
wastingtime101
Hi @kyle@ebay . I do appreciate the response, although it doesn't answer the question. My question isn't about whether sellers should provide GPSR specifics or not. My question is about how eBay's system will behave. Let's see if I can rephrase.
We already established if the buyer is shopping on their EU-specific site, they will not see listings that don't have GPSR specifics. eBay quote from above: "listings without these info won't be displayed on the EU sites for categories where we mandate them."
The question is whether those buyers will see listings that don't have GPSR specifics while shopping on the .com site. Will eBay recognize the buyer's location and hide those listings in search? Or place blocks preventing those buyers from purchasing in affected categories while shopping on .com?
- This question has nothing to do with eIS, only direct shipping.
- Seller does not apply specific exclusions to affected countries.
- Buyer is shopping on .com, not their EU-specific site.
- Will eBay surface listings without GPSR specifics on .com for buyers located in EU/NI? If yes, will a buyer in EU/NI be able to purchase those listings or will eBay block them?
If the answer is yes, those listings will surface on .com for EU/NI buyers to purchase and the system will not block them from making those purchases, then the seller needs to exclude those locations (unless they plan to fill out GPSR specifics).
If the answer is no, those listings will not surface on .com for EU/NI buyers to purchase, or they will surface but eBay will block the buyer from purchasing in affected categories, then the seller can ignore this and not worry about setting up exclusions.
Does that clarify the question?
kyle@ebay
Hey @wastingtime101 we have shared all the information that is available at this time. We will provide updates as they become available.
wastingtime101
Alright, thanks, Kyle. I guess I'll have to implement a blanket block to EU/NI unless more info is provided.
ittybitnot
All Sellers can provide GPSR specifics in the item disclosures section and in their item description."
@kyle@ebay
Thanks for trying, Kyle! But NO, all sellers cannot provide these specifics. I will not be able to sell my sterling silver bracelet made in Mexico in 1956 by a designer/silversmith who is now dead and has no contact information, and no EU responsible person whether I use EIS or ship on my own.
eBay doesn't want the risk of the product being confiscated at the boarders as it enters the EU and either do I if I ship on my own. Best thing to do: No shipping to the EU. Or am I missing something?
stainlessenginecovers
If I only use EIS and do nothing; it would be on EIS to either STOP showing in EU or it would be on them to 'do all that is required'....Correct??
robbie31415
That's my understanding.
I only do EIS so it's up to EIS in my opinion.
If they want to do all of that or deactivate those areas part of the program.
Tbh I don't care what they decide. I don't mind them turning those locations off.
prairieprimitives
Same here. I've used eIS (and GSP before that) but get very few international orders. It won't be a huge loss for me.
orangehound
OPWith respect to "not showing to EU", that would be a massive amount of software to go through listings and determine if the listing is compliant ... unless eBay requires that a half dozen structured data fields be completed in order to be shown in the EU.
I think the penalties imposed by the EU are on the marketplace, and not the sellers. But, because the regulation states that the penalties are to be "effective, proportionate, and dissuasive" with penalties greater than 4% of the sales, I assume eBay will figure out a way to pass the punishment over to sellers.
Again, this seems like an extinction level threat to eBay in the EU. Curious how eBay will adapt.
stainlessenginecovers
to me, the biggest hurdle is 'finding a rep' and the 'language'...something that EIS can do (be the rep-contact for all) and use AI for the language thing...but that's up to them.
Right now, for instance, France, Germany, UK is already 'excluded' (not by me, by EIS?) because of the 'recycle license thingy and/or? I have 16 places 'excluded' (Asian countries so they don't 'copy' my products) along with the US Protectorates (tired of 'other than English' speaking saying 'they didn't read because it's in English) but yet there are 27 excluded, so EIS excludes some on their own (Ukraine, Russia for example are added)
prairieprimitives
Wanna bet eBay will raise fees? Or at least charge an additional "international" fee?
gurlcat
I'm not going to worry about this unless anyone can point to language where it states specific consequences to the seller for shipping items that eBay showed to buyers in those countries. If eBay can't populate the list of countries eligible to purchase an item based on Category and other Item Specifics, that's not my problem.
