I am done with eBay after 24 years.
The time has come where I have removed my listings and closed my shop. I had a buyer misuse returns, I had alerted eBay from day one she was. Received the return on the 8th (Sat), RECORDED me opening it on the 9th (Sunday), contacted eBay TUES the 11th, only to see the return complete on the 13th. Called CS again, they forwarded it to the care dept. I get a response in an hour, only to tell me I had to contact them within 2 business days and I didn't. Funny? I have the email in my inbox asking to rate "how did we do" on Feb 11th @ 3pm after I had called and spoke with Anna, who btw had a rooster crowing in the background. But they also suggested I have free returns on my listings as this will increase sales. UHHHHH, All my listings have this, including the one in question. (which just makes me feel like they are giving generic responses and not doing their job.)
The buyer returned the item damaged, put the earrings UNDER the cotton of the jewelry box, so they shifted around on the carboard, scratching the surface. One of the earrings was missing a battery. Both earrings were turned on to engage the led feature and the safety tabs were not included.
I reply back explaining that I did contact on the 11th and even rated my experience with the agent. Only for them to reply that I did not contact them.
I have pulled ALL my listings, I have closed my shop and will withdraw everything. I'm done. I've also rated them on BBB and filed a complaint about their service.
Ebay was never like this. I can't even say as a seller they are failing, they failed me as a buyer too. And in all my years, this is the 2nd time ever I have ever have a buyer misuse returns, but eBay is catering to their bad behavior as well. (Seller said it was XL, got it, the size was wrong, contacted seller, they said I should have asked for measurements prior to buying. -**bleep**?- Open return, seller closed it out. Call eBay and they said I should have called them as now there's nothing they could do. Huh? **bleep** if you ask me and I was out $150. (I don't know why it was bleeped. I didn't swear but maybe used acronyms?)
When I had expressed they would be charged a restock fee, as they had used the product, they became upset and said if I do, they would leave me a neg feedback, that is extortion, clear as day, and anytime I have encountered that, ebay pulled the review. This time? Nope. Leaving it but it won't count against me.
Also, this buyer has sold 400 items and doesn't have one review from a buyer, but you can see her feedback she left reviews for buyers.
Either way, I just hope it was worth it for them. I have 2K followers just on FB alone that I haven't made a post about this. My Dad and my oldest daughter will be pulling their shops as well. My following is growing on Bluesky, but am waiting till I hit 1K to make a post, which should be in a few days.
I imagine I am not the only seller they are mistreating and not doing their due diligence to research what has transpired on my account. eBay is on the fast track to crashing and burning. And if they are doing this to me, only a matter of time before it happens to you.
It makes me sad that this is how it ends after 24 years, but I simply can not support a company that is this terrible when it comes to support. (while this account says 16 years, I had another account I had used previously that was my buying turned into selling account, but created this one to keep them separate, but last several years I don't bother with the other account and solely use this one. Other account had at least 2k feedback. I will find that other account and pull it too.)
I'm also feeling I should reach out to my local news. As the BBB asked me if I am ok with being contacted by news media and I said Yes, this really needs to be brought attention to.
BYYYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
gloryglorygifts
Did you actually report the buyer for misuse of the return process? If you didn't, I suggest that you do.
gloryglorygifts
BBB is a two-way street. Your buyer can write things about you on there too just fyi, and they can see this thread too, by googling your profile name.
Your local news is not going to care one iota, but I guess you can try.
Good luck to you in your future endeavors.
annadryl
Yes, return abuse or misuse is inevitable in selling, but getting only two shady returns in two decades is awesome! Look at it from the Costco perspective, they probably get two returns in two minutes, for ANY reason!
fbusoni
@annadryl
And it turns out that it was the OP's insistence that the buyer be charged for replacement batteries ($1.79?) that precipitated this entire imbroglio.
Really, this stuff cannot be made up. LMAO
gurlcat
I think the most revealing line in the OP is “And if they are doing this to me, only a matter of time before it happens to you†like she’s the high water mark, unthinkable that she wasn’t entitled to withhold as much of the refund as she wanted, but apparently eBay just recently got so lousy even she is not immune. In reality it was just unimaginably good luck she didn’t have a buyer “misuse†returns before in 24 years ….. not that the 24 years themselves should cushion her from the same MBG policy that affects us all the same whether it’s a first sale or the ten-thousandth.
Seems like any time you see the seller’s number of years in the thread title, you know what’s coming…..
But here’s something I’ve never seen anyone bring up before: what about buyers? Do they get any kind of reward or special treatment for number of years or purchases they’ve made? No, lol. So really it’s only fair that eBay treats every transaction with no regard to either party’s timeline.
fbusoni
@gurlcat
Laughing out loud here at the "high water mark" reference.
