Is this a good thing? We’re simplifying order cancellations
Hi ten_o_nine,
We're reaching out to let you know that today, we're launching an update that will simplify the order cancellation process for both sellers and buyers.
What's new
Buyers now have the option to request an order cancellation using the Cancel order button before the item is marked as shipped.
What sellers should know
•
You retain full control to either accept or decline cancellation requests
•
You’re protected from neutral or negative feedback for any cancellation requests made through our updated process, regardless of whether you accept or decline
•
You may notice a slight increase in cancellation requests, but should receive fewer direct messages from buyers inquiring about cancellations
•
In prior tests, this change resulted in a minimal increase in cancellation requests (maintaining an overall average cancellation rate of 1%, with an increase from .9 out of 100 transactions to 1.1 out of 100 transactions), and a notable 25% improvement in buyer satisfaction, which led to a higher likelihood of repeat purchases
For a detailed overview of these changes, please visit our eBay Community page.
Thanks for being part of the eBay community.
ten_o_nine
OPI just wonder if this will lead sellers to hit the "ship" button as soon as the order is received and could lead to issues with buyer satisfaction with site, I am a buyer too.
gurlcat
I just really appreciate that they shared their test data at the end there, never seen that before here. It feels cringe-y to whip out muh "As a scientist, I ....." but I am a former biologist so I am very keen on experimental procedures and findings. I don't see any reason why eBay couldn't share the fruits of their labor for anyone who's curious, and those who aren't don't have to read it. Hopefully this is a sign of transparency to come!
ten_o_nine
OPSo, can the buyer leave feedback not related to cancelling the order? and can they file a return for INAD or other situations without the ability to leave feedback?
femmefan1946
If an Auction purchase is cancelled in that "before shipped" period, does the Auction automatically move the winning bid to the underbidder or does the Auction end without a winning bidder?
I can see problems with either scenario.
Another reason why I don't use Auctions.
dbfolks166mt
If an Auction purchase is cancelled in that "before shipped" period, does the Auction automatically move the winning bid to the underbidder or does the Auction end without a winning bidder?
I can see problems with either scenario.
Another reason why I don't use Auctions.
I would think this would be no different than it is currently when you cancel an auction order. I use the auction format almost exclusively and currently when I cancel an order based on buyer request I can, if I so choose, extend a second chance offer to the next highest bidder if there was one. I generally do not use that option and simply relist the item just as I would if I was doing BIN orders.
gurlcat
I've never had anyone accept the Second Chance offer. Granted I've needed to try it only a few times because of cancellations, but it really surprised me that it didn't work, particularly when the second-highest bidder had been a steady nibbler for days and was only beaten by a sniper by a buck or two. Seems like they'd jump at the chance -I know I sure have barely-lost lots of auctions that I wanted so bad I would have been thrilled.
inhawaii
The only good thing I can think about by simplifying order cancellations is ... i'd rather cancel an order than handle a return.
selsa84
What's odd is I've had more cancelled orders and non payments in 2 years than I had for 12 years. 99% were buyers with very low feedback.
12345jamesstamps
I think it can be a good thing.
Canceling your order...puts that buyer on my blocked list from future purchases.
monkamoo1
I dont mind cancelling if it is a short time between order and request, but some of my stuff has a longer lead time and I have to pay for it and will not cancel in that case. Ebay should realize that a small seller is not Amazon.com. I am neutral on it only since they say we are protected from negative feedback if I deny the request. We will see.
dbfolks166mt
I dont mind cancelling if it is a short time between order and request, but some of my stuff has a longer lead time and I have to pay for it and will not cancel in that case. Ebay should realize that a small seller is not Amazon.com. I am neutral on it only since they say we are protected from negative feedback if I deny the request. We will see.
Such are the perils of drop shipping.
thetexasbandit
I have not read all the replies, but headed over here to voice my opinion. Thank you for beating me to the punch.
