NEGATIVES LEFT ON UNRELATED SALES?
I have a problem....We shipped a doll to a forwarding service in Delaware....Once received, they inspect for damage and the item was then sent to China....The item was damaged from Delaware to China....We are no longer responsible once it leaves Delaware....They are to file a claim with the forwarding service....I did not refund....I was then left a negative on the damaged doll...I asked Ebay to remove it as it has always been my understanding that we are not responsible for damage once it leaves the shipped to address...The customer then left negatives for 2 vinyl dolls that were in the same box with the same comments about the broken porcelain doll....I contacted Ebay to have them removed as they had nothing to do with the damaged doll....They removed one but not the other?...Then the customer left 3 negatives on dolls sent in a previous shipment....Again referring to the broken doll...I contacted an agent over 24 hours ago with no result...I am so frustrated to keep looking at 5 undeserved negatives in my feedback...I have also used the feedback removal request forms for the three additional negatives that have been left...I would think this would have been an open & shut case...
abclovell
OPMaybe they should be required to open a case before they can leave a negative?
abclovell
OPThe only problem with this is if they refuse to open a case and then leave negatives, is there no recourse?
abclovell
OPOne thing I did learn is to always ask the customer to open a case
abclovell
OPI want to thank everyone for their encouragement, advice & support....I am going to have to learn to live with looking at those 5 negatives on my record for the next year....SIGH....My hubby wants us to put it behind us....I have learned alot for sure!
fern*wood
Probably just as well. I still think some of those should have been removed, but of course what I think doesn't matter. I'll always remember one of my negatives back in the day that read "no good seller" and they didn't even pay. 😂 Since then I've had a couple removed when I didn't ask for them to be, and frankly, I felt I deserved them. So, it isn't an exact science. Your sales are amazing anyway.
lacemaker3
@abclovell
Did the buyer open an MBG case for the broken doll? or for any of the other transactions?
As @kyle@ebay said, in many situations, the eBay protection for defects and negative feedbacks only "kicks in" or is activated when the buyer starts an MBG case. If the buyer did not do that, then the seller does not have a lot of protections that would otherwise be in place.
abclovell
OPNo they did not...I suspect that if I asked for a return of the pieces it would have been obvious the doll was in China and not Delaware which would have voided her claim...
stainlessenginecovers
Why are you stating that the 'freight forwarder' opens the package and would 'send it back' etc. They do NOT open packages (or they do, we don't know, you don't know' they are NOT a 'system of ebay).
Why did you 'send a feedback revision' as that goes to ONLY the person leaving the feedback and you only get 5 a year. If you did NOT make sure the buyer agreed to 'revise', you just wasted these revisions.
abclovell
OPI sell many items that go to Delaware or Oregon first...It is a service that forwards items overseas and saves postage for the buyers....I have been contacted before when something arrived broken at the US address...
stainlessenginecovers
Then someone there was being EXTRA nice and going OUT OF THEIR WAY to do so. It's NOT their responsibility to do so (in fact, how in the world would a 'person' working at this Freight Forwarder have ANY idea what the listing stated, which could have stated 'XYZ Doll with Broken Face for sale for Parts' etc...so IF you were lucky enough for someone that works at one of these Freight Forwarders to put their face in your business, you were one lucky dog and that will... I GUARANTEE- NEVER happen again.
abclovell
OPWhat I meant was, the buyer would be informed if it was broken when it arrived in Delaware who would in turn inform me....This has happened in the past including photos of the damage...I suspect they do that to protect themselves from liability from Delaware to China...
stainlessenginecovers
No; they would NOT be typically notified of anything as again; seldom is the item even opened. FF's are for those that are buying NUMEROUS items from the US and then getting shipped to them in a much better priced package (sometimes part of a full container and will ship in 2 weeks or 40 weeks).
I've shipped to FF's for well over 20 years and I KNOW how they work.
wastingtime101
Some FF offer that service of opening and inspecting items for damage before forwarding. Some offer that service for an added fee. Some don't offer it at all.