Almost all of the threads in these fora are fascinating to me because of how they reveal, reflect or otherwise illuminate the human condition... the eBay dimension of things is often of only marginal interest.
But apropos of your last point... eBay definitely lives "in the moment" when it wants to.
Other times, eBay is a veritable historian -- especially when it comes time to mete out the ultimate, account-terminating punishment.
And no... I do not think that if it happens to the OP, it is a matter of time before it happens to me... I am not chomping at the bit, waiting to close my seller account because I intend to charge a nutty buyer $1.79 for a pack of replacement batteries!
oldwestcoins
I have been on here for 25 years under my main eBay account. It took me a while, but you must think like a business. When I got down in the dumps over a bad buyer or transaction, I always asked myself, "What would Walmart do?" You will only succeed IF you do not take things personally. You cannot allow one bad transaction to void 3,000 positive ones. If you can't do that, pack it in, as you will never successfully run a business anywhere. That includes Bluesky.
plumber162000
I too am also losing confidence in selling on eBay. I had a buyer leave negative feedback on an item they bought. Stating the description was deceptive and the photos were bad. Well to make this short I was not and did not try to hide anything. 19 photos of the item inside and out. The description was clear. They replied siding with the buyer. I also believe AI is being used in their response now. Don't know how long I will hang in there. Been a member for about 24 years now myself.
pf9000
You just need to charge a little more to account for losses. That's what retailers do. It's the cost of doing business.
johnrj1226
In baseball or softball it's 3 strikes and your out not 1. Of course, one can foul off as many pitches as they can before getting a hit, or get hit by a pitch or get ball four. Same thing in life and selling.
In conclusion, "One robin does never makes a springtime." and "Life is not fair get used to it."
jewelbiz
John,
“One robin does never makes a springtime."
I saw this Robin March 22 last year and took this pix while walking in Central Park.
It sure did make me very
happy to see it! Right now it’s 30 degrees outside but feels like 12 degrees.
Spring will be welcome here whenever it comes.
Thank you ðŸ™
jerseyboymusic
All this drama for what looks to be a $36 transaction?
pickapaper
@fbusoniwrote: "In my opinion, your observation goes to the very heart of the issue at the center of this entire discussion. What one sells on eBay will, to a very great degree, determine what sort of buyers one attracts."
OP has found a niche market selling to Cos Play people. (Basically, that is adults dressing up in costumes and accessories to resemble a fictional character, often sci-fi, anime, comics, etc.) I don't understand it but I know a lot of people are into that. According to OP, she has made a lot of money with this and I don't doubt it. But she should understand that not every transaction is going to go perfectly. She has had a very good run on eBay but is now letting one bad $35 experience end her selling here. It's too bad that she feels that way.
lux.ra_14
A disgruntled eBay seller is not news.
getouttaheah
25 years and they are doing this to me too. I've had it! Not the first time they burned me. This time, I sold a non-working for parts only laptop and the buyer says he wants to return it because swollen battery (which is a LIE) and "other factors". No images, no proof of any kind. eBay wants me to give this jerk his money back. $120 sale and I only received $80, after being taxed, feed, sending expense WITH A FEE ON THE SHIPPING. And they want the $80 back and money for a label for the jacka$$??? I've removed all my listings too. As soon as I can, I'm off eBay. They don't deserve the time of day from any of us.
lakefor94
@getouttaheah
Selling any type of junk that does not work is risky business and it does not matter how it is described. Listing items that do not work is just begging for a return.
I have learned to just recycle or throw away the junk. I know it is hard to do when you "think" it is worth something. Junk is best parted with, unless sold locally for cash. Even then, can be a hassle.
getouttaheah
That is just not true at all. I have sold many, many laptops and small electronics that were no longer working as designed. It is useful for repair shops to find parts that may be difficult to find or not being made at all anymore. It keeps the stuff out of landfill, better than recycling it. All recycling is, is is throwing it out. This is the 1st time I ever had it happen. But it's not the 1st time I've had a buyer swindle me and ebay backed that up. There is no such thing as seller protection anymore.
fbusoni
@getouttaheah
It seems to me that the introduction of the eBay money back guarantee (2008?) fundamentally changed the selling landscape here.
I too have been here for 26 years and because I know that on eBay the customer is always right, I have built into my selling model a way to ensure that I can more than cover losses from dishonest buyers.
Thus far, as a result of a very deliberate selling strategy (and some luck), I have not had a bad experience like yours.
But if I had the courage to sell non-working or non-functional items (or --LMFAO -- things like battery-powered LED earrings that are supposed to rotate and provide a light show) to the general public I'd never allow myself to be driven off the platform because eBay refused to get involved in a small-value dispute for the simple reason that that is not what eBay does.
lakefor94
@getouttaheah
When ebay rolled out Seller Metrics, that is when I stopped selling anything that does not work or can't be tested appropriately. That matters more to an account that is fulltime selling.