I think this is all in reaction to sellers like myself who object to 52 other ads , from other sellers, being put on to an ad for my product, considering that I paid for the ad, and the other 52 ads are from users paying the higher promoted listing fees. I clicked on a few of the ones on my ads, and I am sure they are leading the potential customers away from my listing, and to sellers that pay promoted at 10 % to 16 %. How these sellers can stay in business at that rate, plus paying for a store, plus paying for FVF, and shipping fees, when ebay gives them a break on shipping while you pay USPS the traditional business discount, is beyond me. I ramble. I have found that in my business 3% still gets me a very small piece of the game, and when I do get a sale , I keep a large dollar amount of the sale. I am actually making more money, IE: cash deposits into my bank , doing less work, retaining my status on inventory numbers, than I did at 10%. And do not even get me started on Promoted Advanced.... has Ebay ever listed where they were going to spend your $100 ? On Google ? I can place my own ads on Google, why would I pay Ebay to do it , when there is no accountability that I have seen to where the money goes..... Now , back to our regular shenanigans.....
alien_strings
Guess I must be crazy. I always thought you didn't bid to win or hit buy it now unless you were responsible enough to follow through with the transaction. Building off of that idea, I see this as eBay coddling deadbeat buyers.
luckythewinner
Based on years and years of posts on this board complaining about non-payment, I would say that what you "always thought" has never been accurate.
gurlcat
Years and years? -They literally joined today. Welcome alien_strings!

kensgiftshop
Maybe after they win an auction or buy the item, they decide they don't want a fake guitar and want to cancel the order and buy a real one.
gurlcat
He put 'FAKE' in the title ..... twice. Come on.
the-hook-and-the-loop
eBay has specialized in cancelled and lost sales. They know nothing about increasing sales.
gurlcat
Buyer satisfaction has everything to do with increasing sales. Imagine someone comes here for the first time and buys something, then realizes they need to cancel (for whatever reason -let's just be empathic for a minute and say a LEGIT reason, one you could picture having yourself) ...... but unlike other sites they are used to, they see nothing they can click to cancel as quickly as possible. Maybe then they panic and try to find a way to reach eBay, and you know how THAT goes. But then someone tells them, or they guess, the best shot is to hit the Contact Seller button and write out a message request. Then they hear nothing back and next thing they know, they get a notification saying their item has shipped.
If that's their view of how user-unfriendly the eBay platform is, why would they ever come back and buy again?
meme6253
As long as they stick to their word about being protected from neutral & negative feedback, Then i don't for see any major problems with it, But they have gone back on their word plenty of times with other things, we will just have to wait & see.
gregmm
When a customer asks to cancel we do it straight away. But I do a lot of fright and sometimes it is a lot of work getting it ready to go. Few cancel but it could be somewhat of a pain if it did happen. and now we have no say in it. It takes a few days to get it shipper lined up with all the docs. So They could cancel after we line up with the shipper and pack everything then palatalize it. I do not see this as a issue over all but could be at times.
gurlcat
mamacassidy
Yes, this is a good thing.
I'd much rather someone change their mind and cancel BEFORE I send an order out than have to deal with a return. Especially if they were really unhappy and claimed the return was INR.
gurlcat
Agree 100% but (for future reference) I think you meant INAD (Item Not As Described). -INR is for Item Not Received.
mamacassidy
yes, thank you, that's what I meant!
I'm new to these community discussion boards, and I'm still learning. I've been a casual buyer/ seller on ebay for many years, but only within the last year have I had a store and a real 'business'.
gurlcat
Hey, welcome! Insider tip: come HERE immediately rather than try to contact eBay whenever you have a problem. The saddest thing is how many of these threads are by furious/devastated sellers describing what just happened because they thought they did everything right (often based on bad CSR advice) and ended up with terrible consequences ..... and it's too late for any of our advice to do any good. The vast majority of things I needed to learn as a new seller, I learned here from these wonderful folks.
r_lresale
The cancel button doesn't make a difference to me but sounds like a good thing for buyers who have been complaining that sellers either didn't see or was ignoring cancellation request messages.
Protection from negative/neutral feedback for sellers is a good thing since complaints of buyers leaving negs after they asked to cancel.
I think it's a win for both sellers & buyers but we will see how it goes.
rosszonebricks
I don't get that many cancellations, but usually it's because they caught they entered a wrong address, or actually wanted to cancel and order more.
However, as long as they actually stick to this, guess it's 'wait and see' on the real-world low-down on how this goes.
You’re protected from neutral or negative feedback for any cancellation requests made through our updated process, regardless of whether you accept or decline
yuzuha
Yeah, every single cancellation I've had in the past year has been a "Oh no, I forgot to change the address before I checked out" one. I relisted the item and they repurchased it with the correct shipping address.
femmefan1946
I had one US buyer cancel when they realized I was not in the USA.
Since I have Free Shipping to both USA and Canada this seemed odd to me.
Especially since it usually costs more to ship to Canada than to the States.
femmefan1946
The second point, about negative feedback, is a Good Thing.
The rest I suspect will mostly effect those who are emotionally involved with selling and have hurt feelings when a customer puts the sweater back on the rack, or leaves the cereal at the cashier's stand.