To assume all FF offer the service is inaccurate, just as assuming no FF offer that service is also incorrect. Forwarders are not one size fits all in their business models.
abclovell
OPSeems crazy but that is how it has been left....I used Caps because I wanted to be sure other buyers would read it but I see what you mean....Supposedly a couple of agents I spoke with on the phone have forwarded notes to the "resolution team" but I haven't heard a thing...
mam98031
All caps likely does the opposite. All caps are harder for many people to even read. So it may not have the effect you were hoping for.
I'm so sorry Ebay is not helping you with this. I honestly thought they would and should.
abclovell
OP"Here is the most recent reply:
Hello Linda,
We appreciate you reaching out on eBay regarding your items that you sold to buyer “pllk1161â€. I know how important this transaction is for you since you would want to remove the buyer's feedback. My name is Fred and I am glad to assist you through your concerns.
Linda, I commend you for your efforts in raising this concern to us. I know how concerning it is when you tried to have the feedback removed but there were no refunds yet at the time that you requested. Please allow me to assist you further.
I've looked into the feedback you've received for this item and it is allowed under our policies. I see that you’ve done your part in resolving your buyers concern and with this; I highly recommend that you continue communicating with your buyer to come up with an agreement in revising the feedback they left.
As part of your Seller Protection, you can send a feedback Revision request once you have an agreement with your buyer. Feedback revision allows a seller to ask a buyer to change the feedback they left, for example if they left negative or neutral feedback by mistake, or if the seller has resolved a transaction problem to the buyer's satisfaction. And this would only available in cases where the buyer has left negative or neutral feedback.
Here's how it works:
1.. Once the issue is resolved, the seller asks the buyer to change their feedback within 30 days.
2. The buyer receives a notice from eBay, informing them of the request.
3. The buyer then has 10 days to respond to the request. After this time the feedback cannot be revised.
If the buyer revises the feedback, they can leave a neutral or negative rating as it is or revise it upward. They can't change a neutral feedback to a negative. Detailed seller ratings may be adjusted freely.
I trust that the information that I have provided is to your satisfaction. Thank you for choosing eBay and I am looking forward to your further success with us. Have a nice day!
Warm regards,
Fred O.
eBay Customer Support"
fern*wood
Come on Fred..
mam98031
All I can say is WOW. Ebay did say a couple months ago or so they were going to tighten up on removing negatives, but these just seem so removeable. I simply don't get it.
The only other suggestion I have is to look at the buyers Feedback Left For Others. See if there is a pattern of this buyer leaving negatives for sellers. It can show FB abuse on the part of the buyer and that would make your FB removeable.
albertabrightalberta
Of 378 feedbacks left by the buyer, these are the ONLY negs. So there's no pattern.
With that said, I stilll agree that the negative feedbacks on the other items should have been removed.
gurlcat
Thing is, I can see why that may be in order (I'll give an example in a minute) but as with past examples of good-sounding changes, eBay is undoubtedly implementing it horribly, just telling CSR's to cut back on removals without training them to consider any nuance, so what we'll have is arbitrary unfairness but the management will see an overall reduction and think it's good.
So here's that example -I remember a while back (maybe about a year ago?), someone here posted about a seller they had bought from who did an overall cruddy job, so this poster left them a very deserved negative, and knew exactly what not to say, because this poster was also an experienced seller. A day or two later the comment and mathematical ding was removed, so the poster started watching their feedback for the next several days. Over and over they were getting negged and having those removed, no matter how legit the complaints sounded, and the poster had a bunch of before/after screenshots to prove it. The seller was BIG-big, like thousands of sales per month, and I can't remember if they were a TRS or not, but their feedback score was at or close to 100%. But it couldn't be anywhere near that if they weren't getting all this scrubbing done on their behalf.
So that's the kind of thing where too much leniency was obviously going on. But if you juxtapose that against a small seller getting several negs from the same buyer ..... all based on their grievance with just ONE of their purchases .... and even that one wasn't the seller's fault, then that seller's score takes a huge blow because they're small. That would be just devastatingly unfair. In this case the OP is not so small that 5 negs was devastating (their score is still 99.9%), but man, 5 new negs would damage me bad right now.
mam98031
@gurlcat
That wasn't something that affected any of us here. That was when sellers had an Anchor store. They were allowed to get a certain number of negatives removed every 90 days, I think it was 90, it may have been 60. They took that benefit away in the last couple of months.
