Is this a bad attempt at a scam? I'm really confused.
In early April, a buyer ordered and I shipped the next day, like I always do. Tracking showed when it was shipped. Two weeks later, the package had not arrived. She filed a claim, and sure enough, tracking showed that it was still in transit. Two weeks is absurd to travel two states. So I refunded her, told her I was very sorry, and also told her to keep the product if it ever showed up. The loss didn't hurt me. I refunded her on April 20.
Fast forward to tonight, an I receive a rather tart message telling me that she was "highly disappointed." She said she received a necklace, but she had ordered something else.
I replied that I don't sell or ship necklaces, so there must be a mistake and I'd look into it. She immediately replied with multiple images of my packing slip and a very cheap necklace that I've never seen before. She claims that the necklace was in the package.
I replied again with apologies, and also an image of the receipt where I refunded her money on April 20. She immediately replied again, telling me that she's not lying (I never even implied that she was lying). But before I could reply to her again, two more messages came in, each more indignant than the last.
I have no idea what's going on here. She got her money back over two weeks ago. I would think this was some kind of bad attempt at a scam, except that tracking shows that the original package actually was delivered today. A full month AFTER I shipped it.
Has anyone ever heard of anything like this happening? Since she keeps messaging me, I finally asked her to describe the package that she received. All of my packages are identical. Black bubble mailers with a large Thank You sticker over the seal. You have to tear through the sticker to open the mailer. She had to have received something in order to have my packing slip. But I can't stress enough how impossible it is that the package I shipped could have contained a silver beaded chain. I've never even owned anything like that.
huntfishdie45
Yes, we just had a similar case come across these boards. Your package was probably switched out somewhere in the postal system. They put a copy of your shipping label on a cheap item so tracking can't pinpoint what hub the theft took place. When the buyer gets the package, they blame the seller for the mistake and ebay sides with the seller because it looks like you mixed up orders or sent the wrong item. Your buyer could be frustrated and being truthful at the same time. You have already refunded so the buyer will not get her free item. Not your fault, I don't think the buyer has a leg to stand on here so don't worry about it. The original item you sent is long gone.
fabledcrow
OPThanks to everyone who replied. I learned something from all of your responses. She stopped replying last night after I said I didn't think there was anything more that I could do to help her. If she drops a negative feedback on me, I'll leave a response for it. Statistically speaking, it's bound to happen sooner or later.
mam98031
NO. If she hits your FB, you fight it. It is highly likely you will be able to get it removed, so DON'T respond to it. Come back and tell us and let us walk you through the process.
fabledcrow
OPOk, will do. So far so good, though. No feedback left yet. She fell silent after my message telling her that there was nothing more I could do since I had already refunded her money. Hopefully that will be the end of it. Thank you. 🙂
ms.rodriguez*
If you get the negative, you call ebay and ask them to read the emails. Ebay knows what you sold her. It's obvious that she is either a moron or has you confused with another seller. The negative is removable.
Make sure that you block her.
pennysdream
I have one foot in each side.
One foot, Tell her your sorry that this happened to her, and attach a photo of the item she actually bought.
The other foot, At this point just ignore her and block her.
mam98031
@fabledcrow
"In early April, a buyer ordered and I shipped the next day, like I always do. Tracking showed when it was shipped. Two weeks later, the package had not arrived. She filed a claim, and sure enough, tracking showed that it was still in transit. Two weeks is absurd to travel two states. So I refunded her, told her I was very sorry, and also told her to keep the product if it ever showed up. The loss didn't hurt me. I refunded her on April 20. "
This is where the problem started. You don't need to do this at this time nor should you. Shipments get slowed down ALL THE TIME. It isn't an unusual thing at all.
If you shipped with USPS, the first thing I do is go to the USPS website, call up the tracking on the time, there is a place where you can sign up to get email notifications for any movement or activity on the tracking.
Then I go and file for a TRACE on the package. After that I go to the INR that buyer opened and email them FROM the INR. I apologize to them for the delay and I let them know I have filed a trace on the package. It typically takes USPS 48-72 hours to respond, but as soon as I have new info I will share it with you.
The INR will stay open for a few days which gives you time to see if you can get the package moving whether it is with USPS or some other carrier. Then if there is an entry that happens on the tracking Ebay will extend the INR to stay open for another week or so.
Have you viewed the tracking on this package recently. If you haven't, you should. And if it is a USPS shipment, sign up for the email updates on movement.
You are correct it is odd that the buyer is having this reaction. It sounds a bit like they are new at this and the guilt may be getting to them. If also suggests that maybe they have the package now, but you won't know until you look at that tracking.
albertabrightalberta
Did you try to trace back through her feedback (from sellers) to see if she may have purchased the necklace from another seller?