You only sell something now and then on the account you posted with. I suppose an INAD does not matter.
I give away the old laptops that come my way to a gal I know that sells at the flea. Probably have given her a dozen over the years. I don't want to deal with the imminent returns on some of them and the dings for INAD cases in Seller Metrics.
rugerskick
Sorry to see you leave. Maybe consider in the future selling certain items that are lower risk, here. Sometimes its a matter of some items just seeming to do better on certain sites than others. I know you have more issues you stated than just this, so I get it if thats no longer a feasible choice for you. We all have different breaking points, and sometimes an incident is the last straw. This one was yours. Hope you have success in the other places you're on.
I think its just geting harder for sellers no matter where we are, the scammers just keep scamming and the sites in general do not give two squirts about sellers being defrauded.
sodelight
So earrings have batteries now!! 😲
fbusoni
@sodelight
In my opinion, your observation goes to the very heart of the issue at the center of this entire discussion.
What one sells on eBay will, to a very great degree, determine what sort of buyers one attracts.
Ergo, some forethought is definitely required before opening a selling account.
meme6253
I wish we all had crystal balls to give us the inventory answer!
femmefan1946
@fbusoni said
What one sells on eBay will, to a very great degree, determine what sort of buyers one attracts.
There is a "criminal demographic". --Male, 15-35-- that is overwhelmingly seen in trouble with the law.
If it appeals to that person, don't sell it.
meme6253
Some actually do.
oldwestcoins
My earrings have batteries. They are called hearing aids. 😋
slati_2013
If you are upset about one item, think about how stores like Amazon feel. All sellers here each have at least one transaction each year that costs them money and they write off as the cost of doing business. Don't let one buyer run you off eBay.
jbbowers12012
Hi, I would like to respectfully suggest that you re-think this exit. You have likely put in a lot of time - sweat - blood & tears during your selling career at eBay. I am sure that you stressed over many things over the years. But, you were always able to ride it out - rising to the top once again. It would seem a shame to me to just walk-away over one transaction gone sideways and a bit of mistreatment by eBay. You are better than that & you have shown it. IMHO Of-Course! Good Luck! (J.B. From N.J.)
pls-consignments
I completely agree. Having the expectation that eBay (now a publicly owned company) would remain the same as they did 20+ years ago, is like expecting your adult children to fit into their elementary school clothes. I too have been doing this for 26 yrs. EVERYTHING has changed, especially morals, ethics, honesty and greed. None of us are immune to these changes including eBay. The playing field has changed as well as the rules. Its up to us to adapt. Please take a few days off, and reconsider. 😉
vintagecraze50
I run around the house screaming for about 1 hour after a bad buyer experience, then remember all the good ones I have had in 20 years.
adamcartwright
@cybsara
I think you've acted in haste and cut off your nose to spite your face.
isaiah53-57
@cybsara
Yeahhhh... too bad you didnt come here earlier to get the advise from full time posters who sell a pittance here, brag that they are happy to be ebay sellers because they don't have to go to a REAL job on a snow day(how do you live?), complain sales suck when convenient, yet all the while TELLING YOU they got it in the bag and this place is paradise...
Likely the only truly helpful post here is from @albertabrightalberta - Good information the seller could use and likely is unaware of - Maybe even give him or her seconds thoughts on leaving - Nice Job!
hartungcards
Thanks for that truly helpful post.
buyselljack2016
24 years and you have been burned a couple of times. You have lived a charmed existence on eBay.
Been here 24 myself. I would be beaming with delight if I had only had such few issues.
Best wishes in your future endeavors, but as others, I just don't understand.
hartungcards
When your rooster crows at the break of dawn, look out your window and I'll be gone.
femmefan1946
after I had called and spoke with Anna, who btw had a rooster crowing in the background.
I've spoken with her!
She doesn't work for eBay.
She works as an outsourced rep for a subcontractor.
The phone reps have a terrible reputation for getting you off the phone as soon as possible even if that means giving you the advice you want to hear instead of the advice you need to have.
Here are your options for contacting Ebay Customer Service. Please be aware that for social media CS, you send them a Private Message and briefly explain what your problem or issue is. Feel free to leave your Name, address, phone number and/or your email address in this message. It is private and secure and it may help to speed up the response for you.

https://www.facebook.com/ebay— Message button in upper right on landing page.
#204760888466
https://www.instagram.com/ebayforsellers/

https://community.ebay.com/t5/Selling/How-do-I-contact-Customer-Support/m-p/32016431#M1783851 -> Automated Assistant, type AGENT -> enter. You will then get more options.


The social media Chat accounts are covered by trained eBay employees with some authority.
And you get a transcript so you can compare what you heard with what you were told.
