Negative feedback: Problem when blocking the buyer, everything was blocked and I didn't know.
Hello, I think I made a mistake. A few days ago, I sold a box of jewelry, and the buyer told me it was all junk, with only one item worth $15 and the rest broken. I responded asking how we could resolve this, and then I blocked him. I waited for a response, but I didn't receive one. What happened was that when I blocked him, I also blocked him from sending messages. I didn't know that blocking someone blocks everything, even messages. It wasn't like that in the old system. Now he's left me negative feedback, saying he sent a message to return the items, and I never responded. I called eBay customer service, and they said they didn't see the message because I blocked him, and that they'll send the report now. What can I do in this situation?
cristian3_6
OPThank God they finally removed the negative feedback. I contacted customer service and they agreed with me. What the buyer said was in the description. Thank you so much to everyone on the forum for the advice. And I wish you all a happy Thanksgiving!
adamcartwright
@cristian3_6
Great news!
I had a negative FB removed once years ago for exactly that same reason -- the buyer had complained about something that was clear in the description. I'm glad to see they're still protecting us sellers that way.
Happy Thanksgiving to you, as well!
cristian3_6
OPThis is what they told me on eBay
We've made a decision on your feedback request
Hello cristian3_6,
We took a look at the feedback you were concerned about:
Our decision
After reviewing the details, we found that the issue the buyer is concerned about about was clearly stated in the listing when they purchased their item.
As a result, we're removing this feedback for you, including the ratings.
luckythewinner
When I go the Blocked Buyer page, it says right on that page that messages will be blocked:
Block buyers from your listings
If you don't wish to sell to certain eBay members, you can put them on your blocked list. Members on that list will be unable to bid, buy, make an offer, or send you messages
gurlcat
It says that NOW but it didn't use to. And this was another case of ebay making a change to a feature function without notifying sellers. So all this time the OP has been going on the way the feature worked in the past.
cristian3_6
OPNo wonder I have other negative reviews for the same reason: I was blocking them without realizing that messages were also being blocked. It's a shame I didn't know that sooner.
It's also a shame that eBay didn't inform everyone via message that this would happen. I'm not a mind reader to know for sure.
christworks
@cristian3_6 eBay's goofy block feature notwithstanding, your trouble would be significantly reduced if you started allowing returns. You've indicated this is a problem, and so much so that you block buyers when they contact you about issues they have. If you accepted returns, buyers would know they could simply open a return. If a buyer is going to scam you, which seems to be your concern, they are going to scam you whether you accept returns or not. As it stands now your practices are still costing you money (which I assume the no return policy is designed to prevent), you are spending a considerable amount of time dealing with buyers and eBay, and you have a shiny red bullseye to boot.
cristian3_6
OPIt's obvious the buyer wanted to scam me because he also sells and has experience in this. What's more, the buyers I've had the most problems with are the ones who sell the same thing as me. There's always a problem, and I always end up losing because I have to issue a partial refund.
mr_lincoln
Hi @cristian3_6
I haven't read many replies but I read your OP. Yes, years ago Sellers and Buyers could still message each other through eBay on a transaction for 60 days from the date of purchase (if memory serves on that time frame) even if the Buyer was added to the BBL.
You can add them to your Exemption list (same page as the Blocked list) and get back in touch with them to apologize and resume a conversation that might let you two resolve the issue. Perhaps they would agree to a Feedback revision form to change the FB.
cristian3_6
OPI'll complain to eBay, telling them it was a technical problem; that option was unchecked, but they ignored it anyway. eBay didn't remove that option, so I don't think it's my fault.
albertabrightalberta
Wouldn't adding them to your exemption list allow them to buy again, thus risking potential damage from an already unhappy buyer?
And wouldn't adding them to your exemption listing be the same as removing them from your BBL?
I'm not sure how it would work as far as exempting a blocked buyer. I've used the buyer exemption list to allow buyers in a country that I normally block to make a purchase. Not sure how it works with a domestic blocked buyer.
mr_lincoln
@albertabrightalberta
Just thinking out loud ...
Probably not one of my better suggestions although the first part I think I got right about how messaging was permitted in the past on an active transaction but the Buyer was otherwise blocked for Buying and Bidding.
Giving the Exemption list further thought and to your point about international Buyers I believe that list is intended to give a Buyer a pass on all of the other settings on the Buyer Management page that would otherwise block them from Buying AND that they are NOT on the Blocked list.
adamcartwright
Man, I'm tired of this issue.