-And if that sounds like ignorant bluster, here has been my prior experience, when some aspect about the item has been deemed non-forwardable at eBay's shipping hub. They don't do anything to the seller, not even scold or warn about doing it again, in fact they don't even state what the specific reason the item was non-forwardable. They just cancel the sale, refund the buyer FROM THEIR OWN POCKET, NOT THE SELLER'S, and sell the item to a liquidator (who runs a store right here on eBay -I've seen my cancelled GSP/EIS items for sale there -they even get permission to use the sellers' photos, descriptions, even packing materials -I know because I've bought from them several times, found sellers' thank you cards in them and everything, LOL).
I can't remember if these cancelled sales involve a refund of eBay fees or not; I just know that nothing bad happens in addition to a normal completed sale, no additional financial loss, no seller defects. Also the buyer cannot leave negative feedback, although I always write them to express empathy that they couldn't receive the item they wanted.
fbusoni
@gurlcat
Fascinating anecdote about the liquidator! Makes perfect sense.
And I believe that you are 100% correct about the onus falling on eBay. ***
Here is an excerpt from the EU legislation in question, the full text of which can be found here:
If you are curious about the categories of items of concern to the EU, here is another excerpt:
------------------------------------
*** NOTE: The response to @wastingtime101 below (in blue) from community team member Kyle to my mind is evidence that eBay will have our backs; what is eBay going to do, close the account of every seller who erroneously fills out the GPSR specifics??
"Sellers need to determine for themselves whether they need to add this information to their listings when shipping is offered to the EU. Unfortunately, eBay cannot provide legal advice and the answer may depend on different factors particular to the seller and the item. All Sellers can provide GPSR specifics in the item disclosures section and in their item description."
dbfolks166mt
It will be interesting, as you noted, to see how EIS addresses this and if that would fall under their purview as part of the EIS program. It will also be interesting to see how the freight forwarders handle this issue or if they simply cut off EU buyers.
kds99
In the actual EU document, "Antiques" (which are exempted from the new requirements) definitionally includes at least some collectibles, though eBay seems to be looking at not allowing the exemption for items in the "Collectible" categories. I guess collectible postcards are MUCH more dangerous than I thought.
pjcdn2005
It doesn't make sense why a 'Safety Regulation' would include books and other items that don't seem to be a safety concern. As someone else suggested, this seems to be a push towards EU buyers purchasing just EU items.
fbusoni
@pjcdn2005
Bingo!
Does anyone recall the history of US-EU relations after February, 2022?
It would be charitable to say that the US twisted the arms off our European "allies" to ensure that the USA would be their principle energy trading partner.
Never mind what the people of Ukraine are experiencing.
dbfolks166mt
It doesn't make sense why a 'Safety Regulation' would include books and other items that don't seem to be a safety concern. As someone else suggested, this seems to be a push towards EU buyers purchasing just EU items.
On the surface a lot of things would appear not to be a safety concern. Take a pencil for example.
......... I once saw him kill 3 men in a bar with a pencil, with a fu..... pencil.
fbusoni
The books in question are likely a reference to Germany, where anything that promotes, glorifies or otherwise sanctions violence is usually forbidden from entering the country.
I am unsure whether other European nations have similar sensitivities.
orangehound
OPIf these rules have any enforcement teeth, I don't know see how eBay can continue to operate as a marketplace in the EU.
prairieprimitives
Why is that? There are eBay sellers in the EU, so it seems like they will be able to sell in their own country, at least.
1786davycrockett
@orangehound
The GPSR was obviously not designed for sellers of second-hand items, even though the GPSR clearly states that second-hand items are included.
For small sellers, the GPSR rules are ridiculously complicated: why would I spend hours of my own time attempting to dredge up all the information demanded by GPSR, for an item which I have listed at less than $20.00?
As of December 13, 2024 I will no longer be selling to the European Union and Northern Ireland.
One size does NOT fit all.