It seems like a lot of drama for a $50 refund that is only the second in 24 years.
powell-collectibles
I don’t get it. Is this a well-known seller? Highly unique items that draw people into eBay? I feel like I’ve missed part of the plot. Otherwise, is this just a spoof post?
gurlcat
OP said she’s made many contributions to this Community but the profile shows only one reply made In 2019. Maybe another identity, but then why use this one to make the big goodbye rant?
onefootflipper
Different people place the blame very differently when it comes to ebay problems.
When I have a problem customer on ebay I place the fault on the customer, not on ebay. Ebay has to basically always side with the buyers, if it didn't then no one would shop on ebay because it would be scam seller central.
So you have sold 2000 pairs of those earrings on ebay over the years and had one bad experience. Even being conservative in my estimates I figure you made $40,000 on them and will likely make another $40,000 off them in the future and most of those lost future ebay sales are not going to show up in increased sales on Amazon or etsy, they are just going to be lost.
I am actually surprised a Chinese factory hasn't copied your design yet and started selling it for $2 shipped.
hartungcards
And when we come back from this commercial break, a story you won't believe. A seller on eBay has been burned for the first time ever. Don't touch that dial.
oldwestcoins
HA ha. That's cold, but funny. I won't touch the dial.
vintagecraze50
You do understand that every buyer on here including the really bad one’s have at their disposal on all website to start a chargeback. Every website has to cater to the really bad one’s and experience losses one way or another with this type of customer. Ebay has little to no control over these buyers behaviors when they run to a credit card. You will encounter probably as many of your two bad customers anywhere you go.
luckythewinner
Ebay was never like this.
As far as returns are involved, eBay has been like this since 2008 when the introduced the Money Back Guarantee for buyers.
meme6253
Enjoy your retirement!, Sometimes it's that one thing that breaks the camels back, I have come close on a few occasions, Good Luck to you!
tobadger
Agree, that's the way it happened to me after 26 years here. Let it be known that eBay doesn't always keep its word. My explanation is too long to repeat here. I had many good transactions and in person visits before (Mis)Managed Payments came along, but those days are gone.
onefootflipper
Absolutely nothing changed for me when it switched over to managed payments (and that was a changeover that was phased in over years). What exactly happened to you?
tobadger
"What exactly happened to you?"
I looked for my posting about my incident, and it seems to have magically disappeared. Imagine that! Anyway, it was a couple of short paragraphs that are too time consuming to retype completely. Essentially, they held my money captive even though I wasn't required to supply my tax info at that time. In hindsight, I should have let them keep the money and deal with it themselves. It ended my selling career here, and limited my purchases to a very low level. Not a happy camper now.
gurlcat
Do you have another account you might have written the incident post with? The only reason it would have been deleted is if it violated community policies, and those do not include simply posting outrage about an eBay decision, bad buyers, etc.
tobadger
"Do you have another account you might have written the incident post with?"
Nope, one account only. I suspect that somebody just didn't like seeing it. The truth hurts. Only one person in a thousand will care about my experience or even remember it. It's past history now. eBay made their move and I've moved on.
bonjourami
Be unusual for Ebay to pull any post, as they dont monitor the boards, Khoros does. And as long as the posts remain within their guidelines, no matter what is said about Ebay, they remain.You may be overestimating the importance of your post. As Ebay doesnt give a rats behind about a sellers opinion of them.
fashunu4eeuh
Hi @cybsara Sorry for your trouble. eBay has its downside to be sure. But that’s not all of what is going on here. It sounds like you ran afoul of the Money Back Guarantee policy. Hate to say that is not the only one affecting your account, as revealed in your narrative.
Your post is a cautionary tale on why having a foundation rooted in knowing the rules that govern the site is imperative to a seller’s success on eBay. Without it, one cannot make the most advantageous decisions on how to best protect one’s interests.
@cybsara wrote:
â€Ebay was never like this.
It may be that your experience here has not brought you into contact with the fact that eBay has been like this. The rules for the MBG have been essentially the same for years now.
@cybsara wrote:
â€I can't even say as a seller they are failing, they failed me as a buyer too. And in all my years, this is the 2nd time ever I have ever have a buyer misuse returns,..â€
Pardon me for noting that it appears it was the unfamiliarity with the MBG terms that caused the failure. Had you applied within the window of opportunity (the timeframe is outlined in the policy), you likely would have received a full refund. (You were deserving of one if the seller gave you the wrong size info.) eBay’s Money Back Guarantee is one of the most buyer-centric benefits of any online retailer, but you still have to file it according to its terms.
FYI: Recording one’s packing or unpacking is not evidence accepted by eBay because it is not reliable. Such activity is easily manipulated, especially now with AI.
â€When I had expressed they would be charged a restock fee, as they had used the product, they became upset…â€
Restocking fees per se are no longer allowed on eBay, but there is a policy for items being returned in an altered state, depending on the circumstances.
