ITEM RETURNED WITH DAMAGE
RECEIVED ITEM BACK WITH BIG HOLE..NEVER TOLD WHEN RETURNING..FILED A CLAIM AGAINST ME BECAUSE I WON'T REFUND MONEY..I SENT PICTURES OF DAMAGE
prettythingsamora
44 comments
RECEIVED ITEM BACK WITH BIG HOLE..NEVER TOLD WHEN RETURNING..FILED A CLAIM AGAINST ME BECAUSE I WON'T REFUND MONEY..I SENT PICTURES OF DAMAGE
prettythingsamora
OPYes that's the one...thanks allot for your help..yes I'll send refund...even though she sent it back with a hole...just doesn't seem right
duffy4444
@prettythingsamora:
Glad to see you'll be taking this off your plate and issuing a refund. Issue it wiki-wiki (Hawaiian for "right away") in order to keep eBay from stepping in and doing it for you and not returning your eBay fees.
Perhaps the hole in the coat was there all along without you noticing it, or the buyer put it into the coat. Either way, it's not provable and simply doesn't matter.
As I mentioned in my earlier post, most sellers have had a similar situation happen to them at least once. I know I have a few times, and I've used my Blocked Buyer list to at least make me feel better knowing the buyer won't have the opportunity to do it to me again - if in fact it was actually the buyer's fault. So you're not alone and now have a deeper understanding of an occasional cost of doing business online.
Good luck in getting over it and taking measures to cover a similar experience in the future.
Cheers, Duffy
reallynicestamps
So I paid them to shatter my product and paid for extra insurance back then for them to just break it, take the broken pieces back, then give me some of my money back.
Let me share the Good News about Cookie Jar Insurance.
This is just a cute way of describing self-insurance.
Add a small amount (five or ten cents usually) to every shipping charge.
Put those virtual pennies in a virtual Cookie Jar as a sort of premium against problems.
If the customer has a complaint- or a Claim- refund from the Cookie Jar
But
No Refunds without Return.
Pros:
cheaper than third party insurance
no labour expended on making claims.
covers not just damage in transit, but damage by buyer
covers our own idiot moves like shipping the red sweater instead of the blue one
no arguements that lead to negative FB
Cons
Tiny handling charge makes shipping higher than going commando
reallynicestamps
.she paid for return shipping
Take that as a Win.
Refunds and damaged goods are tax deductible.
ryry-jj
Refund, take it to a tailor to fix the hole if possible, then relist.
Ebay has no idea, and neither does anyone here have any idea if the hole was there or not when you listed. Based on your initial post here and the lack of detail, I can only assume you left out details in your listing...it is all we can go on. eBay is not investigating
kibble-net
More proof of the Venn diagram that is a perfect circle, between "People who type in all caps" and "People who refuse to take responsibility".
kensgiftshop
@prettythingsamora
If you want your fee's refunded, you need to refund the buyer before Ebay does from your account.
babyers88
REFUND (you are required too, even if damaged in shipment)
THEN, file a damage claim with the original shipper, generally you have 30 days from date or original delivery.
stainlessenginecovers
@babyers88 which will become the LARGEST waste of time in the history of time.
babyers88
why? I have never had a problem filing a claim. you are allowed to do so why not.
*this is presuming the item was packaged properly, a hole in the item would then be from external causes
about 99.99% of any claim I have ever filed have been paid. no matter the carrier.
for those not in the know, you are allowed to file a claim online with all 3 major carriers, no inspections or taking it anywhere.
you write your statement, you take photos from several angles, you upload the original sales receipt from ebay. submit it online, done.
the more you know........
stainlessenginecovers
It must be 'the more you DON'T know'.
babyers88
ok, not here to argue.
carry on....
fern*wood
Filing a claim is easy, but getting them paid--not so much. Strange, but of the damaged claims I've filed over the past few years, one has been paid because the lady was really nice about showing the post office. I've had good photos, but they didn't help. Each one since around 2000 have required my buyer to take everything to the post office and either they won't or I am too embarrassed to ask. Maybe I'm doing something wrong for inspections to be required and yours don't. 🤔 Is there a trick for that? Thankfully, I haven't had too many damaged ones. I definitely never claim it's a slam dunk.