Something similar happened to me a number of years ago and I found the listing the buyer had purchased and sent a link telling her that this is the listing of item she thinks she bought from me but actually bought from someone else. Also send her a link to the item she bought from you.
inhawaii
In my opinion it doesn't mattet what she ordered and what she received being the she got a full refund. I would just ignore her. I beleive she will still be able to leave negative feedback but i wouldn't worry about it unless it happens. Good luck!
chapeau-noir
Does she have you confused with another seller? Including mixing up packing slips and merchandise? I had a buyer once who was so mixed up that she couldn't keep anything straight and would send me also tart notes about the wrong merchandise that began making no sense. Also, she was one of those people who can never be wrong. She had everything she had purchased from me, and I finally just stopped communicating.
I use those black bubblers and you can't get into them without obvious damage.
Anyway, that's all I can think of - you made her whole and didn't make her fight about it, I think you've done due diligence and used great CS.
fabledcrow
OPI wondered about that -- about her receiving multiple packages and confusing one with another. But dang, it would be hard to mix mine up with something else. What she ordered from me was a bottle of bright green oil with my brand label on the bottle. It says Fabled Crow Apothecarium right on the bottle, and it takes an act of Congress to get the label off the bottle. There's no way it can just fall off. Oy. I suppose she can't leave feedback since she got her money back. But for all of the amazing buyers I have, the rare one that makes a racket really worries me.
chapeau-noir
There are some people who purchase a lot, or may have purchased a ton of stuff at once and start confusing their packages - particularly if it took a month to arrive after you shipped it. I tend to be a little absent minded about some things and periodically something will arrive in the mail and I will have forgotten I even ordered it, then oh yeah, that's right, I did.
fashunu4eeuh
â€I suppose she can't leave feedback since she got her money back...â€
No, she will be able to leave feedback. A refund doesn’t negate it.
Sorry you ran into this sad soul, but you handled this beautifully. She is obviously confused, i’d say, as opposed to being an outright scammer. Since you already refunded her, there is nothing more that you could have done.
The fact that she already received a refund seems lost on her— you made her whole, she is not out anything regardless of what arrived. So I would not hesitate in putting her on my block list—and i don’t say that lightly. (There are only four or five IDs i have blocked over the last 12 years…) There are quite a number of lost souls out there. You’ve done what is reasonable and more, showed superb customer service. Block and move on.
soh.maryl
What makes you think she can't leave feedback because she got her money back?
mam98031
I don't think that is what she said. She said "If she drops a negative feedback on me, I'll leave a response for it. Statistically speaking, it's bound to happen sooner or later. "
dy60609
I suppose she can't leave feedback since she got her money back. But for all of the amazing buyers I have, the rare one that makes a racket really worries me.
-----------------------
seems that it is exactly what she said....................................................
mam98031
Not her most recent post, and the one you quoted was a question.
soh.maryl
OP's message 3/16: "I believe she can't leave feedback since she got her money back."
mam98031
OMG, you find this to be something to argue about??!?!? In post 10 and 12 the OP notes that the buyer can leave FB and she is waiting to see if she does.
As often happens as a thread grows, we learn things. It is no different for the OP.
dy60609
Let me break this down to make it clearer
OP Post #3 ... "Oy. I suppose she can't leave feedback since she got her money back"
soh.maryl Post # 13 replying to that post (not some post hours later down the line) "What makes you think she can't leave feedback because she got her money back? "
you post #14 "I don't think that is what she said." ..................... Well, again, that is exactly what the OP posted........................the OP's post #3 clearly indicated that she supposed the buyer could not leave feedback. Replying to that post, maryl asked why she thought that. You "challenge" the maryl post.
You are not looking at what posts people are replying to.
maryl was replying to post #3....................... not post #10, or post #12. That has been pointed out twice.
Not arguing here...................................... your post #14 was the post that was in error, but at this point you are trying to make the rest of us look like fools.
My post ( # 15) was a reply to "your post" (#14) which was a reply to maryl post (#13).
Your reply to me, post (# 16) "Not her most recent post, and the one you quoted was a question" makes no sense at all. Nobody was referencing the OP's latest post. You are basing some replies on where the thread has progressed to rather that what the posts of others are addressing.
The post that "I" quoted was not a question.................................................... There were no questions in post # 14. Post # 14 is the one that I quoted.
This is going nowhere, other than the typical "deflection of an error", and as it has wandered a bit of topic, so as there will be no acceptance of facts I will refrain from any further exercise in futility.
rugerskick
Yeah she may have gotten your stuff mixed up with other orders. Unfairly taking it out on you.