But there is another factor. If you offer Free Returns, you are obligated contractually to remit a full refund to the buyer. You cannot pick and choose how to refund. The buyer claimed the earrings were initially received with missing parts. Why did you refuse a return—i assume that was the catalyst for the buyer reaching out to eBay. And rightly so.
How did the buyer misuse the return? You did not mention what the initial concern was that prompted the buyer to invoke a claim. But it is clear in the feedback that you chose to believe the buyer was lying, rather than accepting them at their word. And, again, with Free Returns (as you state you have on all your listings) there is no room for discussion or negotiation. The reason a buyer returns an item has no bearing on the amount of the refund. The buyer can return an item for any reason or no reason for a complete refund, and you offer 30-day Free Returns.
@cybsara wrote:
â€I imagine I am not the only seller they are mistreating and not doing their due diligence to research what has transpired on my account.â€
Due diligence was not accomplished, but it was not just eBay who failed to do so in this case. As for mistreatment, as far as can be measured in the post, it sounds like you were treated like a responsible seller who gave their tacit consent to follow the rules set up by eBay but then did not heed them. Every seller agrees to these policies by the act of listing their first item.
Had you been aware of the rules, the consequences would have been entirely different.
12345jamesstamps
Life can be hard sometimes.
To have one buyer make me stop selling...never.
I have had a few hiccups along the road.
Not everyone will be 100% honest.
There is very very limited customer service... knew that long ago.
I say go back to selling those great items you have for sale.
fbusoni
@12345jamesstamps
Excellent perspective.
fbusoni
@cybsara
Madam, eBay is not on the fast track to crashing and burning... is that why you closed your account? Because you do not wish to be caught up in the imaginary maelstrom you seem to anticipate?
As for other sellers having the misfortune to experience eBay's dismal lack of support... yes, many have, and just as many have taken preemptive steps to ensure to the extent possible that they do not run afoul of / remain insulated from nutty buyers. (By carefully selecting what categories we sell in, for example.)
I suspect that if the news media is responsible, they will ask why -- during a presumably successful 17 year selling run on eBay, during which you surely must have made profit sufficient to offset the loss of a cheap pair of earrings -- you were driven to the abyss by what is essentially a nothing burger.
albertabrightalberta
@cybsara
The buyer returned the item damaged, put the earrings UNDER the cotton of the jewelry box, so they shifted around on the carboard, scratching the surface.
Respectfully, whether the buyer claimed that the earrings didn't fit right or not, it really doesn't matter because you have 30-days free returns. You had to accept the return. And because of your free return policy, you could have just deducted 50% from the refund if they were damaged.
And in all my years, this is the 2nd time ever I have ever have a buyer misuse returns
How fortunate you are to have only had 2 buyers that you claimed "misused" returns. Again, with a free return policy, buyers can return items for ANY reason or for NO reason. There's no "misuse" with a return policy.
they failed me as a buyer too. *snip* (Seller said it was XL, got it, the size was wrong, contacted seller, they said I should have asked for measurements prior to buying. -**bleep**?- Open return, seller closed it out. Call eBay and they said I should have called them as now there's nothing they could do.
What do you mean by "the size was wrong?" What size was marked on the item? If it was marked as XL and you opened a return request for "fit," the no-return seller was within their rights to deny a claim for fit. (That's remorse.) However if the item was listed as XL but you received a medium, your claim should have been for NAD - not as described.
stuff4divas
@cybsara didn't read your book, but thanx for letting us know ur thoughts, i guess 😕
BYYYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!
oaklandmaryland
Selling for almost 26 years and totally agree with you. Have been hurt by Ebay MANY times as a seller and buyer. A year ago I had 4 stores and now just 1 store which will end this month. Almost always buy from Amazon. Ebay is swamped with sellers so could care less if they go. Customer Service is not needed as buyers are constantly told they can return anything and get their money returned by claiming NAD. Time for a long rest.
bonjourami
Happy trails, tho I do think you are being overly dramatic after one bad transaction.
fern*wood
You have a lot going on in that post with the frustration of a return on top of it all. I've had a few myself that made me go for a long walk, but so far the good still outweighs the bad for me.
Since you offered free returns, you did have some limited protections for a return not in the original condition and for bad feedback, if you handled the return yourself. It sounds like you involved ebay, though, so that seldom will work in your favor. Also, restocking fees are no longer permitted, but depending on the details you might have been able to keep a percentage of the refund.
Good luck with whatever you decide to do.
cybsara
OPI said restock fee as she was wearing them and she would need to cover the cost of new batteries. When she first reached out, it was in the morning, gave her some pointers on how to position the star, she opens return stating she needed that day for an event, but her photos were at night time and showing that these pointing in an impossible direction, while in full costume. I said she could return, but she would be charged replacement batteries as she is showing she did wear them. And then she went crazy.