I currently have a claim submitted where I received a baggie from USPS saying they were sorry it was damaged, so we'll see if they even pay for that one.
prettythingsamora
OPNOT DAMAGED IN SHIPPING..
BUYER DAMAGED GARMENT AND DIDN'T TELL ME..
I RECEIVED DAMAGED ITEM..WAS NOT DAMAGED WHEN SHE RECEIVED
duffy4444
@prettythingsamora :
This is known as an automatic loss for you, as well as for anybody in your situation who wants to override the policy outcome from eBay. Most sellers here have run into the same situation at least once.
What part of "no returns does not mean no refunds" and "chalk it up as a cost of doing business online" do you not understand? Shouting at us with all caps does not change your reality, no matter where a seller is anywhere online. All a buyer needs to do is the ultimate of a chargeback from their credit card issuer, and then it's almost a 100% double whammy with eBay charging you, the seller, even more.
You've received the advice you need, even though it's not the advice you want to hear. Bite the bullet and move on - or sit and stew over the loss. Your choice.
Best of luck,
Cheers, Duffy
prettythingsamora
OPThanks allot for your reply
babyers88
@fern*wood
in the claims process it allows for you to upload photo's.....
those photos are critical to the process, upload multiple photos from different angles.
primarily with the item in the original box with packing material, then show the damage on the item and the associated damage on the box which could be anything a hole, tears/rips, dented sides, crushed area, etc.
those photo's are what is allowed to be presented in place of a visual inspection. ALL 3 major carriers allow this.
then a simple statement such as: this item was packaged securely for safe transport, under normal conditions it should have arrived undamaged. It appears that (in this case) that a foreign object penetrated the package while in your care. this should have never occurred if handled properly.
I have to also say, if you are shipping anything worth money that you are not willing to just wipe off as a small loss, then be 100% sure it is packed well in a good secure box. poly bag's, padded envelopes, etc are no good.
I ship around 4,000 packages a year (currently) I used to ship 3x time's more than that, luckily not a lot of things get damaged but from time to time it happens, if it is a $20 item it's not a big deal and it's likely not worth the time, but when a $300 package gets jacked up I make sure I get it handled....
If it is worth filing a claim over then it is likely worth having it shipped back, so just have the customer request a return, refund upon return and then file your damage claim. that way you are off the hook from ebay and it is in your best interest to get that claim paid to recoup the loss.
fern*wood
I never have damaged items returned to me. I thought that would void the initial shipping insurance. I guess if it doesn't, that's an easy fix to asking buyers to surrender them to the post office. I do submit the photos my buyers send me, which seemed pretty good, but usually get denied unless they go to the post office with the item.
babyers88
@fern*wood it's almost always best to just have it returned, unless the original packaging was completely obliterated. you cannot depend on or ask the receiver/customer to go out of their way to take it to a post office. I mean you can ask but,.,,,,you know, why put them thru the extra work...for something that was not there fault.
If it is a fedex/ups claim you & the customer/receiver "can" arrange for them to retrieve the package for inspection and return to you, but they then like to deny for any little reason they can come up with and you still get charged for the return cost.
your better off just doing the claim with it in hand, if it gets denied you can appeal it. i once had to appeal one all the way to usps headquarters in Washington DC. to get it paid. took about 6 months.....ugh thankfully that only ever happened once.
spreadlovelikefire
It's 100% voids the initial shipping insurance. Hence why the buyer is suppose to surrender the item to the postal inspector, to stop this from happening.