But for the rest of us with something like that would not have happened.
I think in an effort to make things better, they went too far and are now denying the removal of legit FB that should be removed.
gurlcat
I remember the 'anchor store' topic coming up in that thread but they were getting way more negs removed than the allowance for even that, but it's too fuzzy a memory to be a hill to die on. All in all, I agree with your last sentence.
soh.maryl
Can you help me understand this?
In his very first post, the OP stated that a freight forwarder was used. It's always been my understanding that, in that case, the seller's responsibility for the condition of the item ended upon its arrival at the FF.
So I was wrong all this time?
abclovell
OPI thought so too but because there was no way to prove that the doll is now in China, I wasn't covered ....Even though the email was 30 days after delivery in Delaware?
lacemaker3
@soh.maryl, I don't think that you are wrong about the MBG at all ...
... but the problem is, the buyer didn't open an MBG case, so the protections under the MBG don't seem to apply in this situation. If the buyer had opened an MBG case, it would have been closed in the seller's favor, and then the seller would have been protected.
Because the buyer didn't open an MBG case, there was no case to be closed, and no seller protections were enabled.
It doesn't seem right, but it does seem to be what is strictly written in the eBay MBG policy.
mam98031
Sorry I can't help. I'm not understanding Ebay's position on this either.
djvp53
That's really disappointing. I know you are anxious about how this will affect your sales but I'm hoping it doesn't. You have a long solid track record with good feedback and one cranky buyer. As I said above, I'd still buy from you and I usually look at feedback pretty closely when I shop. good luck.
mam98031
This is really rather bothering me and I need a better understanding of Ebay's current position on removing negative FB.
@devon@ebay
@kyle@ebay
@elizabeth@ebay
I know things are continually changing, but some guidance here would really help many of us. The OP of this thread has 5 negative FB from the same buyer that appears to most of us here as it should be removable, but Ebay disagrees. Why?
A freight forwarder was used. The items are now in China where the buyer is and apparently there was a problem. As the OP describes it, not all dolls were broken or even the same type of doll, but the buyer applied the same FB statement on all FB they left. So that is leaving FB about an different transaction. Then of course is the matter that the items were re-shipped from the FF to arrive at the buyer's address. According to the MBG we are suppose to be protected when the item reships.
I'm not understanding why Ebay is not helping. Please help us to better understand.
kyle@ebay
Hey @mam98031, there are a few things going on here:
As a side note: Rule #1 when receiving a negative or neutral feedback is to communicate with the buyer and try to resolve the issue. This will help avoid revision requests going unanswered.
fern*wood
If I read the situation correctly, It seems that no one looking at the feedbacks realize all but one are commenting on a different transaction. A broken doll occurred, but commenting about it for transactions other than the broken doll transaction seems improper.
kyle@ebay
Hey @fern*wood thanks for the question. That's why I mentioned at face value. We simply don't have enough information to determine if this was in fact, one single broken doll, or all of them that were shipped in that order.
mam98031
I had mentioned this in the post that I tagged for the community team.
mam98031
@kyle@ebay
Thank you for the info. You missed what I think is an important point. The buyer left the same FB for all the items they purchased and that FB only applied to one of the transactions, not all of them. They claimed the porcelain doll was broken, not the other plastic dolls they bought.
There use to be a rule that the FB had to apply to the transaction. Has that changed? Can we now leave FB about other transactions on an unrelated transaction?