But I'm not holding my breath for eBay to fix it.
cristian3_6
OPI just found out today that if you block someone, they're blocked completely. That's why I'll be more careful now.
gloryglorygifts
It sounds like you did make a mistake. Why would you block someone that is reaching out to you with an order issue? I would unblock him and then apologize for your clerical error and tell him that he can return the box of jewelry for a full refund. You can also issue a partial refund should he choose to keep the box and contents.
I don't think that you will be able to get the feedback removed but maybe if you are really, really nice to him you can get him to change it after everything is resolved.
That's my two cents. Good luck and come back and tell us what you decided to do.
cristian3_6
OPThanks for replying. The thing is, whenever I have a problematic buyer, I block them quickly so they can't buy from me anymore. The problem is, I didn't know that blocking someone also blocks them from email. So, yes, it was my fault.
I just found out today when I called eBay customer service and told them I didn't see the message he sent me because I blocked him. However, if he wanted a return, he had to open a case.
eBay should fix that by adding an option to ban purchases and another to ban emails. It's a shame this is happening when I didn't want it to.
cristian3_6
OPIt shouldn't work like this; if I block it, it's so they can't buy from me anymore. But I don't know why the email gets blocked too. There should be an option to block the email within the email app.
albertabrightalberta
What you describe is how it used to be but eBay changed it.
I had a case today with a problem buyer and I wasn't able to block until I knew it was over. During the 3 hours of the buyer sending dozens of unhinged messages, he would have been able to make more purchases and cause more trouble. Fortunately, that didn't happen.
cristian3_6
OPIt's also suspicious if the buyer could open a return and didn't. Isn't that strange?
albertabrightalberta
But you have a "no return" policy and some buyers don't realize they can get a return even with that policy. Many buyers think "no returns" means no returns so they leave feedback instead.
bashort
how about this?
cristian3_6
OPHi, thanks for replying. I have it set up like this, so what should I select?
cristian3_6
OPI have the third option unchecked. So, was the error on eBay's part? Or did the buyer not send me any message?
stainlessenginecovers
@
@bashort that's old. It's still on your 'preferences' but the 'new system' is: When a buyer is added to a sellers blocked list, communication from buyer to seller is also blocked (although we've tested it, a sellers communication can be seen by the blocked buyer)
cristian3_6
OPThat's really bad and eBay should fix it. Why is communication being cut off like that? I didn't know that. Now I know something new. Thanks.
buyselljack2016
It has been suggested that eBay went that route because of seller complaints about being contacted by blocked buyers even though the box was there to be checked for those not wishing communication.
Another case of eBay taking the easiest route to solve the problem presented by some sellers while at the same time creating bigger issues for many other sellers.
cristian3_6
OPThen it wasn't my fault if I had that option unchecked. eBay needs to remove that feedback because I didn't know that blocking a buyer also blocked the message.
slippinjimmy
It no longer works, hasn't for a year or so, been brought to the attention of eBay multiple times, they just stonewall. @wastingtime101 has been working on this issue for a long time, has been getting nowhere.
It's similar type of thing to the Request Total function which is NON-functional most of the time, no matter how many times it's reported it's never fixed, all you get are vague denials.
albertabrightalberta
@devon@ebay
@elizabeth@ebay
@kyle@ebay
Here's another example of a communication problem when a seller blocks a buyer.
cristian3_6
OPHi, thanks for replying.
The thing is, when I have these problems, I block the buyer because I feel like they're lying and just want to return the items and keep the best items
But what do I do if things are missing when the items arrive? Will eBay believe me?
Why didn't they activate the automatic return system? I didn't know that blocking a buyer also blocks their email. It didn't work that way before.
chapeau-noir
Yeah, that needs to go back to being communication as an opt in/out by the seller.
chapeau-noir
What I would do: Unblock and then write the buyer, apologise for your inadvertent mistake (don't tell them they were blocked, that won't help). Then offer what you were going to offer to begin with, or ask him to file for a return.
Leave the feedback completely out of the picture - I know it's staring you in the eye and is frustrating, but it needs to not be a bargaining point. IMHO, a businesslike response pointing to resolution is the better way to go about it (unless the buyer suggests that they're willing to revise it, which would be great).