spreadlovelikefire
USPS will not approve a damage claim if the item is shipped back to the seller. That will void the claim right away as the process requires the buyer to surender the damaged item back to USPS. If they know the item has been shipped back to you then it will not even be considered. I've had several of these over the years and and only one was paid and it was like pulling teeth to get it to go through. They shattered a Pyrex dish Is sent. The buyer had to surrender the item to the postal inspector. Then the postal inspector had to submit the damage claim form (I forget the number of this form) to the opened damage case through USPS. This all had to be done in a certain period of time. In my particular the case, USPS confiscated the broken dish then the postal inspector just forgot to submit the form. So it was denied. Then I had to challenge their denial twice while calling USPS 800 number and also calling the local USPS location where the item was confiscated. It was a whole ordeal and I ended up getting a partial refund from them and they didn't even give me my shipping cost back. So I paid them to shatter my product and paid for extra insurance back then for them to just break it, take the broken pieces back, then give me some of my money back.
I've been a full time sellers for a very long time. I am very familiar with the USPS claims. Damage claims are very hard to get approved and take a lot of time and even then, they mostly get denied. Now lost claims they pay all the time.
The OP is talking about a hole in a jacket that wasn't caused by USPS. And even if it was, USPS wouldn't approve that. The buyer would have to surrender the packaging and the coat to the postal inspector. The coat has already been shipped back to the seller so it's a mute point. Again, shipping back the item in a return voids the damage claim automatically.
prettythingsamora
OPThe hole was done by buyer is why I won't refund..she did not receive it damaged and never mentioned the hole...fur coat under arm that didn't fit her
babyers88
@prettythingsamora your original posting was misleading, one would presume that the item had a hole in the packaging,
as such, you are going to have to take the L on this one. Otherwise ebay will send the refund themselves from your funds and hit you with a hard defect.
as the famous catchphrase from star trek and the borg "resistance is futile"
prettythingsamora
OPNot damaged in shipping...
tobaccocardyahoo
The buyer is going to get his refund.
Whether you are going to lose the item and give the refund or at least get the item back and your fees refunded requires you authorize the refund, provide a prepaid label and refund following the procedures for an Ebay return for Item Not As Described will determine what the outcome will be.
prettythingsamora
OPnot damaged in shipping
..was a coat she damaged under arm trying on..fur coat vintage..she said it didn't fit...she paid for return shipping but it is damaged...she is clearly wrong
.
lacemaker3
@prettythingsamora
I see one real fur coat that you sold recently, on Nov 30. A vintage mink coat which you said "HAS SOME WEAR IN SPOTS". It was listed with 30 day returns, buyer pays return shipping.
Sorry, but if the fur was showing visible wear, then the coat has not been maintained or stored properly, and that means that there was probably more damage than was visible. When a fur coat is not stored correctly and treated regularly to maintain the flexibility, the skin becomes brittle and fragile, and will start to tear with little to no pressure. Torn skin in the arms or under the arms are likely to happen, and it means that the coat is worn out and basically worthless. A coat in this condition can't be sewn or repaired, because the stitching will tear through the fragile skin. So it was not in Good condition, as you said, and was not as described.
Also fur coats require a LOT of ease, so if it measured 21" from armpit to armpit, as you said, that is NOT an XL (extra large). That coat would be considered a small or medium, as women's fur coats go.
When you accept returns, it means that you accept them for any reason or no reason at all. You have to give the refund, or you will not get your fee credit. There is no way for you to win this one, because the buyer was perfectly correct to send it back.
You were lucky that the buyer chose "didn't fit", a remorse return, and paid for the return shipping. They would have been well within their rights to say "not as described" because it was not in good condition, and was nott a size XL.
prettythingsamora
OPThanks for your reply....not the coat in question...had a fur collar...listed with dementions and no damage..
She said it didn't fit..I do no returns but agreed to for her..she paid..when I received it has a big hole under arm..I can not resell..showed her pictures of holes..NO comment..filed a claim to get a refund..can I just give her half refund for damage..I don't want ebay to step in..thanks
mtgraves7984
"... can I just give her half refund for damage..."