According to the OP there are 5 transactions. 2 for porcelain dolls and 3 for plastic dolls. It was ONE of the porcelain dolls they are claiming is broken, but they left the same FB on all 5 transactions.
kyle@ebay
Hey @mam98031 there is still a rule that feedback can be removed if it is for the wrong transaction. However, in order for this rule to apply, it needs to be a "slam dunk" and be very definitive that it was an unrelated transaction. So for example, if OP's feedback said something like "this steering wheel was not compatible with my car" on a sale of a doll, then this feedback would have qualified to be removed for this reason. But in this instance where all 5 sales were dolls, and the feedback says the doll was damaged in transit, no matter how unlikely, it's possible that each doll was damaged. So without having any more information to go off of, we would need to deny that removal request.
traditonalproducts
It appears that I see numerous issues from individuals on purchasing items from China but not the other way. Bottom line is that China is the key to a lot of these issues. Based on the OP's description, why would we have to go through a circus act to remove neg feedback specifically if there was a freight forwarder involved? I know its eBay's system regardless, these issues involve a lot of time, pain, & money on both sides.
djvp53
I'm sorry you're going through this. I would hope that eBay would remove the complaints about the unrelated items from your feedback. Since they won't, i will just say that I'm picky about who I buy from on eBay and this feedback from one grumpy buyer wouldn't dissuade me from buying from you.
Also, your keyboard should have a shift key. Use it when replying to feedback so you don't look like you are yelling irrationally at your buyer. I'm not kidding when I say that the all caps response looks as bad to me as the feedback. Best wishes.
sextons-sweet-deals
I'm just going to comment on your tittle: NEGATIVES LEFT ON UNRELATED SALES?
I have had this issue a few times. When someone buys and then buys again in a short time period without leaving feedback on the first purchase, I will kindly ask them to do so.
Just kind of a security thing with me. I don't want someone buying and buying and then down the road, they try to file claims with eBay or their C.C.
Your situation really opened up another issue that I never thought about.
Side note: If you can't get those negatives removed, you can respond to each and state your case for everyone to read. eBay has increased the space for the seller to explain and give details.
Good luck with this.
gurlcat
Just FYI, positive feedback left by the buyer has zero impact on whether they can open a return or win a CC claim. Feedback is purely for other buyers' info.
abclovell
OPSo sad...
"I pulled all of these up and wanted to see what I could do. I'm not getting the option to remove any of these since the feedback has already been reviewed and removal denied. Beyond that, there's nothing in our removal guidelines that would allow us to take these off. I really do want to see you get these off of your profile, and the revision/reply process is going to be the very best option that we have. Keep working with your buyer, providing the great customer service that you've shown you're capable of, and let's see if we can get positives out of them. Thanks for all your hard work on the site over the years."
chapeau-noir
Sympathetic mush. Good grief. 🙄
I don't understand why these negs weren't removed.
abclovell
OPAnother agent on Facebook is taking a fresh look...Let's hope there is a reasonable outcome
mam98031
Actually, you are correct, according to the MBG, you are not responsible for how the Freight Forwarder packages the items. When you contact Ebay, make sure they understand that a FF was used and the items are now at the customers international address. All 5 should be removable for a couple of reasons.
Please come back and update us.
I would suggest that you contact Ebay for Business on Facebook, Instagram or Twitter for the better trained CSRs.
Here are your options for contacting Ebay Customer Service. Please be aware that for social media CS, you send them a Private Message and briefly explain what your problem or issue is. Feel free to leave your Name, address, phone number and/or your email address in this message. It is private and secure and it may help to speed up the response for you.
https://twitter.com/askebay
https://www.facebook.com/eBay/
https://www.instagram.com/ebayforsellers/
Your options will be on the left. If you use the link below you can only get to the Automated Assistant or Chat box type AGENT in the box and hit enter. You will then get more options. Not all options are available 24/7. It will depend on staffing available. So sometimes you can request a call back and sometimes you can't. Sometimes you have the Chat option available and other times it won't me. If it is important to you to use one of those options, just try back later.
If you use a cell phone or other mobile device, you may need to turn off your Spam filter so that Ebay can call you.
If you are a seller outside of the US or Canada, you will need to use the Chat Option.
https://www.ebay.com/help/home
abclovell
OPI made it quite clear to who I chatted with on Facebook that they used a freight forwarder....They claim because they can't definitely tell that the doll was broken after it left the USA that they can't remove the feedback....I pointed out that it has been a month since the delivery was made which should prove it traveled after being delivered but that didn't seem to make a difference....Also they refuse to remove the other 4 negatives (although a fith one has been removed) as they can't tell which doll was broken???...I have just sent a message letting them know that photo of the broken doll are in my emails...
toomuchstuffagain35
So they really believe that "maybe" every.single.doll. you sent to this buyer (on separate shipments) arrived broken?