And upon receiving them, she returned them in bad condition, contacted ebay to tell them as the damage exceeded 50%. So they forwarded it to the care dept. but now to be told that they don't have record of me reaching out? And it shocks me you all are ok with this. What happens when this is a higher ticket item?
The level of sales I make on eBay is not worth it. I can use the time from ebay to be spent on my other venues that are 10x's more profitable.
It's a sinking ship........
vintagecraze50
Never spark a GO CRAZY response from a buyer. Mostly, that happens when you light the no returns fire, the you owe me more money fire, the you are a liar fire, etc. RETURN for REFUND, NO FIRE.
oldwestcoins
OMG - blah blah blah.
simba6
Throwing out the baby with the bath water. Just add some to your prices to cover such loss. Any form of retail sales will have it's loses. Like five finger discount at B&M stores. Just have to work it in as a cost of doing business.
harborauction
You have been on ebay for 24 years, 18 on this account, and state "this is the second time I have had a buyer misuse returns". That's an incredibly low number over 24 years and for that you're throwing it all away?
Seems a bit of an overreaction to me and you may want to rethink your decision after calming down
I've been on ebay a couple more years than you and wish I could say I've only had a handfull of bum deals, but I can't. I just try not to let emotion get involved in my ebay dealings, it's just business and dealing with the general public is never 100% roses & unicorns
I don't hold much hope that you will get any action from BBB, local news, consumer advocates or anyone about a dispute over $35 earrings but you can try. Good Luck
cybsara
OPI sell on Etsy and Amazon and eBay is not worth it sales wise. And this is the final straw.
I'm sorry mostly everyone is missing the point, but ah well, you'll understand when it happens to you. This is only a cautionary tale, because what happens when it's a $500 item?
Best of luck. 😉 You're going to need it.
oldwestcoins
I hope your new ID on Bluesky is Debbie-downer. It's pretty low of you to wish we all got hit like you did. You also assume we are all too stupid to run our eBay businesses more successfully than you. As one other replier stated, I have no idea why you had to post as you did since you stated you already left. Just go. I have been here for over 25 years and don't plan on going anywhere for a while. And if you believe you will NOT have the same bozo buyers on other platforms, YOU are in for a rude awakening. They are everywhere. Buh-bye.
Best of luck. You're going to need it. 🤣
kensgiftshop
You write it off on your taxes..
gurlcat
So your first and only post here in the community after 24 years is to dump a bunch of bile on us fellow sellers rather than ask for help when you needed it, and you’re quitting because of one bad return? Do I have that right? What did we do to deserve your bitter post, when it’s too late to even do anything about it?
I see you have already gotten one of the kind of replies you might have been hoping for, affirming your choice. Just so you know, that’s his favorite thing to do, lurk and watch for embittered sellers, for the chance to jump in and say “Yessss, yes, come to the dark side.â€
Well enjoy your retirement. Hope it’s everything you dreamed of!
cybsara
OPBecause I know how to research the message boards to look for my answer BEFORE posting. I have contributed endlessly to threads with MY input.
I have other venues I sell on, that outrank eBay and this is not worth my time.
Good luck though, I am only forewarning the level of support I received, for a $150 item and a $30 item.
albertabrightalberta
Your endless contribution (other than to this thread) was one post in 2019.
fbusoni
@gurlcat
Yes, the "dark side" ... LMAO.
Yet there is an irresistible and seeming inexplicable urge to come back here, again, and again, and again, to the place where utter failure was experienced... and then protest a bit too much about how everything is fine and dandy over on the "dark side." Odd, is it not?
onefootflipper
So you are quitting years of success on ebay selling your own earrings over the return of one pair of damaged $38 blinky earrings that likely cost you very little to actually produce. It seems like the time you put into fighting the issue wasn't even worth what it cost you to produce the item in the first place.
You sold at least 51 pairs of those earrings and you are giving up over 1 of them going wrong.
Something like that happens to me a couple times a year. I am not going to throw away $80,000 a year in sales because I lose $50 along the way to some jerk out there.
cybsara
OPThat is my newer listing, as eBay made it impossible to edit the older listing that sold over 2k pairs. Which is another thing that bugs me, this is the only venue that doesn't allow you to edit listings to add variations.
The lack of support for a smaller item is proving that what could happen on a more expensive item and I do have higher value/collectible items I sell.
I have had a handful of friends leave before this, one of which I had just told her I'm done said it was about time.