@prettythingsamora
I'll address this question. No, you can't deduct anything for the damage. Only TRS who offer (at least) 30-Day Returns or sellers who offer Free Returns can make that deduction. You are neither.
lacemaker3
@prettythingsamora,
OK, was it this one? If not, please post the item number.
That was sold almost 5 weeks ago, and you haven't received any feedback for it. You would have received automated feedback about 1 week after delivery, unless there was something to indicate that something went wrong with the transaction (like a return).
All of my comments about the problems with the all-mink coat listing also apply to this one. The dimensions given don't match a 2XL fur coat. From the style of this coat, it is at least 50 years old, probably closer to 60 or 70 years old. Fur coats don't last that long. For a comparison, the style of the all-mink coat says it was probably from the 1990's or 2000's, so it was about 25 to 30 years old, and many fur coats that old are fragile and easily damaged through normal handling.
As @mtgraves7984 said, you are not eligible to give a partial return. If you don't want eBay to step in and help, you will have to give the return yourself. If you do that, you will get a credit for the selling fees, but if eBay has to step in, you won't get the selling fees back.
jbbowers12012
Sadly , my friend I think that your hands are tied on this one. Agreed with everyone. Just refund. So sorry.
bonanza125
Refund the buyer in full and move on. Eat the cost. You will not win especially whenever Ebay steps in. You don't want Ebay stepping in. You are an active seller. Things like this happen. Write it off.
pickapaper
@prettythingsamora
You have been on eBay since 2012 and it sounds like you are not familiar with eBay's Money Back Guarantee which means you can have "no returns" on your listings but no returns does not mean no refunds. (eBay's policy overrides yours.) You can fight or refuse an "item not described" return but if a buyer has eBay step in, you will lose both your money and the item and get a ding on your account.
You will also find out that if you have no returns on your listings, most buyers know that you cannot refuse an "item not described" claim so they will sometimes damage an item just to be able to file a claim to get their money back. To avoid this, you are better off to have "returns accepted" on your listings; this gives buyers more confidence that they are not going to have to fight with you. If you get a claim filed against you, just accept it which will send the buyer a label (you are charged for the label) to return the item and when you receive it back, issue a refund. (Or if it's an inexpensive item not worth paying the return postage for, you can just refund the buyer and let them keep the item.)
prettythingsamora
OPThe buyer received the item in perfect condition..a coat..it didn't fit i don't do returns ..agreed to do return and she pay...received the item damaged..big hole under arm...which was never mentioned in any correspondence..then filed a claim when she clearly damaged item trying on...
.
12345jamesstamps
Everyone here who knows a lot is suggesting to do the refunds...I agree.
Even if you got a rock returned instead you still need to refund.
Artificial intelligence will signal a refund...emails, photos and any video will not be seen.
You can appeal...and usually eBay will charge an additional $20. if you lose.
These people who respond here know there stuff.
babyers88
sadly, as much as we would all like it to be. There is no such thing as "no returns" on ebay.
a buyer can return anything, no matter what they put as the reason or even no reason at all.
Fraudulent returns are covered by ebay, but it is still a "return" and you still have to go thru the process,
failing to refund will just result in ebay getting directly involved which will result in the customer getting refunded (from your funds) and (you) the seller get's a hard defect.
your only best hope is to get ebay involved before the timer times out, and that is strictly limited to fraud in pretty much all cases
klhmdg
Once the item is returned you refund.
Doesnt matter if it has a hole or not.
eBay doesnt look at photos.
Refund or eBay will do it for you.
If eBay refunds you will still pay the FVFs and get a seller defect on your account.
Please turn off your cap lock.
inhawaii
Pictures of the damage means nothing.
Refund the buyer.
Ebay will find on favor of the buyer.
Chalk it off as the price of doing business online.