Jeez louise, FB ebay CS really has gone downhill.
gurlcat
Yes they have. They used to be like night and day compared to the phone CSR's. Now it's like you just get told you're screwed in better English.
gurlcat
I think I want to walk this comment back a little, on further reflection. I DO think I've gotten less help from EFB in the past couple years than I did before that, maybe just because more sellers have become aware of it so they're overburdened. But as for this particular case, I think maybe the criticism is undue. From what the EFB representative said, they would absolutely remove the negs if they could, but couldn't only because the chat rep had already denied the request.
To me that suggests two things:
1. Neg removal is an overlooked area as far as appeals go. Like there should be a way to appeal, not a locked vault once a rep says 'no.' But in the meantime .....
2. OP @abclovell and anyone else reading, in future situations, go to EFB FIRST. Because I still do believe your chances of getting (any kind of) help are higher that way than with a phone or chat rep, whose 'no' may be your last chance.
abclovell
OPI have since refunded for the broken doll although I still feel we were not responsible once it left Delaware....I then sent revision requests and a very nice request letter to the customer....Crickets...
mam98031
I'm sorry to hear that.
Just so you know. I would never send a FB revision request to a buyer without first having communication with them that they are willing to revise the FB. There are a couple reasons for that.
First, the email they receive will come from Ebay, not from you. So it could be easy to overlook or simply delete.
Second, they have a self life after issued. If the buyer doesn't use it within 14 days [I think that is the time], then it no longer is a viable request. You can not issue a second one on the same transaction.
Third, we have a limited number of these forms to use as sellers. You may or may not even have enough available for all 5 of the FB you are trying to get resolved.
So my personal rule is I never send one without first having open communication with my buyer and I know they are willing to adjust the FB.
fern*wood
I was surprised to see you aren't a TRS. I was about to post that since you handled the case and had a return policy that you should have been given some limited protected for the negatives that TRSs usually receive.
albertabrightalberta
@abclovell
Are you implying that your international buyer knows there's no MBG when she uses a freight forwarder so instead, she chose to ding your feedback?
How unfair.
I'd block that buyer yesterday!
abclovell
OPI did block her. I just don't understand why it's taking eBay so long to see that these need to be removed.
toomuchstuffagain35
The response used to be faster but it's slowed down a bit recently.
You just have to be patient.
Other websites are far worse at responding, trust me.
abclovell
OPThank you for the encouragement!
abclovell
OPI verified...still nothing
fab_finds4u
They are not supposed to leave a negative referencing a different item. Contact them on Facebook.
abclovell
OPI can contact Ebay on Facebook?
moretreasures4you
eBay for Business they are very helpful, they will ask for information and it you want them to help you need to give them the info.
abclovell
OPI left a message...I hope someone is able to help...
sin-n-dex
They may take time to reply. Go have a cup of tea and read a book... at some point they'll get back to you to sign into your account (this is legit) and look into your problem. It's best to tell them the whole problem in one message to start, then they can be looking into it for you even if you've left the computer.
C.
abclovell
OPI just verified....Let's see what happens...
I just got done chatting with an agent who advised me to wait 72 hours....That long with FIVE negative feedbacks sitting there!
xadexane
Hopefully you did not lock down those 5 negative feedbacks by replying to each one of them. The last time I asked eBay on Facebook to remove my negative feedback, they foisted me a link back to the regular CS, which then escalated.
I’m glad that I received your email because I work with this type of cases almost on a daily basis, and I am an expert at resolving it. I can assure you that you are in the right hands.
Good news! I’ve looked into the transaction and can see that the feedback qualifies for an appeal and I have already removed it.
I’m glad that I was able to help you maintain a low transaction defect rate. We would like to let you know that we value you and your business and we are always here to do what is right for you.
toomuchstuffagain35
Replying to neg FB does NOT stop ebay removing them - urban myth