I sell on Etsy and Amazon that make selling worth my time and offer support unmatched with eBay.
stainlessenginecovers
There is NO support on Amazon so please stop spreading misinformation and Scammers can get you on either of those sites, as they both offer 'returns' and buyer can 'return a rock' and nothing will be done (they won't take video/pictures as proof either as too easy to modify)
lakefor94
Been selling on Amazon for 8 years. I get double the returns on Amazon for the same amount of sales.
theteamsetguy
@onefootflipper ,
You couldn’t have said it better.
silverstatetreasureboxes
I agree that was a great response.
cybsara
OPWell, that's amazing you have that type of revenue, but mine is not even worth it compared to the other venues that run circles the sales I make here on eBay.
but my point is that over the course of just one year, as a buyer and a seller, the level of support I've received is horrendous and I don't need to wait for it to be one of my more expensive items.
My post is your warning. Best of luck.
oldwestcoins
So have you given eBay over $300,000 in eBay fees? I have. Just leave.
isaiah53-57
Took you long enough - haha- Sorry for the sarcasm - Im sure you wish it had turned out differently as I'm sure all who have left here do.
We started selling about the same time as you - What moved us to put our exit strategy into place was the insanity of the site making us responsible for the destructive actions of THEIR unvetted buyers no matter the proof - In a sense promoting the actions of scammers by giving them no-questions-asked refunds (really what would be the point in questioning, considering the policies) and even allowing them to remain on the site scamming with impunity after untold complaints - Unbelievably, we ran into that EXACT situation - Thats when we realized we could no longer list expensive items here - And if we couldnt count on the revenue from expensive items, selling inexpensive items was to much work for the profit due to their insane fees...
For this reason and a front/back page grocery list of additional reasons - we put principle ahead of profit and moved on to bigger and better - Actually I should thank them for giving us reason to bail - Things couldn't have turned out better...
theteamsetguy
@isaiah53-57 ,
Good for you that you found something better and I don’t mean it sarcastic way. But what I don’t understand is why are you even bothering to be here. You’ve obviously have moved on to greener pastures.
Sorry things didn’t work out you. However, there are many sellers that are happy with eBay including myself. Is eBay perfect? No, but it is good enough for me. There are positives and negatives with most things in life. I’ve always been a half full kind of guy and would rather extenuate the positives instead dwelling on the negatives.
isaiah53-57
Thanks for the sentiment -
I sold on ebay for close to 20 years - It was a great tool during the majority of that time - But exploitative policies and high fees pushed us to seek the next pasture - Surely you know there are many people posting and/or reading here that no longer sell on the site - for the most part, and for whatever reasons, they don't feel they are wasting their time here - If you notice, I have never said I will never sell on this site again - Underlying some of the policies that make the site difficult to utilize, it is still a good tool - a good concept - If they were to change course on some things (Most importantly the MBG) I would consider selling here in the future.
With that said, the problem does not lie so much with the corporation - They're gonna be corporate - The problem lies, in my most humble opinion, with the people who accept those policies, regardless of their exploitation and hurtfulness to businesses... Ready to accept and expect less and less as the years go on like hapless sheep - Never taking a stand - If more people raised their voices or took steps to show they wouldn't stand for certain site changes at their advent, the site would listen...
This is not the first time we left the site - When they went to best match search at the end of 2008 and our monthly sell-through rate dropped from about 80% to 40% overnight, we left for 3 years(people would kill for that sell through rate today wouldn't they?) - Used the site again in 2012 to attempt to liquidate outstanding stock - Did OK, but no where near like the heydays and stuck with it until we had a string of expensive losses right about the time Promoted listings was ramping up - Realized it was time to make a statement once again..
Our leaving was dual-purpose - One part of it was a statement that we would not accept policies that were hurtful to sellers - The other was having no doubt we could make our own way without problem using our God-given smarts and persistence - concepts ingrained by my parents - If more people utilized their courage to take a stand, then corporations wouldnt feel they can do whatever they want - Thanks Mom and Dad - for teaching us to be brave enough to stand for something without concern of contention.
I'm still making statements and supporting those who are also making statements - It is our attempt to help effect change for the better - Its the only way this place will ever improve...
fern*wood
I personally feel the MBG saved ebay in the long run. I highly doubt buyers would have kept coming back after competition entered the landscape without having those protections put in place. Bad transactions would have continued spreading like the fires in California--in both deed and word of mouth. I know I wouldn't risk buying here had that protection not been put in place.
To their credit, ebay also put in a few limited protections for some sellers when buyers take unfair advantage of the return process. Sometimes it hurts, but in the long run it was necessary to save selling here overall.
isaiah53-57
In rephrasing, its not the MBG that is the problem - It is forcing sellers to be the losers of the policy - If they want to give a MBG to their unvetted buyers and allow buyers who have had UNTOLD COMPLAINTS against them continue to thieve uncontsrained , then THEY should be the ones covering the bill - It is their fault buyers have declined - Everything wrong with this site is the company's fault - They should be on the hook for thievery here if they wont do whats needed to control it - Plain and simple...
Seems they are doing it with the new international sales policies right? - Know why? - My guess is because they are exploiting shipping costs to international buyers in a way that allows them to cover losses from theft. - My guess is taking 15% to 25% of the every items selling price is MORE THAN ENOUGH to cover the theft here and take the onus for it off its sellers...
Its self-defeating for the company - Can you imagine how many people are holding back expensive items, or are unwilling to sell here because of the insane risks?
gurlcat
“Seems they are doing it with the new international sales policies right? - Know why? - My guess is because they are exploiting shipping costs to international buyers in a way that allows them to cover losses from theftâ€
That’s an extraordinary claim that would require extraordinary evidence, but you did admit it’s just a guess.
Really it’s only right for them to cover buyer complaints for the international purchases that go through their hub, because their employees put their hands on our packages, they have a chance to inspect the items if they want to, and they choose the overseas carriers, etc. so of course we’re no longer responsible at that point. Likewise, they get to keep any items that get returned or cannot be forwarded, which they liquidate to at least one company that I know of who sells the items right here on the site. So there is one offset right there. They likely also include returns in their tax write offs, same as individual sellers can do.
Also who knows how they handle various kinds of returns -they may refuse remorse returns or require foreign buyers to pay their own return shipping.
In any case, whatever total losses they suffer from issuing refunds is probably worth it just for the sheer amount of additional sales volume they get, from sellers who would otherwise not touch international selling with a thousand mile pole (but that’s just my guess).
Maybe there’s some mutually agreeable way to do domestic returns similarly, but until then the MBG is as close to fair as possible, without having an astronomically large workforce to sit and weigh buyer vs. seller reputations, like you seem to be advocating. It just doesn’t seem like you get the real scale of things. For every one Community post you see of eBay allowing an honest seller to get scammed, there are probably thousands of similar scenarios we don’t hear about. Just way too many for paid employees to field. -Although the Facebook ones sure do perform some miracles here and there, for those of us who know about them.
Maybe you get more reliably good protection wherever you sell now, but you must not get the buyer reach, or you would have absolutely no reason to even consider selling here ever again. It’s a trade off, and only the individual seller can decide if it’s worth it or not.
fbusoni
@gurlcat
Bingo! As if there is something wrong in the first place with a business entity acting rationally to cover real or anticipated losses / shortfalls.
Oh my gosh! The gas station charges $4 for a Snickers bar! It's a conspiracy!!
Oh no! eBay is using PL profits to keep fees down for ordinary sellers!
Hey! That seller is making a few bucks from shipping!
That such elementary concepts are alien to some explains why some are unable to do well on this platform. Not to mention the inability to manage eBay's MBG ... talk about a deficit of business acumen. Good heavens. 🤡
I guess the absence of quality control in the seller onboarding process is good for the rest of us.
PS: my favorite sellers are those from outside the USA. They tend not to be cheapskates... one just bought a one of a kind, out of print book from me for $119... I had tried to sell it for several months and had lowered the price (just to move it) all the way down to $49 and had 15 watchers. Then I did a "sell similar" and within a few days got my foreign buyer. Thank you eBay! â¤ï¸
isaiah53-57
We have a large stock of items that would be very suitable for ebay-type selling - Valuable/Vintage used/new items that can generate high revenue with a lot of eyes on them:
For instance, we just recently picked up a tub of about 25 loose 1980's He-Man Action figures with ALL their accessories including the mini-comics - Very rare figures like Sun-Man, Scare Glow, Sorceress, Clamp Champ, etc - Many of these figures(complete) sell for $200 to $500 depending on condition. We have a large high dollar comic collection - Large rare Lego's Collection - large high dollar video game/game console collection - vintage/old toy collection - high dollar collectible sneaker collection - high dollar deck building & sports cards collection etc etc...
We have a LOT of things like this in safe storage(well packed, sorted and categorized in case our number comes up one day so the kids/grandkids can easily see whats there). I would like to have our grandkids help us sell a lot of these things to make money for cars and college... spend quality time with them ...have some fun with it...
Things like these are well suited for selling here, but the acrid taste of listing a high/higher dollar item here, knowing it can be stolen with ZERO effort on the thief's part, can kill the fun real fast - The fees and promoted listings we can get by, but when they allow scammers to come here for free pickings, seemingly because they need buyers so bad, to the point, where no matter the amount of complaints against them, they just continue scamming with impunity(exactly what happened to us) - As far as I'm concerned, thats using self defeating policies to save their own skins at the expense of their sellers skins -
Yes, it is a trade-off - Though one thing we are not willing to trade-off is our principles and beliefs - We boycott any company that comes between us and them...
So we are simply biding our time - Our stock of items like I mentioned above are valuing up on average - Time is on our side - We wont list here until we feel we have protections that were once common - Or we wait to see what replaces this place - surely it will be something that addresses most of the mistakes of the past, during the fledgling last 25 years of open e-commerce - otherwise, there would be no point in a replacement...